4 ms·
Nice anecdotes. Your comments and links are good at triggering fear, but the data doesn't back you up that football is an usually dangerous sport. Women's soc
by jessriedel 12y ago
Nice anecdotes. Your comments and links are good at triggering fear, but the data doesn't back you up that football is an usually dangerous sport.
Women's soccer has a higher rate of concussions than men's football at the collegiate level, and it has 75% of the rate at the high school level [1]. Similarly, men's college soccer has a higher rate than high school football. In fact, football is higher than the average sport (high school or college) by less than a factor of 2, an average which includes non-contact sports like volleyball.
Will you be preventing your girls from playing soccer?
Yes, football has a somewhat higher rate of concussions than most other sports, a fact that should be considered before participating. And yes, the recent improvement in concussion treatment and monitoring is a great thing which will naturally focus on football since it has a higher concussion rate and since more US high schoolers play football than any other sport by far.
But the idea that football is in its own category of danger is ludicrous. If you're withholding your children from football, you should almost certainly be withholding them from all contact sports.
[1] Table 1 here: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2140075/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2140075/
- markdown 12y agoThis doesn't make sense. You're saying that Football (where hitting another player is illegal) is as dangerous as American Football, where hitting another player with the full weight of your body at high momentum is the point of the game for most positions. Does not compute. From the study you linked to: > Contact with another person was the risk factor responsible for most concussions among high school athletes. You could play an entire season of Football without ever coming into contact with another player. Unless you were a Marvel superhero, that wouldn't be possible in American Football. I skimmed the study you linked to an the conclusion was merely that Football and American Football had the highest rates of concussion... compared to what... track and field athletics? DUH!!
- jessriedel 12y agoMy understanding is that the concussions in soccer come from direct head-to-head collisions (which are not cushioned by helmets) and from heading the ball (which is moving significantly faster than a human being). The fact that you find the similar concussion rates between these two sports surprising is good reason for you to doubt your ability to identify dangerous sports based on your intuition for how violent they are.
- kansface 12y agoAre not concussions in football vastly under reported?
- Avshalom 12y agoEvery time some one does a study they find they're under reported in every sport. They might be more underreported in football but its also under more scrutiny so its hard to say who knows how the reporting rates compare.
- jessriedel 12y agoMuch more than other sports? No, I don't think so. Modern concussion tracking studies take baseline cognitive measurements and then periodically re-measure throughout the year, regardless of whether the player reports an injury. Somebody ran a survey where they looked for replies that indicated "probable" concussions that were unreported, and they found > The sports with the most unreported concussions were women’s soccer (24%), men’s football (21%), field hockey (13%), and cheerleading (10%). http://www.sportsmedres.org/2014/02/unrecognized-concussion-rates-are.html http://www.sportsmedres.org/2014/02/unrecognized-concussion-... I don't believe those numbers are normalized for the number of concussions, and in any case would indicate that women soccer players were slightly less likely than football players to report a concussion conditional on having one. As for "unrecognized" concussions (i.e. the athlete gave a reply on the survey that sounded like maybe they had a concussion) they say > The sports with highest potentially unrecognized concussions were football (55%), cheerleading (50%), and cross-country (28%). which to me means you can't trust this survey at all. Whatever they're interpretting as an "unrecognized" concussion, it happens as often in cheerleading and over half as often in cross-country. On the other hand, if you want a human interest piece, you can go read skierscott's link to the NYTimes blog post about how all those football players are toughing out brain damage....
- kansface 12y agoThanks for the info- perhaps they mean that 28% of probable concussions from CC are unreported? This seems reasonable.
- learc83 12y agoThe thing you're missing is Chronic traumatic encephalopathy. The current theory is that CTE can be caused by the constant repeated non-concussive hits unique to football (at least among popular American sports), so analyzing concussion rate really isn't helpful. >A brain injury study conducted at the Boston University School of Medicine showed that 33 of 34 players tested post-mortem showed clear signs of CTE.[1] Even when you account for selection bias the number of NFL players with CTE is insane. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NFL_players_with_chronic_traumatic_encephalopathy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NFL_players_with_chroni...
- jessriedel 12y agoAhh, good, yes CTE is at least a more interesting critique. However, I believe the non-concussive theory is purely a conjecture at this point. This is one of the authors of that Boston study: "While it remains unknown what level of exposure to brain trauma is required to trigger CTE, there is no available evidence that occasional, isolated or well-managed concussions give rise to CTE," one of the study's co-authors, Dr. Robert Cantu, said in a press release. So basically, you're just stuck with your priors on this one. As far as I am aware, CTE data doesn't provide you with any additional evidence for non-concussive effects beyond what you could have conjectured pre-CTE. Of course, the media has breathlessly reported on how NFL players are all commiting CTE-induced suicide despite the fact that the NFL suicide rate is less than half the rate of the general population... http://loyolamedicine.org/newswire/news/little-evidence-retired-nfl-players-more-likely-suffer-cte-loyola-doctor-says http://loyolamedicine.org/newswire/news/little-evidence-reti...
- learc83 12y agoThat quote doesn't say anything about non-concussive hits. "there is no available evidence that occasional, isolated or well-managed concussions give rise to CTE," He said there was no evidence for occasional concussions, he didn't say anything about repeated non-concussive injuries. Here's a quote from the BU CTE center "We believe CTE is caused by repetitive brain trauma. This trauma includes both concussions that cause symptoms and subconcussive hits to the head that cause no symptoms." [1] I'm a big guy and I live in the south, so you can bet I played my share of football growing up--there are definitely a lot more repeated hits to the head in football than any other popular youth sport. [1] http://www.bu.edu/cte/about/frequently-asked-questions/ http://www.bu.edu/cte/about/frequently-asked-questions/