19 ms·
Study: Half of black males, 40% of white males arrested by age 23
- byoung2 12y agoNearly half of black males and almost 40 percent of white males in the U.S. are arrested by age 23, which can hurt their ability to find work, go to school and participate fully in their communities. An arrest by itself, without an accompanying conviction, cannot be used to deny employment. 1. http://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/arrest_conviction.cfm#I http://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/arrest_conviction.cfm#I
- coryl 12y agoDo arrest records show up in background checks by employers?
- timmclean 12y agoIn Canada, at least, background checks can reveal attempted suicides and dropped charges, unfortunately: http://www.therecord.com/news-story/4538747-names-of-420-000-canadians-are-in-police-database-despite-no-criminal-records/ http://www.therecord.com/news-story/4538747-names-of-420-000...
- astrodust 12y agoThe dropped charges is the worst of this. How many people that were "kettled" during the G20 protests, despite not actually participating in the protests, nor ever being charged with anything, now have a police record?
- ceph_ 12y agoCharges show up on background checks in the US as well. Even if there was no conviction.
- mbillie1 12y agoI believe only convictions / guilty pleas in the US.
- stronglikedan 12y agoNope. Everything. Forever. I have never been convicted of a crime, but I do have felony arrests on my record that have prevented me from getting an apartment, and hindered me from getting into a university.
- tdfx 12y agoIf it goes to court, in most jurisdictions the disposition of the case will be available in a standard background check. For example, if you were charged with resisting arrest and found not guilty, it would still show up but also show "not guilty". Good luck explaining that to an employer, even if you did nothing wrong (and the courts confirmed it).
- wmil 12y agoA "not guilty" verdict means that there was enough evidence to go to trial, but not enough to convince a jury beyond a reasonable doubt. It's far from a confirmation that you did nothing wrong.
- bdcravens 12y agoI have a dismissed DWI that's still part of the public record.
- golden_apples 12y agoI've never had that experience, but I've been turned down on a couple of home rental applications when past arrests have turned up when running a background check. I'd assume the type of business that cared enough to run background checks would certainly catch any arrest on someone's record.
- anigbrowl 12y agoGiven that they're often published in newspapers, you can often find that information in a few seconds on Google. I think it's dreadful that police forces do perp walks and publish mugshots of arresstees who may not even end up getting charged. All sorts of other things show up. I'm named in an eviction lawsuit from the 1990s, which might make someone think I was a deadbeat who didn't pay rent. As it happened the house I was renting a room in was sold and the new owner wanted everyone to leave so he could move in, but nuances like that aren't obvious from the summary records at the court.
- _delirium 12y agoLegally, no, but it's getting common for employers to Google-background-investigate potential hires, and arrest notices can come up in such searches, which employers may or may not put unofficial weight on. Though you might be better off in a big city. In smaller towns, this kind of administrative stuff ends up published: local papers, or even the sheriff's office directly, often put out an arrest blotter with the names/ages/circumstances of everyone arrested in the past day or week, and those end up indexed forever (I gather this kind of situation, where a non-public figure gets minor but potentially harmful facts about themselves prominently indexed Forever, was one of the things the EU's "right to be forgotten" business is worried about).
- opendais 12y agoYa, stuff like that is why we need a right to be forgotten in the US. People tend to see an arrest and leap to conclusions. I say this as a person who has never been arrested. :/
- petercooper 12y agoWhile not as important as having a job, etc, it could possibly affect overseas travel. Someone couldn't travel with us from the UK to our wedding in the US as we learnt that anyone who's been arrested for any reason can't travel under the visa waiver program (they can apply for a visa though but that takes time, money, and an interview). And as far as I understand it, US VWP treaties operate on similar principles in both directions.
- GeorgeBeech 12y agoEh? The law only talks about convictions not arrests. You need to qualify for a Business or Tourism visa to be able to use the VWP. (source: http://travel.state.gov/content/visas/english/general/ineligibilities.html http://travel.state.gov/content/visas/english/general/inelig...) Sounds like your friend got screwed by an over zealous bureaucrat.
- adaml_623 12y agoSounds like he read the question asked when you go here: https://esta.cbp.dhs.gov/esta/ https://esta.cbp.dhs.gov/esta/ and apply for the visa waiver. And he didn't feel like forking out for plane flights just to be turned back at the border. "B) Have you ever been arrested or convicted for an offense or crime involving moral turpitude or a violation related to a controlled substance; or have been arrested or convicted for two or more offenses for which the aggregate sentence to confinement was five years or more; or have been a controlled substance trafficker; or are you seeking entry to engage in criminal or immoral activities?"
- DanBC 12y agoBut see what the US embassy in London says: http://london.usembassy.gov/niv/add_crime.html http://london.usembassy.gov/niv/add_crime.html > We recommend that anyone who have ever been arrested and/or convicted of an offense apply for a visa. In cases where the arrest resulted in a conviction, the individual may be permanently ineligible to receive a visa and in order to travel, a waiver of the permanent ineligibility is required. The Rehabilitation of Offenders Act does not apply to United States visa law. Therefore, even travelers with a spent conviction are required to declare the arrest and/or conviction and apply for a visa. Imagine you've just spent £X00 on a ticket. Would you gamble that (and the cost of flying back if denied entry), and your future chance of entry to the US, on getting through US border controls?
- fredgrott 12y agonot mention that laws to allow erasure of minor offenses differ per state in my state you can erase misdemeanor B and C class offenses after 5 years if 5 years no arrests
- sanj 12y ago"However, an employer may make an employment decision based on the conduct underlying an arrest if the conduct makes the individual unfit for the position in question." Which is more than enough wiggle room.
- byoung2 12y agoTrue. If you are truly innocent of the crime, you should have a good case to get the arrest record expunged (e.g. arrested for a case of mistaken identity and the charges are dropped). If there is enough evidence that you can't file a motion to dismiss, and the case goes to trial, then I suppose you have some explaining to do. The employer might be justified in denying employment if you engage in behavior that results in arrest (e.g. you are a known gang member arrested in a sweep, and later released or you were caught joyriding and the owner decides not to press charges). In this case, the arrest is not the reason for denying employment, your behavior is.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- EGreg 12y agoJust to be clear, even if the charges are dropped, the arrest stays on your record. To get it expunged takes court motions: http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/expungement-of-criminal-records-basics-32641.html http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/expungement-of-crimin...
- byoung2 12y agoI know a few people with felony arrests (charges dropped) who had the records expunged pretty easily. It was a simple form filed with the court, and the record was clean for later background checks. It's a hassle, sure, but it makes the rest of your life much easier.
- jqm 12y agoIn some places it may be easy as filling out a form. In other locations (Arizona for instance), there is no such thing as expungement. The best one can hope for is a little note next to the record saying judgement has been set aside.
- eslaught 12y agoOn the other hand, if you have ever been arrested, even if not accused of anything, and you want to apply for citizenship or a green card in the US, then the burden is placed on you to get proof that you have never been accused of anything [1]. If you fail to provide such evidence (as can happen if you were arrested outside of the US and the police in that country aren't interested in cooperating), then the default presumption is one of guilt rather than innocence. Edit: And in case it wasn't clear, failure to obtain a green card in the US can make it more difficult to find employment, as not all companies are eager to navigate immigration procedures on the behalf of their employees. [1]: http://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/files/form/i-485instr.pdf http://www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/files/form/i-485ins... (page 3)
- anigbrowl 12y agoThat just means it won't be cited as a reason by an interviewer or in a HR letter. But your name and face ina mugshot gallery are definitely not going to improve your prospects.
- squeaky-clean 12y agoAnd when I delivered pizza, my manager wasn't allowed to make me work unpaid overtime. But this is America, and something being "not allowed" doesn't mean it isn't happening all the time. The people affected by this most generally cannot afford legal action to defend themselves against this. Or worse, they're unaware that it's illegal to do this.
- jwgur 12y agoYou don't need to afford legal action to make a FLSA claim; the point about people being unaware of the legal mechanisms available to them (or even the illegality of it) is I think much stronger. If I was working hourly, I'd pray they make me work unpaid overtime, because when I was ready to hop jobs I'd walk into court with a fat 2x back wages (1x + liquidated damages) [1]. If they retaliate, it's up to 3x back wages. [1]: http://www.dol.gov/dol/topic/wages/backpay.htm http://www.dol.gov/dol/topic/wages/backpay.htm
- DanBC 12y agoAn arrest by itself, without an accompanying conviction, can be used to deny non-US citizens entry to the US. UK citizens who've been arrested need to apply for a visa and can't use the visa waiver / esta system. https://www.askthe.police.uk/content/Q683.htm https://www.askthe.police.uk/content/Q683.htm http://london.usembassy.gov/niv/add_crime.html http://london.usembassy.gov/niv/add_crime.html
- dragonwriter 12y ago> An arrest by itself, without an accompanying conviction, cannot be used to deny employment. Your own linked source does not say that -- it says that an exclusion based on an arrest record alone is not considered "job related and consistent with business necessity", and so will not be an adequate defense against a discrimination claim if disparate impact on a protected axis (e.g., race) is established. It does not, however, indicate that deny employment on that ground is per se prohibited. Further, it does clearly state that the employer may use the fact of an arrest, even without conviction, as a trigger for exploration of the "conduct underlying the arrest", and may use that as a basis for denying employment or other adverse job actions even without an arrest -- providing, unhelpfully, nearly the most extreme possible example of an arrest without conviction as an illustration (an elementary school principal arrested but not convicted of sexually abusing minors where an internal investigation triggered by the arrest found some evidence supporting the accusations but still no conviction occurred), which certainly indicates why an arrest without a conviction may be sufficient to demonstrate that the decision is reasonably job related, but does little to illustrate where the boundary is.
- waqf 12y agoClarification: over 40% of young men in the US have been arrested. (It is ambiguous whether "youths" refers to both sexes.) (It is also possible to interpret the headline as saying that 40% of all youths worldwide have been in the US at some point, during which they were arrested, but I doubt many people were confused by that.)
- sudont 12y agoFrom the article: "At age 18, arrest rates were 12 percent for white females and 11.8 percent and 11.9 percent for Hispanic and black females, respectively. By age 23, arrest rates were 20 percent for white females and 18 percent and 16 percent for Hispanic and black females, respectively."
- x1798DE 12y agoThe parent comment is clearly referring to the HN headline, not the article itself. Since young men do not massively outnumber young women, it is not the case that 40% of all US youths have been arrested.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zem 12y agoi did initially interpret it as "of all youth arrests worldwide, 40% take place in the usa", but realised the number was probably a bit high for that.
- haakon 12y agoThe current title says "Over 40% of all young men have been arrested in the USA". This can easily be interpreted as 40% of all young men in the whole world have been arrested in the USA. Instead, it should say "Over 40% of all young men in the USA have been arrested".
- 12y ago
- bentaber 12y agoAny ideas how this compares to other nations?
- jqm 12y agowell... given our vast population in jail I'm guessing it's much higher than other countries?
- kjjw 12y agoSlightly different, but surely related: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_incarceration_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_incarceration_rat... Getting on for nearly 1 in 1,000 people in jail! wow!
- pantalaimon 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_incarceration_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_incarcerat...
- smackfu 12y agoOne key point with this study is that it only covers people who were born between 1980 and 1984, and follows them through their lives. The summary articles tend to ignore that, and imply the same stats apply to people born in all years.
- stonogo 12y agoDo you have reason to believe that people born during that window are particularly jail-prone?
- Iftheshoefits 12y agoA large number of other reasons than your suggestion exist which may alter that rate for other cohorts: the quantity of offenses which allow arrest may have changed, the attitude of law enforcement may be more or less lax, etc.
- smackfu 12y agoCrime is definitely way down in the last 10 years. If you assume that most people are getting arrested in their 20's, then that would imply the rates would change for different birth years.
- eric_h 12y ago> Crime is definitely way down in the last 10 years violent crime is. I don't think arrests are, though...
- pdkl95 12y agoThere is one particularly well-correlated explanation for the higher rates of violent crime in roughly that time window: Ethyl (tetraethyl lead). http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2013/01/lead-crime-link-gasoline http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2013/01/lead-crime-li... edit: as noted in neighboring posts, "arrest" != "crime"
- morgante 12y agoThat's very important to acknowledge, since it means that any and all public policy shifts over the last decade are discounted by this methodology. Of course, it's still an alarming statistic, but I'd hope it's been going down (along with crime rates) since this data was collected.
- pertinhower 12y agoI find this frankly implausible. What percentage of people you know have been arrested? I'm guessing very small (even assuming that many hide it and so you're knowledge is substantially skewed). So maybe that's because of your high/squeaky-clean socio-economic class? No: imagine yourself in any class you care to. Unless that class is much, much larger than your "real" class, then it would have to have an astronomical arrest rate (80%?) to compensate. I wanna see the data.
- rootedbox 12y agoI have a lot of friends that have been arrested. So for me this number is very believable. It's actually not a very hard thing to get arrested. I had friend go to jail for not neutering his cat. That being said.. It's always nice to see the data.
- pyrrhotech 12y agoI agree. I come from a nice area, but I know maybe 10 people out of 2000 who have ever been arrested. And it was just underage drinking for them. Perhaps I live in a bubble, but this is suspiciously high
- furyofantares 12y agoWhile it is suspiciously high to me too, I am also skeptical that you know 2000 people well enough to know if they have ever been arrested
- jqm 12y agoYes, but there are vasts swaths of the country were arrest rates are much much higher than 10 out of 2000 people (not that they would all tell you anyway). I understand living in a bubble.... but you are not at least aware of the vast scale of these areas? If not, you should drive around more in my opinion.
- munificent 12y ago> I find this frankly implausible. What percentage of people you know have been arrested? The narrow-mindedness of this is breathtaking. An article about a peer-reviewed paper containing basic survey results asserts something about the entire US and your response is: "Well, that doesn't line up with my circle of friends so it must be bullshit?" > Unless that class is much, much larger than your "real" class, then it would have to have an astronomical arrest rate (80%?) to compensate. Assuming you're in a "high/squeaky-clean socio-economic", then, yes, that class is much larger than yours. If you live in the US and make $100k or more (which is likely true for many HN readers), there are four times as many people who make less than you. > I wanna see the data. The article links to the paper (behind a paywall). If you want to see the data, get off your butt and look at the data.
- frandroid 12y agoSo am I alone thinking that this is insane?
- burkaman 12y agoI don't think there's a single person on this website who is ok with this.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoThe high school graduation rate in the US's big cities floats around 50-60%. The way I see it about half the kids growing up don't become white collar over-educated cubicle jockeys. I imagine these two groups strongly overlap. You can get a trade job with a endless arrests or even a conviction.
- nmrm 12y agoWow. Most trade jobs require at least a high school diploma; many require some additional training (not necessarily an associates degree, but often a certificate of some sort, and enrollment in those courses requires a diploma).
- john_other_john 12y agoIf you are just arrested in the UK, without any charge or caution, you become ineligible for the Visa Waiver program for entry into the United States. Interesting statistic, therefore, from this side of the pond, having strong links family, business and social in the US. It has often been a double standard in many fields. The trademark laws are highly favorable to US companies versus Madrid Treaty Protocol countries, because the US did not ratify all that treaty. The UK does similar with EU/EC things, also. The trademark side is interesting, as the first enforcement of a trademark registered in a Treaty state against a US infringer, was Society des Baines de Mer, who own the Monte Carlo Casino, against various internet gambling sites, and I thought that may have had more allowance due to shifting policy about online gaming, than treaty affordances. My general view, totally non specific to any country, is there needs to be a rebalancing of laws between genuine scrutiny and thoughtfulness of oversight, versus draconian penalties.
- josu 12y agoAre you a bot?
- nmrm 12y agoOh man, thank you for asking this question. If so, it's a pretty intelligent way to test chat bots, assuming you interpret karma as "votes" the the bot is human.
- john_other_john 12y agoWhat's the fascination? Edit: genuinely curious
- josu 12y agoYour comment seems coherent until you start to read it and realize that it doens't make any sense. If you didn't state that you weren't from the UK I could think that English may not be your first language. What does that paragraph about trademark laws have to do with this thread?
- lotharbot 12y agoThe abstract is at http://cad.sagepub.com/content/60/3/471.abstract http://cad.sagepub.com/content/60/3/471.abstract (there's a paid link for the full study to the right.) I'd like to see error bars, or at least a clear indication of the assumptions that went into the model.
- Scitr 12y agohttp://scitr.com/a1j http://scitr.com/a1j
- jqm 12y agoIf this is even close to correct (and I'm betting it is) we have a serious problem in the country. The solution seems obvious. Stop arresting for minor drug offenses and victimless crimes like underage alcohol possession. Watch the number go back down to reasonable levels.
- stronglikedan 12y agoEven if we could just stop charging people with felonies for victimless crimes, then that would be a good start.
- onion2k 12y agoSounds bad, but assuming an arrest under 23 can happen any time between the ages of, say, 7 and 22, that's actually 2.7% in any given year, or roughly 1 in every 40 male children. It almost certainly points to police officers arresting children en masse in order to discover the real perpetrator rather than any child criminality epidemic.
- altcognito 12y agoMost people consider it pretty bad to be arrested at any point in their life. 2.7% per year is also a pretty awful number considering.
- chippy 12y agoIt's not the rate that makes it bad , but the effects. In other words, it's not that there is a crime epidemic or a major problem with youth, or that every year only 1 in every 40 male children get arrested but that over all their youth-time taken as a whole 40% will have been arrested. But even that is not the key point from the abstract. The key point - what makes it bad are: 1) "Criminal records that show up in searches can impede employment, reduce access to housing, thwart admission to and financing for higher education and affect civic and volunteer activities such as voting or adoption. They also can damage personal and family relationships." 2) "A problem is that many males – especially black males – are navigating the transition from youth to adulthood with the baggage and difficulties from contact with the criminal justice system,"
- jacalata 12y agoI'm going to go out on a limb and say that the arrests are not evenly distributed betweeen the ages of 7 and 22. In fact I'd guess that a statistically insignificant number of arrests occur before the age of 10, and that they cluster around 16-22.
- watwut 12y ago"Sounds bad, but [...] It almost certainly points to police officers arresting children en masse in order to discover the real perpetrator" ... seems to me like a horrible counterproductive thing.
- 12y ago
- EpicEng 12y agoI think that this trend, at least in part, has been influenced by a change in the way that we treat adolescent crime. For example, even when I was a kid (early 90's) you would not get arrested for getting into a fist fight at school. Nowadays, bam; call the cops. Get caught with some pot? Arrested. Get caught performing some petty vandalization? Arrested. Get caught at a party drinking as a minor? Arrested. We arrest kids for things that they used to just get a slap on the wrist/call to mom & dad for. Now they get a court date. We throw the cuffs on kids much more readily than we used to 20, 30, 40+ years ago.
- morgante 12y ago> I think that this trend, at least in part, has been influenced by a change in the way that we treat adolescent crime. For example, even when I was a kid (early 90's) you would not get arrested for getting into a fist fight at school. Nowadays, bam; call the cops. Well, the people in this study were born in the early 80s. So I'm not sure any modern shifts that you point to are the distinctive factor.
- nmrm 12y agoI think they were born in the 80's. Which means they were kids in the 90's and early 2000's, at the very peak of the US prison population boom. I could be wrong.
- EpicEng 12y agoNo, they were 18 between 1997 and 2008, so they were *born in the between 1979 and 1990, i.e., they were teenagers in the 90's or early 00's, same age as me (DOB 1983). "The study is an analysis of national survey data from 1997 to 2008 of teenagers and young adults, ages 18"
- morgante 12y agoI guess we had different ideas of kids. This data is based on NLSY97, meaning the subjects were born between 1981 and 1985. [1] Still, doesn't that contradict your point about these results being based on a substantial difference from when you were a kid? As you point out, this study is based on exactly your cohort. Thus it's not a matter of policies nowadays leading to 40% arrest rates. That figure is based directly on the policies of the 90s. [1] http://www.bls.gov/nls/nlsy97.htm http://www.bls.gov/nls/nlsy97.htm
- JSno 12y agoNo Asian mentioned. Do we exist????????
- smackfu 12y agoOnly 160 of the 8904 survey respondents are Asian or Pacific Islander. That's probably too small a sample to get valid data.
- Crito 12y ago4.8% of Americans are Asian Americans, but only 1.7% of their respondents are Asian Americans or Pacific Islanders? I wonder what went wrong with their surveying method.
- PeterisP 12y agoTheir surveying method is perfectly fine. The study is based on a cohort of kids who were born between 1980 and 1984 (in USA); and in 1980 Asian Americans were only 1.6% of USA population (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_racial_and_ethnic_demographics_of_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_racial_and_ethnic_de...). It does disregard (relatively) recent immigrants in that regard, though; but if it's to be used as analysis of gov't policy/parenting/schooling/etc circumstances, then you'd want to look at people who grew up in USA policies and environment.
- tn13 12y agoWondering what is the histogram of these arrests look like.
- maxk42 12y agoSomething is severely broken.
- voidlogic 12y agoI really want to see a heat map of this phenomena. I have a feeling there is strong geographic and urban/rural differences here. I would also like to see the percentage of the population that has been arrested by age. This statistic is definitely not representative of where I live, that being said I don't disbelieve it, I just want to understand the details. P.S. I am also disgusted when children are charged as adults. Maybe (probably) there needs to be a middle classification of age legally, but lacking that, it is better to error by being to lenient for the youth. The other day I saw a 12 year old girl was being changed with murder, as an adult- ridiculous!
- Tloewald 12y agoIt's pretty hard to imagine you can get figures like this without it being prevalent in urban areas.
- nmrm 12y agohttp://xkcd.com/1138/ http://xkcd.com/1138/
- voidlogic 12y agoThis is often true, but until you see the heat map you don't know that. When its not true, things get interesting. I think this case may not completely match the joke. In this case, I have a feeling due to issues of poverty and education that, for example, the rural South might have a higher arrest rate then the rural Midwest even at locales of similar population density.
- ddlatham 12y agoMost striking are the race differences revealed in the study, Brame says. In particular, the research points to a higher prevalence of arrest among black males and little race variation in arrest rates among females.... By age 23, 49 percent of black males, 44 percent of Hispanic males and 38 percent of white males have been arrested.... By age 23, arrest rates were 20 percent for white females and 18 percent and 16 percent for Hispanic and black females, respectively. By age 23: - Black males have been arrested at a 29% higher rate than white males. - White females have been arrested at a 25% higher rate than black females. While the absolute rate of especially black male arrests is troubling, I find the racial differences in both genders striking and particularly surprising in the female case.
- newman8r 12y agoIt's interesting the article downplays the discrepancy in the female arrest rates based on race.
- cbsmith 12y agoIt's because the author is bad at interpreting statistics and doesn't recognize that a 4% difference when the average rate is closer to 18% is a way bigger difference than a 5 or even 6% difference when the average rate is closer to 40%.
- jakethedog 12y agoThe manuscript highlights the differences among the male populations are significant while those among the female populations are within the estimated confidence intervals.
- cyorir 12y agoCorrect. To see the original, you can check the journal itself [0] (check for it on google scholar if this link doesn't work) or look for it at your nearest academic library, if they have it. It is published in the April issue. The conclusion was that the difference was not significant for the female population. Keep in mind that the study was based on a limited sample so care must be taken when generalizing conclusions from the starting data to the population as a whole. [0] http://cad.sagepub.com/content/60/3/471.abstract http://cad.sagepub.com/content/60/3/471.abstract
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Steer 12y agoSorry if I misunderstand your point, but are you saying that the US is a police state because they wouldn't allow you to drive drunk (endangering other people) or with a gun in your car? I think it is a good thing that it hasn't hurt your ability to get employment since these things are not related, but I still don't understand the police state connection. What changes are you proposing? That everyone should be able to have a loaded gun with or without a permit or that everyone should be allowed to drive while under the influence?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Steer 12y agoThank you for the clarification, that makes more sense. On a side-note, I think a lot of this would be solved by ending the "war on drugs". I agree on your first point, I am indecisive on your second point (What is "mass" surveillance really?) and I don't know enough about the US to understand what you mean by a "militarized police".
- knodi123 12y agoAt least regarding the "loaded gun" incident - there's a much better choice besides "arrest him" and "ignore it". How about a fine? Arrests should be limited to just the people who are a flight or safety risk.
- davidtanner 12y agoCarrying a loaded gun in your car is perfectly legal in Virginia without a permit. Many other states allow for car carry of loaded handguns - it's really not a big deal.
- giberson 12y agoLaws in the US are far too strict. I am one of the people that are covered by this statistic, I was arrested around age 16. For curfew. Curfew, the law that says you can't be outside after an arbitrarily dictated time. Absolutely ridiculous. For what it is worth--my record has been "expunged" and this arrest has not affected my adult life at all.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- NhanH 12y agoI'm not sure, but does this have anything to do with being common law rather than civil law? To be more specific, it's not a matter of the law being "too strict", but rather it's too vague and have to be interpreted by a judge. So until someone actually fight a case, the interpretation could be too broad and can be used easily. In civil law, you pretty much have to iterate everything. Disclaimer: I have no idea what I'm talking about. I used to live in a country with civil law, and since moving to the US, the common law system has always fascinated me.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoThe vagueness of the laws are a different problem. If the laws were just vague then you could have judges interpreting them in favor of defendants as often as prosecutors. If you had to point to one thing as the cause of all this, it is likely to be the privatization of criminal justice. As soon as you have a private prison or a defense contractor selling military-grade equipment to civilian police forces, you create the incentive for those organizations to lobby for more "customers" through broader prohibitions, tougher enforcement and harsher penalties.
- watwut 12y agoOnly 6% of american prisons are private.
- 12y ago
- TomGullen 12y agoUsed to dream of living in the US, moving our business there. Not just due to this, but the more I read and learn about the US, the more that is exposed about the US, the less I now want to live there.
- kghose 12y agoDon't come here. It's terrible, I tell you. Just terrible.
- MrBuddyCasino 12y agoCan't tell if sarcasm or serious
- kghose 12y agoWhatever you do, don't come here to find out.
- alexeisadeski3 12y ago>moving our business there That would be genuinely insane.
- briandh 12y agoIt would depend a lot on where he/she would be moving from how "insane" it would be. Though I agree there are better jurisdictions than the US to move a business to.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoDoes any other jurisdiction ban one's company from leaving? None that I'm aware of. Just losing that future option value is sufficient to deem such a move insane regardless of original jurisdiction - unless for some reason there is zero other option.
- lingoberry 12y ago
- comrade1 12y agoThere are far too many laws in the u.s. and you can never know when you're breaking a law. And enforcement is often arbitrary and based on if the police want to harass/check you, or if they want to pile charges on top of another charge to get you to deal on a plea. Some countries view laws as a failure of society. You don't pass a law until your society has failed in that way, and instead you use social norms/controls. For example, Switzerland has no minimum wage but has a moral minimum wage of around $50K (except for a few worker types) The u.s. seems to view laws as a way to mold society into a vision. But you end up with way too many laws that you could never know.
- donatj 12y ago> enforcement is often arbitrary and based on if the police want to harass/check you This. Absolutely this. So many laws are only enforced if and when you've irritated a cop. There are so many laws in the US about so many stupid things that they can ALWAYS bust you for something if they want to. Always. There's probably a handful of things they could charge me with on my drive home.
- tesq 12y agoIt doesn't take much to irritate a cop. Sometimes, the sight of or bare minimum interaction with you is enough to trigger irritation in a cop for reasons. So many laws are enforced solely because a cop thinks you don't look the part and look suspicious for, erm, reasons. Unfortunately, these reasons are pervasive throughout the justice system so make sure you don't irritate a cop or it could cost you money, time and freedom.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- happyscrappy 12y agoAlso over 50% of violent crimes go unsolved and over 80% of property crimes. Looks like there could be more arrests if they solved more crimes.
- gress 12y agoOr maybe they might be able to solve more crimes if they arrested fewer people and used the resources for investigation.
- vikas5678 12y agoI would love to see a breakdown of what they were most arrested for.
- kareemm 12y agoI'm Canadian, and went to university in Montreal with a bunch of Americans. It always amazed me how pretty much every one of them had some sort of run-in with the police (up to and including being arrested). Usually it was related to underage drinking. At that time I didn't personally know any Canadians who'd been arrested, and a run-in with the police was unheard of (and this isn't because I ran with a goodie two-shoes crowd). I'm 37 now, and can't name a single Canadian I know personally who's been arrested (that doesn't mean I don't know people who've never been arrested; just that I don't know if they have). So I had a feeling the percentage was high, but 40% of young men is... just appalling.
- heinrich5991 12y agoI get a 403, could someone post the contents?
- coldtea 12y agoIn a proper non police-state democracy, on the other hand, e.g some western european country, less than 5% of males/females have been arrested by age 23.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nick_whiu 12y ago*In the US
- icantthinkofone 12y agoI find it interesting that I know no one in any of my immediate or extended family who has ever been arrested and I'm 62 years old. The closest I ever had that happening to me is when I was 20 and didn't know I was breaking a law* . I'm no preacher's kid. I just live my life and try to enjoy myself. I don't bother anyone even when others bother me. I just don't get it. * I was working at a place that went on strike. Picketers took our picture when we walked into the building so they could show who was crossing their line. To be funny, one morning I took their picture. They called the police to say I was harassing them. One young, rookie cop came in ready to haul me off until his sergeant showed up and had a conference with my boss.
- dougmccune 12y agoIf you'd like to download the raw data that this study is based on, I think you can grab it here: https://www.nlsinfo.org/investigator/pages/search.jsp?s=NLSY97 https://www.nlsinfo.org/investigator/pages/search.jsp?s=NLSY... It's a fairly convoluted set of forms you have to work your way through, but in the end you can download a CSV that includes the arrest counts (or a ton of other variables) for all of the nearly 9k people in the study (although not all of them continued to submit data to the survey through the years). More about the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1997 (NLSY97): http://www.nlsinfo.org/content/cohorts/nlsy97 http://www.nlsinfo.org/content/cohorts/nlsy97
- cryptophile 12y agoSince arresting young males should be a goal in itself, I wonder why the stated target of 100% is never reached? Sounds like bureaucratic inefficiency and inertia ...
- ps4fanboy 12y agoBlack isn't a race, neither is White, where do Hispanics fall on this spectrum and Asians?
- EdwardDiego 12y agoI've little experience in apply statistical analysis to this data (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8018014 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8018014, thank you to that user), so forgive me if this is a dumb question, but would it be possible to remove poverty as a confounding factor? I am guessing, based largely on American television I've consumed growing up, that a higher proportion of black males grow up in poverty than white males?
- ajuc 12y agoWow. That's order of magnitude more than where I live.
- gershwinou 12y agoI agree, and you nailed it: State has slowly stolen authority to parentd. Either you allow slap and spank nor you let other call the cops...
- ashwinaj 12y agoI think people need to take a good hard look at where the society in general is heading. I've heard from older folks that they used to be "disciplined" by parents and teachers alike in the 50's, 60's and 70's (and I'm sure the arrest percentage wasn't 40% at the time). And now it's "I don't want a lawsuit so let's just call the police". A book on Asian "Tiger mom" is lambasted by the popular media and people in general. But Asian kids aren't being arrested in such shocking numbers, are they? Isn't it obvious that there is some merit in the "Tiger mom" philosophy? If kids are allowed to do whatever the hell they want without any repercussions ("Mr./miss you're grounded" is not one of those) then what do you expect they're going to do?