2 ms·
Thanks for your very informative comment. The note on katakana isn't very helpful -- but Japanese does indeed have quite few phonemes, 21 according to various
by e12e 12y ago
Thanks for your very informative comment.
The note on katakana isn't very helpful -- but Japanese does indeed have quite few phonemes, 21 according to various random searches (sounds about right). Spanish has 24, French 34 and English 44 according to [1] (No source for Japanese).
Apparently Cantonese has 609-630 or so (due to being a tone language).
Actually that number for English sounds a bit high, I believe 40-41 is more reasonable. Perhaps it includes "all" dialects of English.
[1] http://perso.limsi.fr/mareuil/publi/1209.pdf http://perso.limsi.fr/mareuil/publi/1209.pdf
- bane 12y ago> Apparently Cantonese has 609-630 or so (due to being a tone language). My completely non-Chinese intuition (and having asked the question a couple times to native speakers, including a couple who speak Cantonese), is that the number of phonemes for tonal languages tends to reduce vastly when singing. Since you can't hold a tune and produce tones at the same time.