2 ms·
Thanks for saying this. I can't really comment on your experiments (I;m not qualified) but you can be assured that some people are working in machine learning
by dekhn 12y ago
Thanks for saying this. I can't really comment on your experiments (I;m not qualified) but you can be assured that some people are working in machine learning today specifically having learnt the lessons of pre- and post-CASP. I don't know that I agree CASP was founded specifically because people found decoys, but...
it was an special shock when I learned about ensemble methods (I think they were just called "combined servers" at the time) at CASP and saw that all our hard work (manual alignments, lots of expert analysis of models, etc) wasn't really better (far worse in fact) than a few simply trained ensemble systems that memorized what they were bad at and classified their predictions with the appropriate probabilities.
See also:
http://www.nature.com/nchem/journal/v6/n1/nchem.1821/metrics/googleplus http://www.nature.com/nchem/journal/v6/n1/nchem.1821/metrics...
http://googleresearch.blogspot.com/2012/12/millions-of-core-hours-awarded-to.html http://googleresearch.blogspot.com/2012/12/millions-of-core-... (note, 4 of the 6 projects awarded specifically involved physical modelling of proteins and the fifth was a drug-protein binding job)
http://research.google.com/archive/large_deep_networks_nips2012.html http://research.google.com/archive/large_deep_networks_nips2...
none of the above are coincidental: the first two links are specifically because I went to Google to use those GPUs and CPUs for protein folding and design and drug discovery. The third project is now something I am experimenting with.
- varelse 12y ago> don't know that I agree CASP was founded specifically because people found decoys, but... Here's an example of what drove my work back then: Look at the energies and RMSDs (a measure of distance from the native structure) of melittin in these two papers: Table 2 in http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/pro.5560020508/pdf http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/pro.5560020508/pd... and Table 1 in http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1260499/pdf/biophysj00100-0122.pdf http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1260499/pdf/biop... In the first paper, the energy is higher, but the RMSD is lower. In the second paper, the RMSD is higher, but the energy is lower. How did this happen? Well, in the first paper, phi/psi angles are set directly from a library of sequentially homologous dipeptides to pentapeptides that INCLUDES MELITTIN. So, by the time you get to tripeptides, you're nearly guaranteed to just be outputting the native conformation phi/psi angles over and over again. And this paper is just one of many to make basic mistakes like this. As young turk back then, I got into a rather long and vigorous online argument with one of the founders of CASP who insisted the first paper was a partial solution to the protein folding problem. And I suspect that argument influenced the subsequent creation of CASP. Anyway, it's been nice rehashing my post-doc glory days(tm), but we no longer have any excuses here. We have the tools, we have the technology...