5 ms·
Wayback Machine points to pro-Russia rebels in downing of MH17
- edward 12y agoYou can donate to the Internet Archive here: http://archive.org/donate/ http://archive.org/donate/
- HCIdivision17 12y agoIt's always worth a reminder that the Archive is run on donations, and is a rare, precious resource. Someday I hope it's use as an Internet log file of public record continues to help. Privacy is a big deal, but we also need to combat the memory hole effect. Hopefully a good balance can be struck!
- justincormack 12y agoPresumably google and bings records are already being examined by the FBI.
- bane 12y agoWhy was the previous thread about this killed? I know it's off topic for HN, but it is pretty major fucking news. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8049325 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8049325 edit honestly, if you're flagging this story, you may as well turn in your human card edit2 so this has stirred up something since I'm watching my karma flutter up and down like a butterfly's wings.
- quantized 12y agoIt's on topic with the Wayback Machine involvement.
- greglindahl 12y agoYes, and I'm glad that I was allowed to change the title of the article to indicate the reason why this is relevant to HN. Edit2: and now the title got reverted to the article title, which obscures what's interesting to HN readers. Oh well, inflexible policy in action. EDIT: Given the poor quality of the discussion, I now regret posting this link. Very little discussion of the Wayback machine and how this is a new and interesting way to collect information, and lots of off-topic stuff on the right to be forgotten or non-wayback-machine-related items about this incident.
- adobriyan 12y agoReminds me of 'add "over the Internet" and patent' tactics.
- dang 12y agoOk, we'll change the title back again. I don't think this thread was destined to be very substantive, though. The topic is too hot, for more than one meaning of "hot".
- greglindahl 12y agoThanks, dang. In hindsight, yeah, this was not a good thing to post, even if it is very interesting that the Wayback Machine can play this kind of role.
- dang 12y agoWe do sometimes edit mainstream press headlines to replace a generic phrase (like "web") with a technical name (in this case, "wayback machine" or maybe "internet archive") that HN readers are comfortable with. So your edit was fine. We just didn't notice that right away.
- wglb 12y agoI found this to be the most interesting posts on the subject.
- austenallred 12y agoThere were probably a half dozen of those today. The first one was here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8048083 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8048083
- bane 12y agoGeeze I've been visiting HN all day and didn't see this one. Was it pushed off the main page artificially?
- freehunter 12y agoVery easily flagged off the main page. Here's some folks discussing it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8048550 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8048550
- _delirium 12y agoMost off-topic major news ends up being flagged. There are two main pieces of world news today: 1) Malaysian airlines plane downed in Ukraine; and 2) Israel launches ground invasion of the Gaza strip. I would guess stories about either one are likely to be flagged here.
- bane 12y agoYeah, but you've been on here long enough to know that major off-topic news won't get flagged/will be forced up on the front page for a while. HN understands that sometimes our tech news bubble has to be popped with a little dose of the real world every once in a while. This isn't just a plane crash, this was an aircraft that was shot down while on a perfectly normal commercial flight between two major international hubs. This could have very serious, long-term global ramifications and every person who comes to HN should be aware it happened.
- fleitz 12y agoYou'd have to be living in a basement not to have heard of a major airliner being shot down.... oh wait...
- icebraining 12y agoIf someone lives in a hole so deep that they haven't heard about this, I'd say it won't make much of a difference for them. I haven't flagged this, but I think you're overestimating the importance of the presence of this story on HN.
- bane 12y agoThe value HN brings to a story like this is the in-depth, rational analysis that's much better than the news can muster. Already in the wayback thread on this, I've discovered a news tracking startup and an in depth discussion for people who take this exact flight and route. This wasn't a plane passing between Baghdad and Kabul or some similar dangerous route. There's been a couple of other flying related accidents today also. This is the notable one. If you take a plane frequently (like I expect lots of people here do), you'll probably be interested in this story and the kind of in-depth discussion that only HN can bring to bear on it. edit Just found out the relative of a person I know was on the plane and is now dead.
- ansimionescu 12y agoThis is the last straw. I'm done with this shitty community. Ciao
- aaron695 12y ago> honestly, if you're flagging this story, you may as well turn in your human card No a real human cares about the millions of human beings who die of simple diseases all the time that for starters we could personally donate too and save a few lives. And for seconds have a positive benefit raising awareness to . This story is pure voyeurism. We'll have no affect on knowing this stuff especially knowing it first. Which I have no problem with, it is very interesting to see what will happen. I upped it and found links in this thread very interesting. But no, it's nothing about being a good moral human being.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- austenallred 12y agoIt's interesting how the right to be forgotten seems so desirable, yet when something like this happens it's great that no one can cover up their tracks. Now the pro-Russian separists are trying to delete all sorts of info. We have this tweet about them getting a bunch of anti-aircraft missiles (http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:NF6E5FCKFNEJ:https://twitter.com/dnrpress/status/483248037629018112 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:NF6E5FC...), showing off their new toys (https://twitter.com/grasswire/status/489823087190224897/photo/1 https://twitter.com/grasswire/status/489823087190224897/phot...) and the most important one of the day of the rebel leader (or whoever manages his Vkontakte account) bragging about downing planes before he knew that one was civilian (http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?hl=en&q=cache%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fvk.com%2Fwall-57424472_7256 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?hl=en&q=cache%3...). The http://grasswire.com http://grasswire.com users keep finding more and more of these - It seems desirable that we can delete stuff online and have it go away, but sometimes the Streisand effect (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect) is a great thing.
- gwern 12y ago> It's interesting how the right to be forgotten seems so desirable, yet when something like this happens it's great that no one can cover up their tracks. Now the pro-Russian separists are trying to delete all sorts of info. Are war crimes what 'right to be forgotten' is all about?
- badkungfu 12y ago> Are war crimes what 'right to be forgotten' is all about? Of course not. I think OP is just pointing out that there are pros and cons. OTOH, if I were leading a technologically sophisticated country to war and had the ability, I might look for ways to make my opponent look bad- say, by posting to internet forums using their hacked accounts- and trust that the internet would not forget.
- happyscrappy 12y agoAnd how exactly would you get the video of the plane being shot down? The stupidity of the rebels is explanation enough.
- gwern 12y agoLook at how many versions the WM has for that page - this seems to be a case where the recently unveiled 'on demand' archiving may have massively paid off.
- klearvue 12y agoI was following the news from the conflict in Ukraine and when the plane got downed, pro-Russia rebels were celebrating all over the internet (thinking that they'd downed a Ukrainian supply plane). When it became obvious the plane was civilian, the celebratory posts and videos started to disappear with blazing speeds.
- jqm 12y ago"posts from pro-Russian rebels...on the internet..." You maybe mean posts ostensibly from pro-Russian rebels appearing on the internet?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nextstep 12y agoI don't think any of the passengers were from the US.
- lobster_johnson 12y ago"The State Department was trying to confirm reports that 23 Americans were aboard the downed aircraft, spokeswoman Jennifer Psaki said." (http://www.latimes.com/nation/politics/politicsnow/la-pn-missile-ukraine-malaysia-plane-20140717-story.html http://www.latimes.com/nation/politics/politicsnow/la-pn-mis...)
- nextstep 12y agoAnd once the US Dept. of State investigated, they discovered the 23 Americans claim to be false (but later one dual-national American was found to have boarded the flight): http://www.newrepublic.com/article/118762/false-report-23-americans-mh17-used-right-attack-obama http://www.newrepublic.com/article/118762/false-report-23-am...
- anigbrowl 12y agoBBC news quoted airport officials reporting 23 US citizens. Some US passports have also appeared in photographs purporting to be from the scene. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/malaysia-airlines-plane-crash-boeing-jet-carrying-295-people-crashes-in-ukraine-9612882.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/malaysia-airl...
- nextstep 12y agoYeah, those reports were wrong: http://www.newrepublic.com/article/118762/false-report-23-americans-mh17-used-right-attack-obama http://www.newrepublic.com/article/118762/false-report-23-am....
- dmix 12y agoThere are claims that the BUK was geolocated via video footage before the plane went down: https://twitter.com/djp3tros/status/489848712450277376 https://twitter.com/djp3tros/status/489848712450277376
- adobriyan 12y agoThere are also claims that UA was really trying to shoot Russian Plane #1 which was flying close to malaysian boeing both in time and space There are many claims.
- danmaz74 12y agoWhy on Earth would Ukraine try to shoot down Putin? To get absolutely sure they'll be annihilated by Russia??
- adobriyan 12y agoSince the beginning of the conflict UA did everything they can to provoke Russia into crossing border. Well, almost everything.
- bronson 12y agoA curious statement. How were they doing that? By letting the rebels take over their cities and airfields? By letting Russia have Crimea?
- adobriyan 12y agoPeople burned alive in Odessa. Many people (noncombatants) killed in Lugansk from BM-21 "Grad" bombings. Artillery shooting near UA-RU border, killing two soldiers. Shooting over cross-border stations while refugees were trying to escape into Russia. Many episodes. Kiev declared that 'terrorists' (familiar word, isn't it?) are in Lugansk and Donetsk and started shooting over whole population regardless.
- Torgo 12y agoDoes VK not block spiders like Facebook does? This makes a compelling case against Facebook's policies. If it had been posted only to a Facebook page, WM couldn't have archived it. Somebody else could have, but chances are they would be less impartial about the material they were scraping.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- abuddy 12y agoIt's a public page, not a profile. The posts are visible to everyone including web crawlers. (I'm using VK)
- VMG 12y agoVerifably timestamped information is becoming more and more important.
- dredmorbius 12y agoWorth noting that one of TIA's revenue sources is providing notarized sampled for court evidence. https://archive.org/legal/ https://archive.org/legal/
- cobrausn 12y agoWorth noting: Two days ago, an actual AN-26 cargo plane was shot down [1]. At the time, Ukraine assumed it had to be a Russian missile, because they did not think the rebels had the ability to shoot anything above a ceiling of about 2.5 kilometers. This seems to be confirming that the rebels are the ones doing the shooting. The intelligence agencies of the world are having a busy day, I'm sure. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/15/world/europe/ukrainian-military-plane-is-shot-down-as-russia-adds-to-presence-at-border.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/15/world/europe/ukrainian-mil...
- adobriyan 12y agoThis is just brilliant. AN-26 shooting, allegedly by rebels, proofs that malaysian boeing was shot by rebels. By that logic UA did this because it shot down russian civil plane in 2001, admitting it after months.
- cobrausn 12y agoYou have it backwards. All the piles of evidence that they shot down the MA flight indicate they probably also had the capability two days ago to shoot down the AN-26, and therefore probably did.
- adobriyan 12y agoUA has the very same capability since USSR days and therefore probably did.
- cobrausn 12y agoLet me spell it out for you then - Ukraine had no interest in shooting down it's own cargo plane. Russia would not likely risk firing a missile from within it's own territory. Who does that leave us? Maybe the people who claim ownership of the space, have the means, and are tweeting about their supposed AN-26 shootdowns? If this is trolling, it's bad trolling.
- leccine 12y agoThe also invented time machine: https://twitter.com/vesti_kpss/statuses/478926313831792640 https://twitter.com/vesti_kpss/statuses/478926313831792640
- eruditely 12y agoLet's not be blinded by bloodlust. Let me walk past all of the flamebait and caution that amateur detectives should heed caution before they start pointing fingers everywhere. This wouldn't be the first time that people were certain of guilt only to be demonstrated otherwise later. Let's not make people causalities until the dust settles at the very least.
- trekky1700 12y agoThere was also this news article from just before reports of the plane crashing arose. I noticed it this morning right away because they were in the same area at the same time on the same day. http://en.itar-tass.com/world/741164 http://en.itar-tass.com/world/741164
- st0p 12y agoAs someone who is working for one of the travelling agencies who had people on board (and I'm 99% sure one of my previous employers also had customers on that aircraft), could we please wait with all the speculation? Querying the database to see who might have been on board was no fun. I think that our customer rep's had an even harder time to answer questions. The suffering of relatives and friends must be much worse. I'm pretty sick of all the speculation in Dutch media right now, let's wait for some kind of official investigation and in the mean time light some candles for the deceased.
- funkyy 12y agoI wonder if we will witness first information and propaganda conflict between two super powers taking part in internet. This can be huge - apparently the ones responsible for the shooting will do everything they can to cover it up. Will Putin cut his ties off and leave Ukraine to itself or will he start his propaganda machine? Its a huge loss - people that have nothing to do with this conflict died just because they were in wrong place in wrong time...
- hugh4life 12y agoI don't want to get into the politics, but I wonder about the algorithm the Wayback Machine uses to decide what to cache and if intel agencies manipulate it so the WM can be used for PR purposes. "It is possible that the WM website could have been spoofed somehow to create these records, but it would not be easily done. To do so would either require hacking WM and creating the new records within its system, or spoofing the records by tricking WM into thinking it was accessing Girkin's page when it was actually accessing a third-party site. Both possibilities would be difficult to carry out." Would it really be that hard?
- jqm 12y agoTheir explanation seemed a bit too quick. And did I miss something or is there a reason the actual account couldn't possibly have been hacked or spoofed before being stored on wayback? No, I don't think it would really be that hard for an actor the size of... well, some of the parties involved in this debacle. The rebels probably accidentally shot the plane down. Most likely explanation. But, if someone tries to make hay with this event however, for example using it in public speeches to justify further military aid, advisers or intervention... I'm going to begin wondering about that.
- shmerl 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V5E8kDo2n6g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V5E8kDo2n6g