5 ms·
> Our education system is propped up chiefly because of government. Obviously not propped enough if this professor died in poverty and students need 6 figure l
by rdtsc 12y ago
> Our education system is propped up chiefly because of government.
Obviously not propped enough if this professor died in poverty and students need 6 figure loans to graduate.
> Most of the US goes to public schools, controlled by the government.
As opposed to what? Controlled by Coca-Cola? Starbucks? -- "Do you have a degree?" -- "I sure do, I graduated with MS in coffee arts (MsCA) from Starbucks University, Phoenix". Or just got a "PhD in applied lobbying from Lockheed".
> Students get ridiculous loans they can't default on, courtesy of the government.
The problem is not to just stop giving loans, but let people go to universities without needing loans. If Universities are public, they should admit based on merit. And instead of cycling money through govt to student to university, just subsidize the university and make sure it doesn't spend money on admin assistants, triple layers of bureaucracy, new gyms with lazy rivers and other crap that is not needed. Maybe if it is too hard, just increase % of admitted students based on merit, some that couldn't quite make it and are rich perhaps could buy their way in.
> maybe regulation and government caused the problem in the first place.
Can you point to an example of an attested and well functioning higher learning system not regulated and propped by a government?
- jmckib 12y ago> As opposed to what? Controlled by Coca-Cola? Starbucks? -- "Do you have a degree?" -- "I sure do, I graduated with MS in coffee arts (MsCA) from Starbucks University, Phoenix". Or just got a "PhD in applied lobbying from Lockheed" School vouchers are a great alternative to public schools http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_voucher http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_voucher
- Jtsummers 12y agoMy primary issue with school vouchers is the poor state of private schools, at least here in GA (outside of the major cities like Atlanta and Savannah). The Catholic schools are decent to good, but often are only K-8. There are few private secular schools. The rest of the private schools are very conservative "Christian Academy" types whose education leaves their students complete morons in some fields (math, science, history, civics; I guess, really, everything).
- jmckib 12y agoI bet that if we switched to vouchers then you'd see a lot of new private schools catering to a wider audience. It also might be reasonable to exclude private schools with religious instruction from the voucher program.
- Jtsummers 12y agoI'd like to be that optimistic, and maybe it'd happen, but the politics around here would make it unlikely. Also, wrt the exclusion of religious schools, that'd be a non-starter in the southern states at least. It'd probably make more sense to mandate some minimum curricula or require that inspectors be able to attend the school unannounced if the school is receiving public moneys via vouchers. There'd likely be a tantrum about religious oppression, but, really, man and dinosaurs, contrary to the teachings at many of the churches and Christian academies around here, really didn't live together [1]. [1] Ok, in the conventional sense of dinosaurs, not the XKCD sense of birds as living dinosaurs. http://xkcd.com/1211/ http://xkcd.com/1211/
- sitkack 12y agoYou are not a betting man.
- hnal943 12y agoWow, most other places in the US it is the opposite. Private schools are considered superior. They have to be, because there is otherwise no reason to both pay property taxes and also pay tution.
- Jtsummers 12y agoAround here it's largely politics and religion, not the quality of the school. There's one catholic school with a good academic reputation. The other two I know of are ok. The rest of the private schools are bad to mediocre. They may be better in some ways than the public schools, but not enough (IMO) for the tuition costs.
- rdtsc 12y ago> School vouchers are a great alternative to public schools http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_voucher http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_voucher Are there universities on the voucher system?
- dnautics 12y ago>As opposed to what? Controlled by Coca-Cola? Starbucks? -- "Do you have a degree?" -- "I sure do, I graduated with MS in coffee arts (MsCA) from Starbucks University, Phoenix". Or just got a "PhD in applied lobbying from Lockheed". False dichotomy. There are plenty of things that fit in between "rapacious megacorporations" and "government cronies". Like, for example, unsubsidized nonprofit educational institutes. You know, like you might have found in the 19th - first half of the 20th century.
- rdtsc 12y ago> You know, like you might have found in the 19th - first half of the 20th century. 19th century? So it is easier to imagine going back to 19th century than a system with an accessible public university system without student loans.
- dnautics 12y agoNo, 'going back to the 19th century (-first half of the 20th century)' is equivalent to imagining a higher education system without student loans. Don't see what the big deal is.
- rdtsc 12y agoThe point I was trying to make was that somehow it was easier to imagine time travelling than just looking "across the pond", oh to say Sweden. Or probably other civilised countries.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoIn the 19th century and the pre-social-democratic 20th century, most universities had no student loans because they charged steep fees in cold cash. If you want to eliminate student debt without eliminating students, you need to look at the social-democratic universities of the post-WW2 era.
- dnautics 12y ago
- jdreaver 12y ago> Obviously not propped enough if this professor died in poverty and students need 6 figure loans to graduate. I argue that it is precisely because of government intervention that these things happen. > As opposed to what? Controlled by Coca-Cola? Starbucks? -- "Do you have a degree?" -- "I sure do, I graduated with MS in coffee arts (MsCA) from Starbucks University, Phoenix". Or just got a "PhD in applied lobbying from Lockheed". Are you implying that without government, we as a society would be unable to educate people? > The problem is not to just stop giving loans, but let people go to universities without needing loans. That will make universities even more inefficient. Do you know what will ensure "make sure it doesn't spend money on admin assistants, triple layers of bureaucracy, new gyms with lazy rivers and other crap that is not needed?" The fear of failure that universities don't experience now. The fear that if you don't do your job, students will not willingly give you money. "Harsh capitalism" solves that problem.
- rdtsc 12y ago> Are you implying that without government, we as a society would be unable to educate people? Well I don't have to imply you just have to show a few example of a successful world renown university run completely outside the control of a government. There are example of successful higher education institutions controlled and sponsored by governments. Western Europe has those example. > The fear of failure that universities don't experience now. Again, can you show one single example of a university outside the control of government that accomplishes and is driven by this mythical fear. > "Harsh capitalism" solves that problem Be honest now, have you been reading some Ayn Rand? That is fiction you know that, right?
- alchemism 12y ago> I argue that it is precisely because of government intervention that these things happen. It may very well be that the various 20th-century post-war G.I. Bills started the college bubble in the first place, by democratizing the expectation of higher education to the lower classes for the first time in history.
- thejdude 12y ago> "Do you have a degree?" -- "I sure do, I graduated with MS in coffee arts (MsCA) from Starbucks University, Phoenix". Or just got a "PhD in applied lobbying from Lockheed". Not arguing against public funding of education, but you're making a nice point about the inherent BS of degrees that exist merely on paper. Nobody actually cares about that piece of paper - employers want to know what you DID and what you're CAPABLE of. A college degree used to be reasonable proof of peoples' abilities, but today conflating the two usually doesn't help. Thus post-college unemployment, or idiots running companies from nice positions.