4 ms·
A strange fact popped into my mind, after reading this story and remembering some comments on the "Turing deserves an apology" story. Many people will say that
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
A strange fact popped into my mind, after reading this story and remembering some comments on the "Turing deserves an apology" story.
Many people will say that two consenting adults have the right to do whatever they want in the privacy of their own bedroom. As soon as the act those adults want to do becomes nonsexual (e.g. an unpaid internship, unlicensed medicine), that principle goes out the window.
Very confusing.
- psranga 17y agoHmm, one is an equal partnership, the other isn't. The unpaid internship law serves to give some protections to the little guy. Btw, I really don't understand why a billionaire (?) can't afford to pay hourly minimum wages to a bunch of kids.
- masklinn 17y ago> Hmm, one is an equal partnership, the other isn't. Is it really? Is SM play "an equal partnership" between master and slave?
- tvon 17y agoUh, it's not like the "slave" is someone the "master" just kidnapped. It's an agreed upon situation with an established "safe word" the "slave" can utter at any time to stop whatever is happening.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoAn internship is just like that. The safe word is "I quit."
- tvon 17y agoI don't know what else I would expect from a thread that started on such an idiotic statement, but yes, you can say that sadomasochism and unpaid internships are similar in that you can get out of both of them by saying words.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThe point is that they are both activities engaged in by two consenting adults. It's a common belief that one is not the business of the state, but the other one is. My question: what are the exceptions to the "two consenting adults can do as they wish in privacy" rule?
- masklinn 17y ago> My question: what are the exceptions to the "two consenting adults can do as they wish in privacy" rule? (active) voluntary euthanasia is one, though I think it's legal in a pair of US states (Oregon since '94 and Washington since 2008).
- apotheon 17y agoI think he was talking about a "rule" of dominant ethics or morality, and not the law, with that question.
- masklinn 17y agoAn internship's precisely the same. It's an agreed upon situation with an established "safe word" the "intern" can utter at any time to stop whatever is happening.
- imp 17y agoHe probably didn't become a billionaire without trying to find ways to cut costs as much as possible. He's not running a charity.
- apotheon 17y ago> He's not running a charity. I think that's the problem -- people don't want him to help people if it's not a purely charitable effort, for some reason. If he actually derives material benefit from it, that makes him evil. I don't get that attitude, but for some reason that seems to be how people view it.
- electromagnetic 17y agoNo he's running a business with employees, some of which he isn't paying because they're 'interns'.
- dbul 17y agoI think it really depends on the industry. If someone had offered me an unpaid internship for coding at any point in my life I would have told them no because I am aware that I could easily earn money or I'd probably be better off contributing to an open source project. But consider the hypothetical in another industry. Someone gets a shot at an unpaid internship, they do really well, the company they are associated with gives them a recommendation, and immediately after the internship they get an offer for a position in that industry. Or: Someone does not get an internship, it is a competitive industry, the person ends up working an $8 / hr job for the next some odd years until they get an opening in the industry. It would seem the benefit to the unpaid intern could be greater than the benefit to the company. Of course, there is the scenario where the person becomes an entrepreneur.
- apotheon 17y agoCoding is a much different situation in many cases, specifically because of the availability of open source projects -- which serves the same purpose as an internship opportunity sometimes. Alas, there's no such thing as "open source development" in many industries. Even for programmers, though, open source development doesn't do everything an internship can do. In fact, some people have a really difficult time getting started contributing to an open source project without some experience working closely with other coders to learn something about collaborative workflow and code review (for instance). The exception to that is cases where someone lucks into having a local mentor to help get them over the bar to entry for open source contributions -- knowledge of how to review others' code, figure out how to improve on it, and produce patches for submission to the project.
- uopnuiyb 17y agoSimple solution - call the job a training course and charge the interns $10k to do it!
- apotheon 17y agoYou still wouldn't be allowed to have them do actually useful work for you.
- te_platt 17y agoWho are you to decide the partnership isn't equal? And just how does the internship law protect the little guy? By making sure she can't get valuable experience? Also, just because you don't understand why someone would offer an unpaid internship instead of a minimum wage job doesn't mean it's a bad idea. Should your ignorance be the basis of public policy? I don't mean to come across as rude but come on, I'm a grown adult and don't need or want your "protection".
- yummyfajitas 17y agoWhy is tracking game reports or driving trains unequal, but sex equal? Similarly, why is using sex toys equal, but using colonoscopes unequal? Maybe you could explain what you mean by "equal"?
- ahoyhere 17y agoEmployment is not a private act, it has huge social ramifications.
- kingkongrevenge 17y agoProcreation and norms of marriage and family have enormous social ramifications. There is no distinction.
- ahoyhere 17y agoI'm sorry, but the two have nothing to do with each other. And, honestly, I'm aghast to find such poor reasoning on HN. Employment shapes society. Employment pays taxes, puts rooves over people's heads, causes stress and worry (what if I lose my job!?), informs societal choices regarding basic social services (tied to company healthcare). Finally, employment is a public act because it is a market -- if Joe works for free, that creates market pressure for Tina to work for free, too. With the exception of (almost entirely illegal) sex trade... 1. Sex does not house people 2. Sex does not employ people 3. Joe doing it up the butt does not affect your ability to find a partner 4. Tina engaging in fellatio with her husband does not affect your ability to find a partner 5. Couples not having babies does not affect other couples' ability to have babies 6. None of this affects healthcare or taxes It's simple: it's not a market. That's why employment is a public act.
- apotheon 17y agoI don't know if you've noticed, but sex creates people.
- ahoyhere 17y agoThe sex acts that are considered illegal do not create people. Thus they have no greater impact than childless heterosexual couples who only have sex in the missionary position. Whether that childlessness is intentional or accidental is even more irrelevent. Moreover, spouses/sex partners and offspring are not half as fungible as employees. If Joe and Sue (or Bob and Brad) have a child, don't have a child, or adopt a child, that doesn't affect your ability to have a child or not, as you wish. Meanwhile, employing people for nothing does have an affect on the job market.
- cperciva 17y agounlicensed medicine That's completely different. The licensing of medical practitioners is not based on any notion of protecting society from deviant behaviour; it is based on the need to protect vulnerable individuals from fraud. I have no problem with consenting individuals engaging in sex acts or internships, with or without pay -- but I absolutely believe that fraud, in all its forms, should be illegal, since a fraudulent transaction is not one between truly consenting individuals.
- apotheon 17y agoOne need not be licensed to be honest.
- dasil003 17y agoOne need not keep their train ticket to have purchased one...
- apotheon 17y agoDo you think that refutes anything I said?
- cperciva 17y agoTrue, and one doesn't need a driver's license to know how to drive -- but a system of licensing is the most efficient way of verifying qualifications.
- req2 17y agoIn Illinois, you need a license to charge money to suggest where throw pillows should be placed; interior design is a licensed profession. A system of licensing is the most efficient way of verifying licenses. Licensing helps, but it can be abused. Unlicensed anything isn't necessarily a bad thing, and, legal and mental affairs notwithstanding, buyers should be able to choose between multiple options.
- apotheon 17y ago
- tvon 17y agoThe sexual options for two consenting adults are fairly limited compared to "everything else imaginable that is unrelated to having sex". I also don't see any connection between the two schools of thought, other than them both being things you've read recently. At least I've never seen a "CIVIL UNIONS ARE A CIVIL RIGHT, AND NO UNPAID INTERNSHIPS" sign.
- gabrielroth 17y agoUnder the 13th Amendment, you don't have the right to sell yourself into slavery in the United States. That is, you can't sign a contract under which I pay your family $n and in return you work for me under conditions of slavery. Prohibitions on unpaid labor are an extension of this restriction on your freedom to enter into contract of your own free will.
- cwan 17y agoHow is an unpaid internship anywhere close to being slavery? The unpaid intern can walk away at any time. Further, it's the choice of the unpaid intern - not their family as to whether or not to accept the choice.
- uopnuiyb 17y agoSo in a recession if GM/Boeing/Walmart demand that all new hires work for no pay for their first year 'as intern trainees' that would be OK? If they fire these people on day 364 and get new trainees next year - that would be ok?
- cwan 17y agoWould it surprise you to know that Walmart pays its entry level workers significantly higher than minimum wage? It's relevant because it shows companies like Walmart/Boeing/GM are not price setters / don't have as much control as you presume. Further, the "race to the bottom" in wages is often not desirable or in the interests of a firm. Sure I don't have a problem with the practice you describe, but I'm pretty sure they would being unable to find workers who care enough or are even productive and losing any good workers to others. The employment market doesn't operate in a vacuum.
- defen 17y agoWhy shouldn't they be allowed to? The hit to their reputation if they tried to pull a stunt like that would be far worse than the damage any law could do - they would never be able to hire new people again. You seem to presume that the law is the only thing keeping corporations in line.
- Confusion 17y agoMany people will say that two consenting adults have the right to do whatever they want in the privacy of their own bedroom In that case, both parties are natural persons, in complete freedom, entering into an agreement with each-other that is unlikely to have bad consequences for society. There is not need for government regulation. As soon as the act those adults want to do becomes nonsexual (e.g. an unpaid internship, unlicensed medicine), that principle goes out the window. Because in those cases, one of the parties is either not a natural person (but a company) or it's a natural person that performs specific actions that have a much larger chance of having bad consequences. Companies can only exist by the grace of government regulation. They can be extremely powerful and hence the government must protect its citizens against it's own creations. Government regulation is already the case. The first purpose of the government is to take care of issues we cannot individually handle. Judging who is fit to be a doctor and who isn't is one of them, as much as maintaining a police force is. Government regulation of this is part of its 'reason for being'.
- jamesbritt 17y ago" Judging who is fit to be a doctor and who isn't is one of them, as much as maintaining a police force is." Hardly. Individuals can very easily manage a police force. Look at Blackwater. The reason you might want the State involved in either of these is because you want it to have a monopoly. I really don't want competing police forces and armies. Having competing organizations that evaluated and licensed doctors might be a good thing.