4 ms·
I don't get it how a court can rule that a <natural fact> can be either true or false.
by tomp 12y ago
I don't get it how a court can rule that a <natural fact> can be either true or false.
- vidarh 12y agoIt doesn't. The court has ruled that for the purposes of the legal process involved, it is to be considered fact. All it means is that the court believes that the presented evidence meets the pre-requisite standard.
- rayiner 12y agoTo expand on your, correct, point, making findings of fact is a way to compartmentalize the aspects of reasoning that lead to a conclusion. If you've ever argued with someone, you know that disputes as to facts or reasoning get mixed together and continually rehashed. But disputes can be broken down into disagreements about what happened, and disagreements of what logically follows from certain premises. Then, resolving each of those disagreements individually, usually by weighing evidence against some standard, ensures forward progress towards a conclusion.
- jacquesm 12y agoIf you don't get that then you probably don't get how any court decision is ever possible. The correct interpretation of the headline is that the court found that the evidence documenting this particular fact is strong enough to support the decision to collapse the true/false options to just 'true'. Courts are messy, they deal with uncertainties all the time, so we ask them to clarify what their view is on the veracity of certain facts and the courts then rule based upon the evidence and their interpretation thereof and then we proceed from that new base of certainty. Of course courts err (miscarriages of justice) but this is a low enough incidence that we continue to believe that when a court rules something is 'true' that it did in fact happen. Tricky concept, courts! In the end it's still people and people make mistakes but these people are experts trained to sift fact from fiction.
- tomp 12y agoI understand how most court decisions are made, e.g. those involving legality (or morality) of some action. E.g. it's clear to me why a court could find it legal/illegal that the CIA had a jail in Poland. In this case, however, the court is deciding on facts. I guess what happened here, as vidarh's comment implies, is that the court had some indirect evidence presented, and based on that evidence, ruled that it is more likely than not that the CIA had a jail in Poland (and is concealing the real, definite evidence).
- tormeh 12y agoWell, courts have to decide who killed someone. That's a fact that needs to be decided upon.
- tomp 12y agoBut no one pretends that courts decide in the "fact" - they just determine who is "guilty" of murder. In the US, for example, you have to be certain up to the standard of "beyond reasonable doubt", but even that standard, albeit high, means that the court don't establish facts, but only what the fact is most likely to be.
- tormeh 12y agoHow can you be guilty of murder if you did not, in fact, kill the victim? Absolute certainty is an illusion. The word "fact" is never meant literally by people who've thought about the subject for a while.
- jokoon 12y agobecause a court opinion can't be dismissed, while a media one can.