5 ms·
Show HN: TopLevel – A New Way to JavaScript Your HTML
- hayksaakian 12y agoInteresting, so does it avoid interpreting by using HTML comments as the opening and closing symbols?
- barosl 12y agoBy looking the code, the script injects <plaintext> tag while being loaded. So, all the HTML followed by the script element will lose their meanings, just to be rendered as a plain text. Due to the approach, I guess the start and end tags don't need to be <!-- and -->. It can be anything. The only reason they chose them I guess is that it relieves confusion, though I still think the insertion of the comments in the regular HTML tags looks a bit weird.
- kristopolous 12y agoI'm trying to incur the smallest impact possible on existing scrapers and give a solution which could still be used to make validating HTML.
- phaed 12y agoNice. What is the impact on performance?
- kristopolous 12y agoI've only seen it faster than comparable methods.
- barosl 12y agoThe MDN wiki states that the <plaintext> tag, along with the similar <xmp> and <listing> tags, has been deprecated since the ancient times of HTML 3.2. It also says the support for those tags can disappear suddenly in this HTML5 era. I know the use of <plaintext> seems to be essential for the implementation, but I'm not sure that it is a reliable way. Are there any alternatives?
- kristopolous 12y agoThe only other way I know to break the interpreter is if you force a bad character encoding of a different bit width. I have yet to get it working as reliably across the same wide range of browsers. As far as it disappearing; In order for that to happen one browser group will have to take the first step of intentionally breaking legacy webpages - it seems antithetical to the "render as much as possible" features arm-race nature of the browser world. Then again, I've been wrong plenty of times before.
- user24 12y agoCould a textarea tag work too?
- kristopolous 12y agonot if the document has an existing <textarea> (and thus </textarea>). <plaintext> is rather final ... see here for a demo I just threw together: http://getpostdelete.com/plaintext.html http://getpostdelete.com/plaintext.html The HTML interpreter packs up its bags and goes home - you can't "close" a <plaintext> tag if it's existing in a plain HTML page. However, you can still manipulate it through the DOM.
- user24 12y agoYeah I sort of realised that as I said it. Hmm.
- chewxy 12y agoReminds me of an example I gave in my book about how you can write valid HTML that executes as JS: /* <div id="writeHere"></div> <script src="#"></script> <div>For example here, we have multiple examples of code that execute</div> <!-- */ writeHere.innerHTML='<p style="font-weight:bolder">Hello World</p>' alert("are we JavaScript files or are we HTML?") /* --> */ I saw this once upon a time while debugging some nasty code some publishers used - the whole site was in this style. It was one of the most ingenious things I've seen - the same file, parsed twice, once as HTML and once as JS.
- kristopolous 12y agoWow is that ever clever!
- aidos 12y agoYou'll end up with the leading '/*' (and trailing) showing in the html though. Not much you can do about it I guess (except probably use a css hack to hide it). ps I don't envy anybody who has to spend their day working on code that looks like that!
- dmak 12y agoThis is interesting, could you explain this more in detail?
- Kiro 12y agoNot OP but: 1. Page is parsed as HTML, ignoring the JS since it's wrapped in HTML comments. 2. script src="#" loads itself. 3. Page is parsed as JS, ignoring the HTML since it's wrapped in JS comments.
- MasterScrat 12y agoI fail to see why anyone would use that instead of inline <script> tags? Is it because each tag would then be parsed and run in order, ie you couldn't declare a function at the end of the page that you'd use at the top? It's the only explanation that comes to mind...
- joelbondurant 12y agoDespite the best efforts of millions, XML still sucks as a general purpose programming language.
- kethinov 12y agoHow's this take? https://github.com/kethinov/teddy https://github.com/kethinov/teddy Not exactly a general purpose programming language (as XML really shouldn't be used that way, of course), but I think it takes a lot of the ugly verboseness out of most XML templating systems, including the OP's. Maybe I should post a "Show HN" thread too. ;)
- kristopolous 12y agoyes you should. this thing is amazing.
- kethinov 12y agoThanks! Done: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7852417 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7852417
- kethinov 12y agoAlso, have you heard of ejs? It seems like it has similar design goals to what you're working on. https://github.com/visionmedia/ejs https://github.com/visionmedia/ejs
- franze 12y agowow, ACT3 syntax from 1999 re-invented. ACT3 was the template / programming script of the austrian national news agency. instead of JS we used PERL as the inline script language. oh yeah, in the end i wrote a templating language using this templating language until we ditched it for something sane, namely PHP 3 at that time.
- callesgg 12y ago"Works Everywhere And Is 0.8 KB." Everything is gzip/compressed. It is more interesting to know the real file size.
- kristopolous 12y ago1488 bytes for the minified js and 3773 for the "development" version --- I'll add that ... ok done.
- kaeruct 12y agonice pitch
- abhidilliwal 12y agoI am sure some people will take this seriously and start building apps over this.
- borplk 12y agominimum 10 years TopLevel experience required
- kristopolous 12y ago10 years?! Aw shucks! Count me out then. :-(
- ollysb 12y agoJob description years are like dog years, nearly there.
- TeeWEE 12y agoPlease do not use this. This will block incremental rendering in a browser. http://www.html5rocks.com/en/tutorials/internals/howbrowserswork/#Global_and_incremental_layout http://www.html5rocks.com/en/tutorials/internals/howbrowsers... The way TopLevel works, is by getting the complete HTML content, putting it trough a javascript parser, and then rewriting it using document.write. So this requires all content to be downloaded first, and the toplevel.js to be loaded, before a page can be displayed properly. This breaks all the improvements made in browser, and would significantly slowdown page use. Also, its completely non standard, and a mis-use of js. Nice hack however ;-)
- kristopolous 12y agoLet me respond paragraph-by-paragraph: --- 1. Blocks incremental rendering? Indeed ... for people not TeeWEE, "incremental rendering" means say a 2MB HTML file will be partially rendered prior to the entire payload being transferred. That is no longer the case here. 100% true. As an aside, I'll think hard about how to overcome this. --- 2. The description of how it works? Correct. Very succinct. Good Job! --- 3. Significantly slow down a page? This depends on the page. If it's a small-footprint HTML page which leverages templating, then the base page will be quite small. If the design previously loaded unneeded dependencies which were only applicable to a subset of users, then this provides a very easy way out without requiring lots of technical knowledge - and probably a good speedup to boot. As far as actual tests, I've refactored a number of personal projects with this library, and the time to where the spinner stops (if I load the two versions side by side) isn't noticeable through my eyes. I can't honestly tell which one is which. --- 4. A "mis-use of JS"? It's certainly non-canonical - but I'd argue that many "standard" common practices got their start being just as heretical and then were later replaced by standardized ceremonial ways of doing things.
- al2o3cr 12y agoYo dawg, I heard you liked PHP and Javascript so I made your Javascript work like PHP...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kristopolous 12y agoOk I'll bite ... I made a version that uses "<?" and "?>" as the stanzas --- on a gist: https://gist.github.com/kristopolous/7d68c3c7cec5f9ac5bc3 https://gist.github.com/kristopolous/7d68c3c7cec5f9ac5bc3 Lines 35-37 are the change. Have fun.
- integricho 12y agoFor me it's another layer of complexity introduced into the already overly-complex webapp architectures.
- Guthur 12y agoI would like to suggest using Knockout for this sort of thing instead. And as I side benefit you get can get reactive observable and a rich HTML binding syntax. We do this sort of conditional rendering with KO in our application and it works great. It's quite a mature and focused library.
- LukeB_UK 12y ago> The stylesheet above will never load unless the branch is satisfied. Or if the user has JS turned off.
- SimeVidas 12y agoFrom the readme: <img src="logo_<!--= (isMobile() ? "50x50" : "200x200") -->.jpg"> Isn't this a SPOF? If the toplevel.js script fails to load/execute, the <img> will request "logo_.jpg" which does not exist. (The example implies that "logo_50x50.jpg" and "logo_200x200.jpg" exist.)
- phpnode 12y agoyes, the whole thing will break if JS is disabled or that script fails to load, but this is hardly a unique failing of TopLevel. Most websites will break under these circumstances these days.
- lnanek2 12y agoI kind of prefer my HTML and CSS to be declarative and not a bunch of complex conditional commands...
- simonhamp 12y agoI think you just saved the life of <plaintext> Cool though. Any performance examples from older/mobile browsers?
- evaneu 12y agoFirst of all good job. Totally different approach, not mainstream way of thinking. Main question: What are real life usecases?