6 ms·
IBM announces $3B research initiative
- chm 12y agoIn what countries will they spend the money? Who can apply for grants?
- anigbrowl 12y agoA reasonable question; I don't know why you were downvoted. Per the article, the spending will be in the US and Europe, but I don't know which European countries. If you're engaged in research then your best bet would be to contact them through your institution.
- chm 12y agoI am beginning my studies (2nd year MSc) but my professor might be interested!
- akuma73 12y agoThe end of Moore's Law will have profound effects on the entire technology industry. What happens when computers stop getting faster? There's no obvious successor to CMOS on the foreseeable horizon, so it's good to see that IBM and others are searching for solutions.
- eru 12y agoMoore's Law is not about speed per se. It's about transistor count on the chip that is cheapest per transistor. (If memory serves right.)
- boyaka 12y agoThe reason Moore's law worked so well is largely because of this. When we began creating transistors on integrated circuits, the only thing preventing us from making them exactly as small as they are today were things like cost and the capabilities of fabs to make them reliable and stable. So ever since we started making them we've stepped down the size by about half, rather than something smaller that would be more difficult and expensive to make. The entire manufacturing industry gradually became more efficient, increasing reliability and reducing the cost of fabricating the integrated circuits. The history of performance speedup hasn't been solely due to doubling the transistors. Other types of architectural improvements in memory, buses, parallelism, multiple cores/threads have yielded performance doubling or more. Memory access has always been a huge latency and there are lots of ways to improve that without just making the transistors smaller. We have a lot of work to do still! The majority of our computing has been on the x86 architecture, which basically stems from the 8080 which was designed in the mid 70s. We can still discover new and better architectures and materials. It's just the standard shrinkage of IC's that was the basis of Moore's Law originally has reached its limits.
- wmf 12y agoThat's also ending, as transistors will not get cheaper and chips will probably not get larger in the future.
- tedsanders 12y agoI envision competition between a few forces: (1) As the ROI on R&D falls, R&D will be drastically cut and the industry will become even more commoditized. Less R&D spending means chips get cheaper. (2) Capital equipment will last longer because it won't need to be replaced with new versions every couple years. Fewer equipment purchases means chips get cheaper. (3) As performance/$ wanes, demand will fall in the short term. At first prices may crash if capacity is overbuilt, but in the medium term, production will stabilize at a smaller level than before. Because of economies of scale, prices will be higher at this smaller scale. (I believe this is what happened to the RAM market a few years ago.) This force may cause chip prices to rise. (4) As software continues to improve, the value of chips will rise, even as the chips themselves stagnate. This will cause the market to grow, and economies of scale will drive prices down. (5) As has been happening for years, the industry will continue to consolidate. Less competition between producers will mean higher profit margins and higher prices. Overall, (1), (2), and (4) will lower chip prices and (3) and (5) will raise chip prices. But I think the overall trend will be lower prices, though perhaps not as the drastic rate to which we've become accustomed.
- weland 12y ago> As software continues to improve That's a fairly big assumption.
- dsuth 12y agoSoftware optimisation will become important again.
- islon 12y agoWhat do you mean "again"?
- saltvedt 12y agoIt doesn't seem to be important now. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth's_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wirth's_law
- bane 12y agoEven if you make particularly efficient code, the giant tower of abstractions we all operate on top of make running your code dozens of times slower than it could possibly be running on bare metal.
- mikepurvis 12y agoThe most interesting piece of this puzzle to me is initiatives like MirageOS, which let you run your application very close to the metal—you give up a lot of convenience when you dump the traditional OS, but you give up a lot of inefficiency, too.
- wmf 12y agoOr you could keep the convenience while dumping the overhead by using Docker. As a bonus you also get to be cool.
- mikepurvis 12y agoDocker is still a full Linux kernel. The point of MirageOS is that your app is the kernel.
- eru 12y ago
- annnnd 12y ago> What happens when computers stop getting faster? Software will have to stop getting slower. >;-)
- agumonkey 12y agoDecrease in progress in CMOS will diffuse as pressure in other areas, new materials, new techniques, new structures, new software paradigms... or maybe just different usage. Do we really need that much computing power ? It's slightly ranty but not entirely. First spreadsheets were used to fit in 64k. For the average user an old laptop would do fine, in that area progress is self fulfilling marketing prophecy. For enterprises .. maybe (the few I worked at had very low grade network and database infrastructure, so opportunity to evolve) Hard science and medicine, they deserve smart and fast tech.
- NamTaf 12y agoInteresting. The article makes the following claim: As the leader in advanced schemes that point beyond traditional silicon-based computing, IBM holds over 500 patents for technologies that will drive advancements at 7nm and beyond silicon — more than twice the nearest competitor. I would have guessed that Intel was the big player here in the low-level hardware space. What has put IBM at that position, besides sheer age?
- arjn 12y agoIntel is the big player in that space.
- Hermel 12y agoFundamental research. For example, Karl Alex Müller discovered super-conductivity while working at IBM's Swiss research lab and later won the Nobel prize for that (http://www.uzh.ch/about/portrait/nobelprize_en.html http://www.uzh.ch/about/portrait/nobelprize_en.html). Also, they invented the scanning electron microscope, along with other discoveries relevant at nano-scale. IBM is one of the very few companies that does fundamental research with a time-horizon of decades, and not just one product cycle.
- NamTaf 12y agoThanks for the detailed info! Really appreciated :)
- selimthegrim 12y agoYou mean _high-temperature_ superconductivity. The regular stuff has been known since the turn of the 20th century. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heike_Kamerlingh_Onnes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heike_Kamerlingh_Onnes
- nl 12y agoIBM does a lot of basic research. Intel and IBM have a long standing patent cross-licensing arrangement in place.
- jmspring 12y agoIBM has traditionally had a lot of very strong research labs including IBM Almaden. That said, they also have a reputation for driving out relations with academics and local researchers in the name of "budget" -- very similar to the overall outsourcing regiment Cringely has outlined. I'd like to know which of the labs are getting this money and what hiring they are doing contrasted with any downsizing they previously did.
- gaze 12y agoYeah I dunno what's up with quantum computing. DiVincenzo isn't there any more.
- z3phyr 12y agoThey are looking for Digital Nurosynaptic solutions. Traditionally it has been Analog. Can someone explain how would it work out?
- boyaka 12y agopulses? I typed it into google and found this: http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/login.jsp?tp=&arnumber=5976989&url=http%3A%2F%2Fieeexplore.ieee.org%2Fxpls%2Fabs_all.jsp%3Farnumber%3D5976989 http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/login.jsp?tp=&arnumber=597698...
- aidenn0 12y agoI don't know this in particular, but these days just about any analog circuit can be implemented in digital with better resolution, smaller die area, and lower power consumption. (In analog domain, your resolution is limited by SNR, in digital, it's limited by number of bits).
- marcosdumay 12y agoExcept for digital to analog, and analog to digital conversors. As far as I know, our neurons are belived to have analogic interfaces, thus they could not be interfaced by a digital circuit. If somebody found out that they are digital, that'd be very newsworth, at least for me.
- skrebbel 12y agoMy pet theory is that IBM's goal is to make lots of money with boring IT consultancy so they can spend it all on fun fundamental research.
- porlw 12y agoMaybe Google should buy IBM.
- capkutay 12y agoDoes google have $200b in cash?
- skrebbel 12y ago(oh, and, the pet theory also includes occult Illuminati-ish inauguration rituals for C-level executives. "swear to $DEITY that you will spend lots of dough on fun fundamental research or forever stay the meager mid-level manager you are". Candles, catacombs, robes, distant humming male background choir, that sort of stuff) (they'll keep the shareholders in check by a mixture of nonsense and honesty about why IBM really needs to do so much fun fundamental research. if all C-level people talk the talk the same, and otherwise don't suck at what they do, then i bet they can keep the shareholders from getting all too grumpy about spending $3B on something that might pay off in 20 years, maybe)
- xienze 12y agoNo, their goal is to make lots of money with boring IT consultancy so they can plow it back into stock buybacks and other financial engineering tricks.
- Keyframe 12y agoI've been following this topic for quite some time. Probably because I always wanted to be an EE/HPC engineer, but never was. When you listen to what guys from IBM, Intel, Applied Materials etc. have to say, then it seems that 5nm will probably be the last silicon based process. III-V (Boron, Nitrogen group) type of materials will then be next, with most likely candidate being GaAs (Gallium arsenide) which is already being used in niche productions. What is more interesting than semiconductor base used is lithography process. Deep UV (immersion, using refraction of medium such as water) lithography currently used is showing its limits for ever smaller features. So, they came up with Extreme UV lithography which uses mirrors to project features onto surface, because at that short wavelength everything is opaque. Applied materials has a machine with EUVL apparently (there is one on their site and a nice video with description) as well as ASML (their machine reportedly costs $88 million). There is a probability that with new semiconductor base (group III-V) there will be a reset back to 22nm or similar and a race down to bottom once again. We'll see.
- skaevola 12y agoSemiconductor processing is amazing technology. A quote you'll hear in these circles: "Gallium arsenide is the material of the future and will always remain so"
- Keyframe 12y agoHah, I've heard that! It's a really interesting field that blends physics, maths, chemistry, electronic and electrical engineering, computer science and other fields. Really amazing even to the outsiders like me, and it's not too hard to follow.
- doctorcroc 12y agoOne of the cooler research topics going on now is the use of block copolymers for even more precise lithography, at the nano-scale. Really interesting stuff!
- typon 12y agoGaN, SiC and Diamond are also very good candidate materials. Also don't forget multi-patterning, which is what has allowed us to get to 14nm in the first place. I reckon Intel will ditch their immersion lithography which they love so dearly and move on to other techniques, which is when I will actually get excited about these techniques. X-Ray Lithography is also being investigated and seems to hold some promise. The crazy thing about all these advancements is that no one knows what the future will hold, and right now we are essentially living under a renaissance era, witnessing the death of Silicon. I just hope the stuff I'm working on succeeds so I can make that cash money.
- magic_man 12y agoIBM just did massive layoffs in hardware. I used to visit essex junction plant a bunch and they had a lot of layoffs there. I don't know how much commitment Management there has toward hardware.
- johnward 12y agoThere is probably more interest in developing the technology and then licensing it. It seems like IBM doesn't want to be in the hardware market unless it's high margin.
- capkutay 12y agoThere's so much hype over big data, analytics, machine learning, predictive analytics etc. In silicon valley, we're predisposed to think this disruption is the result of startups, tech companies (google/yahoo certainly get a lot of credit), and top engineering universities. But the truth is the only company effectively doing, and more importantly, selling this stuff at scale is IBM. Everyone in the data management space is hoping to get just a piece of IBM's pie. While we talk about the latest updates in hadoop and spark, IBM is closing $50m deals with telcos, banks, and governments all over the world. If you're a startup in analytics and you don't think of IBM as a competitor, you're probably naive or your market isn't big enough.
- yeukhon 12y agoI think the strategy is not to compete with IBM at first and there are plenty of potential clients out there. Banks and big government won't switch to trust a startup after working with IBM for twenty years. The risk of a failing startup and buyout is a real risk. Even should you do such transition, it will take a long time. Maybe for small components you can switch within months. I like PG's advise to startup founders: go out there, sell your product, do the necessary customer supports (do demo, train users, troubleshoot, etc) and stop the hype because big companies like IBM and VMWare can sell their product with ease. I think the right attitude is to start small, build the reputation and make progress.