5 ms·
This is insane. The plaintiff, Equustek Solutions Inc., says the main defendant, Morgan Jack, sells networking devices that infringe on their trademark. The d
by bambax 12y ago
This is insane.
The plaintiff, Equustek Solutions Inc., says the main defendant, Morgan Jack, sells networking devices that infringe on their trademark.
The defendant sells these things online; the plaintiff wants his websites to be dereferenced from Google.
The court agreed and asked Google to remove the links on all its properties worldwide (not just google.ca).
But what does Google have to do with this?
Why does the plaintiff not go after the infringer, to shut his websites down and/or fine him and/or get him in prison?
Telling Google to remove the links (worldwide!!) is like issuing an injunction against all restaurants the world over to stop selling food to anyone called "Morgan Jack" in the remote chance it will have an effect on his business.
- johnchristopher 12y agoWell, it's often said around here that we should consider Google to be in the ad business, right ? Then following that logic Google is actually advertising illegal stuff by providing links to Morgan Jack's website on Google's own site. I am not convinced by that line of thoughts, though. > Telling Google to remove the links (worldwide!!) is like issuing an injunction against all restaurants the world over to stop selling food to anyone called "Morgan Jack" in the remote chance it will have an effect on his business. But Google would be the only restaurant on the whole planet in that analogy.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoWell Google is the only one that matters. Sure Bing and DDG exist and you can sometimes bump into a person using either of those, but for majority of the population, Google is the Internet, for better or worse.
- DanBC 12y agoTo further the analogy - it would be like telling McDonalds to not sell food to this person but ignoring In'n'Out Burger and Burger King. I understand the point about forcing Google to stop sellin advertising to this person. I am confused about how a disappeared person continues to pay for services from Google; why didn't anyone get a court order to force Google to release information about the infringer? {edit: i did not downvote parent. I am not sure why parent has been downvoted}
- tempestn 12y agoGoogle isn't selling advertising to him. Their only involvement as far as I can tell is that his sites show up in organic search results.
- DanBC 12y agoThanks for the clarification! I hadn't heard about this before today and doing a bit of research it sounds like something that has been going on for years - since at least 2007 - and there has been some really dodgy practice. (But I still don't see why Google is targeted here). http://www.rudy2.com/datalink-equustek/ http://www.rudy2.com/datalink-equustek/ And it seems that Datalink have made some effort to clarify the situation: http://1770-kf3.com/ http://1770-kf3.com/ > We would like to clarify that DataLink no longer sell/promote the following Canadian manufacturer’s products. “Equustek Solutions Inc.’s products (www.equustek.com), as listed below, are no longer distributed by Datalink:” DL2000 DL3500 DL4000 DL4500 DL6000 DL7000 EQ7000 DL-PC DL-PCI DL-PCIe DL-PC/104 DL-STED EQ-DCM “Customers of these products should contact Equustek directly at the website above or toll free at 1-888-387-3787" I don't know this area so I have no idea what I need to type into a search box to get a Datalink result turning up where I should be getting an Equustek result. (And I'm trying across different search engines).
- seacious 12y agoI wonder if this will eventually lead to google making use of a decentralized federated search strategy where they provide the technology to everyone who wants their site to be findable by means of google, but do not actually produce the results themselves. From a technological pov that would certainly be far more challenging than their current system, but it might make them less of a target legally.
- mseebach 12y ago> Well, it's often said around here that we should consider Google to be in the ad business, right ? Then following that logic Google is actually advertising illegal stuff by providing links to Morgan Jack's website on Google's own site. Google is in the ad business in the same way a newspaper or a magazine is: Selling ads is the major source of income. Every time someone says that Google is an ad business, for calibration remind yourself that so is the New York Times. Anyway, Google linking (in the regular results section, not ads) to the website of a given business is similar to a newspaper or magazine stating in editorial content that a certain business exists and what its address is. That is obviously not "selling ads" in any way, shape or form.
- rayiner 12y agoYes, everyone would do well to remember the NYT is in the ad business too.
- Natsu 12y agoSome part of me wonders what would happen if they were to turn off Google to Canada for a day and list the judge's phone number as the person to complain to. (Probably one very angry judge, but I wonder...)
- tempestn 12y agoProbably a lot of angry users, anti-trust proceedings, and a bunch of other stuff they don't want.
- kryptiskt 12y agoSounds like something from here would apply: "Contempt of Court includes the following behaviours: - Fails to maintain a respectful attitude, remain silent or refrain from showing approval or disapproval of the proceeding - Refuses or neglects to obey a subpoena - Willfully disobeys a process or order of the Court - Interfere with the orderly administration of justice or to impair the authority or dignity of the Court" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contempt_of_court#Canada http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contempt_of_court#Canada
- jrockway 12y agoWill the US extradite someone to Canada for contempt of court?
- jacquesm 12y agoThey could simply seize the assets of Google Montreal.
- vacri 12y agoI imagine Google going dark in Canada would hurt Canada more than it's worth (playing out the fantasy scenario). I don't just mean search, but at this point there'll be plenty of companies that rely on Google Apps, including gmail.
- shakethemonkey 12y agoThis wouldn't fly in the USA: "It is clear from the record that Google was never named as a party to the suit, was never served with process, never waived or accepted process, and never made an appearance in the suit before the expunction order was entered. Nothing in the record establishes that Google stands in privity to the commission or to Jackson. Accordingly, we hold that Google was not a party to the suit and that the trial court lacked jurisdiction to enter orders against Google." [1] [1] https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20140609/07402727525/texas-appeals-court-vacates-order-commanding-google-to-hunt-down-third-party-content-destroy-it.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20140609/07402727525/texas...
- jt2190 12y agoThe issue is that a lower court issued a temporary injunction against Morgan Jack to stop selling their products in British Columbia while the issue was being sorted out at trial. Morgan Jack then disappeared "into the cloud" and continued to sell their products online, via links to their products in Google search results. Equustek then claimed that Morgan Jack was still in violation of the court order to stop selling in BC, and that's the issue that has gone to the BC Supreme Court: Is Google "doing business" in BC when it presents Morgan Jack's links to BC residents? The court ruled that under the current rules, Google is indeed doing business in BC, and can be ordered to remove links to Morgan Jack by a BC court.
- Tyr42 12y agoEarlier, Google already agreed to remove their website, as defined by some 350 urls. But the defendant started auto generating new urls, which had to go back to the judge (I think) to be blocked. Google was fine with blocking specific urls worldwide by court order. Now, the ruling requires google to block them, even if they change the url. That's the new upgrade that required the ruling.
- peeters 12y agoHow about drawing parallels to a similar situation? A child porn ring manages to stay online via using ever-changing URLs and relying on Google's indexing. Prosecutors of course go after the people maintaining the network. But Google still has a moral and legal obligation to stop indexing the network if feasible. I'd say at the end of the day it's a matter of degree. In both situations, a content provider has been deemed illegal is leveraging Google to stay afloat. But while in one case Google's obligation seems like a no-brainer due to its heinous nature, the other elicits less passion.
- opendais 12y agoUsing that logic... Russia can ban all LBGT sites on Google because it has been deemed illegal.
- peeters 12y agoThat's not my logic at all. The GP asked what this has to do with Google. I'm saying there are clearly scenarios where Google has a responsibility to limit access to content, even content they don't provide. In my opinion, it is not tenable to say "let the courts go after the child pornographers, but Google shouldn't be asked to block access to their content". And notably, I'm not even arguing that Google should ever be ordered to block sites worldwide. The GP's argument has NOTHING to do with the worldwide nature, on the contrary, that it is worldwide was only parenthetical in the comment. The same argument would stand even if the decision only affected Canada. It argues against involving Google at all, and that's what I'm debating.