4 ms·
Let's definitely challenge its intent. We're talking about public figures in some cases, here. I'd say the right of the public to know and freedom of speech (th
by Karunamon 12y ago
Let's definitely challenge its intent. We're talking about public figures in some cases, here. I'd say the right of the public to know and freedom of speech (the concept, not the law) trumps "privacy" (aka a weak attempt to suppress publicly known facts via legislative diktat) on the open internet.
Look at what's being taken down here...
I hope:
* That this site gets mirrored en masse,
* That the EU regulators get a taste of the Streisand effect and how that applies to censorship
* That anyone who filed a censorship request (that's all this is, just dressed up in more flowery language) learns how the internet works.
- nemetroid 12y ago> Let's definitely challenge its intent. We're talking about public figures in some cases That's hardly challenging its intent.
- Karunamon 12y agoThe point being that, much like the cookie law, this law is simultaneously misaimed, ineffective, and backwards.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- _delirium 12y ago> We're talking about public figures in some cases The decision explicitly lists that as a legitimate exemption: search engines may reject removal requests for information concerning someone who has a "public role". If Google took down information pertaining to a public figure, it is probably their error. Now you can argue that this decision will in practice lead to many such errors, but that's a slightly different attack on the decision (arguing that it's impractical to implement accurately vs. arguing that it's in principle wrong, even when implemented accurately, are at least conceptually different criticisms).
- fpgeek 12y agoIf Google is the one making the call about whether or not someone is a public figure, where exactly do you expect them to draw the line? Do you honestly expect them to draw a line in the public interest? Personally, I'd expect them to do everything they can to minimize the cost of compliance (where that cost primarily includes the cost of processing requests and the risk of being hauled into court again). In principle, they also care about search quality, but, as long as they deal with the most blatant cases, I think the impact on perceived (not actual) search quality will be small and the impact on relative search quality might even be positive (in other words that the best-case scenario for Bing is matching the precision of Google's blocks and they might do worse). In practice, I think that means wild overblocking of results that should be public because the cost of refusing a request is larger and more immediate. And so far as I can tell that's what we're seeing so far.
- nmrm 12y agoThis is literally the exact same argument as "security trumps privacy". NSA et al. argue that they need to know about everyone's dirty laundry in order to protect civil society from terrorists (or whatever). You argue that the public needs at-your-fingertips access to everyone's dirty laundry in order to protect civil society from (idk? dictatorship that will inevitably ensue if sleazy reporters don't get their ad revenue?) How about this alternative: whenever something actually important is de-listed, concerned citizens can mirror en masse. But when some trivial bit of gossipy sleaze reporting that no on cares about is de-listed, we let it die its rightful death. I see no reason to Streisand-effect private citizens trying to rebuild their life after some reporter decided to make a quick buck profiting off of a single stupid mistake. The fact that you're so gung-ho about contributing to these people's continued misfortune in the name of your political agenda is deeply troubling.
- hyperpape 12y agoThe baffling thing about this argument is that the EU apparently doesn't think that this information is so terrible that it can't be published--just that we have to suppress links to it. And since the ruling only concerns older material, it's built into its logic that these articles are things which the public once deserved to know but now must forget. So your talk of sleazy reporters has no place here.
- nmrm 12y agoThere is an excellent post below by user gaius addressing this issue. You seem to believe that search engines are not force multipliers for for-profit gossip mongering; this is demonstrably false.
- GrinningFool 12y ago"You argue that the public needs at-your-fingertips access to everyone's dirty laundry in order to protect civil society from (idk? dictatorship that will inevitably ensue if sleazy reporters don't get their ad revenue?)" Actually he argued much more narrowly that the public needs access to the dirty laundry of public figures. And I'm inclined to agree. This narrow argument is very different from the broad argument you're casting it as - I didn't see anywhere that OP said "everyone's dirty laundry".
- cbr 12y agoWhy would the site need to be mirrored? If it's run by an American, hosted in the US, and doesn't do business in the EU then (not a lawyer) it's US law not EU law that applies. And (again, not a lawyer) under US law posting facts like this is completely legal.
- jcfrei 12y agoThe fundamental problem without a "right to be forgotten" is that missteps and deliberate mischief are not covered equally by journalists. the news making process is not a perfectly efficient system (ie. not all cases get covered equally) - some cases simply get covered because they are funny, just filled a remaining gap in the newspaper, were especially bizarre, were very embarrassing, etc. other missteps (of similar gravity) do not get covered. this law allows such people to counter their misfortune, while the cases which are actually important to the public still remain to be seen for everybody. If you look at hiddenfromgoogle.com, it links to quite a few of such cases. They are to a large extent mundane and exaggerated stories (which are typical for dailymail and the guardian). They carry no/very little importance for the general public - however can be very incriminating for the individual itself.
- DanBC 12y agoYes. When I'm searching for a academic's name I am more likely to be interested in that person's work than some theft they committed years ago. I guess this shows the flaws in Google's algorithm and the destructiveness of shitty SEO. Irrelevant information is pushed to the top of Google's first page and useful information is dropped. (People who need to know someone's criminal record status can use existing mechanisms to get that, so long as they're complying with the various laws about rehabilitation of offenders. Google should not be your method of getting reliable conviction or arrest information about a person.)