5 ms·
I'm trying to put this as constructively as I can: Proudly dismissing Windows on the second line of your copy makes me not want to take you seriously. There's n
by skrebbel 12y ago
I'm trying to put this as constructively as I can: Proudly dismissing Windows on the second line of your copy makes me not want to take you seriously. There's nothing wrong with not supporting certain platforms, but bragging about it makes you seem a bit snobby.
EDIT: And I'll grumpily admit that this also bugs me because Windows is me favorite OS and Breach looks like a thing I would actually use. I hope its just circumstance. And not some goal in itself to not support it out of some far fetched principle.
- angersock 12y agoI'll take it a step further--it usually indicates to me hipster script-kiddies that don't know how to properly support multiple platforms beyond pasting together makefiles from Grandpa Google. EDIT: Downvote all you want--how many times have you had to deal with packages that magically only build on Windows, OSX, or Linux? Or only on a particular version of Ubuntu?
- spolu 12y agoHehe, in that case, it also means writting a substantial amount of code specifically targeted to Windows...
- angersock 12y agoSuch as? I'm pretty sure Chromium and Node build just fine. https://github.com/joyent/node/wiki/installation https://github.com/joyent/node/wiki/installation http://www.chromium.org/developers/how-tos/build-instructions-windows http://www.chromium.org/developers/how-tos/build-instruction... EDIT: https://github.com/breach/exo_browser/wiki/Building-the-ExoBrowser https://github.com/breach/exo_browser/wiki/Building-the-ExoB... What else am I missing from your package.json?
- spolu 12y agoWithin the ExoBrowser to open a window and install web view controls
- Mikeb85 12y agoOnce you experience the *nix was of doing things (after the initial learning curve), the Windows way is a huge pain in the ass.
- angersock 12y agoI've done 'nix development, and agree that for certain things it's much nicer. On Windows, VS debugger beats everything else I've seen hands down. It's not hard to support Windows if you're writing good cross-platform code; there are a lot of libraries (Qt, Boost, etc.) that make things much easier than they used to be. Again, I see lack of Windows support mostly as programmers being lazy (and I've said the same thing about lack of 'nix support, so don't think I'm being biased). If you don't write portable code you're doing it wrong.
- Iftheshoefits 12y agoI think the downvotes are more for your tone than whatever point you're trying to make. Also, code portability for a project like this is important, but that's not universally true. Having a hard and fast requirement for code portability imposes a set of concerns, design and maintenance issues that complicates a project. It (almost) never comes for free, and is a legitimate concern for any project--even ones where a portability requirement is almost a given.
- integraton 12y ago> I see lack of Windows support mostly as programmers being lazy "Lazy" would imply that Windows support is somehow a requirement that's being shirked by developers, which frankly it isn't. Microsoft is not entitled to have developers support, expend effort on, or even give a moment's thought to their platforms.
- LocalPCGuy 12y agoWindows is still by far the primary platform users (maybe not devs) use, and yes, for any serious project, it is most definitely a requirement. I didn't get the sense from the website that it wasn't going to come to Windows, just that they haven't had the chance to get it working yet. I don't find the devs attitude lazy unless they actually come out and say screw it we aren't going to both to support Windows. And this attitude being displayed toward Microsoft is just lazy (and very likely the province of the young), because while they did give us a crappy browser and Webforms for way too long, and they are fun to poke fun at, they've done more than most companies to push both the computer revolution and the Internet as a whole forward to what it is today. So give them a little credit, pull your head outta the sand and actually take a look at what they do once in a while also. You might be surprised what you find.
- spolu 12y agoHi skrebbel, didn't want to appear snobby at all... We just didn't have the time to port the whole thing to windows :( What would you write in that button?
- skymt 12y agoReplacing "only" with "now" (or nothing at all) would improve the tone.
- spolu 12y agoDone! Thanks.
- temp4god 12y agoAlso, how about a screencast/screenshot?
- spolu 12y agoYou can find some in /hack
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoSorry but I don't think this was right. "Now available on [apple]/[linux]" suggests that it was previously available but not on those platforms. You're going to find a lot of people searching high and low for the .exe file IMO. Personally I'd stick with "Available on [apple]/[linux]", drop the "only" if you're worried about it sounding like it's a choice for exclusivity reasons. Then you probably need to add a by-line below the button indicating "MS Windows and other OS versions not yet available, please contact us through the forum [or whatever] for details". Or have a click through to gather email addresses so you can contact users later if MS Win or other versions come out. Copy is hard, huh.
- LocalPCGuy 12y agoBetter yet, have a little spot where you ask for developers with experience porting things like this to Windows for their help.
- bichiliad 12y agoWhat copy is this? I agree, but I don't think I see what you're referring to.
- notastartup 12y agoI think you are overreacting. Maybe they will support Windows down the road. I'd like to see it too on Windows.
- kingmanaz 12y ago>There's nothing wrong with not supporting certain platforms, but bragging about it makes you seem a bit snobby. A modern, HTML5-capable browser which performs well on a A2000, A3000, A4000, or A1200 running AmigaOS 3.1, with 128mb of RAM, a 33-50mhz 680030+ processor, and a 2 or 4mb Picasso video card would make one "seem a bit down to earth". It would also make a lot of us old-time Amigans happy.