8 ms·
Washington, Minnesota officially endorse a “safer, faster” traffic merge
- dubfan 12y agoI see the negative effects of early merging regularly. The freeway onramp closest to my home leads to a frequently congested portion of the freeway. People merging ASAP often end up having to stop on the onramp, blocking traffic behind them which can then back up onto surface streets. They do this despite the onramp merge lane continuing for quite some time after it first connects to the freeway.
- ch4s3 12y agoThis is pretty brilliant, but how do you encourage this without a light or years of including it in driver education?
- dubfan 12y agoEven including it in driver's education isn't likely to help. Driver's education teaches people to use blinkers, but from informal observation I'd estimate 1/3 of drivers in my area don't use their blinkers at all.
- ChikkaChiChi 12y agoIn Minnesota there are posted signs such as "Stay in your lane until the merge point" which seem to work pretty well.
- ChikkaChiChi 12y agoIn practice zipper merging works amazingly well. MNDOT has used signage to tell drivers to maintain speed and stay in their lanes for the past few years of construction in the northern Twin Cities. You wouldn't believe how much faster traffic moves when these simple reminders are posted. The problem is that without the signs (and enforcement) drivers in the Twin Cities Metro regularly shoot to seal any gap that may allow someone signaling to enter their lane, regardless of the distance to the merge point. This behavior also occurs in on-ramp situations where drivers are entering the highway and slow lane drivers refuse to move over, but don't want you in front of them! I have driven in many states and never has the mentality that you cannot, MUST NOT, let someone ahead of you been as bad as it is here. Minnesota Nice, indeed.
- dusing 12y agoI live in the Twin Cities and "Minnesota nice" means merging incredibly early when a lane is posted as closed. As a transplant I can always count on getting and extra 1/2 - 1 mile ahead by staying in the closed lane. It is getting better, but still 40% of the time the car at the end of the zipper merge is NOT happy to see you, and thinks they are letting you in. Signage is helping at the big construction areas.
- hockeybias 12y agoYou nailed it.
- VikingCoder 12y ago"Getting ahead" means you're not following the whole point of this idea, which is to MINIMIZE the speed differential between the two lanes. If you want to show people how it's done, you go the same speed as the cars next to you in the open lane, and zipper merge at the end. GRRRRR. Yes, THEY are doing it wrong, because they're early merging. (IDIOTS!) But you are ALSO doing it wrong. I'm reminded of the George Carlin comment that everyone who drives slower than you is an idiot, and everyone who drives faster than you is an asshole.
- dusing 12y ago"Getting ahead" does not mean speeding, and its hard to go the same speed as the full lane when it is at a stand still. I do slow down from the speed limit significantly just in case someone wants to pop out.
- tedsanders 12y agoThe whole point of zipper merging is to minimize speed differences between lanes for maximum efficiency and maximum safety. The proper way to execute a late zipper merge is to match speeds and merge at the end. You are not correctly zipper merging if you are passing other cars before merging at the end.
- 12y ago
- aenean 12y agoTraffic management is a fascinating intersection of sociology, fluid dynamics, behavior change, and urban planning. If you're interested in this field, I can't recommend the work of Tom Vanderbilt enough. His book "Traffic" brought urban planning to the masses in the same manner "Freakonomics" made social and public policy accessible. http://tomvanderbilt.com/traffic/ http://tomvanderbilt.com/traffic/
- ChikkaChiChi 12y agoI'm always blown away but how smoothly some areas handle congestion when overpasses are being built or repaired.
- iLoch 12y agoI've always found it fascinating how a single bad driver can cause a massive traffic jam ("ghost traffic jam"). I think this should be taught when you're learning to drive as part of some sort of mandatory basic training - zipper merges should be in there too.
- hero454545 12y agohere's a post you might enjoy: http://www.smartmotorist.com/traffic-and-safety-guideline/traffic-jams.html http://www.smartmotorist.com/traffic-and-safety-guideline/tr...
- lotsofmangos 12y agoCritical Mass by Philip Ball has some nice bits on traffic. http://www.philipball.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=15:critical-mass-how-one-thing-leads-to-another&catid=3:books&Itemid=4 http://www.philipball.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&vie...
- pwenzel 12y agoAs a driver in the Twin Cities area, I can back the stereotype that Minnesotans don't know how to zipper. It speaks so truly of the Minnesota condition. People begin often merge far too early, and get offended when folks like myself "budge" at the front of the line. Learn to zipper, darn it! Edit: This TPT parody, How to Talk Minnesotan, shows how to drive in Minnesota (scrub to 11:58): http://video.tpt.org/video/2365042610/ http://video.tpt.org/video/2365042610/ If you ever lived in rural Minnesota, you know this is completely dead on.
- smacktoward 12y agoSince the big obstacle to zippering is people's perception that it's rude (since you appear to be "pushing to the front of the line," as it were), one could argue that this is a case of Minnesota Nice hurting more than it helps :-D
- ChikkaChiChi 12y ago"Minnesota Nice" tends to be an in-joke according to many of the people I've asked about it here. :)
- ChikkaChiChi 12y agoGenerally I've found that most drivers in the Twin Cities have not acclimated to "city driving" the way many of us from other areas learned. People here drive as if they are exempt from the responsibility of piloting a 2 ton death roller skate and what it could possibly do to others while they text their friends.
- jerf 12y agoPeople think they are being nice. Education can work very quickly and efficiently on such people by showing them they aren't being nice after all. I live in the US in a "nice driver" area with a number of traffic circles. On a fairly routine basis I come up to a traffic circle and stop because there is someone in it coming towards me, but then they try to "helpfully" stop and wave me in, slowing down themselves, everyone behind them, and even slowing me down as now I'm confused and less likely to move. Or I get stuck behind such a person in the circle and have to stop gracelessly as they unexpectedly stop in the middle. (This being a traffic circle it's not that dangerous due to lack of speed, plus over time I've learned to predict who is going to do this based on the car body language...) I haven't yet witnessed this causing an accident but it's just a matter of time, it snarls things up that badly. They think they're being friendly. If someone would explain that "friendly" is using the traffic circles as designed, they'd probably do the right thing in the future, but so far I haven't discovered the hand gestures that properly express that.
- molf 12y agoI'm surprised this is written like zipper merging is some kind of recently discovered secret. Zipper merging (or weaving) has been standard practice in parts of Europe for 20 years (maybe longer – I can't really remember anything else). Since March 2014 it is even mandatory in Belgium, and anyone merging early may risk a €55 fine [1]. It has been repeatedly advocated and promoted by various governments in Europe [2] and I doubt anyone questions its effectivity. Some experiments have been done in the past with alternative methods like zipper merging with groups of cars, but this is only applied when traffic can be regulated (with lights or traffic controllers). The nice thing about zipper merging is that with enough public knowledge, drivers can regulate merging themselves. [1]:http://www.vandaag.be/binnenland/145761_ritsen-verplicht-vanaf-1-maart.html http://www.vandaag.be/binnenland/145761_ritsen-verplicht-van... [2]:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNhnLYI2Efw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNhnLYI2Efw – Dutch government TV ad from 1989 which explains and promotes zipper merging (albeit very poorly, I must admit).
- ChikkaChiChi 12y agoIt's not the concept that is newsworthy, it's the decision to actively promote it that is.
- dubfan 12y agoMore importantly, the decision by American transportation authorities to promote it is newsworthy. It seems like Northern Europe takes a more systematic and serious attitude towards driving, while the American attitude is more "eat my breakfast while driving 50mph in the left lane, and give the finger to everyone who passes me on the right"
- craigds 12y agoAgreed. Zipper merging has been standard practice in New Zealand my whole (28 year) life. Except we call it "zip merging" because "zipper" sounds awfully foreign around here. I didn't know there was another way to merge until I read this article.
- 12y ago
- adrr 12y agoI thought the zipper merge was the standard way to merge? You stay in your lane till the merge section(end of your lane) and its every other car. Maybe its a California thing.
- reustle 12y agoSame in PA. I've always remembered merging like this.
- kelnos 12y agoI've rarely seen people in (northern) California do proper zipper merges. CA has some of the most clueless and inattentive driving I've ever seen.
- flomo 12y agoDisagree. I used to reverse-commute through the Golden Gate Bridge and the Caldecott Tunnel, where the freeway went from 4 lanes to 2 in both places. 99% of drivers manage to zipper-merge properly. Likewise, almost everyone zippers at the South 101 Central Freeway merge. California drivers may or may not be bad, but they're much better than the ones in Minnesota.
- joshwa 12y agoI wish some of the "exit only" lanes would change to be zipper-merge-able-- in SF, think about the 7th street exit on 80E just before the Bay Bridge-- two empty lanes!-- and lots of "cheaters" whereas with a zipper merge everything would move faster. IIRC California officially endorses early merging, though?
- _delirium 12y agoYou could just make two exit lanes in that case, and merge them as or after they exit. People exiting at the last minute from a non-exit lane though aren't really merging, but rather changing lanes. And it doesn't really result in a proper zipper merge since not everyone is exiting, so you can't predictably alternate cars.
- colanderman 12y ago"Merge rudely." It's only rude if no-one else is doing it (i.e. you're speeding ahead of everyone merging early). If everyone stays in their lane until the merge point, no-one's zooming ahead, so it stays fair.
- iLoch 12y agoThis works pretty well where I live. Here in Vancouver, a major bridge that takes traffic into the downtown core is only 3 undivided lanes. There's a huge amount of traffic flowing over this bridge in the morning as it connects work to home for somewhere in the range of 60,000 - 70,000 commuters daily. From the residential side of the bridge, traffic zipper merges from 4 lanes into either one or two depending on the time of day. The traffic is coming from two different sources (west and east) so each source will zipper merge and then the zipper merged lanes will zipper merge onto the bridge. I honestly have no idea what this would look like any other way. Zipper merges are obvious and natural if you set them up right - what it takes is the knowledge to do it. Once people know that they should be yielding to the mergers, the whole merge process speeds up considerably.
- arecurrence 12y agoI see this as well whenever crossing the Lions Gate southbound. I suspect if there weren't 4 lanes merging together it would be a different situation (I don't see people doing this correctly in other parts of the peninsula that merge).
- curtis 12y agoLate merging works fine in Seattle, and in my experience the lane that's closed moves substantially faster than the open lane because Seattle drivers will actually let you merge in. That's not how I recalled it working when I lived in Texas though. In Texas if you got caught in the closed lane you were pretty much stuck there for a while, while the guys in the open lane whizzed by too fast for anybody in the slower (possibly stopped) closed lane to merge safely.
- kelnos 12y ago...and in my experience the lane that's closed moves substantially faster than the open lane because Seattle drivers will actually let you merge in. I think that's actually because more people are early-merging than late-merging. So you have more car volume in the open lane than the soon-to-be-closed lane leading up to the merge. Definitely a way better situation everyone early-merging, but sounds like there's still room for improvement: ideally both lanes should move at about the same speed.
- arjie 12y agoIf the person merging late had to stop, then it means they went too far without getting a space (because they didn't take the chance they were given or no one gave them space). This is the problem with zipper merging: if everyone gets it right it's beautiful but the failure mode is near catastrophic (effectively stopping one lane) and easy to get into. One or two bad actors can ruin it.
- bignaj 12y agoSeattle drivers are some of the worst mergers on the planet. You'll see a half-mile-long line of early mergers and then an entire unused lane. Absolutely blows my mind.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- joshstrange 12y agoI have to deal with such a merge almost daily as the main road I use is under heavy construction. I am an "early merger" mainly because the people in the left lane (right lane goes away) will not let you in if they have a choice and it is widely seen as being a "douchbag" if you fly down the right hand lane expecting to be let in at the end. I'm not saying that I disagree with this article in fact I've sat in near standstill traffic in the lefthand land and I've had plenty of time to wonder if merging at the merge point does make more sense, which I think it does. I personally wish they would have closed off the entire right lane as there is only a couple hundred meter stretch where this road is 2 lanes and so I wish they had just kept it a single lane all the way though while construction was underway. Here is the road in question: http://s.joshstrange.com/oRq9.png http://s.joshstrange.com/oRq9.png From where you see Louie Pl it turns into a 2 lane road then goes back to 1 lane at Opportunity Way then back to 2 lane where you see it get fatter again. However construction makes the road for a mile or two after Opportunity Way 1 lane only so the 2 lanes for such a small stretch are almost more trouble than they are worth.
- notacoward 12y agoZipper merging works great as long as everyone on both sides is willing to alternate (or if strong enforcement requires them to do so). Otherwise, letting "late mergers" scream past fifty "early mergers" often creates a situation worse than simple early merge. There's plenty of blame to go around. * The vast majority of the people blasting down the late-merge lane clearly have no interest in alternating or merging into the largest/safest gap at the end. They'll squeeze into the smallest latest gap that they think they can possibly get away with. * Quite a few of the early mergers feel they've already done their part. Whether they're competitive, territorial, or sincerely concerned with traffic flow/safety, they're not much interested in alternating with the late mergers either. So how does this play out every effing day at construction projects and toll booths? You end up with a few late mergers playing chicken with a few early mergers at the chokepoint, jockeying for position inch by inch and degree by degree as they try to cut each other off. That's where all the "vigilantes" come from - they're people who are already stuck in the aftermath, they know how it happened, and they have decided that they'd rather settle for forced early merge than botched zipper merge. Without enforcing proper merge behavior on both sides, zipper merge just becomes a big Prisoners' Dilemma game with a few defectors screwing all of the cooperators.
- ericHosick 12y agoZipper merging is the optimal solution. People early merge because they think it is the optimal/moral/better/'done my part' solution. If everyone knew about zipper merging there would be no early mergers (and 'late mergers' don't exist within the context of zipper merging).
- Klinky 12y agoIn simulations zipper merging is an optimal solution. In reality, relying on thousands of drivers to properly follow specific directions and be completely aware of their surroundings is a flawed solution. Telling people how to do something efficiently doesn't mean they'll do it that way. People are extremely loose when it comes to following driving rules, e.g. speed, texting, minimum distances, merging, etc..
- beejiu 12y agoAs a driver in the UK, I don't understand what exactly the difference between a merge and an overtake is. It is quite common here for roads to change from 2 lanes to 1 lane. There's no signage telling you to merge. There's no rules telling you what to do. You just operate by the same logic as an overtake, and you'll find that, quite naturally, everybody 'zip merges'. Perhaps the reason for the inefficiency is having rules in the first instance.
- o0-0o 12y agoThe difference is localized. The UK is much smaller, and therefore has less regional tastes about merging. In the Midwest and Eastern seaboards of the US you have polite and diverse people respectively. In California, you have experienced drivers. California works like the zipper merge already, and the rest of the US is flummoxed by what to do - depending on where you are.
- teamonkey 12y agoI don't think it's so much about being smaller, more that there is only one set of rules for the whole country and those rules are more strongly enforced. Also, from what I can tell, the driving exam is far more rigorous in the UK.
- bsder 12y agoSpeeds in the UK are way slower than the US, and cars are way more expensive to run in the UK than the US. Consequently, everybody and their dog doesn't expect to drive a car in the UK.
- kelnos 12y agoSince this is a solution that requires "everyone" to change their behavior, my guess would be that it'd be more productive (and faster?) just to wait for self-driving cars to be prevalent enough that they "set the tone" for what constitutes normal driving in these situations.
- malandrew 12y agoThat video explanation made no sense to me. Basically the "interface" presented to the drivers has not changed, so why would drivers deviate from how they currently merge? Because the government said so? I don't see this working. However there are two solutions that could promote zipper merging: (1) Force both lanes to the center before moving that center lane to the side that is available ahead: ____________________________________________ \________/ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ________ ____________/ ______________________/_____________________ (2) Present a long-barrier between both lanes well before the merge that only permit late merging, so that those in the continuing lane feel morally obligated to let those queued up in. ____________________________________________ _ _ _ _____________ ____________________ / ______________________/_____________________
- thirdstation 12y agoOption 2 physically walls off the Late Mergers in addition to mentally (in the minds of the Free Laners), making them easier to ignore. I like option 1 because it forces everyone to move.
- joezydeco 12y agoYeah, option 2 would lead to someone hestitating/stopping in that lower lane. Then that whole lane is stopped because the front driver is too afraid to merge into moving traffic, and the moving traffic is going too fast to stop and let a lower lane driver in.
- Negitivefrags 12y agoIn New Zealand we just have signs like this all over the place: http://i.imgur.com/AtaDOGX.jpg http://i.imgur.com/AtaDOGX.jpg
- joelcollinsdc 12y agoIts pedantic, but I think this is sublty different than what is being dicussed here. All over the US, there are situations where 2 lanes converge to 1 and drivers "take turns" merging. But I think the scenario that is being discussed is a little different, where there is 1 "working" lane and one "closed" lane, the thought process of drivers in the lane that they know is 'closed' up ahead is to merge early. I wonder if cultures where queueing (like, in the grocery store) is not as common as in the US have this problem? I suspect not.
- korzun 12y agoWant faster and safer traffic merging? > Part of DMV road test should cover highway and emergency (road block) situations. > Utilize responsive testing (how fast person reacts to something). Could be an in-house application. > Older drivers should have extra testing once they hit certain age. > Re-test drivers every 10 years. > Driving and doing your make up? Reading a book/iPad? Eating chipotle? License suspension. Bye bye. In general every situation where I had to steer out of the way was caused by an older person who should NOT be driving. Zipper merging on New York roads? Fuhgeddaboudit.
- DanBC 12y ago> In general every situation where I had to steer out of the way was caused by an older person who should NOT be driving. Do you have any statistics about driving accidents? Because all the stats I've seen show that older drivers are safer better drivers than young people, and this is especially true when comparing to young males under the age of 26.
- Noted 12y agoIt's been awhile since I've looked into it, but I seem to remember it being more or less that the young, and very old are both less safe than the middle.
- korzun 12y agoThose statistics do not include cases where older person switches lanes into your car and you luckily avoid it. They also do not include cases where other people cause accidents and go on their marry way while you wreck your vehicle avoiding them. Like the other poster stated, it's young (novice drivers) and old drivers. It's also a scientific fact that you reaction time decreases as you grow older. >Because all the stats I've seen show that older drivers are safer better drivers than young people. Sure. http://consumerreports.org/cro/magazine/2012/10/teenagers-and-older-people-are-the-riskiest-drivers/index.htm http://consumerreports.org/cro/magazine/2012/10/teenagers-an... http://www.cdc.gov/motorvehiclesafety/older_adult_drivers/adult-drivers_factsheet.html http://www.cdc.gov/motorvehiclesafety/older_adult_drivers/ad... > Age-related declines in vision and cognitive functioning (ability to reason and remember), as well as physical changes, may affect some older adults' driving abilities.5 > Per mile traveled, fatal crash rates increase starting at age 75 and increase notably after age 80. This is largely due to increased susceptibility to injury and medical complications among older drivers rather than an increased tendency to get into crashes
- niix 12y agoSeems great in theory, but what if the other drive isn't willing to let you in - or - vise versa?
- walesmd 12y agoOn most military bases, and therefore in military heavy towns like San Antonio, the zipper merge is used to great effect. I've even seen it used at T-intersections (where the perpendicular road must stop) - on almost every military base, when traffic is backed up, you'll see drivers immediately implement the zipper - one car from right of way, one from the intersecting road.
- thirdstation 12y agoPerhaps instead of merging one lane into another, the animosity toward late mergers can be alleviated by making all lanes move. If no one feels like they are in the free lane, they'll be forced to cooperate. So, on a two-lane highway, make one center lane and have both lanes funnel into it. then you can move that free-flowing lane wherever you need.
- thirdstation 12y agomalandrew types faster than me. And has better ASCII art.
- justinpaulson 12y agoThe problem is, there are two very different ways to merge based on the flow of traffic. If traffic is moving, then early merge is the preferred method. If traffic is not moving, then a late merge makes more sense. The problem is people who do not merge early when traffic is flowing. These people wait until the last second to merge instead of finding an opening while traffic is flowing and force traffic to slow down in order to let them in. And the really real problem is that the average driver in the USA has no idea what they are doing and should probably not be driving at all. It would take a huge change in the way we train drivers to get them to recognize when they should use each type of merge. And forcing people into one way to merge or the other is not really the "fastest/safest" way, because it varies on conditions.
- anishkothari 12y agoThis 2008 article in Wired[1] changed the way I merge forever and it has paid off when I drive in Chicago's endless construction and traffic. [1]http://archive.wired.com/culture/culturereviews/magazine/16-08/pl_print http://archive.wired.com/culture/culturereviews/magazine/16-...
- IgorPartola 12y agoI really wish people would actually do this. I call this "driver karma". For every person you let in, you get to go in front of another person. If everyone followed this heuristic, we wouldn't have a problem. Oh, and if you let a bus full of people in front of you, your score is increased by the number of people on the bus :).
- dr_faustus 12y agoWell, this is (has always been) the standard in Germany and it works pretty well. We even have one of those great German words for it: Reißverschlussverfahren (= zipper procedure). Concerning people not letting you in: In case of ending lanes (except ramps) you are obliged to let people in. There is always the occasional douchebag that doesnt but it almost never happend to me. At worst you have to wait for one car to pass.
- txlMan 12y agoIn Germany we've been doing this for decades. Welcome to the future.
- Brian-Puccio 12y agoLocally (metro NYC), I've heard this referred to as "alternate merge" and it's usually mentioned in the context of someone saying something along the lines of "there was a traffic jam due to an accident and then when it was MY TURN to go, the person in the other lane didn't let me in". Usually there's a comment about how the plates were from out of state, too. This is not to be confused with, e.g., a road that splits and the left lane split it moving fine and the right lane is backed up and a driver in the left lane waits until the last possible second to move over, often times coming to a complete stop, thus backing up what should be a free-flowing lane. No, in that case you didn't move over in time, you don't get to slow down traffic, you take the lane you're in and keep going, you'll have to take the next exit.
- Jach 12y agoAlternatively... Since the government forces me to bring my vehicle to one of their locations every other year for emissions testing, have them install a speed control unit with a beacon to communicate with other cars. (Yes it will be harder to install on some cars than others -- even just the beacon would be valuable.) Over the course of five years, retrofit every vehicle with a beacon and have it already installed on new cars, have severe penalties for vehicles caught driving around not broadcasting their signal, and now everyone can have a bit more automation in their automobiles since the systems will enforce safe merge gaps and other nice things like computer-enforced speed limits. Plus it prepares everyone for a fully automated experience that can come sometime in the 2020s. I can dream right?
- mark-r 12y agoThe nicest thing about zipper merging is that everyone can see the fairness of it, when it works. It's the lack of fairness that most infuriates people with the free-for-all system. Minnesota still does a very poor job of letting people know where the expected merge point is.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoI grew up and learned to drive in Washington; I moved away 20 years ago but come back regularly, and if there's one thing I know about Washington drivers it's: they can't merge for shit.
- bpdenimy 12y agoSo Negitivefrags is probably right that the best top-down way to get this to happen is to place signage. But it's sort of fun to think of the best bottom-up way to get this to happen, assuming your local government isn't putting up signs. For example, I love going a constant speed in start-stop traffic (letting gaps appear ahead of me then closing them as traffic stops) so as to smooth out the ride of everyone behind me. So what's the optimal way to get this behavior to spread? It's probably not just to gun it to the front of the line and yell 'zipper!', everyone just thinks you're an asshole. VikingCoder suggests "If you want to show people how it's done, you go the same speed as the cars next to you in the open lane, and zipper merge at the end." I love it, because it's really awkward, and people will note it enough to maybe think through what's happening, what your logic is. But I dunno, maybe there's something else more clever out there, too.
- zobzu 12y agoEarly merge feels more polite, late merge is safer and faster on the overall traffic (and much faster if you're the only one doing it + you're seen as impolite) They want to make it more common. Pretty sure everywhere in EU everyone late merge. In west USA at least, I only see early merges.
- barnwell5 12y ago"Optimal" means different things to different people. What the DoT may be trying to maximize (safety, lack of frustration) is generally not what drivers want to maximize (overall speed) and I think there's confusion about that when zipper merge is discussed. The linked article uses the word 'faster' but the Minnesota pdf they cite actually says "Our analysis has shown that the Zipper System has no effect on travel time through the work zone." Here is a Michigan DoT paper[1] from 2007 that analyzed zipper merge studies in various states and countries. Only 1 out of 6 showed statistically significant increase in throughput. "It was found that the system did not increase the throughput or decrease the length of the queue." (Netherlands) "It was found that the throughput did not increase, but the queuing was more efficient and there were less frustrated drivers." (UK) "Beacher, Fontaine, and Garber (12) found that there was an increase in the throughput and a decrease in the queue length; however, the difference was not statistically significant." (Virginia) "However, flow did not appear to be significantly affected by the dynamic late lane merge system." (Kansas) "The data from both of the studies shows that the typical queue length decreased and the lane usage were nearly equal, but the throughput decreased slightly." (Minnesota) "The results from Maryland’s deployment show an increase in the overall throughput, a reduction of the maximum queue length, and a more even distribution of volume between lanes." 1: http://www.michigan.gov/documents/mdot/MDOT_Research_Report_RC1500_Part1_209842_7.pdf http://www.michigan.gov/documents/mdot/MDOT_Research_Report_...
- blahedo 12y agoA lot of people and a lot of articles discuss resistance to this as a matter of misguided "politeness", and a LOT of the support for it carries a tone of smugness---there is definitely a weirdly emotional component to this. But here's the fairly objective thing I want to know: the people who have been (very negatively!) described as "early merge vigilantes" generally operate by staying in the lane that goes away but pacing the cars in the other lane, blocking the people behind them from zooming ahead; and then quickly merging just before the lane goes away (usually an enabler in the other lane will make this work better so neither has to slow down or stop at this point). So here's the question: isn't this exactly what the zipper merge is supposed to accomplish, with both lanes travelling the same speed? Why is this so-called "vigilante" behaviour being described as bad? If a driver that's smug about their late-merging behaviour being optimal is going noticeably faster in their lane than the lane that merged, doesn't that mean that what they're doing is exactly not a zipper merge? Perhaps the answer is that the ideal to aim for is not "late" merging, so much as "speed matching" merging: when there is a merge ahead, if you're in the faster of the two lanes (whichever one that is!), slow down a smidge now and then you won't have to screech to a braking halt at the merge point (and you'll also make the flow better for everyone behind you). Zooming ahead because there's a briefly clear section of road may be "late" merging in some sense, but is not the same thing as "zipper" merging and is not improving flow.
- lamontcg 12y agoThe point is also to fill both lanes, so your last suggestion doesn't work very well. And I've been known to be a "vigilante" before. I'd give it up in a second if people would actually start filling the other lane. There's a merge here in Seattle -- the southbound I-5 collector-distributor with the onramp to 90 where it merges back into I-5 -- where people zipper halfway reasonably well and I actually routinely stay in the less-filled lane and late-merge. Washingtonians are awful at late merging/zippering though. Even when people are late merging you get tons of people merging early and then the line moves forwards and it screws over the lane that is being merged into. People just won't simply drive forwards to the merge spot. Dividers might help in some cases, but when the road is empty and everyone is doing 60+ mph the dividers are going to cause accidents. You could try to put down double lines on the road to block merging, but nobody pays attention to those here either. Getting zippering into drivers ed and getting them early, spamming the TV with ads, and putting signs up all over the place and carpet bombing the message might work. Happy to see them doing this. Oh yeah, and there's definitely an emotional component to it. When I'm stuck behind 50 cars and some asshat in a BMW goes speeding past to late merge the world goes completely red. I would love to stop doing that. If everyone zippers the asshat just has to pick a lane like everyone else, and there's no way to "cheat". And yes, "asshat" and "cheat" are all in my own brain. I find it extremely difficult to stop thinking that way when I see it though.
- GreenPlastic 12y agoI'm the asshole who merges in at the last possible second. It's really annoying that they're doing this as I routinely save 10 minutes off my commute by jumping into lanes that will eventually merge in.
- Cthulhu_ 12y agoI've recently sold my car (a crappy Opel) and replaced it with a motorcycle, and my behavior in traffic has definitely changed re: merging. The other day there was a mile-long queue in front of a highway exit, traffic was up on the hard shoulder or whatever the term is. If I were still in my car, I would've been polite and just queued up - would probably cost me 15 minutes to get to the exit and further on. Now though, I did full D-bag and just drove past most of the line. At the exit, the queue started breaking up, leaving plenty of room for me to merge into. Actually if everyone took a motorcycle instead of their car, most of these problems would be gone. But that's probably a silly argument.
- buro9 12y agoThis sounds like Italian driving. If you haven't driven in Italy, expect zero braking during merges. I really do mean zero. Trucks will move over (at speed), cars will move over (at speed). The "zipper" action is seamless and fluid, even when the vehicles are temporarily extremely close to each other. Just look down the road, see a merge may happen. If you are a truck move over, if you are a car you may need to accelerate to move over. The first time you experience this it looks and feels scary, especially as people merge with only 50cm-1m between vehicles. But once you're used to it you realise that you virtually never slow down and merges are really quick and easy.
- Shivetya 12y agoWith the low cost of portable lighting and signage why not traffic light both lanes and alternate who goes through, just like we do with highway congestion on ramp lights?
- emerod 12y agoIn contrast to the states promoting zipper merging, Indiana recently redesigned some interchanges to effectively eliminate the single merge point. They added extra lanes so that one "preferred" lane (the one that formerly backed up everyone for three miles) is no longer the sole access for any of the off-ramps. Now, everyone has basically three miles in which to merge into, out of, or across this lane, rather than piling into it all at once. This picture doesn't show the full extent of the redesign, but the yellow highlighted part is the former problem lane. http://www.in.gov/indot/files/MPOICI69_NBInterchange_2012.JPG http://www.in.gov/indot/files/MPOICI69_NBInterchange_2012.JP... http://www.in.gov/indot/3071.htm http://www.in.gov/indot/3071.htm
- mchanson 12y agoI've never understood early merging. Why eliminate a lane of traffic before necessary.