3 ms·

Choosing to fight a man with a knife who is trying to rob you is stupid and dangerous, regardless of your training. I'm not sure what this says about the thesis

by ammon 12y ago

Choosing to fight a man with a knife who is trying to rob you is stupid and dangerous, regardless of your training. I'm not sure what this says about the thesis.

goldenkey 12y ago
If anything, I think the article serves to boast on the author's intelligence. And we all know what it means when a man talks about his penis size..
ilaksh 12y ago
I think it suggests that a big part of success is luck. He was lucky that man didn't really know how to use the knife or intend to kill him with it. Anyway forget the mugging analogy because it is a stretch and distracts from useful information. First, people aren't so much smarter than others than they think. People who persevere are more likely to be "lucky", since they keep trying until they are "lucky". Another huge aspect of this is self-identity. If you think you are supposed to be a consulting VP, then you can be. Most people don't think that. Another huge aspect of success is advantage. This can be in the form of a social network or just having a slightly well-off uncle to give a loan at an important time. Or it can just be physical health. When it comes down to it, circumstances play a larger role than I think most people in our current structure want to believe. This is not a machine that rewards merit. There is also a strange focus on the individual in this mindset. But I go back to the belief that innate intelligence differences between humans are generally not nearly as great as we think they are. I also think that often circumstantial difficulties can be overcome, if there is enough perseverance. So I think one of the most important factors may be identity. In other words, who do you think you are?
- vinceguidry 12y ago
  If someone is mugging you with a knife, guaranteed he never took the time or the expense to learn how to properly use his weapon. Or he wouldn't have any need to mug someone.

by ammon 12y ago

Choosing to fight a man with a knife who is trying to rob you is stupid and dangerous, regardless of your training. I'm not sure what this says about the thesis.

goldenkey 12y ago

If anything, I think the article serves to boast on the author's intelligence. And we all know what it means when a man talks about his penis size..

ilaksh 12y ago

I think it suggests that a big part of success is luck. He was lucky that man didn't really know how to use the knife or intend to kill him with it. Anyway forget the mugging analogy because it is a stretch and distracts from useful information. First, people aren't so much smarter than others than they think. People who persevere are more likely to be "lucky", since they keep trying until they are "lucky". Another huge aspect of this is self-identity. If you think you are supposed to be a consulting VP, then you can be. Most people don't think that. Another huge aspect of success is advantage. This can be in the form of a social network or just having a slightly well-off uncle to give a loan at an important time. Or it can just be physical health. When it comes down to it, circumstances play a larger role than I think most people in our current structure want to believe. This is not a machine that rewards merit. There is also a strange focus on the individual in this mindset. But I go back to the belief that innate intelligence differences between humans are generally not nearly as great as we think they are. I also think that often circumstantial difficulties can be overcome, if there is enough perseverance. So I think one of the most important factors may be identity. In other words, who do you think you are?

vinceguidry 12y ago
If someone is mugging you with a knife, guaranteed he never took the time or the expense to learn how to properly use his weapon. Or he wouldn't have any need to mug someone.