4 ms·
I'm an European and treason and espionage are political crimes (they not against universal ethics in any way). If Snowden is a traitor, then he spied on my beha
by nabla9 12y ago
I'm an European and treason and espionage are political crimes (they not against universal ethics in any way). If Snowden is a traitor, then he spied on my behalf against U.S. government. For me and many other citizens of so called free word he is a hero. He should get a medal.
In U.S. media the discussion centers around Americans being spied and if that is illegal. As a non-American, I see U.S. UK and other mass surveillance countries as constantly attacking me personally. As more and more people feel the same way, it will eventually have real consequences to U.S. interests. It might take generation or two, but it will happen. Why would U.S. want to make new enemies?
First world countries are very interdependent on each other and this kind of attacking harms us all. Even in the cynical machtpolitik world view this can be seen as shortsighted strategy.
- opendais 12y agoI think the reason Americans don't see foreign spying as an issue is this: If the US spies on a German citizen, the US can't go and arrest said citizen without the German government's consent. However, when you spy domestically, the US citizen can't exactly defend himself and can get railroaded under National Security...then tossed in jail. There is a very, very big difference between what domestic security forces can do to you vs. foreign ones.
- marcosdumay 12y ago> If the US spies on a German citizen, the US can't go and arrest said citizen without the German government's consent. What isn't true anymore (replace Germany with Pakistan for an extreme example) and don't really matter anymore, because it looks like all the mafias that own governments are supporting each other nowadays.
- ninv 12y ago>If the US spies on a German citizen, the US can't go and arrest said citizen without the German government's consent. why arrest when we can blackmail them. (evil laugh)
- dragonwriter 12y ago> If the US spies on a German citizen, the US can't go and arrest said citizen without the German government's consent. Patently false. See, among numerous other incidents and legal cases, United States v. Alvarez-Machain, 504 U.S. 655 (1992). The US can and does arrest foreign citizens in foreign countries for offenses committed in foreign countries without the consent of any foreign country, and has done so overtly for quite a long time.
- tptacek 12y agoThat is a disquieting case that sets an insane precedent, but note that it does not enable the USG to use unwarranted foreign SIGINT to introduce evidence in a criminal case. (Hopefully this comment clarifies instead of sounding dismissive; that citation was very helpful).
- dragonwriter 12y ago> That is a disquieting case that sets an insane precedent, but note that it does not enable the USG to use unwarranted foreign SIGINT to introduce evidence in a criminal case. That's what parallel construction is for, which is rather orthogonal to the issue of whether the target is a foreign citizen located in a foreign country at the time of the arrest or a US citizen in the US at that time. And also note that options for action based on NSA surveillance aren't limited to arrest followed by criminal prosecution.
- tptacek 12y agoThe parallel construction discussion is also very complicated. I should be clear: you're right, the comment made upthread about how noncitizens are insulated from the impact of US surveillance was not valid.
- mpyne 12y ago> That's what parallel construction is for Parallel construction relies on having other law enforcement agencies available with which to conduct the parallel evidence (re-)gathering. How would that work in a foreign country? It seems at the very least we'd have to have FBI or similar in their country (which limits the possibilities to nations with agreements that permit this). The U.S. LE agent abroad would then still need to be able to detain and search for the evidence to re-locate, all while maintaining U.S. rules of evidence, and all while not getting arrested by the host nation in the process. The latter sounds like a guarantee to me if you should even whisper a hint that "parallel construction" is taking place over there. A counter-argument is that Constitutional protections are not all considered to apply on foreign soil by U.S. courts, but given that these actions would be taken by an agent of the USG I'm still not sure how such a case doesn't get thrown out immediately. > And also note that options for action based on NSA surveillance aren't limited to arrest followed by criminal prosecution. But nor are the options literally infinite.
- dragontamer 12y agoLearn US Govermnent 101 please. The NSA is a military agency. The Military is not afforded police powers. The NSA is restricted in its ability to cooperate with the FBI. Furthermore, any illegally gathered evidence is tossed out before it is told to the jury. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fruit_of_the_poisonous_tree http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fruit_of_the_poisonous_tree The US is allowed to spy on its citizens, as appropriate under the 4th amendment. IE: With warrants, due process, and all that good stuff. When the DoJ / FBI fails to comply with the rules, illegal evidence is tossed out before trials even begin.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoGood grief. Stop pretending that NSA and DOJ are playing by the rules. We know they're not. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/08/dea-and-nsa-team-intelligence-laundering https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/08/dea-and-nsa-team-intel...
- Kim_Bruning 12y agoUS government 102: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction .
- opendais 12y agoEh? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction NSA hands it over to the DEA who arrests you based on an investigation based on that information. They've been doing it and getting away with it so I think your believe that the Fruit of the Poisonous Tree will protect you is false.
- dragontamer 12y agoParallel construction proves my statements. On the books, legally and in front of a judge, the NSA and DEA are not allowed to work with each other. Parallel Construction is a (probably illegal) technique that DEA agents are using right now to get around the legal authorities. But it involves DEA agents lying under oath towards judges. IE: I don't think the practice of parallel construction is going to hold up in courts in the long term.
- tptacek 12y agoI'm not a good person to argue with about Snowden's status as a traitor or a spy, because I don't think he is one either. As for the rest of your comment: I find it frustrating the extent to which Europeans seem to believe that their own governments aren't spying on them. Obviously, people in the UK have the weakest argument here (there's an argument that the UK's SIGINT programs are even more aggressive than those of the NSA), but the arguments for, say, Germany and France aren't that much stronger. (Also: If there's a SIGINT conspiracy theory I do buy into, it's that every modern country in the world is culpable for SIGINT, because they leverage their partners for access to SIGINT that they cannot lawfully generate themselves, on a quid-pro-quo basis.) You see this manifest itself all the time with supposed privacy startups launching from the "safe confines" of Switzerland, a government that has a track record of cooperation with SIGINT. An assertion I believe to be true that would I think be helpful if more people understood: NSA surveillance --- however unwise much of it is, and I think there's a lot of unwise and unlawful stuff happening --- is not a secret effort to create a New World Order headed by the NSA. It's a means to an objective shared by most (if not all) of Europe. European companies don't cooperate with NSA because they're afraid of NSA; they cooperate because they have shared interests --- both in security (terrorists are a greater threat to Europe than to the US) and politically (China and Russia have as much if not more influence over the economies and geopolitical status of Europe as they do to the US).
- Htsthbjig 12y ago"I find it frustrating the extent to which Europeans seem to believe that their own governments aren't spying on them" That is because they don't at the same extent that Americans. First, although Europe's economy is bigger than the US when you consider all countries combined, each state has its own Security services. Being fractured means they are much less powerful than 50 billions a year NSA. It also means they could decide what to share and what not with each other. Second, they don't control tech companies like the US does thanks to the fascist(the State controlling all businesses) Patriot Act Laws. You have the option to collaborate with them or not without going to jail if you tell anybody. Europe has the scars of similar fascist laws in Germany, Italy, Poland... and they are very careful abut them.
- Amezarak 12y agoThe US and UK are not the only mass surveillance countries - as the Snowden revelations have confirmed, virtually every first world power is. It looks more to me as if the only countries not engaging in mass surveillance are those without the resources to do so. It is not clear to me why the fact of foreign surveillance alone should have greater consequences for the US than for France, Germany, etc. To me it appears the NSA revelations have been exploited by certain political factors, especially in Europe, to strengthen their own mass surveillance efforts; for example, it strains credulity for me to believe European efforts to get more services located in Europe because of the NSA revelations are really for your protection and not so the BND and other European surveillance organizations can access the servers directly without having to negotiate for them with the NSA in a tit-for-tat. That would contradict everything we know about mass surveillance programs in European countries.
- alexschleber 12y agoBlanket #surveillance, a domestic enemy to the Constitution? Discuss... "I, [name], do solemnly swear that I will support & defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign & domestic...that I will bear true faith & allegiance to... same [constitution]; that I take this obligation freely, without any... purpose of evasion..." 4th Amendment to said U.S. Constitution: "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, & effects, ... against unreasonable searches & seizures, shall not be violated, & no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, & ... particularly describing the place to be searched, & the persons or things to be seized." --- Who's committing the treason...?
- AJ007 12y agoIf the NSA's ability to spy is a critical piece of national security -- then that which opposes it is a national security threat. It isn't the Greenwalds or the Applebaums who are the targets, it is the people who are elected President, run for Congress, or run big technology companies. The only people who have come close to spelling this out are Senator Ron Wyden and Bill Binney. That was before Snowden's leaks. I'm not impressed by tech's leadership on this. Their fear today will mean a new generation will see secret pervasive surveillance as a feature to be added to; and perhaps that generation already does.