3 ms·
(3) Our patent system grants Wacom monopoly rights measured in decades in return for, well, no societal benefits that are readily apparent.
by CamperBob2 12y ago
(3) Our patent system grants Wacom monopoly rights measured in decades in return for, well, no societal benefits that are readily apparent.
- rayiner 12y agoThe benefit to the consumer is that some other company didn't just copy their technology down to the silk screening on the PCB, eliminating their ability to get any return on their R&D. Wacom is a terrible example for an anti-patent rant. Digitizing pen input is really hard to get right. N-trig has been working to come up with their own independent technology for years now. This is exactly the sort of R&D-heavy product development that's most endangered by copying. Without patents we'd be stuck at Wacom 1.0, and N-trig wouldn't have any incentive to come up with independent technology with different characteristics.
- CamperBob2 12y agoFine, give them a limited monopoly. But for 20 years? Um, no.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoThe case for a monopoly has been put - and it's one I agree with - but I' with camperbob here, patent monopolies are too long. They don't respect the change in product lifecycles that's come about in the last century or so. If it took 10 years to produce the next line of products and if products were manufactured to last that long then 15-20 years seems fine. But the patent term is far too long compared to the product lifecycle (in computing/electronics fields at least); patented tech is too often redundant by the time it enters the public domain. I'd like to see maybe 5-8 year terms and possibly with a cap that looks something like "if global revenue is 100 times the number of inventors times 50 years times the 90th percentile pay in the country where patented the patent lapses" (the idea being selling at a 1% patent premium that returns enough to reward the inventors with never having to work again means the patent should lapse) [but admit that would be a very hard law to draft without leaving loopholes; there's probably major flaws too, one really would rather look at profit but it's too easily manipulated I feel]. Anyway, can someone justify the 15-20 years over a 5-8 year term (for electronics, say)?
- rayiner 12y agoI don't disagree with any of this. What's a sensible patent term in aerospace, where a single design might take a decade to bring to market, and what's sensible in consumer electronics isn't the same.