4 ms·
The Pi would be infititely more useful to me if the ethernet interface was attached to a "real" bus and not hung on USB. Here's to hoping that will be the next
by xorcist 12y ago
The Pi would be infititely more useful to me if the ethernet interface was attached to a "real" bus and not hung on USB. Here's to hoping that will be the next upgrade!
- egeozcan 12y agoI agree, and bet it would also reduce power consumption even further because of higher efficiency. Does anyone know if they use the USB bus because of the space constraints?
- copperx 12y agoCould you explain why would it be better for you?
- xorcist 12y agoBascially performance, one way or the other. Ethernet over USB is terribly CPU and power ineffective. I've also found the Ethernet to be a bit wonky (I suspect sleep mode issues) so I suspect reliability could be improved as a bonus.
- xiaomai 12y agoWhat's the implication of being on the same bus? More CPU usage for ethernet?
- TorKlingberg 12y agoDoes the chipset support a "real" bus?
- pja 12y agoWhich bus exactly? Reading the BCM2835 datasheet ( http://www.raspberrypi.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/BCM2835-ARM-Peripherals.pdf http://www.raspberrypi.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/BCM283... ) the chip has a couple of UARTS, 2 SPI interfaces and a USB interface. The only interface that can do DMA is the USB one. All the others have relatively small FIFO buffers and require the CPU to do all the I/O work. So you could attach an ethernet interface to one of the SPI buses, or bit bang a few GPIOs but surely the CPU load is going to be painful? Edit: Oh wait, there's a main SPI bus that can do DMA as well. See page 148 on the doc linked above. If you can find a suitable chipset & driver then have at it :)
- userbinator 12y agoThe internal bus - AMBA/AXI/etc., so it's basically another peripheral block the CPU can access directly. (That datasheet is also very incomplete - there's lots of other interesting stuff in the SoC like the MIPI CSI/DSI interface, and if you felt perverse enough and had the right skillset you might be able to get Ethernet-like data transfer out of one of those...)
- someperson 12y agoSome people appear to have used the SPI bus to attach a new Ethernet port to a Raspberry Pi: http://www.raspberrypi.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=44&t=18397 http://www.raspberrypi.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=44&t=18397
- Quequau 12y agoI agree and it isn't just the RPi that is like this... it's every board based on an ARM SoC that was designed for a mobile device like a smart phone.
- Alupis 12y agoSwitching to another (faster) bus won't necessarily improve anything. You have CPU overhead to contend with, as well as relatively slow I/O on the SD card. So, just because the port is moved to a faster bus and could support GbE, doesn't mean you would get GbE performance. Your home network is likely already faster than the Pi can handle, let alone your internet speed. A file transfer across your network (scp a video to the SD cart for example) will already burst, then slow down as-is. You can see, the SD cart write i/o is the current bottleneck.
- xorcist 12y agoThere is lots of competition in this space. The obvious contender is the Beaglebone which has "real" Ethernet (among many other things).