3 ms·
You have to wonder what the economic impact would be if government policy were driven by a top ten list of quality-of-life issues. Would there be PSAs on TV sug
by Zigurd 12y ago
You have to wonder what the economic impact would be if government policy were driven by a top ten list of quality-of-life issues. Would there be PSAs on TV suggesting a bong hit instead of a drink? Would soda pop be locked up behind the counter? "Got more milk than you can digest?" How many points of GDP would it be worth to do the necessary social engineering?
The other side of the coin is: What is the total cost of successful industry lobbying that makes harmful products seem normal to the public?
I suspect that fascination with experiments in optimizations is what drives interest in things like Soylent.
- chrisdevereux 12y agoOr David Nutt's suggestion that, as a public health issue, we should be trying to engineer a drug with the same subjective effects as alcohol but without the toxicity or addictiveness: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/nov/11/alcohol-benefits-no-dangers-closer-think http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/nov/11/alcohol... (such a chemical would, in practice, be immediately banned in most countries)
- paulhauggis 12y agoIsn't this what quaaludes were in the 70s and 80s? (and they were quickly banned)
- chrisdevereux 12y agoHabit forming and toxic, so no. But yes, they were banned.
- Zigurd 12y agoMore, or less, than alcohol?
- chrisdevereux 12y agoComparable, I think. Definitely addictive. Less liver toxicity, but easier to overdose fatally (respiratory depression).
- Scoundreller 12y ago"Toxic" is a misunderstood term. Toxicity is all about dose. The water piped into my residence can be toxic despite meeting drinking water-quality guidelines. If I drank its full output continuously for just minutes, I'd be dead of water intoxication.
- andreasvc 12y agohttp://www.drugs.com/quaaludes.html http://www.drugs.com/quaaludes.html Doesn't seem to fit the bill to me, it has strong withdrawal effects and makes people do reckless things, according the link above.
- evan_ 12y agoSynthehol! http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Synthehol http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Synthehol
- SilasX 12y agoPhenylethylamine?
- adwf 12y agoThe tricky part in my mind is determining what exactly a quality of life issue is in the first place. I know plenty of moderate, sensible drinkers who would consider their quality of life lowered if there were any more restrictions placed on alcohol. It's not just a price issue, but all sorts of things like not being able to buy alcohol on a Sunday, despite not being religious. Or one that I personally still experience from time to time - being asked for ID despite being 12 years over the age limit. These are all quality of life issues in my mind. If we were to solely go on doctors guidelines, life would be pretty boring. No sport - too dangerous. No drinking - too much liver damage. No sailing, no cheerleading, no mountain climbing, etc... There comes a point at which you just have to tell the doctors that it's all well and good pointing out the risks, but ultimately, life is about risks. I can barely see the point in living if we deny ourselves all the slightly risky things just because of the potential downsides. It's cowardice wrapped up in a fresh new label for the modern age.
- Argorak 12y agoThis is all covered by standard models of quality of life - including medical ones - to be found everywhere, including wikipedia or in your favourite journal. Any sane doctor won't tell you to stop playing soccer if you like it, even if is a rather dangerous sport in the lower leagues.
- Hytosys 12y agoMaybe your thoughts apply to yourself and you aren't part of the immediate problem, but binge drinking has been known to be the cause/catalyst in incidents involving bystanders (temperament, drunk driving, etc.). To a personal extent, everyone respects free will. That's not the problem. It's certainly on another caliber, but the dissonance actuated in your arguments remind me a lot of anti-vaccine arguments.
- Zigurd 12y agoThe threshold for binge drinking described in the article is well into the "I'd be smashed" territory, so there's no alcohol scaremongering in this case. Also things like free-soloing (corrected as per comment below), and for that matter things society frowns on like needle-drug use, are self-limiting and have orders of magnitude less impact than binge drinking. That's where prioritization washes out pursuing ineffective optimizations.
- zo1 12y ago"You have to wonder what the economic impact would be if government policy were driven by a top ten list of quality-of-life issues. " Not all issues boil down to "economic impact". Nor is it the only determining factor when deciding on such matters. You have to take into account peoples willingness, or lack thereof to do these things you speak of. Otherwise, you'll have to concede that all you're trying to do is maximize peoples' output for the purpose of benefiting the country, as if it were a farm.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Not all issues boil down to "economic impact". Arguably, they really do, but you have to remember that economics is about the distribution of scarce things (both material goods and services) connected to experienced utility (money is just a -- rather poor in many respects, but also very convenient -- proxy for utility.)
- gress 12y agoSome kind of platonic ideal of economics may be about experienced utility, but in practice it's just more politics.
- dragonwriter 12y agoI think you are confusing the study of economics with the talking heads discussing economics in the mainstream media. But even if you were right, and "economic" was just a code word for "political", it would be even more true (though for a different reason) that all issues of government policy boil down to economic impact.
- gress 12y agoThe academic study of economics is no different. There is not a science of economics.
- Zigurd 12y agoI wholeheartedly agree that there is a lot wrong with GDP. It sure isn't directly equivalent to quality of life. BUT when the issue is morbidity and mortality among the working-age population, GDP isn't that bad a metric. And it has the advantage of appealing to greed.