11 ms·
I really don't want to be negative, but I also really don't see the point. Cheaply and quickly producing basic single-sided PCBs really isn't hard. Photochemic
by jdietrich 12y ago
I really don't want to be negative, but I also really don't see the point.
Cheaply and quickly producing basic single-sided PCBs really isn't hard. Photochemical etching can be done with $100 worth of equipment, a couple of feet of bench space and a little practice. Using a $3500 machine to produce poorer quality boards doesn't make much sense to me. Likewise, the pick & place functionality just isn't very useful in producing prototypes - the setup time will be equal to or greater than placing the components by hand with tweezers.
There are a swathe of recent projects based on conductive ink, but I don't think that they are solving a real problem. I use PCB fabrication services because I need soldermask and through-hole plating, not because photoetch is particularly inconvenient. Someone downthread discusses the problem of printing resolution and fine-pitch parts, but that's really a secondary issue. Without soldermask, it is very difficult to get good joints without bridging on fine-pitch ICs; Without plated vias, it is extremely difficult to route traces for even a relatively simple SMD IC, let alone a BGA.
The boards shown in their publicity materials are trivial and would be easily prototyped using veroboard. I believe that represents the limit of their technology. I can just about see a niche for their product in education, but even that is quite tenuous; The throughput of this machine is likely to be a major bottleneck in a classroom setting versus etching 30 boards on the same panel. I learned to etch PCBs in secondary school, and the process is now much cleaner and safer thanks to modern etchants. Three bubble tanks and a UV box cost considerably less than $3500 and are far more reliable than any CNC machine.
If photochemical etching isn't an option for some reason, you can buy a basic CNC router for far less than $3500, which can produce good basic PCBs while also taking on a vast range of other tasks.
Frankly, the whole effort smacks of "3D printing" hype. There seems to be a generation of designers who have a nozzle-shaped hammer and see everything as an additively-manufactured nail. There are some compelling applications for additive manufacturing, but it is by no means a silver bullet.
- ilaksh 12y agoWhere do I buy the photoetch machine and is there an easy way to use it? It is automated based on plan files you give it? I can see how someone who is familiar with placing electronic components would be sceptical of waiting a long time. But if there is a convenient setup even a slow automated placer would help me since I am not familiar with electronics or have steady hands. Are there automated pick and place machines that are general purpose? I think if you take this concept and improve the speed and capabilities then you can replace a lot of human labor.
- jdietrich 12y ago>Where do I buy the photoetch machine and is there an easy way to use it? There's no special machinery necessary, and it's so easy that a child can do it. The technique involves applying a resist material to the copper-clad board where traces are needed, then using a corrosive liquid to etch away the unwanted copper. Simple PCB etching requires only a plastic tray, a couple of bottles of chemicals, an ordinary clothes iron, a blank copper-clad board and access to a laser printer or photocopier. A slightly more advanced method requires a UV exposure box, which can be bought for as little as $100. There are dozens of excellent tutorials available, just search online for "PCB etching". Pick-and-place machines work fantastically well in production quantities, where components are supplied on tape reels that can be automatically fed into the machine. In small quantities, correctly aligning the components is a major problem, requiring either a great deal of human labour or a very sophisticated machine vision system and a complex multi-axis CNC machine. Placing SMD components by hand is a fiddly but simple job, especially with the aid of a magnifying lens. For experimental and prototyping purposes it often makes more sense to use through-hole components, which are somewhat bulkier but much easier to handle. Through-hole components can be used with solderless breadboard or veroboard, which allow you to build and test circuits without producing a PCB.
- altcognito 12y ago> and it's so easy that a child can do it. ... > then using a corrosive liquid to etch away the unwanted copper Do I then dump the wastewater into the stream in the backyard?
- jdietrich 12y agoFerric chloride etchant can be safely poured down the drain if it is neutralised with washing soda and filtered to remove the precipitated copper. Alternatively, it can be mixed with a proprietary neutralising compound and disposed of as solid waste. The etchant itself is quite harmless; It is the copper ions which pose an environmental hazard. Many alternative etchants (e.g. cupric chloride) have an indefinite working life and so pose no disposal issues.
- Osmium 12y agoI can't speak for this specific solution, but veroboard drives me (personally) bonkers and it's not enough of a hobby for me to justify investing in photochemical etchers. Being able to design a project on a computer, and get a PCB for a few dollars, would be great. I'd definitely play around with electronics projects a lot more if I could do more prototyping on a computer. The other thing that would be great is something like a Shapeways for PCBs. People could upload their own projects, then they print the PCB for you (and even ship you a bag of components), for you to build yourself.
- jdietrich 12y ago>The other thing that would be great is something like a Shapeways for PCBs. The service already exists. Numerous companies will produce small quantities (>5) of a PCB design from a Gerber file at a reasonable price and many will also do assembly. Prices vary depending on quantity and lead time; Amongst the cheapest are Itead, who offer ten 5x5cm PCBs (two-layer, with soldermask and silkscreen) for $14 shipped. The main reason to etch your own boards is lead time, as it can take a week or two (plus shipping from China). European and American PCB houses can turn around boards in as little as 24 hours, but at much greater cost. http://imall.iteadstudio.com/open-pcb/pcb-prototyping.html http://imall.iteadstudio.com/open-pcb/pcb-prototyping.html