3 ms·
> PROBABLY AVOID: Elliptic Curve signature schemes. Including Ed25519?
by lisper 12y ago
> PROBABLY AVOID: Elliptic Curve signature schemes.
Including Ed25519?
- cperciva 12y agoProbably. As I said elsewhere, this is subject to the caveat that sometimes you need the performance characteristics of ECC; I'm providing advice for general-purpose computing environments which do not have any such constraints.
- lisper 12y agoNot that I really feel comfortable challenging you on anything crypto related, but it seems to me that Ed25519 is superior to RSA in every conceivable way even for general-purpose computing environments. It's more performant, easier to generate keys, the signatures are shorter, and there are fewer ways to shoot yourself in the foot (e.g. no padding issues). Is there a reason you don't actively advocate it other than the fact that it's not widely used?
- api 12y agoThis PDF is a tiny bit old, so I wonder what they'd say today. I guess it depends on how conservative you want to be. RSA has been through a ton of cryptanalysis and peer review and has stood the test of time. Ed25519 is newer. It's highly regarded but hasn't been analyzed as much or used as heavily so you're taking a bit more of a risk.