7 ms·
Ikea C&D's 8-year old Ikea furniture hacking website
- mdaniel 12y agoI wonder had Jules turned over the domain to them (or might still, given the intention to transfer the site to a new domain) if IKEA would have just made it a blind redirect to their main site, or just killed it to prevent the next Jules from having it. I almost thought they would start their own DIY community, but running a community is a ton of work and I doubt it would increase their sales by a large enough percentage to warrant it.
- kourt 12y agoLet's use this as a case study: What (according to HN) should IKEA have done? On one hand, trademark preservation is important. On another hand, how many companies would kill for a community of "Raving Fans" like this? And in addition to enthusiasm, the site seemed very high quality and thus complementary to Ikea's marketing.
- cperciva 12y agoLet's use this as a case study: What (according to HN) should IKEA have done? Buy the site and pay the owner to keep on running it. If it's owned by IKEA there's no trademark dilution problem...
- protomyth 12y agoIKEA could license the the site for $0 to use their trademark.
- jacquesm 12y ago> Buy the site and pay the owner to keep on running it. I think that would send the wrong signal to would-be copycats. I think the chosen solution, allow them to continue but non-commercially is a pretty good one. If it's a fan site then it should be non-commercial.
- pan69 12y agoYou can then sue the copycats, I guess.
- Niten 12y agoI don't think it would send that message at all. IKEA Hackers wasn't just some site using the IKEA name, it was a high-quality and well-established community. If IKEA had purchased this establishment, I don't think a reasonable person would conclude they would give the same treatment to just any other trademark infringer. And even non-profit sites need money to pay for hosting.
- lessnonymous 12y agoSurely it's not hard to solve this one? Buy the site. Acquisition style. Now they keep the community, the fan base, the long tail, and the passionate founder. He gets to work on it full time and they get rid of other peoples ads.
- jacquesm 12y agoIt's not that easy though. Setting precedent for infringement being rewarded with a buy-out might send all the wrong signals. If they did that a few thousand 'hack with Ikea' sites would jump up overnight. The problem with these suits is usually not the specific case at hand but everybody else that will use the opportunity if they no longer defend their trademark vigorously. And buying out a site like that would probably not qualify as defense but as reward. If the price was $0 or the former owner would pay a token fine and the site would then be run by the former owner but under the IKEA umbrella then it might work. But an actual payment for something that leveraged a brand would be a big mistake imo.
- joering2 12y ago> Setting precedent for infringement being rewarded with a buy-out might send all the wrong signals. Just exactly what wrong signals did Google send when they bough Youtube? Unless we are blind and skip the fact youtube willingfully hosted 90% of ifringe content.
- jacquesm 12y agoThe analogy would be that google bought googletube, which they did not.
- nasmorn 12y agoThey don't infringe on anything IMHO. This is a fan site promoting the use of the companies products. This is not the same as using the tm to sell look alikes. If sites adding massive value to a brand over almost a decade can expect to be noticed and acquired how is that bad for ikea.
- 12y ago
- newy 12y agoGrant a trademark license at no cost.
- aw3c2 12y agoCan't a trademark owner give permission to someone to use it?
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoThis is the obvious retort to the usual 'they had to do this, or else they'll lose the company' hysterics that so many corporatist types parrot. They could have easily just allowed him use of the name and if Ikea was ever in some kind of trademark lawsuit could have stated so. They chose not to for their own reasons, but the idea that business is forced to act this way and that Ingvar Kamprad is this grandfatherly old man who loves cheap furniture and not the ruthless head of a major world-wide corporation is asinine.
- arn 12y agoOur original TouchArcade.com logo had a space invader in it. Taito contacted us, liked our site, and gave us a free license. We later changed the logo to avoid that long term dependency. But that was very nice of them.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nagrom 12y agoHere's what I would do: I'd give them a revokable licence to use the Ikea trademark as long as only Ikea products were used on the site. That way I would expect to be able to defend the generic trademark argument. I'd get rid of their advertisers, give them referral links to replace that income and maybe eventually bring them in-house so as to control the content. All this would cost maybe one person per year, maybe one and a half. If I can raise a few hundred thousand dollars a year extra this way by heavily promoting products from the site, I can easily justify it. That shouldn't be too hard a target, given that Ikea is a massive multinational. That's maybe a few hundred extra sales per store per year. It's possible that Ikea considered something like that already and it doesn't make sense to do. It's not presented like that though.
- guelo 12y agoTell their lawyers to chill out, leave the site alone, thank them for being fans, send them free IKEA furniture to hack on.
- pdabbadabba 12y agoIkea should have done nothing, because the site's use of the mark probably did not infringe -- I suspect it was protected by the doctrine of fair use. In the trademark context the fair use defense is available when "use of the name, term, or device charged to be an infringement is a use, otherwise than as a mark, ... of a term or device which is descriptive of and used fairly and in good faith only to describe the goods or services of such party, or their geographic origin." 15 U.S.C. s. 1115(b)(4). The use of the word "Ikea" on the site clearly is used merely to identify the goods being hacked -- it is "descriptive of and used fairly and in good faith only to describe the goods." The bigger problem, possibly, is that the site as a whole generally echoes the Ikea brand (thought not particularly strongly). This, in conjunction with use of the word "Ikea" could possibly give rise to the overriding possibility of confusion. At most, Ikea should have asked ikeahackers to tweak the design of the site a bit (maybe use some different colors). I am not a trademark lawyer, so I'm open to being corrected. But I think ikeahackers could probably have prevailed in court, especially after some design tweaks.
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago>But I think ikeahackers could probably have prevailed in court, especially after some design tweaks. // I disagree, especially in non-US courts, largely because of the "commercial" nature of the site. Any revenue makes it commercial, that doesn't obviate fair use but it makes extremely difficult to win on that claim. People arrive here because of Ikea's brand and products, they see Ikea livery and designs and then are forwarded to purchase other products to the gain of the site owners. The "New Kids" case fits quite well with the case in hand and recapitulates the test for whether nominative use is infringing or not. http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/metaschool/fisher/integrity/Links/Cases/newkids.html http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/metaschool/fisher/integrity/Lin... One might feel that the Volkswagenwerk AG vs Church case mentioned makes Ikeahackers a winner [see the footnote for key differences!] but the test stands that there is (ibid.) >"a nominative fair use defense provided he meets the following three requirements: First, the product or service in question must be one not readily identifiable without use of the trademark; second, only so much of the mark or marks may be used as is reasonably necessary to identify the product or service; [7] and third, the user must do nothing that would, in conjunction with the mark, suggest sponsorship or endorsement by the trademark holder." //
- jacquesm 12y agoWell, she gets to continue to run it so I don't see what the problem is. Their only condition is that it goes non-commercial which I think is fairly reasonable. They also talked with each other in a constructive fashion.
- rm445 12y agoI'm not interested in what IKEA should have done, according to their own interests, but in what they should be allowed to do. Someone ought to be perfectly entitled to run a site on a commercial basis, that discusses Ikea's products and mention's Ikea's name. The line is crossed when a reasonable person would think that the site officially represented Ikea. I don't know where the music would have stopped if this guy had chosen to fight. I don't blame him for not doing so, but I hope the outcome would have been that he was fully entitled to run his site as he chose, so long as he attempted to avoid anyone thinking the site was officially run by Ikea.
- jeroen 12y agoShe, not he. The author is female.
- __david__ 12y ago> On one hand, trademark preservation is important. That seems reasonable, up to a point. To me it seems difficult to argue that point when the brand is already so large that some rinky dink site could never measurably impact the company's brand recognition/reputation.
- noonespecial 12y agoThank their lawyers for the excellent legal advice, and then forbid them from sending the C&D because its such monumentally bad PR. Follow that up by instructing them to find an alternative way to deal with possible trademark issues. The best course of action from a legal perspective is often not the best course of action from a business perspective.
- eps 12y agoOn third hand, how has heard of this site before today? This community of raving fans is less than a drop in a bucket for IKEA.
- psychometry 12y agoWhat is the benefit to Ikea (or other companies with armies of lawyers who like to threaten loyal customers) by sending cease and desist letters to sites like this?
- eli 12y agoWithout passing judgement on this example, there's at least a hypothetical risk that if you don't continuously defend your trademark, you could lose it! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_trademark http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_trademark
- jonknee 12y agoConsidering it has been 8 years they either aren't very continuous or not very good at finding violations. Has to be a better way to handle this.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoThere's no genericisation happening on that site. It's a fan site. It's like saying that "ikeasucks.com" is going to lead to genericisation of the mark, there's no chance as the trademark is only being used to refer to what the company uses it for. On a general point you can defend your mark as much as you like it can still take the elevator to, or get hoovered up by genericisation by the public - google it on Bing if you don't believe me. ;0) Strictly speaking ikeahackers.net is using the mark in a commercial way (because of the advertising) and so by UK/EU TM law seems to be infringing. There does also appear to be a strong possibility of confusion - the site is very "on message" for Ikea IMO and uses their livery and it's own design to imitate well the Ikea style. From the sites perspective they can use a different [distinct!] name and make clear they're not legally associated but only a fan site, acknowledge Ikea's RTM in the footer for example and disclaim association. That seems sufficient to differentiate and avoid possibility of actual confusion (though they could still be sued of course). Adding in products from other suppliers would help here too ... that of course is bad for Ikea, but they're the ones pointing the gun at their own feet. From Ikea's point of view. License the site, pay the content creator a nice fat salary to carry on and thank them sincerely for marketing your products so well for you. It can't possibly be cheaper in lost good will and lawyers salaries to sue "Jules".
- jakubmal 12y agoThe guys behind ikeahackers should escalate this to higher positioned managers within Ikea, until they have a chance to talk to someone who will understand and appreciate the idea behind the website.
- jacquesm 12y agoNo legal action would ever be taken by a company like this without the appropriate managers being 100% aware of the situation. Even if they claim later publicly that they did not know once the backlash starts up. Lawyers don't just act on lowly minions talking to them, someone with specific powers must authorize the action.
- scrollaway 12y agoThis is true but not necessarily entirely correct either. IKEA probably has a legal department handling things such as trademark issues, knockoffs etc; that department may have very little contact with marketing or much-higher-ups. It's unlikely nobody would be aware of this if this was over "months of negociations", though. Still, I think this is a case where a lot of bureaucracy has clouded what should be a very clear cut case. It's possible if a reasonable top-of-the-chain higher-up is told about all this and it is clearly demonstrated that (assuming this is at all what the site owner wants) IH could be acquired or affiliated and the whole thing could turn from bad PR to good PR, they would tell legal/laywers to sod off.
- jacquesm 12y agoI think you fail to understand the basiscs about how IKEA is put together. The brand is not owned by the parent company: http://www.thelocal.se/20120809/42514 http://www.thelocal.se/20120809/42514 So when you do something with the IKEA brand and furniture all kinds of 'reasonably considerations' that would flow from brand being owned by the mothership go right out the window. Likely the only kind of employee the brand company has is IP lawyers.
- 12y ago
- jacquesm 12y agoIkea handled this pretty good I think: FTFA: "Long story short, after much negotiation between their agent and my lawyer, I am allowed to keep the domain name IKEAhackers.net only on the condition that it is non-commercial, meaning no advertising whatsoever." That could have been a lot worse. She gets to keep it, they don't see their brand diluted in any meaningful way or exploited commercially. I count a whole pile of ad banners on the site, IKEA branding (including their colors and logos) everywhere. She really got off very light. And if she switches to another domain in time then there will be 0 harm.
- nperez 12y agoI don't think they handled it perfectly. Why would they need to ask for a domain transfer? The domain itself isn't necessarily related to their brand (for example, it could refer to a person named Ikeah Ackers or something). I understand asking for an end to ad revenue, and I think it's obvious that pulling in revenue while using someone else's trademark will result in this, but I would not have taken kindly to their demands if I were in that position. The resolution is OK but they must know that you can't break even on $0 revenue, so it's a death blow to this brand in the long term. It gives her time to rebrand and relaunch.
- vobios 12y agoThe domain name could refer to a person named Ikeah Ackers. However, given the contents of the site, it is clear that the domain name refers to IKEA. I am not a lawyer, but I have been involved in a trademark-related domain legal proceeding. I lost the domain name, but learned some valuable lessons. To make the long story short, I believe this is what ICANN would refer to as using the using the trademark in "bad faith" under Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy. More specifically, "Evidence of Registration and Use in Bad Faith" can be demonstrated that "by using the domain name, you have intentionally attempted to attract, for commercial gain, Internet users to your web site or other on-line location, by creating a likelihood of confusion with the complainant's mark as to the source, sponsorship, affiliation, or endorsement of your web site or location or of a product or service on your web site or location" (see https://archive.icann.org/en/udrp/udrp-policy-24oct99.htm https://archive.icann.org/en/udrp/udrp-policy-24oct99.htm). In this case, it seems that the domain name holder is using the IKEA name to attract users for commercial gain. In a UDRP proceeding, IKEA would most likely be able to gain control of the domain name. On a side note, the site is great. I am glad I found out about it.
- porpoisemonkey 12y agoThere's quite a few comments that have been posted that refer to the site owner as "he". Jules Yap is female. http://jules.ikeahackers.net/ http://jules.ikeahackers.net/
- jacquesm 12y agoFixed. Playing 'a boy named Sue' as penance. Thanks.
- jeroen 12y agoThere is a picture at the top of the post with a female character in it. The amount of "he"s in this thread is probably a good indication of how much time a reader spends looking at such things.
- jacquesm 12y agoOr, you know, that the name 'Jules' is used for males the vast majority of th time.
- jeroen 12y agoDid you really notice that there is an image with a girl in it at the top of the post and still think that the author must be male? My first association with Jules is male (the only Jules I know is a guy), but the image gave me second thoughts.
- jacquesm 12y agoI read the text, never looked at the image, but now that I have looked at it, it seemed like just an illustration anyway, not a picture representative of the author.
- nirajd 12y agototally understand IKEAs concern. I thought this was IKEA's website before I read the article.. IKEA should acquire / host this community on their dime & domain
- viggity 12y agofwiw, particle-board-hackers.com is available
- alexnking 12y agoIt's alarming to me that we allow corporations to control how and how we are not allowed to use words. Trademarks should be limited to preventing people from selling similar products using your company name. They shouldn't be a way for companies to control related culture.
- cuillevel3 12y agoAnyone remember ikeaheights?
- contingencies 12y agoThis is an amazing cultural reference point for modern western thinking. I mean, no longer do you actually build something out of real materials like wood: rather, you take the notwood chipboard+plastic laminate available in an over-marketed unit shipped half way around the world in volume, modify it, then post to the internet about how to do it. Finally, people respond with anecdotes like the comment here ... http://www.ikeahackers.net/2014/06/balcony-bar.html http://www.ikeahackers.net/2014/06/balcony-bar.html ... this is going to be some hardcore retro content in another twenty years.
- dspig 12y agoTo be fair, Ikea can be the cheapest source of some raw-ish materials like mirrors, glass tabletops, metal poles, even some forms of solid wood. Why not take advantage of their economy of scale - do you know the alternatives haven't travelled just as far?
- vtlynch 12y agoFor anyone arguing this was the right decision... the bottom line is that now Ikea has made me very aware that they care more about the brainless legal bullying of corporate business than applauding a patron who loves their goods. I can only imagine being an artist, finding someone has created a site about my work, and then deciding that I should attempt to sue or censor that person.
- CodeWriter23 12y agoI suggest she rename it πkea.com
- duncan_bayne 12y agoNot only is management clueless, but their front-line support staff refuse to escalate complaints about the issue: https://gist.github.com/duncan-bayne/74d6e38c506000982237 https://gist.github.com/duncan-bayne/74d6e38c506000982237
- thelostagency 12y agoI say it was handled quite badly, IKEA doesn't need the extra revenue but the site dominates a growing niche that IKEA might no longer be wishing to be associated with as they try and push upmarket.... Dumb idea all round to act like this, and good luck to IKEAHackers.net