7 ms·
Okay, what the heck is with this business of secondary markets for licenses in the US? You can sell a liquor license? You can sell a taxi license (aka medallion
by twic 12y ago
Okay, what the heck is with this business of secondary markets for licenses in the US? You can sell a liquor license? You can sell a taxi license (aka medallion)? Why? How does treating licenses as property make any legal sense, or serve any public good?
In the UK, if you want to sell booze from your shop, you write to the council and apply for a license. They check you and your shop out, and if you seem okay, they grant it. If you want to drive a taxi around your town, you write to the council and apply for a license. They check you and your car out, and if you seem okay, they grant it. This seems really simple and, frankly, natural. It's how all sorts of licenses work in the private sector too - think about copyright licenses, tenancies, etc. How on earth do you get from there to licenses being a kind of property?
- jstalin 12y agoHere's a decent history on why the US liquor laws are the way they are: http://reason.com/archives/2014/06/04/how-not-to-legalize-a-drug http://reason.com/archives/2014/06/04/how-not-to-legalize-a-... These licensing schemes have become nothing more than rent-seeking by those established with existing licenses.
- dublinben 12y agoLicenses become valuable property when they become scarce. In every US municipality I'm aware of, the supply for both liquor licenses and Taxi medallions is tightly restricted. When you simply cannot get a new license by applying to the appropriate authority, it begins to make sense to pay tens of thousands of dollars to adopt an existing license.
- gress 12y agoThat only answers why they are valuable, not why they are property. It is the issuing authority that intentional makes licenses into property by honoring them after they have been transferred. The quesion is, why are these licenses honored after a transfer?
- dragonwriter 12y agoThere's two aspects to the kinds of licensing at issue: (1) Quantitative limits, and (2) Substantive requirements (which vary by specific license) that limit who can use the license. Letting licenses be transferrable is a way of limiting the public-agency workload in managing #1, because you then have less work managing a queue of pending-availability license requests at the public agency. Even where license are transferrable, the recipient generally has to submit paperwork to the agency and be approved that the meet the appropriate requiremetns related to #2 before they can use the license.
- gress 12y agoAren't your last two points contradictory?
- dragonwriter 12y agoNo, there's a difference between substantive review of applications with availability and queue management (and responding to inquiries) about applications pending availability.
- gress 12y agoReally? It sounds like the agency has to check that the applicant meets the criteria for the license in either case. Where is the cost saving?
- dragonwriter 12y ago> It sounds like the agency has to check that the applicant meets the criteria for the license in either case. They aren't two alternatives, they are two different functions. Verifying that the applicant meets the criteria once there is a license available (given the quantitative limits) is one function. The other function is managing distribution of the limited number of licenses. The amount of work required by the public agency for the latter function (#1 in my original list) is greater when if the only way for that to happen is people to surrender unused licenses and then new applicants to apply to the issuing agency and be waitlisted until a slot is available than if a license that the current holder can be transferred directly to a new applicant.
- Permit 12y agoI think the parent was asking why the licenses were transferable. I can't sell my driver's license to an aspiring driver, why should I be able to sell a taxi license or a liquor license?
- Jtsummers 12y agoUnless there's a test or certification, transferring them is more like transferring ownership of a car or house. You can't sell your driver's license because that license certifies that you meet the state's minimum demonstration of competence as a driver. A taxi driver has already demonstrated that, they just need permission to act as a taxi driver, which was deliberately made as a scarce resource. It's really more of a coincidence that they are both called licenses, they permit you to do something (drive cars, operate a taxi service), but one certifies competence, the other merely conveys permission. EDIT: Perhaps of interest, I went to Prince Edward Island last year and met some fishermen. Apparently their licenses can be sold (they effectively take out a mortgage given the cost) and are used as a sort of retirement plan by the fishermen that own them. But they also (according to them so I'm not sure the precise legal considerations or if it's convention) require that you spend some years working for licensed fishermen before you can purchase one. So sort of a hybrid between the driver's license and the taxi medallion model.
- logfromblammo 12y agoIt doesn't serve a public good. It raises prices by limiting supply. It is almost pure protectionism, to eliminate competition. Impose an artificial barrier to entry, and everyone already past the barrier can work a little less, and reap higher profits. Ensuring safety and quality of service is merely a pretext, and mostly everyone knows that is just political flimflam. It is a corrupt practice that is tolerated because it seems to benefit businesses somewhat more than it hurts customers. In some cases, they are NOT property. They are treated as such to move the cash around, but the person exercising the privilege sets up a sham business arrangement with the licensee. For instance, the licensee of the cab medallion "hires" a manager with his own metered vehicle, garage, and roster of drivers, has no involvement in the day-to-day operations, and just cashes the checks.
- eli 12y agoIt's hard to make blanket statements about the US, it varies quite a bit by state, county, and municipality (that's part of the point.) Around me, the process is (theoretically) similar to how you describe: you make an application to a local body of elected officials, there's a hearing, and they deny or approve it. Neighbors have an opportunity to object or seek concessions. And I don't think you can really sell a license.
- rayiner 12y agoYou make a license trade-able when you care about limiting the supply, but you don't care who gets it. The purpose of a taxi medallion is to limit the total number of taxis, and the purpose of a liquor license is to limit the number of establishments that sell liquor.[1] But the government doesn't care who has the license. Making it trade-able ensures that the license goes to the person or organization that values it most highly (Coase Theorem: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coase_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coase_theorem). [1] These purposes aren't, on their face, unreasonable. Taxis generate undesirable congestion, and establishments that serve liquor tend to create undesirable drunk people. If you don't believe me, take a walk through Wrigleyville in Chicago on a Friday night, where you can see an endless parade of taxis picking up an endless parade of drunk students.
- chimeracoder 12y ago> These purposes aren't, on their face, unreasonable. Taxis generate undesirable congestion, and establishments that serve liquor tend to create undesirable drunk people. If you don't believe me, take a walk through Wrigleyville in Chicago on a Friday night, where you can see an endless parade of taxis picking up an endless parade of drunk students. I agree that sometimes this setup (licenses to restrict supply) make sense, but taxis are not a good example of where this provides a net benefit. I'd rather have a bunch of taxis than a bunch of drunk college students driving. Furthermore, from a city planning perspective the most efficient use of both road space and real estate (parking) is to have cheap, on-demand taxis instead of personal car ownership. If public transportation is fairly extensive and always available (as it is in NYC), it makes sense to eschew personal ownership of cars and use taxis for the rare case when public transportation isn't enough. Overall, this reduces congestion, and is one of the reason that taxis are oftentimes taxed less (or pay less in tolls) than personal, non-commercial vehicles. In fact, I posit that a significant reason that services like Hailo and Uber exist in NYC specifically is that the supply of on-demand taxis is heavily restricted[0]. If the supply were left up to the free market[1], Uber and Hailo would be able to provide some added value (the convenience of the mobile app and the "premium" feel), but not the level that they are now. [0] Since the 1970s, the number of medallions available has not increased commensurately with the increase in population [1] but with the same laws regarding nondiscrimination of service with respect to destination, credit cards, etc.
- stonemetal 12y ago> How on earth do you get from there to licenses being a kind of property? How on earth do you prevent it? You need to provide stable access to licenses, so that if Joe drives a cab he doesn't end up jobless next year because he lost the taxi license lotto. Suddenly Joe has something he can sell, access to his license. Say we tie the license to the person driving the cab then Lucky cabs can't fire a bad driver because then they lose a license.
- bane 12y agoYou issue as many licenses as their are passing applicants.
- joshuapants 12y agoThat defeats the purpose of the license. It's not like a driver's license where the goal is to establish some baseline level of competency, it's there specifically to limit the number of taxis/liquor stores/etc.
- bane 12y agoIn many areas it is just like a drivers license and that regime works pretty well. It's a weird desire to arbitrary limit licenses. What's the purpose of that? Limiting the number of sellers doesn't really do much to limit buyers or consumption. It sounds like a bad idea that's carried forward out of momentum not something that needs to be fixed. It should be replaced with the better approach.
- stonemetal 12y agoIt is an attempt to prevent a tragedy of the commons. NY doesn't have enough road capacity to handle all of the taxis that would be profitable in a free market. Therefore they limit the number of taxis to ease congestion.
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago
- chrisdevereux 12y agoIf nothing else, why not make the licenses non-transferrable and auction the available licenses? Seems like they're missing out on an easy source of income by letting third parties benefit from the restricted supply.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoPresumably the answer is corrupt officials? That seems to be the only thing that makes sense - they don't want the State to make the money they want their friends to make it and, of course, share it with them??
- orp 12y agoFun fact about the UK. In order to get a license to drive a taxi in London, applicants need to pass an extensive test. Passing the test takes years of preparation and multiple attempts. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_the_United_Kingdom#The_Knowledge http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxicabs_of_the_United_Kingdom#...
- dublinben 12y agoI bet you could write a bot that pastes that link any time a comment mentions UK and taxis in proximity.
- twic 12y agoJust be grateful it's not the one about MRI showing black cab drivers have significantly enlarged hippocampi. (for those not familiar with cerebral anatomy, the hippocampus is the part of the brain responsible for racism, swearing at cyclists, and tax evasion)
- rhizome 12y agoThere's a documentary about that called "The Knowledge:" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYZcG2mY9Fs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYZcG2mY9Fs
- mabhatter 12y agoYou still write the council and get permission.. You just have yo "buy your place in line" from somebody that already has one.
- the_watcher 12y agoI don't have a problem with secondary markets (such as the iPhone secondary market that pops up around all new model releases, based on the private manufacturer making the decision to limit supply), but when it's enabled by regulations and is a product of regulatory capture, there is essentially no justification for it in my book.