5 ms·
Alternatively, regulate the last mile as a utility and create a wholesale/retail market. Also called "structural separation."
by Zigurd 12y ago
Alternatively, regulate the last mile as a utility and create a wholesale/retail market. Also called "structural separation."
- hga 12y agoI would say that as "further regulate", as in the companies in questions, the cablecos and telcos ("AT&T", Century, Verizon) are already regulated government enabled monopolies.
- nickff 12y agoIs this not what the government did to the telephone companies providing internet services, which subsequently caused them to stop investing in their infrastructure, thus resulting in the current market situation, where only cable companies provide broadband?
- hga 12y agoNope, or at least not directly. AT&T and Verizon (US Worst/Century never really cared about this) stopped when the Great Recession hit. Since new home construction also took a big hit, there was also less demand (although I know Century is spending non-trivial sums to wire up new residences for people attracted to North Dakota Bakken formation hydrocarbon extraction).
- vertex-four 12y ago> Is this not what the government did to the telephone companies providing internet services, which subsequently caused them to stop investing in their infrastructure, thus resulting in the current market situation, where only cable companies provide broadband? Last I checked, they never split up Bell into separate retail, wholesale, and infrastructure divisions operating as separate companies. Look at BT's organisation for how it's better done: BT Wholesale sell everything from the exchange to the backbones to retailers, and BT Openreach (generally) maintain the last mile. Then, there's a market of retail ISPs who buy services and space in the exchanges from BT Wholesale, BT Openreach, and other companies, and sell a whole Internet service to businesses and consumers. If BT Wholesale or BT Openreach didn't get off their arses, there's now enough money floating around in the right places for any retail ISP or group of ISPs to invest in replacing them. They don't really want to, as there'd be a bunch of red tape and figuring out how the regulations apply, but they could if they needed to. We also have Ofcom, which is a very strong telecoms regulator which keeps this market running fairly (i.e. various parts of BT can't give out special discounts to retail ISPs, new services fall under the same regulations, etc). We've had a few bumps, but all in all, it's going well for us. Many in the cities and large towns now have access to 70Mbps fully unmetered, unshaped Internet access through a number of ISPs for no more than their previous Internet package cost, and they can also often get Internet access through American-style cable companies (Virgin being the big one). We're still trying to solve the problem of investment in rural areas, but there's actually been a couple of success stories regarding independent community ISPs, and I've noticed various towns you'd generally regard as "small" having their exchanges being upgraded to support fibre.
- stretchwithme 12y agoOr have homeowner associations own the last mile. Give them he ability to switch their entire local network from provider to provider to get better service and/or lower prices. That sort of model could be used for all sorts of utilities. Collective ownership is not a bad thing when its very, very local. Especially when individuals have a direct, immediate say in who's acting on their behalf.
- nitrogen 12y agoPeople don't even trust their HOAs to tell them when and where to store their trash cans. Maybe a better type of entity exists that is less susceptible to petty, hyper-local personality politics.
- warfangle 12y ago>susceptible to petty, hyper-local personality politics Well, that puts most small local municipal governments out of the running too.
- nitrogen 12y agoMost likely, yes, but once in a while you have a solid group of like-minded, motivated people that can come together and produce the municipal broadband success stories we read about. I'm sure there are a few rare, decent HOAs out there, too.
- stretchwithme 12y agoI don't know about that. Our trash cans are in the trash room here. But I'm sure some of these arrangements are more disorderly than others. In any case, most HOAs and municipalities are fixed. They typically don't expand or contract based on people removing their property from the arrangement. If people could vote with their feet, these entities would have to be responsive. When people were nomadic, they lived together in groups and did many things collectively. And if the arrangement became oppressive, they left. That was a natural check on corruption. We need the same ability, even though we are no longer nomadic.