2 ms·
Your complaint about peer review might be valid but it's irrelevant to this particular study (using the term peer review when describing a study isjust somethin
by dekhn 12y ago
Your complaint about peer review might be valid but it's irrelevant to this particular study (using the term peer review when describing a study isjust something PR people do to make them seem more valid). Peer review isn't a panacea, but that's not really its role, either. We expect too much of peer review, but it's not directly related to the issues of replication or open data (it certainly doesn't prevent either of those things from happening).
Studies like this actually build on previous studies, and if carried out properly, address many issues about individual publications.