11 ms·
Yogscast Kickstarter failure is a painful reminder of the risks of crowdfunding
- Afforess 12y agoCaveat emptor. A rule of thumb I learned from my parents long ago is when you see something you want to have, wait two weeks. If you still want it in two weeks, and can afford it, then buy it. I suspect a little bit of waiting and research would have informed these backers to the potential disaster that was coming. I remember this kickstarter and I thought it was a joke, but the fans don't want to hear that.
- jiggy2011 12y agoI think the problem with game related kickstarters is that a lot of the backers are probably fairly young and have a poor understanding of the amount of resources and risk involved in a project of this size. To an 18 year old $0.5 mil sounds like a lot of money and it would seem like it should be possible to make 3 games with that much but they don't understand how quickly it can get swallowed up because they have limited experience with the business world.
- lotu 12y agoSo they spent $50 dollars to learn a life lesson. Honestly, that much cheaper than it could be. If the game designers were deliberately trying to exploit this then there would be a problem.
- darklajid 12y agoAnd here I stand, having just ordered a OnePlus One, after I forgot all about that thing until I got a 'Here is an _invitation_ to buy our product, valid for 24 hours' mail. I guess they succeeded to work around my own "Let me think about that" protection.
- tinco 12y agoSo 13.000 people risked $50, and they lost. This is a painful reminder? It's just $50, it's no ones livelihood except the that of the Winterkewl people. They thought they could do something, turns out they couldn't. Why does this author take offense to the tone? Isn't it clear as day? The game won't be made, so the backers won't get their reward. The studio did their best, but it wasn't enough so now they're stopping. Yes the Kickstarter says there should be a refund, but obviously the studio should have spend all of their money by now. That refund clause is just to make sure companies don't go taking money without being indebted to the backers if they fail. This one does go bankrupt, so everything is in good order. He says Yogscast and Winterkewl are to blame, what for? For attempting to do something cool for their fans but failing? There's no shame in that.
- beering 12y agoSo you're saying that if I overpromise something and get a bunch of people to give me money for it, I have an escape hatch to never repay the money? Then it's appealing to start some BS kickstarters, never deliver, and never refund the backers (and isn't that a problem already?). Is Yogscast to blame? Sure - they misled people into paying for overhyped vaporware by throwing their name on it. They also have the money to refund people, and right now they're trying to hang on to their money as tightly as they can.
- tinco 12y agoNo, because that would be mismanagement, it would make you liable for a lawsuit by the backers. The government would hold you personally responsible for the debt of your LLC and you might go to jail. There's no escape hatch, this is business. Yogscast has nothing to do with this endeavour, it's a separate LLC that attempted to make money. I don't see why Yogscast would not try to hang on to their money. They have mouths to feed as well don't they? I don't get why people are out for blood over $50 lost on a bet.
- smacktoward 12y ago> Yogscast has nothing to do with this endeavour, it's a separate LLC that attempted to make money As TFA notes, the entire Kickstarter page (https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/winterkewlgames/yogventures https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/winterkewlgames/yogvent...) is written from the perspective of Yogscast. "We feel incredibly lucky to have been given the opportunity to entertain you as we play games made by other people..." "Countless times we've felt limited by games and come across features we have wished we could change. 'Come On Blizz!' Simon would yell..." "Since we'll be helping to develop the game we'll be able to ask YOU the players what features you want and actually have them created..." "We aren't programmers or artists but luckily we have close friends at Winterkewl Games who are..." "We started concept work and pre-production during our trip to Los Angeles in October 2011..." "Winterkewl’s artists, modelers, animators and programmers are partnering with us on this project to create the game our community wants..." "We're truly honored to have the opportunity to bring the Yogscast to life in a game of our own making..." So it's not hard to see how people could have gotten the impression their involvement in the project would be deeper than "we handed it over to those guys, blame them."
- beering 12y agoI think this is ripe for a lawsuit if money is not refunded. You can name both Yogscast and Winterkewl in the suit knowing that Yogscast has enough money to pay damages. Yogscast would then try to get out of the suit, but it'd be tricky for them to shed their responsibility in the matter (which apparently they're trying very hard to do, according to the article).
- Navarr 12y agoI can't imagine that Yogscast HAS any responsibility in the matter, considering the kickstarter was run by "Winterkewl Games LLC" who was developing their first game "in partnership with Yogscast" Clearly they're the ones with the legal responsibility.
- beering 12y agoIn lawsuits, it doesn't really matter. You can name anyone and everyone who's connected to the matter, and then sort out who gets dropped from the suit in court. For example, if Yogscast was actually behind a lot of this, then it wouldn't be fair for them to hide behind a shell company that takes the blame. Otherwise you could just play a game of setting up little shell companies with no money, let them go bankrupt, etc.
- belandrew 12y agoKickstarter's terms are very clear that you may receive nothing in return for your money, just like with other investments.
- wisty 12y agoKickstart is very clear that if it falls through, then it's not Kickstarter's problem. The terms are very clear that there's a contract for the vendor to deliver or give a refund. There's certainly warnings that vendors can go bankrupt and leave you with nothing, and Kickstarter tries to ensure this won't be Kickstarter's problem. But the vendors have a contract to deliver or refund.
- VikingCoder 12y ago
- moosehawk 12y agoLewis from Yogscast had some responses on Reddit a couple days ago: http://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/2apng1/yogscast_cheat_backers_for_567000_on/cixkr3u?context=1 http://www.reddit.com/r/Games/comments/2apng1/yogscast_cheat...
- TheMakeA 12y agoThey should release the unfinished game and source code/assets to backers as a sort of liquidation.
- kjjw 12y agoI wonder why this isn't their first reaction. The game looked reasonably well fleshed out in their latest videos (they'd even been releasing demos and alphas.) Is it possible Winterkewl are holding on tight to the IP for some reason?
- Blaaguuu 12y agoI'm a little surprised this hasn't become an accepted practice yet... Tons of game developers fail to complete their projects for one reason or another, and the open-source scene for PC games is practically non-existent (actual games, not middle-ware). I wouldn't expect publishers to ever open-source unfinished games, but for indies that don't need to protect their IP, it seems like it would be a pretty great move to open-source your code and assets under a non-commercial license, if you can't complete a relatively mature project. It seems to me that it would be beneficial to everyone involved... but maybe I am missing something.
- brandoncapecci 12y agoIt's because so often they leave it reluctantly, hoping to finish it sometime in the future. I also think there's the gaming community in general has a culture that puts ideas on a pedestal as this great commodity that's inherently valuable.
- georgeecollins 12y agoI guess, but an unfinished game and source is pretty valueless. People who work on an unfinished think there work adds up to something valuable (an engine, some art) but I have seen people try to sell unfinsihed projects many times and they are almost never valuable. And they are only valuable when they come with a team that is passionate about continuing to work on them.
- 12y ago
- Glyptodon 12y agoI don't really have a problem with this. Kickstarter projects shouldn't lead to backer entitlement. Campaigns are a risk that everyone can pitch in a little for in the hopes of success. Pledge at an amount appropriate to risk and you'll lose the bet here and there, but it's part of the game.
- Cakez0r 12y agoKickstarter need to create rules that protect the backers who can't reasonably be expected to understand the risks. 1% of the project's funds could've paid for an industry expert to take a look at their project plan and tell you they are likely going to fail.
- BrainInAJar 12y agoKickstarter is an interest free business loan with absolutely no obligation to deliver or recourse if they do not. You'd have to be a damned fool to Kickstart anything for-profit, and people Kickstarting things think you're an idiot ripe for exploitation. If you want money to start a project take out a loan or sell equity.
- wangman 12y ago"The Yogscast's Yogventures was the first Kickstarter I ever saw that set off alarm bells in my head" What? Was this also the first Kickstarter the article author ever saw?
- steven2012 12y agoThe failure of these Kickstarter projects is several orders of magnitude less than what we will see when crowdfunding of startups hits full stride. It's a snakeoil salesman's wet dream, to be able to sell a great idea, "fail" and say "sorry, we tried". The only difference is that it will be 13,000 people losing $50 as opposed to a handful of rich people losing $1M each.
- whybroke 12y agoOne of the more interesting things is that the demos were almost entirely just the demo form a marching cubes package they bought on the Unity Asset store for $100 [1]. Even down to the textures. The only additional feature were the two rigged characters and a those few building meshes. The creator of that package, formerly an enthusiastic developer of a cool product, pulled his product from the asset store when yogcast's kickstarter hit half a million and apparently abandoned game development entirely. [1] http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/introducing-voxelform-voxel-terrain-marching-cubes-with-real-time-deformation.94224/ http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/introducing-voxelform-voxel...
- shinykitten 12y agoI skimmed through that thread. For those interested, here are the salient posts. Where winterkewl finds the package: http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/introducing-voxelform-voxel-terrain-marching-cubes-with-real-time-deformation.94224/page-6#post-823980 http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/introducing-voxelform-voxel... Where the creator acknowledges that winterkewl is using the package for the kickstarter campaign: http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/introducing-voxelform-voxel-terrain-marching-cubes-with-real-time-deformation.94224/page-7#post-893009 http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/introducing-voxelform-voxel... Here is where the creator pulls the package: http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/introducing-voxelform-voxel-terrain-marching-cubes-with-real-time-deformation.94224/page-7#post-928356 http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/introducing-voxelform-voxel...
- AlyssaRowan 12y agoEh, that's how it goes. Sometimes development pans out; sometimes, it falls flat. With crowdfunding, we the people get to choose what things we want instead of publishers - which does mean we take the risks in case it misses the mark, and that is a very real risk. I backed this one myself; a little bit, basically to see what happened. I like YOGS (back to when I played right alongside them on WoW, actually - small world!). They're always looking for another fun platform to play/tell stories with. The developer/s were inexperienced; although it wasn't quite clear just how green they were, I was aware that this one was looking a bit wobbly, as I'd never heard of them, and I was getting Molyneux vibes from the promises. After I saw the alpha and beta, it was clear Winterkewl just couldn't deliver the goods to anything resembling a reasonable quality, which is why Yogscast didn't feel comfortable really going forward with it like that any more. Pity about the lead dev's marriage. Isn't the first marriage killed by game development; won't be the last. Obviously the studio is bankrupt (or to the extent that it isn't, needs to refund). Interesting to see Yogscast did at least get the source and assets out of the ruins of this project (although they're not very good assets, unless you really want a dwarf beard simulator), and they seem to have some kind of rescue plan with another studio. Let's see what happens. I'm pretty sure no-one's swimming in half a million quids' worth of Jaffa cakes out of this one - but that's development. Sometimes it goes like this and goes nowhere. Sometimes (like Elite: Dangerous, which is turning out brilliant) it goes to the stars. I'm actually glad we can choose to take these risks with crowdfunding. Just, you know, remember it's not a pre-order.