12 ms·
I Sold My Startup for $25.5 Million
- bruceb 12y agoHow did they write an article on the outcome of my startup in 2016. You are good Slate. Ok I won't quit the day job(startup). But seriously I wonder how much the employees actually got. Any guesses?
- ForHackernews 12y agoHe says: > Having only raised $1 million in funding, the vast majority of the deal proceeds would go to employees. Also, a significant piece of the deal—more than 10 percent—had been set aside for restricted stock for them. It mentions 12 employees, so if you figure ($25.5m - $1m) * 10%) / 12 = about $204,000/per person in stock. We can only speculate about the non-stock allocation.
- bruceb 12y ago"the vast majority of the deal proceeds would go to employees" That wording seems indicate over 50%? Or am I missing something?
- spacefight 12y agoThe founders might count themselves in to the employees.
- maaku 12y agoVery misleading.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jjoe 12y agoI'm curious how much the founders walked out with. This is almost never disclosed even by articles that claim to seek transparency.
- binofbread 12y agoThe title is a bit misleading in my opinion, but it was a good success story nonetheless. Congrats to Brad and the team. Edit: By title I meant subtitle. I think it was changed on HN.
- mattm 12y agoMan, that ending is brutal. So the point of building a business and selling it is so you can post about it on Facebook? Congratulations on all the effort and succes, nonetheless.
- Fuzzwah 12y agoThat struck me as strange too. I guess it shows that different things drive different people.
- brandnewlow 12y agoI kept asking the editor if it was a funny enough ending. Sorry it fell flat! I was hoping to end with something a bit silly but that people could relate to. Who hasn't announced big news on Facebook before?
- steven2012 12y agoI had the same reaction. The entire article was pretty interesting but ending sort of took the wind out of it and made you seem really superficial, as if your goal was to now brag to all your friends. Oh well, who cares what we think, you're a millionaire!
- bsaul 12y agoI found it more honest than funny, but definitely not weird. A question i have now : now that you've made a company "for the cash and glory", are you going to make a company that truely interests you ? I'm not saying you can't find interesting things in online advertising company, as i've been in one myself. But every day i spent in that company, i kept asking myself "is this really what i want to do with my skills ? Help selling credit purchase to poor people searching for "debt" on google ?"
- amirmc 12y agoIt runs the risk of sounding conceited rather than funny. It almost came across to me that way, but not quite (I could see the attempt at humour). You're not coming across that way here, just so you know.
- 12y ago
- mattzito 12y agoThe really critical point I'd like to highlight is this one: > Marin’s team sent over a list of hundreds of technical, legal, and business questions that we’d need to answer for the deal to go through...Tracking down document after document was tedious beyond compare. Having your ducks in a row as much as possible can make a huge difference in the complexity, risk, and overall stress of doing a sale/acquisition. I don't mean Day 1, of course, but once you're starting to have conversations around acquisitions, it's really helpful to make sure your books are clean, that you have clearly documented your software stack, all of the third-party code you use and licenses, all of the contracts and MSAs you might have signed iwth your customers, employment agreements with contractors, and so on. It's annoying, but once you have it done it's relatively easy to keep up to date. When we sold our last startup, our CFO had done this 10+ times before, and on the first day of the due diligence, he handed over a URL for a data room with hundreds of documents, categorized and neatly organized. The acquirer's lawyers said it was the easiest DD they'd ever seen. EDIT: I sentence misplaced words in a
- orware 12y agoPoints like this are the best to learn about early on (this article was the first one to mention it that I've read, so it's definitely something I'm going to try and keep in mind in case I need it down the road...though I'm far away from Silicon Valley and probably won't build a company that'll be acquired anytime soon). Thanks for highlighting this point for others!
- Osiris 12y agoI just started working at my first startup. Given that the employees are so crucial in building the product that is sold, why is it so uncommon for significant proceeds from M&As to go to employees rather than founders? I realize that VCs like to take the lion's share, but even with what remains most of the stories I hear are of founders taking large payouts while employees get relatively little. I applaud Perfect Audience for recognizing the value of employees and allowing them to participate in the windfall.
- ig1 12y agoFounders hold the majority of the stock because they shoulder the majority of the risk in the early days, employees are largely reward through their salary rather than their stock option. That said most employees make out reasonably through a combination of options & golden handcuffs.
- maaku 12y agoNo, founders hold the majority of the stock because the standard unequal terms of silicon valley favor founders over employees (and investors over everyone). Founders got the ball rolling, but it is the employees that took the company from rough product to something acceptable for M&A. Employees can and should be getting a fair shake, but only if we take steps to change the norm together.
- mbesto 12y ago"One thing that did cut through the exhaustion was a task I’d been anticipating for more than six years: writing the Facebook post in which I announce to friends, former friends, frenemies, ex-girlfriends, college roommates, future wives, and family members that I was not in fact an obscure failure but a new, minor footnote in the annals of Silicon Valley startup successes." Amen. This has been personally the hardest thing for me about being a tech entrepreneur. My friends all assume that overnight I'm going to be the next Zuck (I'm not) and wonder why I don't have time for them. Let's take aside the fact that I'm a fairly privileged person, it doesn't negate the fact that putting my heart and soul into a startup, means many of my relationships have taken a back seat. That sucks, but you soon realize the relationships that are most important to you will ultimately wait.
- sriramk 12y agoI once got to meet a bunch of M&A/corp dev people from Google/FB and other companies together and asked them "What would you do if you were a founder and wanted to streamline an acquisition?". Across the board, the top response was "Have all your paperwork in order from day 1 - employment agreements, IP assignments, every single thing you can think of"
- beat 12y agoWhen I started on my company, I set up an LLC just to have the business entity, but I don't think it's nearly clean enough or sufficiently separate from personal finances. Now that I'm moving into the next phase, I'm reincorporating with a fresh C Corp structure. Since the old entity never hit revenue generation, it's not a big deal to leave behind. One of my goals for the new entity is to have a totally clean entity with perfect notes, for eventual acquisition.
- czbond 12y agoIf your IP was assigned from you to the LLC, you have to do an assignment (and potential payment from your C corp to the LLC). Just trying to help you keep it clean since that's your priority.... [Not a lawyer, but double check]
- stevoyoung 12y agoYou might still want to talk about this with a professional accountant or tax lawyer. Even though your LLC didn't make money, it made your IP. Your C corp technically has to buy that IP from your LLC - which cost something. Once you are small, no big deal, if you get big you might have a problem at hand. Definitely talk with a professional to make sure you are taking appropriate steps in transferring the IP.
- gamblor956 12y agoEven though your LLC didn't make money, it made your IP. Your C corp technically has to buy that IP from your LLC - which cost something. That's likely wrong (at the federal level, at least). Single-owner LLCs are disregarded for tax purposes unless they expressly choose to be treated as corporations, so generally for tax purposes an LLC's owner is treated as directly owning all of the LLC's assets (and as directly earning all of the LLC's income). Contributions to a C-corp are generally tax free (see, e.g., IRC 351). State tax regimes may differ.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoBleurgh, interstitials. Yes Slate, I came to read the article, no I'm not staying around now ...
- callmeed 12y ago> What you realize, though, is that partnerships are rarely a real thing. This is tangential to the core of the article but I can't stress enough how true this is. In the two companies I've co-founded, we've been approached for partnerships by huge companies (Oracle and Adobe) and tiny, 1-person, pre-revenue shops. In almost every instance, it's been a net loss in time and money. The tiny shops just want help making inroads into your industry and customer base. The huge companies just want to show they have "partners" to their direct reports or sales leads. They'll ask you to build out some integrations (on your dime) and scrap the entire project 6 months later (true story). To them, it's a rounding error but to a startup, the financial and opportunity costs can really hurt. There's a reason Gail Goodman calls partnerships a "mirage" [0]. It's great that this call turned into an acquisition for Perfect Audience. I would advise everyone to take Brad's advice: take the call and maybe a meeting–but just one. Unless the meeting goes well and the strategic fit is too obvious to ignore, just say "no" to partnerships. [0] VIDEO: http://pawel.ch/post/71104054756/the-long-slow-saas-ramp-of-death-i-have-just http://pawel.ch/post/71104054756/the-long-slow-saas-ramp-of-... [0] TRANSCRIPT: http://businessofsoftware.org/2012/10/gail-goodman-the-long-slow-saas-ramp-of-death/ http://businessofsoftware.org/2012/10/gail-goodman-the-long-...
- sunir 12y agoNah. You're just letting the people approaching you set your company's priorities. It would be the same as letting the first salesperson to cold call you direct which product to buy. With your limited investible resources, you have to decide and direct where you will invest them. Not using partners to extend your offering or distribute your offering means you are reinventing the wheel trying to meet customer demand or trying to reaching every single customer in the world with your own people and dollars. Good luck with that.
- callmeed 12y agoI appreciate the counter-point but you haven't said anything to convince me otherwise. The presentation I referenced and other replies seem to back that up (if the CEO of Constant Contact says it ...). My main point was directed at people who are new at this. I've been there and I can smell a bad partnership right away (and most of them stink). But when you're new at this, it's an easy trap to fall into. Big companies dangle their customer base in front of you ("Wouldn't you love to get your product in front of our $HUGE_NUMBER customers?"). When you're new at this and deep in the slog of trying to grow your startup, that's a hard thing to resist. (btw, I don't consider having an affiliate program part of partnerships)
- 7Figures2Commas 12y agoThis is a success story no doubt; a $25 million exit in under 3 years and with just ~$1 million in funding is obviously a better outcome than what the vast majority of startups will ever realize. But it also highlights just how hard it is to realize a meaningful windfall as a startup employee. Even if you assumed that the 12 non-founder employees equally split 50% of the company (which is almost certainly high), likely none would net $1 million after exercising their options and paying taxes. What's worse: the vast majority of this deal was paid for in stock. The Marin Software stock chart over the past two years is not very inspiring, which is especially interesting given how good the market has been to so many other tech/software companies. In an all or mostly stock deal involving a public company, you are ideally acquired by a company with a rich valuation. That's not the case here. The $2.7 million in equity retention grants, if split equally amongst 12 employees, adds $225,000 for each, but that too is stock and the employees have to stick around and work for it. I don't know much about the acquirer, but working for stock that has for some reason languished during one of the most impressive bull markets in history isn't a very compelling proposition. This all seems lost on the founder of the company. I can't help but wonder if it's lost on the employees too.
- jjfine 12y agoIt's still probably huge for their net worth.
- gibybo 12y agoIs there anything preventing the employees/founders from just immediately selling the Marin stock for its cash value? It's a public company so it should be trivial to sell for very near the same value given in the deal.
- ryanburk 12y agohaving been involved with a few acquisitions in the past, usually the terms of the deal have a lock in period where you can't sell to aid in retention. then you add on top of that new retention grants to handcuff folks as best you can.
- 12y ago
- bdevine 12y agoI haven't heard this term before, but maybe that's just me: "... it became clear that ad retargeting—in which you show ads to people who recently visited your website—was where MARKETEERING dollars were going" (emphasis mine). That's an interesting turn of phrase: it evokes Disney's Imagineers, who can be loosely said to be engineers with a heavily creative bent, and applies it to the act of marketing, thereby implying a more heavily creative and technically adept form of "marketer". I wonder if "X-eer" is an inchoate language trend?
- Pxtl 12y agoHah, my instinct is the opposite. To me it invokes a racketeer - somebody who has carved out a business niche for themselves by creating problems to solve instead of finding them.
- bdevine 12y agoNice catch! I didn't go there at all, but maybe I should have!
- smacktoward 12y agoNah -- "marketeer" is a modern formulation, but the basic form of "X-eer" has been in use for a long time now. Some examples: Mountaineer: first use 1600s (http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=mountaineer&allowed_in_frame=0 http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=mountaineer&allowed...) Pamphleteer: first use 1640s (http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=pamphleteer&allowed_in_frame=0 http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=pamphleteer&allowed...) Auctioneer: first use 1708 (http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=auctioneer&allowed_in_frame=0 http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=auctioneer&allowed_...) Profiteer: first use 1910-1915 (http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/profiteer http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/profiteer) There are even earlier examples in English (pioneer and charioteer, for instance), but those didn't come from adding "-eer" to an activity; they were loanwords (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loanword http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loanword) from other languages, like Old French, which used "-ier", "-eur" and "-aire" the way we use "-eer" today. (So charioteer, for instance, started out as charioteur.) Once the words were adopted by English, the spelling migrated to the form we know today.
- joshdance 12y agoI liked it. Seemed more honest than many posts about acquisitions I have read. Congrats to the team.
- finalight 12y agowonder what the rest of the employees will do...find new job or just relax for their entire life?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- danielweber 12y agoDamn, video with audio plays as soon as I go to that page.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jpadvo 12y agoSo, what should a early startup be doing with "ip assignment"? We hire people from places like elance and odesk - and a few irl people - is there something we should have been having them sign?
- Spoom 12y agoFor contractors, they should have terms in their contract that assigns all copyright in their work exclusively to the company. http://www.epiclaw.net/2011/01/10/beware-work-made-hire-language-independent-contractor-agreements http://www.epiclaw.net/2011/01/10/beware-work-made-hire-lang...
- graeme 12y agoConsult a lawyer if this concerns anything important, but I know at least elance has standard terms that all IP belongs to the person who hired the contractor. https://www.elance.com/q/sites/default/files/page_pdf/legal/independent-contractor-services-agreement-13.pdf https://www.elance.com/q/sites/default/files/page_pdf/legal/... You would want to check they're not using code they don't own, of course. The agreements bans it without disclosure, but in practice I'm sure many elance contractors use GNU code without mentioning it.
- smoyer 12y ago"Total strangers on the Internet were speculating on why we sold, how much we might have made, and what our revenues might have looked like." This is what the Internet does, and for better or worse, I hope my (advertised) speculation[1] what taken in the vein it was offered - without judgement or malice. Now that we know more about the deal, I'd like to add my congratulations to you and the employees. I've sold two companies (well ... my part of them) so I know the anxiety that comes right before and right after the sale. It sounds like you've made a very wise decision and I wish you the best as part of Marin. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7837232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7837232
- jordo37 12y agoNo worries! All of us over at PA were more amused/surprised by the analysis than reading malice into it. Just very strange to have it happen to you!
- smoyer 12y agoMy item c was clearly wrong ... I also should have mentioned that selling while you're strong is a fantastic way to gain leverage during negotiations. If you can't walk away, you WILL lose.
- andywood 12y agoCongrats!! That's a pretty big win!
- jw989 12y agoWhy are there no waffles?
- pyfish 12y ago"Unlike a lot of other startups that give options to their employees, we’d given them actual shares." Nicely done and congrats.
- skkbits 12y agoCan we get following information from founder or does anyone know ? 1. When perfectaudience was started ? 2. How much revenue it had at the time of selling ? 3. What was rough ( though not exact ) percentage of company holding by owners at the time of selling ? 4. What software technologies they used for this platform ?
- shamdressup 12y agoStep one: have money >Perfect Audience started as an ad design product called >NowSpots, which was itself spun out of a previous company >called Windy Citizen, a local news aggregator that I >bootstrapped (entrepreneur speak for self-financed).
- brandnewlow 12y agoThat'd be a great point if I hadn't started Windy Citizen with $3k to my name and $100k in student debt. I moved into subsidized housing in Chicago so I could save money.
- redmaverick 12y agoWere you a solo-founder when you started it? How did you build your team and find a cofounder?
- brandnewlow 12y agoI was more or less a solo founder. It took me 4 years to find a proper co-founder. I had to fire my first co-founder and my second co-founder. I had to generate significant revenue and traction before my current co-founder felt secure enough to leave his job and join up.
- ForHackernews 12y ago> I moved into subsidized housing in Chicago so I could save money. Not sure how I feel about that. Section 8 is supposed to help people who are struggling, not subsidize early-stage startups. I guess it's probably a net gain for the economy, but you should strongly consider giving back and donating some of your money to groups that help underprivileged families in Chicago.
- dshuang 12y agoHe had 3k to his name and 100k in debt. That's not struggling?
- yunfangjuan 12y agoCongratulations to Perfect Audience. It's a great outcome!
- latj 12y agoWhy do you have to keep selling a secret from employees?
- fedxc 12y agoWell done. No need to read any longer.
- justplay 12y agodoes that guy/founder is an HN user ? I dont see any of his comment, though he mentioned Hackernews in his article.
- Tossrock 12y agoHow did he go 3 years, ending with a team of 12, on just a $1MM seed round? Were employees paid entirely in equity?
- budu3 12y agoPresumably the employees were paid from revenue.
- solomone 12y agoIt's funny how this is even a question. Often times a business goal will be to be profitable, but that seems foreign in tech.
- brentd 12y agoFunniest thing I've read on HN in a while.
- brandnewlow 12y agoWe generated great gobs of revenue!
- WadeF 12y agoWith 10%+ MoM growth it's pretty dang easy.
- Confusion 12y agoLet me blow you mind: where I'm working we're slightly smaller than this, after 6 years, with no funding at all. And we've built an amazing product entirely bases in what oud customers actually need.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jimmyjohnson12 12y agoYeah huge tech firms reached out to our company. After going out of our way (many miles) & spending a ton of money to demo they were horribly rude. They literally took their huge name/foot and squashed us like a bug. They promised us the moon and the sun and when we arrived it was hell with how they treated us. Saying things as they showed us to door... "You better run fast the race is on." This is after they baited us for our secret sauce with promises of helping us out and or more (we didn't divulge everything). Also, they blocked our tech from working during our demo (wth?). Well after that experience when other big tech firms reach out .. one recently asking let us understand how your technology works. I'm like HA screw you! Partnerships are a time sink. One that could go nowhere, get you feeling squashed like a bug or actually provide a win. Though that's how it all goes with this entrepreneurship game. Game on!
- ZanyProgrammer 12y ago"a software platform which helps small businesses buy online ads" is worth 25 million dollars? What a messed up world we live in.
- green22803 12y agoI'd probably have said "We Sold Our Startup", but otherwise, congrats to them!