3 ms·
>will allow the UK to seek civil redress against companies that have no link to the United Kingdom // No, not "no link" as you assert. Instead the S8 you quote
by pbhjpbhj 12y ago
>will allow the UK to seek civil redress against companies that have no link to the United Kingdom //
No, not "no link" as you assert. Instead the S8 you quote says they must have whole or partial control of a telecoms system located at least partially in the UK. [There's clearly no point in having powers over those who don't control the system as they're useless in getting information/control from that system.]
It's right that a company acting in the UK - eg offering a service to users, those users being in the UK - should come under UK law IMO, that's sovereignty.
I'm not comment on the other aspects only the jurisdiction aspect here.
- pjc50 12y agooffering a service to users, those users being in the UK should come under UK law This is an attractively simple but terrible line of thinking. It implies that everyone is e.g. obliged either to block Chinese users or obey Chinese censorship (and infosurveillance) law. Global jurisdiction is bad enough when it's just the US. If every country's jurisdiction extends to every website, that's a disaster. It's entirely possible for countries to have laws that are completely incompatible: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/oldnewthing/archive/2003/08/22/54679.aspx http://blogs.msdn.com/b/oldnewthing/archive/2003/08/22/54679...
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoI actually don't have a problem with those things mentioned in the MSDN article. If you want to do business in different countries I think you should expect to make some effort to abide by the laws and customs of those countries. If India, for example, want to block your software because it shows a particular border then why should "but we made it in USA" make any difference at all - India is a democratic sovereign nation, no? A mere informational website? Well it's a problem, if you simply off-shore a news server to by-pass reporting restrictions and such that clearly makes a mockery of the legal system and those it's seeking to protect. To me it's fine to serve up that news if you don't undergo business in the country in which the legal blocks have been put in place. If you expect anyone to abide by any laws online then how are you going to square this except by user origin, where the actions become realised.