4 ms·
When we get our fuel from trees, we've created space for new trees to grow. In contrast, when our fuel is coal, gas or oil, eventually we run of of places to p
by hollerith 12y ago
When we get our fuel from trees, we've created space for new trees to grow. In contrast, when our fuel is coal, gas or oil, eventually we run of of places to plant trees (or we run out of the whatever is the scarcest nutrient for the trees).
This is the basis for the claim that burning trees is friendlier to the environment than burning fossil fuels is.
I am NOT pushing the claim, just pointing out that you have not yet successfully refuted the claim.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoOk, continue the chase through cause and effect. That stove consumes many precious and rare components (thermocouples, conductors, computer chips!) Its manufacture totally blows any comforting thoughts about carbon footprint savings. "Green" arguments like this product are marketing and 1st-world-consumer foolishness. Build a campfire and cook in an iron pot - that might save some carbon. This thing? No.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- stcredzero 12y agoThe problem with arguments like this, is that it only takes into account costs for today's industrial infrastructure. If everyone thought like this, there would be less innovation. (No domestic solar panels, for one thing.) That said, there are probably smaller carbon footprint items that will accomplish the same thing. Bulk D Cells, some D-cell holders and a USB charger would be what I'd use for extended emergency preparedness.
- dublinben 12y agoMost serious backpackers use alcohol stoves, which burn a renewable fuel that's more efficient than wood.
- sitkack 12y agoMost serious backpackers aren't concerned with nursing portable electronics with a low efficiency TEC. People who actually need to use electronics in remote locations bring a LiPo battery and a solar charger.
- personZ 12y agoYou seem really passionately against this. This is a camp stove. You cook things on it. It has a fan to provide a very efficient, very clean burn. It happens to have a charger on it as a side effect of being a fan driven burner. I guarantee that "getting power for free while cooking breakfast" is dramatically more efficient than a solar panel. Add that hiking I'm going to cook multiple times. Number of times I'm in open sunlight, at a fixed location for a period of time -- approximately zero. Not sure what you have against this, but it seems to be founded in the notion that you think this is a wood-powered USB charger, when it's a camp stove that also provides USB charging.
- Turing_Machine 12y agoWood is free and available on the trail. You have to buy (and carry!) alcohol.
- dublinben 12y agoYou could buy a lifetime supply of alcohol for the price of this stove, and carry a month's worth of it for the weight of this stove. This is a gimmick for people who can't go camping without their electronic gadgets. It's a bad stove and a bad charger put together.
- Turing_Machine 12y agoThis stove weighs 33 ounces. The Trangia backpacking alcohol stove sold by REI weighs 5.75 ounces. 1 quart of denatured ethanol weighs about 28 ounces (varies slightly depending on denaturant, but not by much). 28 + 5.75 = 33.75 > 33. Next.
- Turing_Machine 12y agoActually doing the arithmetic and demonstrating that an alcohol stove plus a standard-sized container of fuel weighs more and doesn't give you the USB charging capability gets me a -1? Nice. We won't even go into the fact that some people go backpacking in places where fuel has to be flown in (which, coincidentally, also tend to be the places where having a GPS or satellite phone can save your life).
- micro_cam 12y agoAlcohol stoves are nice and light but (along with any stove without an off valve) are technically illegal in most national forests and have started forest fires. If you spill one it is almost a guaranteed forest fire as you have invisible flame everywhere. Personally I'm a fan of isobutane models after years of fighting with white gas models.