4 ms·
"Your individual responses are not vehement; however, last time I looked you had > half the responses in this thread (needless to say all taking the same "side"
by jimbokun 17y ago
"Your individual responses are not vehement; however, last time I looked you had > half the responses in this thread (needless to say all taking the same "side"), which suggests that for whatever reason this is an issue you have strong feelings about."
Just because the counter arguments were so poorly argued. Much of the counter arguments were in the vein of "that guy doesn't think the Internet really changed people's lives, he's obviously an idiot" "Yeah, you are so right, he's obviously an idiot," instead of explaining ways in which the Internet has made QUALITATIVE improvements to people's lives compared to 1959.
You finally get to the point of arguing that the wide availability of air travel might be a qualitative improvement over what we had in 1959, but after much nattering on about fuel efficiency and social change that still doesn't change the fact that the experience of driving an automobile in 2009 is largely similar to that of 1959. I might even agree with you on the airlines point. What I object to is all of the "this guy is obviously an idiot" without citing any obvious counter examples to his real points. In my experience, Hacker News is usually better than that, with people employing bad arguments getting called out even by people who happen to agree with the opinions. That is not aimed exclusively at you, just the general tone of responses I was reading here.