4 ms·
Jack is not upset because he couldn't buy the shares at the price he wanted. He is upset because someone was offering shares at a specific price, and Jack was
by rahimnathwani 12y ago
Jack is not upset because he couldn't buy the shares at the price he wanted. He is upset because someone was offering shares at a specific price, and Jack was willing to pay that price, but the order was not executed. The reason the order was not executed is not because someone else accepted the offer before him, or because Jill cancelled before he tried to accept. It was because Jill was able to see his acceptance in transit and cancel part of her offer as a result of this new information. This isn't how markets are supposed to work. If Jill had posted a single offer for half the number of shares that Jack wanted, it would be different.
Someone shouldn't need to use Thor or some other delaying mechanism to accept open offers. The latency between different exchanges (which was exploited in this example) does nothing to increase market efficiency.
You're right that I shouldn't care about this as a practical matter, as the impact on me is very small, but that doesn't mean it's right.
I really appreciate the clarity in your comments on this thread.
- throwaway283719 12y agoHere is our point of disagreement, then - I think that this is exactly how markets are supposed to work (in the presence of multiple exchanges). The job of a market maker is to supply liquidity at a price/risk tradeoff that is reasonable to them, subject to the information available to them. If there are multiple exchanges, and someone trades with them on one exchange, then the set of information available to them has changed (specifically, their knowledge of the supply/demand balance for a particular stock has changed). It's only natural that they will want to change their prices in response. Now, we could change legislation to either (a) go back to having a single exchange or (b) restricting the ability of market makers to move their quotes on one exchange if they trade on another. But that won't necessarily result in a better deal for non-market makers, because instead of quoting 20,000 shares split across 4 exchanges, the market maker now quotes 5,000 shares on 1 exchange. The benefit is that all market participants have a more accurate idea of the true liquidity available in the market. The disadvantage is that you have removed the element of competition between exchanges, so the exchange is no longer incentivized to offer low fees and keep improving its service.
- _delirium 12y agoDo you have opinions about a third proposal that's occasionally floated, (c) discretize the market's timeline to something smallish but not miniscule? For example, the market maker can move their quotes however often they want, but changes take effect on the next tick, which happens every (say) 1 second. So therefore you can't trade on advance knowledge in the sub-second range, and market makers can't gain a trading advantage vis-a-vis investors solely by having a slightly lower latency connection to the exchange. It's possible there's some massive downside to that, but afaict the advantages of liquidity that market-makers provide mostly accrue at larger timescales. So it's not clear the millisecond-shaving game is really improving markets (though it provides interesting challenges for technologists).
- kasey_junk 12y agoHow do you pick the timeframe? Seconds are still too fast for humans. Minutes would be too fast for people who are not professional traders, hours would be too fast for people who can't be near a computer all day. There is always a locality advantage in the market, this has been true as long as there have been markets, and it will be true forever. Why do we as market participants care? The other problem with your scenario is that you make market making more risky. The riskier it is, the higher the profits must be. This means that the market makers must keep the bid/ask spread higher (their means of making a profit). This cascades to all of us in the form of higher execution costs.
- _delirium 12y ago> The other problem with your scenario is that you make market making more risky. The problem with the current scenario is that it makes market making more expensive, as it requires a lot of technological investment into the microsecond arms race. This means the market makers must pull in more revenue from their trading to cover these expenses, before they even get to thinking about making a profit. This cascades to all of us in the form of higher execution costs. The huge amount of money being spent on HFT infrastructure, software development, etc. is ultimately being paid by market participants. It's worth considering if this is an arms race worth funding to the max, or if 99% of the benefits could be had much more cheaply just by putting a floor on execution latency, thereby rendering this whole millisecond-shaving industry unnecessary. At the very least, I'd be interested in seeing rigorous models that show a benefit to, say, markets that can trade at 1-microsecond granularity vs. 1-millisecond vs. 1-second.