5 ms·
The Internet is about to change
- haseman 17y agoOne of the great things about the internet is it's always about to change. I think these services have interesting models....but I'll be damned if I'm going to let a 'sales tax calculator' blow a sale because it goes down. A rational business cannot rely on services they can't, at least in some small way, control.
- TimothyFitz 17y agoTrue, but decoupling services via HTTP just makes the fault lines more explicit. I imagine more of these services (like many of the current webhooks stuff Jeff Lindsay is putting out) will be opensource and easily adapted to virtual appliances / dedicated hosting. That way you can choose exactly when hosted vs hosting it yourself makes more sense.
- jes 17y agoRational businesses also have to decide what work to outsource and what work to do internally. If there was a reliable provider of this service, I think many businesses would outsource it.
- akd 17y agoIn fact, complications in calculating sales tax cause many businesses to outsource their entire payments to something like PayPal. If instead they had a number of competing sales tax calculators and other services, one can imagine a payment platform built on a loose network of services with the ability to failover when one goes down.
- mattezell 17y agoExactly. It would seem that one of the biggest problems facing the Internet and the growing dependence on Internet based services/applications is the fact that you are often fully dependent on (and at the mercy of) a single fallible system. If our next generation of web services/applications relied on (is designed to be) a "cloud" based system, capable of dynamically switching between the multiple available services of a specific type, your users could rely on your service, regardless of what a single given service's stability or status is - one goes down, another one picks up. *trivial example: Think Twitter outages - if there was instead a redundant vanilla twitter-like messaging system, outages would not impact usability of its applications... This said, I cannot help but wonder about the fiscal reality of such a infrastructure. In 'narrowing the delivered content more specifically to match the actual desired data' and 'its delivery mechanism' being hammered out, I can't help but wonder about the 'pay off'? Where is the mechanism that allows "content owners" to 'brand' and/or capitalize on "their" data. But that is a different discussion altogether...
- anamax 17y ago> In fact, complications in calculating sales tax cause many businesses to outsource their entire payments to something like PayPal. How does PayPal address that problem? I don't see anything on the paypal site that concerns tax rates for different items in different jurisdictions.
- mrshoe 17y agoIt's hard for me to believe that push technology is going to revolutionize the internet. Why? Because it didn't happen last time (or the time before that). From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PointCast_(dotcom) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PointCast_(dotcom): The PointCast Network used push technology, which was a hot concept at the time, and received enormous press coverage when it launched in beta form on February 13, 1996. Since the early days of the web, people have recognized that the pull model has serious limitations. Unfortunately, pushing data to users has never been compelling enough to spark anything that qualifies as a revolution. People really want data to be pushed to them if that data is intended specifically for them (e.g. email and IM), but not if it's general weather and news data. I do love Cuban's honesty, though: Would NY Times online readers pay $1 a month to be guaranteed that they get their news first, before anyone else? I dont know. Most people would claim to be able to predict the future in order to make their point. He doesn't. EDIT: I should add that his idea that "Huge databases can talk to huge databases and exchange data more efficiently" is cool and makes much more sense than pushing data to users. We're actually working on something along those lines right now...
- tptacek 17y agoI'm not sure I see the connection between AOL implemented in a screensaver and a new design idiom for web applications.
- mrshoe 17y agoMany of us probably don't remember these early days of the web, but a lot of companies were founded (and acquired) because they were going to be part of the impending "push technology" revolution. PointCast is just the poster child for that movement which never really made any big waves.
- tptacek 17y agoI guess my point is, "push" meant something different then.
- 17y ago
- redorb 17y agoby my knowledge he is atleast weeks if not months late, on the news ... but he does give a "reason to care" - which adds value to the conversation... - The web.. seems to change, slowly when we think its changing fast and really really fast when it seems boring.
- blhack 17y agoI'm sorry, maybe my ignorance is showing here, but in the example, aren't they pretty much just describing a cgi? for example... example.com/cgi-bin/gettaxes.cgi?state=AZ&longzip=85251&ammount=82521&trans_id=23894 which returns some text? Am I totally missing the point here?
- natrius 17y agoI think his explanation is just wrong. My understanding is that the web app says, "Hey, if you give us a URL, we'll POST (or GET, PUT, etc) these parameters to it whenever a certain event happens." On your machine, you just set up a script at the URL. Then whenever someone you follow on Twitter tweets, for example, Twitter will POST user=blhack&tweet=My%20spoon%20is%20too%20big to the URL you gave them. That effectively gives you a push API instead of the conventional pull APIs. http://webhooks.pbworks.com/ http://webhooks.pbworks.com/
- Tichy 17y agoStill, I don't see how "webhooks" help? Isn't it equivalent to having two webservices, one having a method for registering URLs?
- natrius 17y agoYou do have two web services. If you wanted to implement what I described today, you'd have to periodically poll Twitter's API or RSS feed for data. With web hooks, there's no more polling. Twitter calls your web service when there's new data. Actually, now that I explain it that way, it doesn't seem that revolutionary. It just makes building neat hacks a tiny bit easier.
- blhack 17y agoI think you just got buzzworded, ;-)... It sounds like this magical "push" thing already exists. It is called "get" and "post". For example, my website is a stupid news aggregator (http://www.gibsonandlily.com http://www.gibsonandlily.com). If a story gets more than ~30 points (which is really rare since there are only a few people that post there), it calls up tinyurl and says: "Hey...tinurl, if you wouldn't mind, could you please give me a tinyurl of this link so that I can post it to twitter?" Tinurl responds "Hey, I'M TOO BUY POSTING TO TECHCRUNCH, GO AWAY!" To which my server says "But c'mon, tinurl...pleaaaseeee????" Tinurl: "Fine, here, no go AWAY! Also, aren't I frigging revolutionary?!" Then it calls up twitter and says "Hey, uhm...brah, like zomfg wutcha doin? Check out this uber link!" and twtitter posts it. This isn't some revolutionary "push" feature, this is just standard cgi action. It sounds like this is the same thing, just in reverse...which really isn't that "revolutionary", more like "duh".
- fnid 17y agoThis technology has been around for a long time. It's fundamental to PayPal IPN, their payment notification system. I also thought it was funny that he said websites constantly monitor the url for POSTs. I imagine a web server in an infinite loop, "Did someone post? Did someone post? Did someone post?"
- datums 17y agoEveryday the biggest databases on the internet talk to each other. Did someone forget about DNS ? I enjoy the 2.0 apps and technologies being developed, some are being called disrupted others revolutionary, If you weren't around 1.0 I can see how that's possible. PubSub looks like it could help make communication between apps/server less complicated, not a changer.
- pyre 17y agoI don't see anyone commenting on the amount of bandwidth this will free up though. Instead of someone's RSS Client polling 30 websites every 15 minutes, you have a single 'hub' that gets pushed data once (the hub doesn't even have to poll). This is not to mention all of those blog sidebar feeds that display things like flickr/delicious/twitter/etc. On the other hand, this might screw up 'reader statistics' depending on how it's implemented.
- progrium 17y agoI think Joshua Schachter told me something like 40% of hits on delicious return Not Modified. Because of polling.
- TweedHeads 17y agoImagine the web as a giant chatroom where servers talk to servers and clients to clients. You will get instantly updated only things that are worth being updated instantly. The real-time web is here.
- progrium 17y agoI think it's great this idea is gaining mindshare. However it seems like most people miss the point... even after me telling them they are.
- geuis 17y agoI think I'm on the outside and ignorant of this, but I don't get it. Of course I'm very used to working with subscribing to events in javascript and this sounds similar conceptually. However, I don't grok what the advantages are between urls.
- TweedHeads 17y agoYour browser will become like a chat client and there will be two main events that will interact with you in real time: Browser events and page events. A browser event will update the chrome, like toolbars, statusbar, etc, so your icons can notify you of events happening on your subscriptions. A page event will update the content of the page you're browsing in real time, new posts or comments (like disqus), stock tickers, sports plays, etc. That is the real-time web as I see it.
- omouse 17y agoCorrection: the Web is about to change. The Internet, not so much. The protocols are still pretty much the same.