3 ms·
When ever there have been a dispute regarding export control of crypto and microsoft, they have opted to exclude encryption or use something like DES with low k
by belorn 12y ago
When ever there have been a dispute regarding export control of crypto and microsoft, they have opted to exclude encryption or use something like DES with low keysize. Microsoft has also sold exploit tools for windows, which is serious regardless if FDE software was one of the exploits targets.
So, given their history, has they done anything to actually earn our trust?
- tptacek 12y agoWhat are you talking about? Microsoft doesn't source even an appreciable fraction of the exploits for exploitable bugs in Microsoft products. There is a 9-figure business in reversing WinAPI software, discovering vulnerabilities in it, and weaponizing them with exploit code. Microsoft is a bystander to that industry.
- belorn 12y agoI would not call Computer Online Forensic Evidence Extractor (COFEE) to be a bystander. Might be small in the grand scheme of things, but password decryption, data and volatile memory extraction is commonly associated with exploit kits for a reason. It uses vulnerabilities in windows in order to bypass the need to ask for permission. If a company develop a kit that exploits the internal design of their own product, you are not a bystander. Bystanders do not sell exploit kits.
- tptacek 12y agoAre you seriously comparing a crappy forensics tool to a modern exploit kit? Do you think Wietse Venema and Dan Farmer are suspicious for having released The Coroner's Toolkit? Should we all stop running Postfix now?
- belorn 12y agoIn what way is The Coroner's Toolkit using postfix vulnerabilities? The only relationship those two project has is that they share the same developer. COFEE however exploit microsoft own products. It seems you are arguing that trust is not effected if companies first sells a product, then sells exploits for that product in secret. It may be small, or unimportant, or old product, but it doesn't really matter to me. Trust is not something that should be given out lightly.
- atmosx 12y agoYou mean that Microsoft is a victim, who is actively fighting against this 9-figure business, not just a bystander. Otherwise why bother with exploits, just build good, solid C# backdoors and get over with it already.