5 ms·
Hacking goes squishy
- fgh 17y agoHmm, interesting, although I'm not sure that we're quite comfortable yet about GM here in Europe, especially for things that enter the food chain.
- biohacker42 17y agoI don't give a damn about food GM. It's not about feeding the hungry or helping the planet. That's the marketing speak. The reality is that it's hacking roundup resistant genes into crops so that you can (or have to) buy and spray MORE roundup. That's very good for Monsanto and DuPont's bottom line. GM work in industry, think bio manufacturing of industrial compounds, and obviously human health is absolutely worth pursuing.
- c3o 17y agoJust in case anyone from Vienna, Austria is reading this: There's a talk on exactly this topic at local hacker space Metalab tonight: http://metalab.at/wiki/Metaday_25 http://metalab.at/wiki/Metaday_25 [german]
- noverloop 17y agoreminds me of "Our Neural Chernobyl" by Bruce Sterling http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hackers_(anthology)#.22Our_Neural_Chernobyl.22 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hackers_(anthology)#.22Our_Neur...
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoArticle concerns biohacking particularly manipulating living organisms - could HN have some editorial system to ensure articles posted have a proper descriptive title or maybe a categorisation system.
- gehant 17y agoSquishy was a pretty good indicator that it wasn't going to be your typical hacking article IMO... But if you are insinuating that biohacking is not relevant: http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoNo insinuation. Squishy suggested it may not be programming, but there's no reason why it couldn't be a neologism or brand name in that field.
- gehant 17y agoah, I didn't think about that possibility - so that means it's still yours for the taking Although I love the economist, I find they tend to touch upon computer technology less frequently as compared to the natural sciences
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoThere's an article in Compute! from July 1991 that uses the term "squishy" to describe technology with a natural feel - soft buttons, rounded corners, etc. (I'm thinking Existenz!).
- anigbrowl 17y agoI had no difficulty guessing the content from the title, and the Economist (which chose the title) has quite a good editorial system already.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoYou guessed merely from the term "squishy" that it concerned moving towards low-cost of access to bioengineering DNA enabling non-professionals to participate? That's a pretty good guess IMO, so good that I think you're lying. The Economist have a good editorial system but they don't choose the title simply to inform. I thought that part of the HN ethos was presenting useful information in a succinct way avoiding cruft and unnecessary marketing tactics. An uninformative title is a marketing tactic designed to get you to see adverts around an article that you wouldn't otherwise have perused - that presumably is why the Economist chose that title (yes also to be mildly entertaining and close enough to the subject to avoid alienating users).
- anigbrowl 17y agoNo, I guessed it from a decade's worth of familiarity with the Economist's editorial flavor, their regular coverage of bioengineering trends, and a number of other contextual factors. Please consider similar possibilities next time someone disagrees with you, instead of denigrating their character.
- pbhjpbhj 17y ago"I had no difficulty guessing the content from the title" - OK you might feel "lied" is a bit strong but you didn't guess from the title _alone_, lets say you bent the truth - you used other information, a background of knowledge of the types of articles in the publication mentioned along with information about their titling techniques, to have a guess. My original point was that the HN title was poor as an indicator of the material in the article. You've just proved my point - if you had never read the Economist could you have guessed the field of the article? "Hacking goes squishy" I stand by my assertion that this is a poor title and that no-one could derive the subject matter of the article from the title itself - one might get "biology" from "squishy" but I don't think you could really go any further. It could equally well be use of a new cooling technique to make syrup-and-ice drinks have improved mouth feel.
- mustpax 17y agoThis might be the first time I've seen a mainstream news publication use the work "hacking" to mean something other than "criminal subversion of computer systems." And we're talking Economist here, not Wired or another geeky outlet.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoTrue, but they used it a little too often in the sense of "amateur", which doesn't do justice to what hackers are in computing today. In biohacking it's a different matter in 2009.
- anigbrowl 17y agoamateur is one who loves a particular activity; doing something for nothing is a matter of choice, not of inability.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoOf course, but I think most hackers nowadays are not amateurs.
- biohacker42 17y agoBut the FBI may genuinely be wary of biohackers Obviously, the government has never seen any invention it's not scared of. This goes all the way back to the steam engine. Before anyone here dredges out the old tired super virus or gray goo. There's no such thing as gray goo and never will be because you'd have to violate the fundamental laws of thermodynamics to get it. There are plenty of super viruses and bacteria in nature. Neither HIV nor MRSA came from biohacking. As I have said before, anything we create would be like just one more bullet in a machine gun shootout. Sure it could be the one that gets you, but then again, there's an infinity of stuff out there that can also get you.
- darien 17y agoI think it was stephen hawking who said that the only way for humans to ensure their salvation from man-made super viruses in the next 100 years would be to colonize space. Outrageous? Sure, but so is cancer, atomic energy and quatum entanglement.
- asdlfj2sd33 17y agoI think that was more of hard sell for space exploration then a warning against super viruses.
- steveklabnik 17y ago> There's no such thing as gray goo and never will be because you'd have to violate the fundamental laws of thermodynamics to get it. As someone who only heard of "grey goo" very recently, care to explain why this is the case?
- asdlfj2sd33 17y agoIn one way gray goo already exists. The world is literally covered in tiny nano machines eating and multiplying as fast as they can. And many of them are deadly to us. We call them bacteria and fungi. "grey goo" beyond the natural goo, as often seen in fiction, multiplies and moves so fast as to violate basic laws of physics. For example there's only so much energy stored in stuff that could be eaten.
- Locke1689 17y agoThat is one freaky picture. http://media.economist.com/images/20090905/D3609TQ7.jpg http://media.economist.com/images/20090905/D3609TQ7.jpg