5 ms·
First of all, this argument begs the question: why are some people so insistent on buying milk right now that they are building multi-billion-dollar computer sy
by pdonis 12y ago
First of all, this argument begs the question: why are some people so insistent on buying milk right now that they are building multi-billion-dollar computer systems and running special data lines with sub-millisecond latencies to do it? Needing milk so desperately that you can't wait until the grocery store opens in the morning is supposed to be an unusual condition, not the normal way of doing business.
But more importantly, HFT is not the same as liquidity. HFT only works in the first place because there are already market orders being placed; if no one but HFTs wanted to buy or sell stocks, no trades would take place. So the HFTs, by themselves, can't provide liquidity; they have to wait for someone else to do it, and then execute their trades to help narrow the bid-ask spreads.
I'll agree that there is some value to narrowing the bid-ask spreads; but is it enough value to justify the enormous effort and the enormous amount of human talent that goes into HFT, that could be doing lots of other valuable things? I don't think so; I think all that is a sign that the incentives in our society are screwed up.
- pierrealexandre 12y agoAre you aware of the distionction between market orders and limit orders? HFTs by themselves can provide liquidity (like any other investor), namely by entering a limit order in the order book. They can also by themselves narrow the bid-ask spread, namely by entering a limit order at a price more competitive than the current first limit. Of course, someone else has to send a market order to the exchange for a trade to execute.
- pdonis 12y ago> Are you aware of the distinction between market orders and limit orders? Yes. > HFTs by themselves can provide liquidity (like any other investor) Exactly: like any other investor. Meaning, the "high frequency" part of HFT is not what provides the liquidity. (I admit that I should have made that clearer in my previous post.) Suppose an HFT enters a limit order that is more competitive than the current limit. Either some other investor would have been willing to trade at the same price (as the HFT's limit order), or not. If not, then it doesn't matter how fast the HFT places the limit order; it's going to increase liquidity in any case. So the "high frequency" part is not necessary; the key is that the HFT is an investor willing to trade at a certain price. But if some other investor would have been willing to trade at the same price, then the only difference the HFT makes is speed: the liquidity gets added sooner than it otherwise would have. So the "high frequency" part doesn't change anything except who the profits from the trade go to.
- tptacek 12y agoThe "high frequency" in HFT compared to human traders is a little like the "high fructose" in HFCS compared to table sugar. To wit: "high frequency" changes the relationship of HFT to other sell-side traders; it's what allows HFT shops to potentially outcompete human market-makers. However, it's the category of sell-side traders in general that matters for liquidity. You're using imprecise language here (for instance, referring to market makers as "investors"), but the clear implication is that you believe that normal, "buy-side" investors provide adequate liquidity. But they don't, and we know that, because the more competitive the sell-side gets, the lower spreads get.
- pdonis 12y ago> you believe that normal, "buy-side" investors provide adequate liquidity Well, of course that depends on how you define "adequate". What is all this incessant trading of stocks for? What value does it provide? For example, if I'm an investor (a "real" one, not a market maker, to use less imprecise language) with a long time horizon, something like 30 years, because I'm saving for retirement, how does HFT make me better off?
- tptacek 12y agoOne obvious benefit of "incessant trading of stocks" is that buy-and-hold investors can move in and out of a position for much less than they could in the 80s. The "incessant trading" reduces costs, which can be very important even to value investors when there is some extrinsic prompt to trading.
- pdonis 12y ago> buy-and-hold investors can move in and out of a position for much less than they could in the 80s In other words, brokerage fees, or the equivalent, should be lower, so the overhead to execute a trade is lower. That has some value, yes, but not a lot, because a buy-and-hold investor, of course, doesn't execute many trades, so the overhead cost of executing trades is already pretty small for him. Also, most "buy-and-hold" investors hold mutual funds, not stocks, which changes things. See below. > costs...can be very important even to value investors when there is some extrinsic prompt to trading Yes, but as I just noted, most "buy-and-hold" investors are holding mutual funds, not stocks, so they aren't paying the direct costs of stock trading anyway. When I want to rebalance my 401k, I don't trade stocks, I trade mutual fund shares, and they're all shares of different funds offered by Fidelity or Vanguard or whoever my 401k provider is. (And with most 401k's, certainly with the ones I have, as long as you don't rebalance too often there is no fee for rebalancing.) So decreasing the overhead cost of trading will only appear to me, if at all, as a decrease in mutual fund fees; but with most 401k's the individual doesn't see those anyway, because they're provided through employers. I don't know how much the fee question affects the negotiations between employers and mutual fund providers for setting up 401k's, but in any case that's at least two layers of indirection between me as a retirement investor and the overhead cost of executing individual stock trades. So I can see some small benefit, yes, but is it enough to offset the high social cost of having so many smart people doing HFT instead of something more productive?
- rsync 12y agoThere is a (false) assumption among laypeople that limit orders "no longer work". This (false) assumption is propagated regularly by articles and books wherein the same pattern repeats itself: 1. limit orders are defined 2. "... but on that morning Joe Trader was shocked to see that his limit orders weren't working!!" 3. description of Joe Trader NOT using limit orders ... or using them and canceling them and chasing prices ... or whatever. I've seen this pattern in a lot of media since the Lewis book. In reality, limit orders haven't changed and you can set a limit and go to sleep / go on vacation, just like you always could.
- smileysteve 12y ago> why are some people so insistent on buying milk right now Because NOW is when we have the most actionable knowledge. If you don't buy now, what if the price never goes back down? You missed a buying opportunity.