3 ms·
Your response is the natural instinct, but it's ultimately misplaced. It is completely rational for people to notice that corruption is highly correlated to cer
by jerf 12y ago
Your response is the natural instinct, but it's ultimately misplaced. It is completely rational for people to notice that corruption is highly correlated to certain locations in the world, and you're not going to be able to just assert your way into making that false. The correct response is to make it irrational by making it not true, and working to root out the corruption in question.
It's hard. I don't even have words to describe how hard that is. But it does at least stand a chance of working.
(This seems to be ground deeply into the human psyche. In general, a group of any kind is best off in the long term if the group polices itself for misconduct more aggressively than any outsider could. But the human instinct is to band together, assist each other to various degrees in covering over problems (often not even deliberately per se, but as a side effect of the system's structure), and band together to attack anyone external who notices anything amiss. This, alas, works in the short term quite well, but is death in the longterm.)
- coldtea 12y ago>Your response is the natural instinct, but it's ultimately misplaced. It is completely rational for people to notice that corruption is highly correlated to certain locations in the world, and you're not going to be able to just assert your way into making that false. The correct response is to make it irrational by making it not true, and working to root out the corruption in question. That's like saying "blacks are lazy" and when someone complains you tell them that it's normal for people to make such correlations and that to fix this he has to work on "making it not true". You got it backwards. The burden of proof is on you. You have to prove what you state with regards to corruption is true. Not just speak like it's a given, and demand of them to fix it. >This seems to be ground deeply into the human psyche. (...) the human instinct is to band together, assist each other to various degrees in covering over problems (often not even deliberately per se, but as a side effect of the system's structure), and band together to attack anyone external who notices anything amiss. This is a generalization that can be said for all groups. Not a proof (or even an indication) that any charge of "something amiss" from somebody external is right. I have friends that studied in the UK (including Cambridge) and the US. My anecdotal evidence is that tons of papers in Comp-Sci in those countries are also BS, to keep the churn rate up). And academics return favors to other academics all the time, with regards to favorable reviews, etc. (Btw, I'm not Chinese, so the pop psychology 101 above doesn't apply).
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoWell, there is corruption here and many of the papers I personally read from China are not very good. That being said, MSR-Asia is still MSR even if we are located in China, and we have very high standards. I would also suggest that quality can come from China, its a numbers game: we have a lot of people in this region, and there is bound to be some gems that you might encounter if you are objective. Casting a stereotype over a whole region just isn't useful in that regards. All I'm asking for is fairness. Too many of my colleagues have to disguise where they are from to even get by double blind review (there is a bias against China-based papers, and so we take careful care to extra-anonymyze our papers). This is ridiculous and immoral.
- jrochkind1 12y ago> It is completely rational for people to notice that corruption is highly correlated to certain locations in the world What you just 'notice' is anecdotal and biased by, um, your biases. It's not a correlation until you actually demonstrate it in a validly constructed analysis. Of course, the trick is that legitimate attempts at validly constructed analyses are also effected by biases of the analyzers. When your conclusion is something that 'everyone knows' (but not neccesarily based on legit analyzed evidence), I think it's especially at risk of confirmation bias (when you try to muster the legit analyzed evidence). It would be very interesting to find historical examples in the US of something that, for a while, scientists simply believed in, and believed that valid objective scientific experiments have shown to be so -- but then later the scientific community came to the opposite consensus. (ESP in the early 20th century might be one example, believe it or not. Look it up!) Science isn't quite as foolproof as one might like or assume.
- judk 12y agoFor example, the scientific "fact" that Caucasians are a superior races than Negros and Mongoloids.
- jrochkind1 12y agoYeah, good point, I don't know why you got downvoted -- at one point, that was consensus science -- and there was all sorts of scientific research, the overwhelming majority of scientific evidence, that people believed demonstrated it. At the moment, consensus science is that there isn't even such a valid object of inquiry as 'race', so you can't even make claims about it. (Although this is changing in interesting ways too, post-genomics)