8 ms·
Uber Isn’t Worth $17 Billion
- vikramhaer 12y agoGreat write-up. For those interested and not already aware, Damodaran's own site has lots of great posts on finance and valuation. This article seems to build on his original analysis done here: http://www.aswathdamodaran.blogspot.com/2014/06/a-disruptive-cab-ride-to-riches-uber.html http://www.aswathdamodaran.blogspot.com/2014/06/a-disruptive...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jasondc 12y agoThe author fails to mention Uber is creating a new market, and shouldn't be valued at the size of the existing market it is disrupting. Aaron Levie had a good tweet about this: "Sizing the market for a disruptor based on an incumbent's market is like sizing the car industry off how many horses there were in 1910."
- mscarborough 12y agoLet's not get ahead of ourselves. We've had taxis and black cars for decades, it's nothing new. What happens when every existing taxi company has an app? Because that's what's happening. Then what we have is Uber/Lyft/whatever trying to avoid any regulation, while everyone else with the same thing are actually doing it. So disruptive!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pbiggar 12y ago> We've had taxis and black cars for decades, it's nothing new. People drank coffee before starbucks.
- andyroid 12y agoNot sure about the point you're trying to make, but if you somehow think Starbucks is "disrupting" coffee consumption, please think again. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_coffee_consumption_per_capita http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_coffee_c...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- antidaily 12y agoOk, but why male models?
- beering 12y agoI think the author hit this point by accounting for an accelerated growth of the "underserved" taxi market. He puts it at 6% YOY - what do you estimate it to be?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- fraserharris 12y agoSF (Uber's most mature market) has grown 20%+ YOY from 2009 - 2014 based on some rough math: "When we got this company started (in 2009) we were pitching the seed round and we pulled a bunch of research from this report that showed that San Francisco total spend on taxi and limo was like 120 million bucks. But we’re a very healthy multiple bigger than that right now, just Uber in SF. So it’s not about the market that exists, it’s about the market we’re creating." - Travis Kalanick [1] http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2014/06/06/uber-ceo-travis-kalanick-were-doubling-revenue-every-six-months/ http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2014/06/06/uber-ceo-travis-kalan...
- vikramhaer 12y agoI feel like this comment was made without reading the post. "Uber’s growth potential rests not only on being able to claim a larger share of the car-service market but also on expanding this market by attracting those who use public transportation or drive their own cars." He even mentions that his base case is assuming uber remains in the car-service related business.
- Pxtl 12y agoExcept that Uber is, currently, a car-service. Now, you can argue that Uber has the potential to be more than a car service, but right now Uber's product is a car service. And there's only so much market for a car service. It's a new kind of car service, but still a car service.
- aetherson 12y agoHow many horses were there in 1910? Serious question.
- xivzgrev 12y agoI respect Aaron a lot, but that's an unhelpful comment. An investor is trying to think through a fair valuation. If we can't value off of the horse & buggy market, then what are we going to? Henry Ford's H&D (hopes & dreams)? I think for any company, especially those attacking an established industry, that those markets that have a higher probability of being attacked should be valued higher. So yes I would say the horse & buggy market, at that time, SHOULD comprise the majority of the valuation for Henry Ford. There are other use cases that could be imagined, but I'd discount heavily. Then as time goes on, and people start figuring out NEW uses for cars that were not even possible with horses and/or expanding the market, then we can begin weighting those components more heavily. Eventually, the horse & buggy portion will be a minority part of the valuation.
- cjf4 12y agoAaron Levie would seem to be an expert on how to create massive valuations from relatively tiny revenues.
- sixQuarks 12y agoI'm not arguing that Uber is worth $17 billion, but the author completely brushed off the entire reason why investors are valuing it at $17 billion. Only in the last paragraph did he mention that Uber may be looked at as a "logistics" company and not a taxi service. Hello? Of course that's what investors are banking on when they value the company at $17 billion. Uber is not a taxi play, just like Amazon is not just a book seller. A great analogy of this article is when people were saying Amazon wasn't worth $3 billion back in 1997 because the online book market wasn't big enough. Could Uber fail to become a logistics company? Of course. But it's not delusional to think otherwise.
- gfodor 12y agoAgreed this type of analysis of Uber is hilarious, your example is the best I can think of. Imagine an article from 1997 with detailed charts and data around the book market, and using that to question Amazon's business model. It's almost charmingly short-sighted. All you need to know about this article is the phrases "self driving car" and "autonomous car" appear zero times.
- kylebgorman 12y agobut "driverless car" does, as you would know if you had RTFA.
- MarkPNeyer 12y agothe dude totally dismisses driverless cars as something that uber could do 'because it hasn't succeeded yet.' they've already spun up 'on demand' services for ice cream, pedi-cabs, mariachi bands, kittens... multiple times. so it's not like they haven't demonstrated they could start new markets. once driverless cars become common, do you really think people will just have their driverless car sitting at home doing nothing all day? wouldn't it be nice if you could hook your driverless car up to a API that would keep it busy and give you a cut of the revenue? uber could do that. so now imagine a world where cars now generate revenue for the people who own them, without them needing to hire a driver, find customers, or do anything besides pay for occasional repairs. 17 billion is a bargain.
- Tarang 12y agoOnce someone said a company is worth people are willing to pay for it.
- chris_va 12y agoThis article makes a lot of hand-waving, possibly incorrect assumptions to arrive at its conclusion. It may or may not be the right conclusion, but it provides very little analytical insight, and is mostly useless.
- Guvante 12y agoWhy do you say that, he goes into detail on all assumptions he makes and includes the data points he used to make his conclusion as well as variants on all important points to show how they affect the outcome. If there are incorrect assumptions that he made then point them out, your yourself are hand-waving by saying vague statements about the article.
- chris_va 12y agoPoint. Incorrect assumptions/starting points: * Customers pay Uber, and Uber takes 20 percent of the fare, while the rest goes to the drivers. [actually, this varies by uber type, and can be significantly less than 20%] * How you estimate Uber’s future cash flows depends, mostly, on three things: the size of its potential market, the size of Uber’s share in that market, and what percentage of gross receipts Uber takes. The assumptions you make on each question can dramatically affect Uber’s valuation, so let me walk through mine. [This is correct in that small changes can dramatically affect the valuation, and makes some assumptions about Uber being unable to innovate past its current market segment. Estimating these numbers is basically a poorly educated guessing game, and materially changes the analysis, and thus makes the conclusion poorly substantiated] * For my base case valuation, I’m going to assume that the primary market Uber is targeting is the global taxi and car-service market. [ Most of the arguments in favor of Uber's high valuation are around extending the market, not supplanting it, and thus the author completely ignores the entire basis of the valuation ] * Assuming taxi revenues in the rest of the world add another $50 billion to this total, I arrive at a total market of $100 billion. [ "Let's just guess at 50% of the market, hand wave." ] * The bad news is that the market will be tough to dominate. Unlike technology companies in other businesses, like Google, Facebook and eBay, the network effect and winner-take-all benefits are limited. [ Unsubstantiated ] * That, along with the regulatory restrictions protecting the status quo and the competition Uber faces from Lyft, Hailo and others, lead me to estimate a market share of 10 percent. [ Woof, handwave ] * My instincts tell me that Uber’s slice will decrease over time, but I’m going to make the optimistic assumption that the company will find a way to differentiate itself and continue to claim 20 percent of gross receipts. [ More handwaving ] * Other assumptions are going to affect my estimate of Uber’s value: how much it costs to operate the company,3 how much it spends to grow the company,4 the tax rate it pays,5 and how costly it is for Uber to borrow money or attract new investors.6 [ Great, we've determined that small changes in profitability/operating expenses/market size dramatically affect valuation, but let's just guess at all of the major parameters. Not that the author has a better option, just that it makes the conclusion highly suspect ] Also, though not explicitly mentioned, the author picks an arbitrary return on capital, 10 year time horizon for NPV, and other makes assumptions/simplifications that drastically affect valuation.
- OoTheNigerian 12y agoWhat people fail to understand is that Uber, Lyft and co are much more than the Taxi market. They are in the transportation business. People like me that would never have taken a taxi in San Fancisco use these services. They are creating new markets. When you really think of it, car ownership for a majority of the people is really silly as most cars are idle 90% of the time. Car manufacturers should be afraid because once Uber, Lyft and Co start a subscription business (pay a fixed amount monthly for a generous travel distance monthly) fewer people we see any reason to own cars. That will be a good thing.
- NDizzle 12y agoYou... wouldn't use a taxi, but you'd use Uber? Why? Cars aren't going anywhere anytime soon. Any kind of subscription business won't work in the 'burbs and beyond, which is the majority of the country. SF reality distortion field in full effect. Yo.
- bcoates 12y agoI'm not in SF, but the whole taxi experience is shitty in LA: 1. Long waits (~10m minimum usually) 2. Unreliable (they'll take calls and never manage to show up) 3. Bad attitude/customer service 4. Constantly trying to rip you off by taking weird routes or trying to use the meter on flat-rate airport trips 5. High prices for shitty cars compared to Uber's range of services I'd ride taxis, but only when I had to. The bus system was a more pleasant and reliable way of getting from one place to another. Uber has really changed that. For the 30% of the population that lives in cities it's a realistic alternative to dealing with a car, particularly if you're not a kid chauffeur.
- mrweasel 12y agoInteresting, I would never use Uber over a taxi, at least here in Europe. I really agree with the taxi drivers, Uber needs to follow the same rules they do, the rules are there for a reason. I don't know how it works in the US, nor do I really care, I want a taxi and not depend on having to buy a smartphone to get it.
- Pxtl 12y agoThe question is how quickly and effectively Uber can branch out and dominate all the "Uber for X" concepts that other start-ups are chasing. If Uber stays in the car service industry? Then yes, they're pointless. If they develop "Uber for housekeeping"? "Uber for babysitters"? "Uber for take-out"? Then yes, Uber is worth $17 billion.
- calbear81 12y agoI didn't see anything about how UberX/Lyft been able to create new demand via much lower fares when compared to taxi cabs. I very very rarely ever took a cab and preferred to walk, bus, or drive because of the cost. Now with UberX and Lyft, I often just call one because the cost is 35 - 50% less than what a cab costs and the experience is so much nicer with app payment and pleasant drivers (feedback loop).
- gfodor 12y agoAll I can think of when it comes to Uber is that the day that Google announces their partnership with Uber to bring self driving car services to the masses, it will be the equivalent to the baptism scene in the Godfather 2 for taxi drivers everywhere.
- austenallred 12y agoOf course Uber isn't worth $17 Billion dollars right now - no one would argue that. The valuation is based not only on what the company is worth right now, but on what investors expect it to be worth in the future. My startup got into an accelerator at a $500,000 valuation. Were we worth that when we started? Of course not. The hope was that we would be by the time we got out.
- angersock 12y agoInvestors are as stupid and biased as any other subset of humanity...they just have more money with which to display their prejudices.
- joshdance 12y agoUber is worth $17 Billion because that is how much someone paid for it.* The question as to Uber will ultimately be worth $17 Billion when those investors try to sell their shares is another question. And to that question, the Aaron Levie tweet is a good heuristic - "Sizing the market for a disruptor based on an incumbent's market is like sizing the car industry off how many horses there were in 1910." *of course they only bought part of it, but the easy math of 'they bought x amount for y, so total worth is z'
- kylefox 12y ago>> “For my base case valuation, I’m going to assume that the primary market Uber is targeting is the global taxi and car-service market.” Uber is not (only) competing with taxis and car services. They are competing with vehicle ownership. This single assumption dramatically affects the size of market Uber is serving.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sshconnection 12y agoI made a similar argument in a prior comment. Particularly once driverless vehicles take off, the economics of vehicle ownership shift massively. Uber will be able to maximize utilization of vehicles and deliver them quickly due to coverage. The idea that network affect doesn't matter here is incredibly short sighted IMO.
- aetherson 12y agoUber has recently made it irritatingly difficult to figure out what their rates are, so let's go with Lyft, which has very similar prices. Their SF rates are $1.35 per mile[1] -- assuming that you never have a waiting fee, never hit a minimum fare, and never pay during surge pricing (yes, yes, "prime time tips"), and, mysteriously, never pay their "safety" fee. If you drive 7,000 miles a year (so, about 5,000 miles less than average), that's $9,450 dollars per year. The TCO of a Honda Civic, assuming 15,000 miles a year (more than twice what we're assuming for the Lyft rider!) is on average a couple thousand dollars less per year [2]. Rideshare is not a reasonable substitute for car ownership for anyone who is cost-conscious, and it will never be until and unless autonomous vehicles exist. [1] https://www.lyft.com/help?article=1263247 https://www.lyft.com/help?article=1263247 [2] http://www.edmunds.com/honda/civic/2014/tco.html?style=200498302 http://www.edmunds.com/honda/civic/2014/tco.html?style=20049...
- kylefox 12y agoFair point — but doesn't this assume price per mile remains constant over time?
- jdh 12y agoAnother point: it would help to know the terms associated with this investment to decide if it was smart. Author treats stock as if it was a public company, which is understandable. i.e. these investors bought $1.2B of stock at a $17B valuation, and would need to see massive market growth, massive share, and margin stability to make 2x their money. However, it's reasonable to assume they got preferred stock. So their return profile looks like: if Uber is worth anything more than a couple billion dollars (which they may view as near-certain), they get their money back + interest. Then they hold an option should Uber execute like Amazon, as others have suggested, and dramatically exceed their near-term market potential. Valuing this is quite tricky: presumably the people who invested $250M less than a year ago thought: I only have to clear ~$400M to get my bait back, now that number is 3-4x higher. While it is highly likely that the new investors have some sort of preferred return, it's possible (though less likely) that have a participating preferred or some other more complex instrument. Maybe the market price for straight preferred was "only" $12B valuation, and the company said: "How about we 'guarantee' you a 2x return, with a participating preferred instrument, but we want a 50% higher price, so in an upside case we are diluted less?" This stuff is pretty common in these later rounds, though admittedly more on the "bubble unicorns" than the true unicorns, who have utmost market leverage. But you can see how even just the vanilla preferred stock would really change your personal calculation of whether you want to put your nest egg into Uber at this price.
- digz 12y agoThis is an important point. Further to that, Uber should be a company with very clearly understood ROI. They put X number of dollars into a new city and get Y number of users and make Z number of dollars over a few years. Because they've done this in dozens of cities, they've got these numbers down. From Uber's perspective, any money they raise should look as much like debt as possible. Why? Debt means existing shareholders won't be diluted. If a growth company can safely issue debt, it always will. Probably not realistic for Uber to issue 1.2B in straight debt today (interest on that would amount to roughly 20-40% of their current revenue), so they would seek as much of the economics of the raise to resemble debt as possible. The more it resembles debt, the less we learn from the headline numbers about implied valuation.
- 12y ago
- govindkabra31 12y agoA very well thought out article.. however, of the future markets that the author dismissed, "moving services" does not look as unbelievable. (article says-- "Uber could extend its reach into other businesses such as car rentals, moving services and even driverless cars, but I don’t see evidence") Ton of companies-- amazon, google, postmates, insta cart-- are looking for viable local logistics. And Uber can have a play in that; initial experiments in New York seemed encouraging.
- segmondy 12y agoI've given up on valuing start ups. I've come to realize that I'm not that smart after I didn't agree with Facebooks valuation. These companies are worth whatever the market/people agree to pay for it. It doesn't have to make rational sense. I've accepted this, because I don't argue when someone wants to pay $10 million for a painting because it's the only copy that exists and is a thousand years old. So why argue when it comes to the value of a company determined by the market? If the owner insisted that his company is worth that much, we might have a disagreement, but with the market saying Uber is worth $17 billion? $17 billion it is.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoCome back in five years. You may find out that Facebook was not in fact worth as much as people thought. That doesn't mean that you were wrong (except in the very near term). And, if you aren't going to jump on the bandwagon based on the greater fool theory, then figuring out that the market is temporarily wrong is a good way to avoid losing a lot of money.
- contingencies 12y agoI came here to post Neither is Facebook but found this thread, instead. Basically, there's a lot of people tasked with finding places to invest money who need to look busy and the US - nay - the west - is pretty dry on real productive organizations right now. Software slash services has become the excuse for capitalism, and fundamentally we're just delaying the inevitable. Growth has stopped. Resources are finite. It's official.
- adamzerner 12y agoFrom what I understand, the value of Uber is in 1) user experience, and 2) logistics technology. Regarding 1), this isn't much of a barrier to entry. Competitors could easily copy their UX, curation, app etc. I suspect that this will happen, forcing Uber and future competitors to lower their prices. Regarding 2), I don't know much about their technology, but something makes me question whether Uber will really have that much of an advantage in logistics technology 10-20 years from now. Finally, I've always thought that cars are an extremely inefficient way to get around, especially in cities. I suspect that there will be innovations in transportation, and that there won't be too big a market for traditional taxis 20 years from now.
- wellboy 12y agoUber might become the first $1T company in the world and it's not about processing taxi fees at all. It's about that self-driving cars are already safer than humans. In 5 years potentially, nobody would drive their cars by themselves anymore, because self-driving cars are 5 times safer than humans driving them. For that reason, people would have to pay 5 times more for insurance if they want to drive the car themselves --> nobody would drive cars by themselves anymore. Then, where do you order get these self-driving Google cars? You order them through Uber(http://techcrunch.com/2013/08/25/uberauto/)and http://techcrunch.com/2013/08/25/uberauto/)and that's why they can raise at a valuation 100x of their $200M revenue (http://techcrunch.com/.../leaked-uber-numbers-which-weve.../ http://techcrunch.com/.../leaked-uber-numbers-which-weve.../). Uber menttioned that the ground transportation market in San Francisco is around $22B and this is for 800,000 people (http://qz.com/218717/what-people-who-think-uber-is-worth-17-billion-believe/ http://qz.com/218717/what-people-who-think-uber-is-worth-17-...). Now multiply this by 10,000 so that you are at 8B people and you have a market of 220 trillion dollars. Now that number is probably a bit too high, but that's why Uber is valued at $17 billion right now.
- gojomo 12y agoHas Professor Damodaran, the author, reviewed the same internal documents that Uber's professional investors have seen?
- gdeglin 12y agoThe author of this article seems to have an impressive background: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aswath_Damodaran http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aswath_Damodaran Given his experience, I'm struggling to understand why he's so quick to dismiss the possibility that Uber will successfully expand into tangential markets, or that it's at least reasonable for investors to bet on that possibility. In the spreadsheet the author provides, the possibility of growth into additional markets seems complete ignored. Even if the chance of such growth was small, surely it should factor in to the valuation to some degree?
- timr 12y agoIt's interesting that the author gets to a valuation of ~$6B, because that's approximately the current valuation of a number of unprofitable internet startups (Yelp ($5.52B) and Pandora ($5.67B) leap immediately to mind). I've been joking with my friends that you can probably subtract about $4B from current internet company valuations to get to the "correct" number given revenues and market sizes...but really, if you take Yelp and Pandora's current valuations down to 35% of their current value (35% is the ratio of $6B/$17B), the number is about right (e.g. $2Bn for Yelp, which gives a price/sales of ~7). It's a little scary to think that the market for growth stocks may be overvalued to the tune of 65%, but the ratio passes the sniff test for a lot of stocks that I'm following.
- adamodar 12y agoI am flattered that so many of you read my piece and felt the urge to respond. To begin with, I hope I did not come through as claiming a monopoly on the truth (and fair value). I tried to make my best assessment of what I think Uber's value is today, given what I know about the company. It is true that I valued it as a car service company but that is the only business where it has a business model that works right now. As many of you argue, there are potential markets here (moving, car rentals and even car ownership) that Uber could enter. If that is the argument for the extra $12 billion, the pieces are in place to estimate whether you can justify that addition. These additional markets (especially car ownership) could make the potential market much larger, but the question then becomes whether Uber's business model can be expanded into these businesses, while preserving the its profitability. Take, for instance, the driverless electric car market which is the alluring possibility. Even if you are an optimist on this development, I am still grappling with the role that Uber will play in this market and the profitability that will ensue. Will Uber continue to play the middleman role, and if so, who will it be negotiating with? If the electric cars are owned by Google or some other large entity, will Uber have the bargaining power to demand a large slice? In closing, here are three beliefs that I bring to the table. First, I am a believer that DCF is a tool that can be expanded to cover almost any narrative you may have. Second, I have no illusions about being right, when there is this much uncertainty about the future, but I would rather be transparently wrong (where you can see the assumptions that i have made and change them to reflect your narrative) than to be opaquely right. (I think that providing absurdly large valuation ranges as your base valuation is a cop out, as is making fluffy statements like "I think Uber has lots of potential and is worth a lot") Finally, I think that there is a big difference between pricing (where the number you attach to an asset is what people are willing to pay for it right now) and value. I have a great deal of respect for the pricing process (which is what delivered the $17 billion for Uber) but I also think that pricing is driven by mood and momentum, both of which can get ahead of the facts.