15 ms·
Stop The JerkTech
- nness 12y agoI wonder if this is conceptually similar to "Tragedy of The Commons." (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons) I can't really see how these services are not just the exploitation of services for the public good. Pretty disgusting behaviour.
- crapshoot101 12y agoNot really - the tragedy of the commons is the examples of oceans fisheries or trash on the street, where any one person doesn't have enough ownership to care enough to ensure continual sustainability. Ironically, this is if anything, a counter to the tragedy of the commons (albeit an awkward fit) - they're trying to price something that has an assumed value people took for granted. Again, I'm not saying its something great, but its not this concept.
- endgovernment 12y agoNo, unpriced public parking is a GREAT example of a tragedy of the commons situation. Un-owned property is used inefficiently. This is a fundamental economic principle.
- ChristianMarks 12y agoThat's one reason I use unexploitable public goods, like public tranportion, and go to salad bars not trendy enough for some kid to want to scalp.
- ChuckFrank 12y agoThat in and of itself is a good reason for great public goods. They are, or should be, by definition 'unexploitable'.
- MBlume 12y ago> Thankfully the city of San Francisco is fighting Sweetch and Monkey Parking with cease-and-desist orders. The city of San Francisco should be fighting Sweetch and Monkey Parking by cutting out the middleman and drastically raising their parking fees.
- vellum 12y agoThey could also use sensors that detect when a parking spot is free, and upload that information to an app or the web.
- zevyoura 12y agoThey're actually doing both of those things, though not on a spot-by-spot basis: http://sfpark.org/ http://sfpark.org/
- silencio 12y agoActually, they used to do it on a spot-by-spot basis to generate info about demand to change pricing, as the prices are often different depending on which block you park on (!). My original reason for using the sfpark iPhone app was that it could tell you where to go for the nearest currently-open street parking spot. They even had a publicly available data feed for this for other app developers to use: http://sfpark.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/SFpark-parking-sensor-data-feed-specifiation_2012-07-20.pdf http://sfpark.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/SFpark-parking-... Unfortunately they stopped providing sensor data about half a year ago with the end of the pilot program. But the sensors are still physically around, and SFMTA (hopefully) are looking into improving sensor technology to upgrade, and seeing if it makes sense to release this data again. Personally between that availability info and that SFMTA has not been afraid to tinker with pricing changes - definitely a big FU to Monkey Parking et al. Not sure why they didn't work with private lots and home garages or something instead - that would make a lot more sense than messing with something that's already in the works.
- wpietri 12y agoThey're doing some of that. But there's a problem with that: plenty of people who live here can't afford a sudden major bump in living expenses. In the long term, correct pricing is part of the solution. But in the short term, it'd be unfortunate to solve the problem by screwing poorer people. And anyway, this could be a temporary spike in demand. Once places like ZipCar and Uber get ahold of self-driving cars, I expect there will be a big decrease in car ownership.
- bunkat 12y agoWhenever I hear about these I always wonder what the people that found them are thinking. I mean, what type of person would you have to be to decide to try and screw over the restaurant industry (which already has historically low margins) just to make a buck? I can't even imagine how many fake reservations they would need to create to make that idea worthwhile for them. And what investors would give them money to do so?
- wpietri 12y agoI mentor at startup events, so I know exactly what kind of people they are. The good ones are people who just haven't thought it through. They've found some sort of demand, and they're doing the standard hack-the-system thing that the startup culture trains them to do. Once it's rolling, it's like Mencken said: "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it." The bad ones are the sort of entitled douchebags that would have previously gone into investment banking or some other industry where the money's great and ethics aren't emphasized. But now startups are the high-status, high-money thing, so that's what they're after.
- eevilspock 12y ago"It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it." Because nearly every internet business gets it's revenue from advertising, a lot of good people jump through hoops to convince themselves that they have not made a deal with the devil. The downvotes[1] come fast when I point out this moral and cognitive dissonance, usually without any counter argument since they just want me to go away. When I talk to anyone who's livelihood doesn't rely on advertising or marketing, there is near unanimous agreement that advertising is fundamentally manipulative and dishonest. Besides the social cost of Advertising, there many other costs[2]. The idea that advertising gives us free web content and services is utter bullshit. - [1] The cowardly downvotes with no counter argument have already started. Upton Sinclair is the actual source of the quote at the top. A wise man who got a bunch of downvotes in his time. [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7767811 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7767811
- wpietri 12y agoGod yes. The whole point of commerce is the creation and exchange of value. The great startups have been great because they create massive amounts of value in the world. Startups like this don't create value. They just shift the value around. In the case of these startups, they shift the value to rich people while pocketing the cash. They are essentially parasitic. Not only is that a dick move, it's dumb for a startup. Google can earn $60 billion in revenue per year because they create even more value than that for its users and customers. Startups that don't create much value have very limited opportunities for capturing value. As the parking app show, regulators are perfectly happy to ban things that don't create value, especially when they have obvious negative externalities. That's what happened to the entire telemarketing industry for example. So please, people: focus on creating value, not just on whatever bullshit will bring a few dollars through the door.
- NhanH 12y agoJust to be clear: I agree with your point on focusing on creating value. And after I read your comment, I agree that none of the startups in the articles are truly creating that much value. However, is it that simple to qualify when you're creating value? If I had read the article before HN's comments, I'd have thought the startup is cool (admittedly trivial and silly, but we have a lot of those nowadays), rather than parasitic. I'd have thought it's just a clever hack in helping more efficient distribution - in the true spirit of capitalism. Yes, while it would shift the value to rich people, it also free up the rich people's time, so they (rich people) can create more value. Assuming that rich people is richer because society decides that their time is more valuable, they can create more value in the same amount of times of some other poorer people. Of course, that might be not morally justifiable. But creating value and being morally correct is orthogonal. I'm not living in SF the SV area, but I've a few friends there. Every time they talked to me about startup ideas, I've always felt off about those ideas. I kept telling myself that trivial value is still value, and potentially if it can help many people, the net gain would still be large. How do I know where to draw the line? Edit: it seems like quite a few people have problem with my post, so let me rephrase the middle paragraph a bit: Ignoring the mentioning of rich/ poor, parking spot is a commodity. And just like other commodity in life, everyone values it differently. What's wrong in letting people paying for what they think it's worth for? The rich will always have advantage in buying commodity, and that's a fundamental issue in our society, but that's an entirely separate problem to fix, and the solution isn't telling people to stop producing commodity, or distributing them. In this specific case of parking lot, it's bad either way because a private company is skimming profit from public space.
- namocat 12y agoI completely agree with this article, but wonder if it's inevitable for someone to jump in and try to make profit off of services for the public good if there are people out there willing to pay for it. For example, if we had sufficient parking in the city, these startups would never even cause a blip. Someone must have been driving around for half an hour looking for parking and then thought to themselves that, at that point, they would pay someone good money to just be able to find a spot - and suddenly the idea for a business was born...
- wpietri 12y agoI think it's great that people want to solve problems, but this isn't actually solving the problem. It's shifting the problem from rich people to poor people. In contrast, there are plenty of startups that are actually making the parking problem better. City CarShare and ZipCar are reducing the number of cars in the city by having cars available on demand. GetAround and RelayRides are upping the number of drivers per car. Uber and Lyft (and taxis and transit) let you get somewhere without having to park at all. Parking Panda and Park Circa are turning unused private parking spaces into publicly available inventory. Even Amazon is helping: part of what makes happy to do without a car is the fact that they will make almost anything I want show up in a couple of days.
- aiiane 12y agoYeah. The real solution to parking in SF is to have fewer people driving, which would involve improving the public transit options.
- walshemj 12y agoAlways struck me as off is SF that has a trolly buss system why they didn't extend that with trams for longer distance commutes. Or did NIBY residents stop any such developments.
- oh_sigh 12y agoThe reservation is obvious bullshit, but I just don't see a problem with selling your parking spot.
- ar7hur 12y agoThe problem is it's not your parking spot, but public property.
- chatmasta 12y agoPossession is 9/10 of the law. ;) EDIT: Probably down voted because of length, but I'm pointing out that this is an opinion lots of people have, and there's a reason it exists as a truism. If you pass a law against apps like this, how could you possibly enforce it? The seller's car is already in the spot, and police can't get a real time notification that he's using the app. By the time they realize what happened (if ever) the spot has been sold.
- aiiane 12y agoHence why they go after the "racketeers" - the one facilitating it in an organized way.
- wpietri 12y agoAnd of course you can subpoena the racketeers, follow the money trail, and ticket both buyers and sellers. According to the city attorney, it's a $300 fine: http://www.sfcityattorney.org/index.aspx?page=599 http://www.sfcityattorney.org/index.aspx?page=599
- couchand 12y agoYou might look into the concept of a thought-terminating cliché [0]. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thought-terminating_clich%C3%A9#Thought-terminating_clich.C3.A9 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thought-terminating_clich%C3%A...
- oh_sigh 12y ago
- aosmith 12y agoSeems like reservation hop is engaging in deceptive practices. I bought tablesniper.com ~5 years ago with the same idea but didn't proceed after talking to attorneys.
- tyoma 12y agoThe restaurant issue I'm somewhat conflicted about -- I don't know enough about the business so some of my thoughts maybe impossible for various reasons. If people are willing to buy reservations, why not just charge more for the food until there is no waiting list? Or just charge for reservations (or at least those at preferred times) and keep the money for the restaurant? Whats the inherent reason that reservations have to be free with no charge to cancel? As for parking, the sooner cities get rid of hidden car subsidies the better. Artificially low priced street parking and building codes mandating garages are some of the more insidious subsidies that make everyone pay for those who drive. If the spots went for market rate, these apps wouldn't exist and the extra money could be used to improve public transit.
- fidotron 12y agoRight - what I get from the parking stuff is just how undervalued parking actually is, and just how poorly cities deal with it. The restaurant one is dodgy though. I could approve of a system where they've paid the restaurant in order to sell on a reservation (so the restaurant gets something even if there are no takers) but as it stands it's just a con.
- wpietri 12y agoParking isn't undervalued. People just pay in time, not money. Better to say that it's inefficiently priced. Shoup's "The High Cost of Free Parking" is the bible on that: http://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Parking-Updated-Edition/dp/193236496X http://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Parking-Updated-Edition/dp/1...
- fidotron 12y agoIt's totally undervalued. Ask the average person if they think the price of parking is right and they'll probably claim it's outrageously high, when the existence and apparently enough-to-be visible success of this app prove the opposite is true.
- 12y ago
- nl 12y agoJust wait someone realizes that it costs less for a driverless, electric car to sit in a traffic jam than a car park.
- aaronwall 12y agoThen they can have a fleet of them which go into traffic at peak hours & allow people to bid to have them removed from traffic. ;)
- ivanca 12y ago"What is your business model?" "Extortion" "Well, it is a time-proven way of making money; and you may go to jail, so I can see you are not afraid of risk... like a true entrepreneur!"
- jordanthoms 12y agoMafiaJoy?
- nl 12y agoIt's more serious than that. Car owners (or co-ops) can send their cars to loiter in deliberately created traffic jams and have them wait there all day, because it is cheaper than paying for parking. Then you press a button when you want your car, and it turns out of the traffic jam and comes and gets you. If you actually want to go down the road that has been selected as the most appropriate place to loiter... too bad for you.
- randallsquared 12y agoPeople keep using the phrases "the rich" and "the wealthy" in connection with this parking app (I heard this same phrasing on the NPR story about it last night), as though having a smartphone in the US and using it for parking is a sign of wealth. Firstly, a Virgin Mobile (no contract) Android phone is $30. Gas is well over $3 a gallon near SF. If you can afford to drive a car (even assuming it was given to you and you therefore have no payments), you can definitely afford a smartphone. Secondly, the company rep was quoted as saying that the highest price ever paid for a spot was $15. Is this is steep price to pay for a couple hours parking? Sure. Is it only for the wealthy? No, I'm thinking not. The reservation thing is much more of a "jerktech" startup because of the potential harm to the restaurant[1], but the parking startup seems like a win, all considered: people who care more can purchase certainty, and people who don't care as much couldn't be certain of getting a parking spot even before this, so... [1] though they could just require showing photo ID in the reserved name to effectively combat this, at least for a while.
- clay_to_n 12y agoI see your distinction between the two, and agree that the restaurant app clearly hurts the restaurants. But the parking app hurts every other driver in the city who doesn't take part. I really don't see how using auctions for every parking space is better for the whole than keeping public parking what it is now (public).
- Untit1ed 12y ago$15 worth of $3/gallon gas can take an efficient car a long way - there's a pretty big gap between paying that to travel 100 miles and paying it just to not drive anywhere for a few hours. It makes little difference to the wealthy, but for those who can barely afford to drive as it is it makes the situation even worse. But that's not the reason it's jerktech, it's because the parking space was already paid for with taxes. What monkey parking's doing isn't much better than brigands setting up in front of a bridge and demanding a toll from anyone who wants to cross it. (edited for grammar)
- fudgekludge 12y agoJust wanted to chime in to say that in SF if you have a parking permit you can park in some spaces for up to a week until street cleaning. When I had a car I would have gladly paid someone $15 to get a spot on my street on a Thursday knowing I could leave it there until Wednesday. Spots open up all the time but are filled quickly. I'm not defending the app, but there's definitely a (small?) market for something like that here.
- jbackus 12y ago> Don’t concert ticket re-sale sites like StubHub encourage and take a cut from scalping? Yes, and I’m not a big fan of them for that reason. If the demand for a band’s ticket is high, they’re the ones that should be making the mark-up, not some sleazy guy with 20 computers who bought 40 tickets the second they went on sale to turn around and flip them. But at least that guy has to bet his own money that he can resell a private commodity he bought. This is a weird opinion. This kind of resale is common in markets where producers would rather guarantee selling their entire product at a certain price as opposed to risking overpricing. Same reason many farmers sell off crops immediately to middlemen instead of trying to maximize price selling directly. They aren't being exploited, they're hedging risk. I would imagine that centralized ticket websites like StubHub also improve the venue's distribution in this case. If venues don't like resellers, they can follow Louis CK's actions[1]. [1] http://thenextweb.com/media/2012/07/03/louis-c-k-sees-ticket-scalping-drop-over-96-by-switching-to-selling-tickets-himself/ http://thenextweb.com/media/2012/07/03/louis-c-k-sees-ticket...
- jasonlotito 12y agoThe author isn't linking StubHub to these other startups, rather, they're saying "at least that guy has to bet his own money that he can resell a private commodity he bought."
- jbackus 12y agoYes, I'm glad he isn't dismissing them. I'm just saying that it isn't as simple as returning profits to the producer.
- Nursie 12y agoSome venues and some acts think this behaviour is scummy too, and go to great lengths to stamp it out. It's pretty antisocial to snap up as many tickets as possible and then relist them at double the price within seconds. If you can't go, fine, but if you're just profiteering then you're inserting yourself into a transaction where you're not wanted. It's the shows that sell out in seconds that these guys try to get in on, so there's no risk to the venue or the act anyway, scalpers are just basically extortionists at that point.
- Mikeb85 12y agoThe good news is that while markets can be irrational in the short run, eventually things that create no value ARE weeded out. And the restaurant industry for one, while very competitive, is also a fairly tight-knit community (due to the rigours and stress involved in the business), and word gets around fast. I'm sure cities will also crack down on auctioning public parking spots, to the extent that it will be an unprofitable exercise.
- icambron 12y agoI dislike all of these companies, but I'd have put it all differently: The first one, Reservation Hop, is simply indefensible because it relies on fraud. It's deceiving restaurants into thinking the person asking for a reservation is a real person. Not only does it involve lying, but it's fundamentally different from scalping a ticket because if no one "buys" the reservation, the restaurant gets nothing and was perhaps force to turn down legit customers, whereas the scalper actually paid for the ticket (though it may have been inefficiently priced, see below for more on that). It also creates no-value-added intermediary in the process. It's just a dick move all around. I do suspect that a trade group for the restaurants could get Reservation Hop cease-and-desisted, but the general solution here is for restaurants to take a credit card as part of the reservation process. The parking ones are a bit different, in that they're taking advantage of inefficiently priced parking. Ever notice how it's really hard to find a spot on a street full of first-come-first-serve, inexpensive parking? It's for the same reason there are long lines and empty gas pumps before a storm with anti-gouging rules in effect, or in stories about the Soviet Union. You can park there for long periods of time even though you may not have a pressing need for the spot, whereas people who have such a need can't get one. Normally we manage such supply and demand issues through prices, so if you need a spot badly enough you might be willing to pay for it and one will be available because most people aren't. [1] What happens almost inevitably when you have an inefficiently distributed good is a secondary market or some sort of cultural mos, both of which are usually ethically dubious. In Boston, people "reserve" spots by putting cones or lawn chairs in "their" spots and expect you to respect it less you get your car keyed, thus compounding the inefficiency. There are places where you can pay for people to "hold" your spot, and I've had someone try to sell me theirs once. These companies are filling in exactly there, except with technology. To be clear, I think these companies are pretty crummy. But my point is that they're the almost inevitable consequence of a pretty terrible system for allocating resources. I.e. if we want to fix this, the best way to do it is to fix the underlying problem rather than shaming businesses like this. EDIT: to be clear, I'm not against shaming them if it makes you feel good; I just think it's not the solution to the problem. Even though that description overlaps in places with the article, I like my framing a lot better. The article is coming from this place where entrepreneurs are expected to be these angels descended to Earth to fix all the "common man's" problem through innovation. Then we immolate ourselves because the community/scene turns out to be full of non-special people who are sometimes kinda shady and take advantage of bad policy and lax enforcement to make money, just like people in all other walks of life. (In an age where so much relies on technology, I don't even think it's reasonable to think of "startup tech stuff" as a scene or a space or a community at all.) Maybe it's fun to wring your hands about it and I can see a publication like TC likes to see things through that lens, but I don't think it's a very helpful way of approaching these problems if your real goal is to solve them. [1] An important question here, given the context, is doesn't this just help the rich get parking at the expense of poor people? Well, yes, it kind of does. On the other hand, if you can't find a spot, it doesn't help poor people much, except insomuch as poor people may be willing to spend a longer time trying to park (in which case, we're making them pay for it with their time, which doesn't seem good either). But more importantly, if we want to make things easier for poor people, we should give them money so that they can do what they want with it (including parking!). That's way better than making parking artificially cheap, because a) it's a lot more flexible from the poor person's perspective and b) it distorts the allocation of resources way less.
- aaron695 12y agoHow about stop the circle jerk. They are parasitic, arguable, but so what if they are? People dislike that, so what? What is the story here exactly? It seems to me it's just link bait with everyone agreeing they dislike these apps. It's an article saying being rude is bad. I don't see why people think this article has value other than they get to throw in a me too. And at the end of the day, I'd imaging most people here are also working for parasitic companies who just hide it a bit better. i.e. Advertising including SEO. This to me is more of a real story.
- funkyy 12y agoIt seems that the part of young generation is extremely demanding. So demanding that they misunderstand "communal" with "my". I am part of generation that is happy to destroy public property just because they can. Generation that sells what is rightfully owned by all. Its sad that mentioned startups are more like vultures rather than tigers. Good that someone finally publicly named those companies.
- icebraining 12y agoOh, please. Every generation had people selling common goods. The "tragedy of the commons" wasn't exactly coined last year. The reason these companies are made of young people is because they're tech startups.
- trysomething 12y agoFrankly there is no need to keep beating the drum about these startups. This is at least the 4th article about the parking apps on HN's front page in the last couple weeks. It's also been on TV. This is not not deeply interesting anymore, and as such I am flagging it. I hope others will do the same.
- gfodor 12y agoI'm going to go out on a limb here and say that the reservation thing, while being a bit sketchy in that the guy uses a fake name, doesn't seem as abhorrent as people seem to be making it out to be. If the guy was printing money hand over fist like an evil villain that'd be one thing, but it sounds like a weekend hack. An experiment. You know, the type of thing we encourage here so as to learn something. He cancels the reservation if nobody buys it. He's focusing on restaurants where demand outstrips supply (by definition.) My guess is the net effect of this experiment is probably increased revenue for the restaurants involved. It would be interesting if he presented numbers. It's an interesting experiment. Should it be literally turned into a business, as-is? No, because it requires a) lying on the phone and b) leaves the possibility open that restaurants are going to leave money on the table, so beyond being unethical you probably don't want to make enemies of the people who are providing the service your customers are paying for. It's not viable, and it's both dumb and unethical to form a serious venture around as-is. But let's admit it, he's found something interesting that perhaps with some tweaks could be turned into something disruptive. In the startups I've worked stuff we ran small stuff like this all the time: things that we'd never try to scale since we were breaking the rules a bit, but we were trying to learn something and knew the way we were executing on it "in the small" did not cause any real harm. But if we are going to just hang people out to dry immediately for releasing small experiments to test gaps in the market or test boundaries, then we've lost what it means to be a hacker. I don't like the idea that my entire reputation can be ruined if I launch a weekend hack that ends up on valleywag and starts a hate train fueled by wider hatred around the tech industry. Part of the reason startups work is because you can bend the rules a bit while you are small and under the radar while you look around at the edges for the opportunity for a real business you can stand behind. But with Twitter and the tech press even single individuals no longer seem to be able to stay off the radar if their experiment will drive clicks from angry readers and re-enforce their stereotypes about the tech scene.
- ipsin 12y agoDrivers selling parking spaces in San Francisco are potentially open to fines of $300 according to the city attorney. It seems very polite that they're going after sites like Monkey Parking instead of simply reserving spots for $5 or $10 and then busting the sellers at $300 a pop. I suppose that in that case, Monkey Parking would just become a component in an entirely different sort of ecology.
- ynniv 12y agoRegulate or save your breath. Jerks don't care whether people think that they're jerks or not.
- Ihaveagreatapp 12y agoEarly squatting on parking spots - like when a company is early to offer people social networking or online video, and they can then charge people endlessly based on their proprietary spot for activities that should remain free - public domain video and human interaction? Yeah, the parking guys are the only exploitative, piggybacking guys around on the web.
- neurobro 12y agoThere is certainly a high level of jerkiness in making fake reservations, but I think it's overblown in the article. If a restaurant is exclusive and popular enough to require reservations, and people are willing to pay $5-10 for a reservation, why don't they just charge $5-10 for reservations themselves, or require a small membership fee to make reservations, or start rejecting customers who can't prove they are the "Dick Jerkson" who made the reservation, etc? (That last one would only need to be a temporary measure, as most people are going to ditch the app after being turned away once or twice.)
- neilk 12y agoI don't understand your logic. Just because countermeasures could exist, it doesn't mean that the original offenders aren't so bad. Nor does that place any new responsibilities on the restaurant, to piss off their customers who by now might have been going to the same restaurants for decades, with the informal system. Furthermore, an ID check isn't as painless and easy to implement as you say. Often, other guests arrive before the person who made the reservation. Public figures make reservations under assumed names. And the name on someone's ID may not match the name they typically use (read patio11's brilliant piece http://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-names/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/06/17/falsehoods-programmers-b...). And then there's just the offensiveness of requiring people to carry ID in the first place.
- neurobro 12y agoI'm not saying the app is less bad because countermeasures exist, only that the app is not as bad as the article makes it out to be, and countermeasures exist. Restaurants constantly have to adapt to changing conditions, which is how they end up with reservation policies in the first place. The point of the ID suggestion (which was only one idea) would be to somehow identify users of the app, let them travel all the way to the restaurant with their date or client, and reject their reservation. This will kill the app faster than begging the developer to be less of a jerk.