2 ms·
It's not clear to me from the article how apps are able to gain permissions just from updating. Is it because future updates run under the 'new' system while th
by MBCook 12y ago
It's not clear to me from the article how apps are able to gain permissions just from updating. Is it because future updates run under the 'new' system while the current version still runs under the 'old' system?
I'm not sure I think this is so bad. Granular permissions can be annoying and confusing. If you surveyed the Android owning populace how many really care about rough/accurate location? "I want this app to know where I am" doesn't seem that bad. Read vs send SMS? I can sort-of see why you might want an app to only send, but I can't think of a case where you'd only want it to receive.
I may be colored by living in the world of iOS. There are very few permissions. Apps have access to your location or they don't. They can see your phonebook or they can't. They can access your photos or nothing. The fact that Android has more 'dangerous' abilities (sending SMS, phone calls, etc) makes it more difficult.
Some of this may just be poor categorization. I would expect most phone related stuff (phonebook, dialing, call log) to be under a single permission, but the ability to re-route calls should be under a different one (or only setup through settings).
I'm also surprised that there is a permission for using internet access. How many apps really don't need that? It seems like most everything people would want to use (games that show ads or scores, social media, browsers, etc) would need it, so you're just training people to say 'yes'. The keyboard example is a good one, but that sounds like certain things should just be a special type of app with different restrictions.
Sounds to me like Google is trying to fix the 'every app requiring every permission' problem by reducing the choices to be more understandable.
- duskwuff 12y ago> It's not clear to me from the article how apps are able to gain permissions just from updating. Is it because future updates run under the 'new' system while the current version still runs under the 'old' system? The permissions required by an application can change from one version to another. Previously, if an update demanded more permissions than the version it replaced, the user would be asked to confirm the change. Now, this permission "upgrade" will sometimes be allowed silently.
- MBCook 12y agoIs that only in category (read phonebook -> read phonebook & make calls) or across category (read phonebook -> read phonebook & setup a VPN)? I can understand the first given what they're trying to do, the second would be outrageous.
- duskwuff 12y agoWithin a category. However, as explained by the article, even that can involve some pretty serious escalations (e.g, "read SD card" to "format SD card"!).
- 2muchcoffeeman 12y agoThe fact that Android has more 'dangerous' abilities (sending SMS, phone calls, etc) makes it more difficult. I'm also surprised that there is a permission for using internet access. A few months back I had to deal with this on my home network: https://adblockplus.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=11849 https://adblockplus.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=11849 My brother had Adblock Plus on his Android tablet and it was continuously sucking down data to do nothing, presumably in a background process. It makes sense that if you want to give devs lots of power when making apps, you need to give users finer grained permissions. Maybe you can group things or whatever, but you probably shouldn't be making permissions coarser grained or forcing users to install 3rd party apps to get control of their phone again. This is one of the reasons I use iOS. I don't really have to worry too much about apps doing dodgy things because they are severely hamstrung to begin with.