8 ms·
Uber plays hardball with early shareholders
- fiatmoney 12y agoIf you can't sell it, you don't really own it.
- gecko 12y agoEh. I own a lot of stock in one of the companies I used to work for. I can't legally sell it. That doesn't mean I don't own it, but I mentally adjust its on-paper value appropriately, basically multiplying its on-paper value by the chance that the company might go public. In effect, what I own is a lottery ticket, but I do own that ticket.
- pfortuny 12y agoNo: if you can't sell it, it is not money-equivalent but you own it anyway. You cannot sell your arm, or your life, or so many other things. And at the same time, it is not that they can't sell it. They can't at the price they expect. Which is different.
- Istof 12y agowhat would you say about the value if you can't sell it? 0?
- joezydeco 12y ago"This fear of being viewed as a startup enemy also is why none of the early Uber investors we spoke with would allow us to publish their names." What is a "startup enemy" and how does wanting to recoup some of your investment make you one?
- opendais 12y agoIf you got into a legal battle with your employer, there would be consequences to future employment. The same is true of investors. A legal battle with a company you invested in might close off access to future deals. Now, a reasonable person might evaluate the facts of the case if they have time...but not everyone has the time and/or would agree that they should sue Uber. It is alot like having worked on a porn site I think. Some people would go "Oh, cool, you worked on a big project there that had the kind of scale we hope to achieve." Others would look at it and drop your resume directly into the trashbin. I suspect there is a similar effect on VC/Angel access to startups that are popular enough to have a bidding war like Uber.
- angersock 12y ago"If you got into a legal battle with your employer, there would be consequences to future employment." I mean, is this really the case though? Any reasonable employer I know of would say, "Oh, well, that's unfortunate, but your business", and move on. I think this repeated meme is just a good way to keep workers in their place.
- UK-AL 12y agoIt normally effects the first job you get after the legal battle. However after the first job, nobody cares because you've proven yourself not to purposeful "trouble maker", and most likely makes the company look bad instead. Markets are a fickle beast...
- opendais 12y agoI have an Aunt who is no longer able to find a job in the industry she originally worked due to a legal battle with someone who is well known and respected in that industry. She has a job in a different industry now and makes significantly less [like 50%]. She doesn't think she'll be able to retire before 70 because of it. Admittedly, the industry was very small and incestuous and it isn't like Tech where labor holds alot of power at present. I also have a family friend who is an idiot and did something similar for stupid reasons [it turns out he signed paperwork he thought he never had, didn't keep copies]. He ended up in a government job eventually but he spent a couple years on welfare because he didn't believe my parents when they told him no one would hire him. It really has an impact, at least anecdotal. It is possible I'm unusual in having close relationships with 2 people who had this happen and its much rarer in the general population.
- danielweber 12y agofamily friend who is an idiot and did something similar for stupid reasons [it turns out he signed paperwork he thought he never had Was it a noncompete?
- opendais 12y ago
- unchocked 12y agoA "startup enemy" is someone who puts their own interests above those of the startup.
- joezydeco 12y agoSo, basically, your VC money is awesome, wonderful and welcome until the check clears...and then you're the "enemy" for wanting to stay in control of it. Doesn't this reduce every early investment in a startup into a binary thing? You either lose it all, or hit a home run. Unless you pull a Groupon and exit everyone before the IPO.
- unchocked 12y agoI believe the context is what an employee does with her equity stake, rather than what a founder does with the capital. And no, I don't think it does.
- joezydeco 12y agoThe quote mentions Uber investors, not employees, even though the article deals mostly with an Uber employee trying to sell shares. This is why I'm a bit confused.
- danielweber 12y agoWill Phil Greenspun ever get VC funding again? (I'm not a big fan of him, personally, but at least he let the rest of us see how incredibly offended VCs get when you don't roll over and play dead.)
- skizm 12y agoIsn't there a law that if there are more than 500 shareholders for a private company that the company must go public? Sounds like a totally reasonable reason for keeping a tight hold on the stock.
- opendais 12y agoYes, but they should pay market rates for the stock. The article made it sound like they were trying to buy it up at $4 billion evaluation when they knew they'd be auctioning some off for $10+ billion.
- skizm 12y agoIs there any reason for them to pay more? I mean sure, it is a bit of a dick move but they seem like they aren't exactly trying to buy back the stock. They just don't want too many people selling. So either they get cheap stock or they block the sale. Win win for Uber, right?
- opendais 12y agoIt is an abuse of monopoly power in this situation to pay below market rates. You don't screw people who had faith [investors; early employees with equity] in you. They shouldered a good deal of risk and you knifed them in the back by paying below market rates.
- ganeumann 12y agoNot that I think Uber is handling this constructively, but there's a valid reason why they would not offer the valuation bandied about in the press: they are not buying the same equity as the $17 billion+ equity. The venture investors bought Preferred equity, the shares being sold by the employee are almost certainly Common equity. Common equity is worth less than Preferred equity. The times I have seen offers to buy Common shares in connection with a Preferred round, the discount has been as high as 50%. This makes sense: assume you are an investor putting $1.2 billion into a company that has previously raised $300 million (this is roughly the recent Uber situation.) You are investing at a $17 billion valuation. Now assume that you were very, very wrong on the valuation and the company ends up selling for 90% less: $1.7 billion. You still get your money back. If the company goes on and sells for $34 billion, you double your money. This asymmetrical payout is one reason venture firms are comfortable taking the risk of such a high valuation. Now assume you bought $10 million of Common shares from a former employee. If the company ended up selling for $1.7 billion, you would get back roughly $100,000 (assuming the preferred owns half the company.) You don't really have an asymmetrical payout: you stand to lose money if the valuation is wrong. A wider the spread between the Preferred price and the Common price implies less confidence in the Preferred valuation. The actual valuation is the Common valuation, and the extra amount paid for Preferred stock is a kind of option value. So an alternative explanation to Uber short-changing its Common shareholders is that they believe the expected value of the company is closer to $4 billion than $17 billion and the Preferred buyers think the range of possible outcomes has an extremely large standard deviation.
- bickfordb 12y agoIt seems like reforms are needed to protect workers from predatory stock option contracts like these. Workers have almost no negotiating power in these cases, since they usually have common shares and no board voting power.
- gohrt 12y agoUltimately, workers need to value the options properly: ~$0. Interestingly, with options/RSUs clauses in employement contracts, workers are making "investments" in privately held securities on the order of ~$100K. In general (outside of employment contracts) such investments are not legal if the worker is not signed off as a "sophisticated investor". I would like the SEC to close this loophole, by mandating some minimum disclosure requirements about the potential risks of options/RSUs, and barring employers from making misleading statements.
- opendais 12y agoI'd say the options are worth more like 5% of whatever their value is when you get them. They aren't worthless but it really is a high risk gamble that you are going to get value out of them.
- RyJones 12y agoA lottery ticket with 5% odds of payoff would be phenomenal. I think $0 is the proper value - I've never worked for a startup that paid dollar one on options. Warning, if I work somewhere, you should short that stock / not take options. Sorry.
- opendais 12y agoFair enough. Maybe it is more like .1-1%. I made up the 5% number off the top of my head tbh. I'd really need to sit down and see what % of startups actually go public. That would be a fairer number to use. 1 in 20? 1 in 50? 1 in 100? Please keep your profile updated with where you work so I can short them. <3
- 12y ago
- throwoptions 12y agoI'm in what might be a very similar position: I'm employed at a startup and was just given an option grant as a performance bonus. I believe I can't sell the stocks, and we're not really looking to go public, so I don't know what use they are or what any of it means. Is there a certain class of lawyer I can take my paperwork to and pay some fee for them to go over it and tell me what my options are (no pun intended)?
- free2rhyme214 12y agoYes there are lawyers who can help you however, options are essentially worthless unless the company goes public. Option grants, employee benefits, bonuses...these are all carrot sticks employers use for employee retention. Bigger companies like Google can offer bus rides, better benefits, higher salary, etc. Make sense?
- rickyc091 12y agoAre you upset you received options instead of cash for your bonus? If so, you could have mentioned that you would take a salary raise instead of options. There really isn't much you can do with options until they go public or the company gets bought. You can also try to sell them on Secondary Market or SharesPost.
- throwoptions 12y agoOh, I'm not upset, I'm doing quite well otherwise, I've just been unable to find a law firm advertising anything related to what I'm looking for, which either means to me I need a specific type of lawyer to evaluate it or any ol' lawyer might work?
- rickyc091 12y agoAhhh, it's probably better to have an investor look over it as they probably deal with hundreds of these. It would probably be the simplest route and they have a clear understanding of this market.
- Guvante 12y ago
- jeremymcanally 12y agoIt's amazing to me what companies will stick in these contracts, and how deep down the rabbit hole they'll stick it. It's their stock to do it with, of course, but it's just annoying that seemingly employee-centric companies will do such seemingly abusive things. For example, I've seen instances of sale restrictions being four contracts deep (e.g., "shall be governed by (x) agreement", and that agreement says "shall be bound by terms in (y)", and so on) in an agreement that employees were only ever officially given a draft version of but apparently still held as effective. It should have never been signed of course, but the obtuse nature and comforting language these things are couched in can be confusing. At the same time, it's also unfortunate that people don't do research to look at other instruments for liquidity (like pre-paid forward transactions) that the restraining company has zero control over. In Uber's case though, it seems like they're actually paying on the up-and-up. Many companies intentionally deflate the fair market value of shares far, far below the actual valuation (like 1/25th the value paid by investors in the last round, for example), so offering to sell at what the investors paid in at is pretty decent. Private equity is confusing and usually doesn't work in your favor. My general advice is to always appreciate it, but never depend on it as part of your compensation in any way (and Good Lord, don't bank your retirement on it!).
- pjc50 12y agonever depend on it as part of your compensation in any way This is very true. I've been in the position of having worthless share options before. It's something everyone who's tempted to work 80 hour weeks because they have share options should remember. You should also remember the Google cook, who had $200m in options that the company tried to do him out of because he wasn't a developer.
- simulate 12y agoAre we talking about Charlie Ayers, the Google Cook? He earned $26 million from his options, not $200 million. He also had over 150 employees and 5 executive chefs reporting to him. He did well and was fortunate but he also wasn't just some guy in a lunch room preparing cafeteria food. EDIT: There is a nice description of Ayers in wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlie_Ayers http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charlie_Ayers
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoThey shouldn't be surprised, they knew Uber was going ot be disruptive and not inclined to follow regulatory practices when they signed on.
- riter 12y agoI would imagine of they happen to be an S or C Corporations. I believe C-Corps are mandated to go public if they exceed 100 shareholders per SEC. It also depends.
- sheetjs 12y agoThis is a commonly held belief but is false: > Companies with more than $10 million in assets whose securities are held by more than 500 owners must file annual and other periodic reports. http://www.sec.gov/about/laws.shtml http://www.sec.gov/about/laws.shtml The reason people believe that it forces companies to go public is because, in many cases, the incremental cost to going public (above and beyond the filing) is insignificant compared to the advantages.
- bthomas 12y agoIs there room for legislation to ensure at least some liquidity in employee stock? I hate turning to government, but the current system makes it literally impossible for an employee to value options.
- jstalin 12y agoNot sure why this is news. Virtually every privately-held corporation or LLC has a stock transfer restriction. Any company that doesn't is an outlier.
- tzs 12y agoThis part was interesting: > The employee also learned that Uber had amended its bylaws more than a year earlier, in order to restrict unapproved secondary sales. It was unclear if the bylaw change actually applied to shareholders who had not been party to the vote — lawyers seem to disagree on this point of Delaware law — but Uber threatened litigation if he tried to proceed. So he held. The financial and reputational hassles of a lawsuit would have just been too much, even if he had won. One of the main reasons to incorporate in Delaware is that they have an extensive body of settled law on complex corporate issues. That Uber has managed to handle what should have been a pretty common and routine thing in a way that apparently is unclear under Delaware law is worthy of a story.
- wpietri 12y agoThe news to me is that they are using the restriction to buy stock cheap and sell it dear, screwing their early supporters out of the difference.
- robbiemitchell 12y agoWhat a non-story. This is a typical way for a private company to manage who owns its stock -- namely investors, employees, and former employees. It's basically a right of first refusal. You sell your options back to the company at the current market rate -- the rate at which that most recent investors purchased equity. That's your liquidity. The company will do this because it believes the options are undervalued compared to what they'll be worth in the future. If you don't want to do that, you hold and wait for the options to go up (or unfortunately down) in value. If the company doesn't want to buy them, you _should_ be free to sell to others. Restrictions in _those_ cases would be worth writing about.
- boucher 12y agoA right of first refusal is usually the right to buy at the same price as a third party has offered, not at some other price determined by the company.
- robbiemitchell 12y agoAh, I think I meant right of first offer/negotiation. Similar to real-estate arrangements in NYC.
- xtrumanx 12y ago> You sell your options back to the company at the current market rate -- the rate at which that most recent investors purchased equity. Why should the "market rate" determined by the most recent round of investments? A lot could have changed since then. > If the company doesn't want to buy them, you _should_ be free to sell to others. Restrictions in _those_ cases would be worth writing about. The issue isn't having to sell back to Uber but having to sell it at Uber's price.
- robbiemitchell 12y agoIt's true that a lot could have changed since the previous investment round, but isn't that often the case in venture capital funding? Paying a different price for one person's equity changes the valuation for everyone as the new market rate. This can be bad for an individual (could be sold for higher on private market) but also good (prevents someone else from selling at a major discount). Companies want to control valuation much more closely than that, so valuation is pegged to investment or some other major event. Whether that's a good way to do things would be a nice discussion topic, but that's not the same as saying uber in particular is playing hardball. A little bit of research would reveal that it's standard practice.
- jcnnghm 12y agoI think that anything more aggressive that the right-of-first-refusal at the third-party offer price is unconscionable.
- paul 12y agoPre-ipo transfer restrictions are pretty normal. It never even occurred to me to try selling Google pre-ipo. It wasn't really a thing before secondmarket came along, and arguably trading on those markets is taking a company public without their consent. If I ever start another company, I would definitely have transfer restrictions. It's pretty important to control your equity, and I think the day-trading mentality is toxic. (I would also avoid ever trading on the traditional stock markets, but that's a larger topic)
- danielweber 12y agoTransfer restrictions need to buy the stock at the offered price. If I have a good faith buyer willing to pay $200 per share, the company should offer $200. I was a start-up where the board just decided to be as difficult as possible, just to be difficult, and said, "you will need to hire an auditor to review the books to come up with an accurate market value, and we will not cooperate with the auditor", not in those exact words. Which of course completely breaks the books of a minority shareholder in a moderately successful company.
- dsl 12y ago> It's pretty important to control your equity, and I think the day-trading mentality is toxic. Equity is compensation. You can't tell your employees what to spend paychecks on, and you shouldn't be trying to block them from gaining liquidity. Maybe a doctor just told them they have a year to live, and won't be around for your planned 2019 IPO. Unless you are granting them voting shares it is unfair to lock them into your vision of the company going forward, especially if they have departed.
- paul 12y agoI agree that it needs to be clearly communicated (and perhaps they did not do that in this case), but there's no reason why equity must be liquid. I certainly have no expectations of immediate liquidity in my startup investments. Voting is a non-issue. Assuming things are structured right, the founders should retain majority control. The investment is primarily an investment in their vision, not something to be micro-managed by shareholders.
- winterchil 12y agoWhat hasn't been mentioned yet is that employees hold Common Stock, whereas the investors generally hold preferred stock. The preferred stock is worth more than the common stock because of special protections/provisions/voting rights/etc. It's perfectly reasonable that the price would be lower on a buyback program. On the other hand controlling the equity is pretty important and it's not surprising they won't let it go to open market. Welcome to the wonderful world of being a minority shareholder.