4 ms·
There have been a lot of changes. One of which is that America can no longer do cost-effective public works, paid for via government funds. The government used
by adventured 12y ago
There have been a lot of changes. One of which is that America can no longer do cost-effective public works, paid for via government funds. The government used to be able to spur all sorts of economic gains that way, from huge dams generating cheap electricity to the interstate highway system. Now we vaporize $800 billion (ARRA stimulus program) and barely get anything for it.
The only thing in this category the government seems to be able to afford these days (other than lots of wasted military spending), is scientific research funding.
Another huge difference is that America has taken on truly massive liabilities, from public debt to entitlements, that did not exist in 1948. Those entitlement obligations alone will squeeze the government's budget to death over the next 20 years. That leaves a lot less money for everything else.
As an economic burden, healthcare has become a huge portion of the economy and government spending compared to 1948, and will remain substantial no matter how they cut and squeeze costs in the coming years. That money can't be spent on bridges, roads, electrical grids, research, etc. It also doesn't help that Americans overall have been much less healthy in terms of diet in the last 50 or 60 years, contributing substantially to that increase in healthcare costs (helped by the government subsidizing things like sugar and corn, and promoting really stupid food pyramids).
- nerfhammer 12y agoUS federal debt in 1948 easily dwarfs the current federal debt as a % of GDP, as a result of war spending Granted ongoing liabilities are a different thing than war bonds
- benihana 12y agoIt's like you skimmed the entire comment, saw the thing about debt and then commented on something completely tangential to the point GP was making. The point was how much we spend, the point was the government in 1948 was a completely different beast than it is today. American society was also completely different.
- wutbrodo 12y ago> The government used to be able to spur all sorts of economic gains that way, from huge dams generating cheap electricity to the interstate highway system. Now we vaporize $800 billion (ARRA stimulus program) and barely get anything for it. There's a big whopping [citation needed] right here. The fact that the stimulus was unaccountable wasted money is a canard that people with an agenda (and a willingness to ignore facts) like to tell themselves. There have been a multitude of studies estimating the impact of ARRA,and the consensus almost across the board has been positive: several macro firms (Moody, IHS) estimate that the ARRA saved around 2.5m jobs total (up to 2014), and the CBO and other economists estimate that more than 3m jobs were saved by 2011 alone. Note that I'm leaving out any Democratic or White House sources (who had even more positive estimates), to avoid the possibility that they're politically biased. Hell the best the Republicans could do in their campaign-fodder "list of most wasteful stimulus projects" was TWO PERCENT of the ARRA's total. Even if the Act hadn't done anything useful (which it did), it's widely considered by economists to have prevented a much deeper recession, which alone is obviously worth the expense. In the event that you're focusing not on its overall effectiveness but on the fact that nothing "visible" was built (like a big dam): 1) That's an awfully juvenile way to measure impact ("I don't see big concrete structures going up everywhere! The money must have 'vaporized'!"). 2) The ARRA consisted of a huge amount of tax cuts (36% of the 800B), so if you're going to claim that 800B "vaporized", you need to account for the extra productivity from the income effect from those tax cuts. 3) It's very disingenuous to completely ignore context: if our freeways are crumbling and we build shiny new ones instead of maintaining the old ones (which was a significant provision of the ARRA), that would be a pretty stupid idea. And yet, by your metric, that would be preferable in order to have a visible impact. 4) A big chunk of the ARRA was explicitly designed to fill in huge municipal/state-level spending cuts that were choking off local economies (there were towns that were actually shutting their police/other critical services down). If local economies cut N billion and the ARRA replaced that N billion, the ignorant response would be "SEE WE DIDN'T GET ANYTHING FOR N BILLION". I really hope I don't have to explain why comparing against the situation before instead of comparing against the situation that _would_ have occurred absent the ARRA is absolutely idiotic (this was also an issue when people were assessing the macreconomic effect of the Act). TL;DR: It's an awfully simple-minded approach to say "Where are all the big new fancy buildings??? We barely got anything for the ARRA!". It ignores the tax cuts in the Act, privileges new construction over needed maintenance/upgrades, ignores spending on electronic systems (EMR, etc), ignores the effect of sustaining local spending after huge cuts. It's honestly the _worst_ metric for the usefulness or "economic gain" of an act that I've ever seen.