5 ms·
I find myself wondering about trees: what happens if you "slide" back in time, then create a "new timeline" from that point in the history? Does it get appended
by barrkel 17y ago
I find myself wondering about trees: what happens if you "slide" back in time, then create a "new timeline" from that point in the history? Does it get appended to the current timeline?
Is it all strictly online? If it also works offline on the client, how does it deal with synchronizing multiple "timelines" created by copying the saved file?
- mcav 17y agoIt looks like it only lets you browse history linearly, rather than edit and branch. (If you can, it isn't immediately obvious.) They say "With our new Time-Slider, you can browse the complete history of a document using a familiar user interface." (emphasis mine) It says nothing about editing.
- joe_the_user 17y agoThe nice way would be to have this work complete independently of undo, so an undo and edit would look like further edits to the machine. But it seem unlikely the edits you did last week between revision 2.3 and revision 2.4 would especially interesting to look at. Perhaps yesterday's edits would useful... What I would like would be an editor which would go-back only on a given selection (cutting and pasting would make implementing such a feature hard but git because clever things...).
- thorax 17y agoThis is actually what I've always wanted in a browser. An intuitive way to do Back/Forward that handles multiple branches. :( I'm really surprised someone hasn't done something good with this in a major browser.
- snprbob86 17y agoI haven't tried it, but a quick search turned up this Firefox extension, History Tree: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/13316 https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/13316
- chriseppstein 17y agoI came here to say that. When I go back in my browser, I want it to show me the site I was looking at scrolled to where I was scrolled in the tab I was looking at.
- ori_b 17y agoWhy leave your browser at all, in that case? I just have about half a dozen desktops, and instead of closing an application I move to a different desktop. With suspend-to-ram and/or hibernate, I never have to worry about restoring application state.
- kingsley_20 17y agoI always thought http://www.irider.com/demo/index.htm http://www.irider.com/demo/index.htm did this well. Costs money though.
- makmanalp 17y agoThere is a firefox addon that colors tabs according to which tabs you opened them from, which is not exactly what you want, but still useful nonetheless.
- thorax 17y agoWell, tree-style tabs allows them to be nested that way. It's my favorite extension.
- omouse 17y agoThe web browser uses a stack which is why you can't have multiple branches. You can blame that on Tim Berners-Lee or Marc Andersson, I'm not sure which twit set that precedent.
- wwalker3 17y agoPhototoshop has apparently had this feature for some time. They call it "non-linear history". You can go back to earlier revisions, try new things starting from there, then if you don't like it, erase that history path and go back to your first one. You can also "snapshot" your history so points on it have intuitive labels. They don't display it as a tree, but it's logically identical -- just flattened out into a list form with the inactive branches grayed out.
- omouse 17y agoIt's called version control and branching and merging. It's a solved problem.
- roc 17y agofor geeks writing code, sure. but not for hacks writing web content or your mother writing an email.
- omouse 17y agoFine-grained version control can solve that problem. Unfortunately there isn't much support for it at the moment. So it's all a solved problem but no one uses it. I was doing some research for a paper on fine-grained version control to be able to deal with web content, recipes, songs, and other types of "documents" which rely on things other than paragraphs and lines. There has been a LOT of research done on the subject and I found some papers that deal with version control for Web content and some for dealing with XML content.
- artost 17y agoThere is a text editor called e-texteditor (http://e-texteditor.com http://e-texteditor.com) which has this feature, with a nice visualization of the resulting tree.