3 ms·
The brain does not have unlimited self-organizational ability either though - it's why neurological development in the womb is so important, because if the prot
by XorNot 12y ago
The brain does not have unlimited self-organizational ability either though - it's why neurological development in the womb is so important, because if the proto-brain doesn't get initially structured just like, we don't wind up with something capable of general reasoning later in it's life.
So I don't really think this is a problem - or I'd contend we don't know enough to say it definitely would be.
- Udo 12y agoI think I failed to get my point across, then. If you go back to my original comment, you'll find that priming the developing brain has in fact been addressed and that's not what I mean. I was referring to the concept of hard-coded relationship predicates which make the system easy to program from the outside, but which have the drawbacks I already talked about.
- ssdfsdf 12y agoI agree, the way that the system reasons should be configurable by the system itself. Of course you have to give it some fundamental operation(ultimately we operate within the mappings of the universe), but this should be as low level as possible, allowing the system to build its own composite structure with which to reason.
- joe_the_user 12y agoThe qualities of any finite system are finite so "unlimited" doesn't mean much here. At the same time, one thing that's notable about human intelligence is that, in comparison to source code, the learning and the skills gained in one context can be much very easily mobilized for use other contexts (see Winograd and Flores' use of Martin Heidegger's term "ready at hand" in their critique of AGI, etc). And yes, I'd love to put this claim in more exact but but that would only be possible if we'd solved the question of "what is intelligence". Yes, since the problem isn't solved, we can't prove that a lack of flexibility will doom any given system. But I'm still fine pointing out that my human intuition, honed by many years of evolution, says any general intelligence requires far greater flexibility than is evident in most humanly constructed logic systems.