5 ms·
"Value is subjective - so in the end, why would we rely on the government to establish value in the first place?" We don't. The government takes the logical p
by timr 17y ago
"Value is subjective - so in the end, why would we rely on the government to establish value in the first place?"
We don't. The government takes the logical position that all such internships are illegal, so regulators don't need to make that subjective judgment.
In this light, the answer to your second question is "yes" -- the government is erring on the side of worker safety. It's a judgment call, and you can disagree with it, but both sides of the debate have perfectly reasonable arguments.
- apotheon 17y agoI find it disturbing that when "both sides of the debate have perfectly reasonable arguments" the knee-jerk response is "Let's regulate the fuck out of it!"
- timr 17y agoIt's not a knee-jerk response. For future reference, a good indication of a knee-jerk response is a remark that reduces an opponent's arguments to seven-word soundbites involving profanity.
- apotheon 17y ago> It's not a knee-jerk response. How else would you describe a response that doesn't even take into account the possibility that one could avoid government regulation when there's apparently no solid proof that regulation is better than the lack of regulation? It sounds like a knee-jerk response to me. Why don't you default to "We shouldn't spend a bunch of extra money on regulation when we don't have any reason to believe regulation will help, or even won't hurt!" instead? If you have some meaningful, reasonable explanation for that choice, I guess I might have been mistaken about the idea that it's a knee-jerk response, but you haven't shared any reasons so far, and there aren't any obvious explanations for why wasting resources on regulation that might just make things worse is better than avoiding that regulation.
- timr 17y agoBeing "knee-jerk" means being reactionary and reckless, whereas I am making a single, limited argument: the law prohibits unpaid labor uniformly in all situations. It does not require a regulatory value judgment to make a decision. You may not like the values the law represents, but you can't attack its implementation as subjective.
- apotheon 17y agoAre you now saying that all you did in the first place is affirm that something exists -- something we all know already exists -- in the midst of discussion of whether it should exist? WTF is the point of that?
- cwan 17y ago"worker safety" - Huh? Where is the safety of the worker here being jeopardized? It's not perfectly reasonable to the person being denied the choice. Clearly for the employer, the task(s) aren't of sufficient value to pay for the work otherwise, if they couldn't get unpaid workers, they would just pay for it. Instead, banning the practice makes society tangibly worse off as the work on the margins isn't being performed and the next paid job the unpaid intern will get will likely be lower paid on average because they have less experience.
- rapind 17y agoIn some situations sure, I can agree with that. But to say it makes society tangibly worse I strongly disagree with because it assumes that all or at least most unpaid interships will benefit the internee. I don't think that's the case.
- cwan 17y agoThen why would an unpaid internee stay at their position if they didn't see any value to themselves? There generally is at least some value even if it's a line item on a resume (that can have significant cumulative value)
- rapind 17y agoSeriously? Have you never worked somewhere because you hoped it would pay off huge in the end, even though you had other and higher paying options? Just because a job is attractive, doesn't mean it's going to further your career or somehow increase your value. And if you can't pay the bills while you're pursuing it, who ends up paying? Not the company who got your hours for free.
- cwan 17y agoYes - but the point being presumably you wouldn't stay at that dead end unpaid position forever. As for the huge payoff in the end, that's sort of what entrepreneurship is as well - there's absolutely no certainty of a payoff but one does hope for it. Why would you take an unpaid internship though if there wasn't some expectation of "more"? If there is then yes, there's a value to that "option". But presumably this isn't the case in some job like telemarketing or other really marginal menial tasks that you might realize within the first couple weeks if not month of doing it?