11 ms·
U.S. Marshals Seize Cops’ Spying Records to Keep Them From the ACLU
- opendais 12y agoYep, not an abuse of power at all. Seizing all the evidence to interfere with a legal proceeding. This seems perfectly legit to me! /s I'd hope that the U.S. Marshals [as a service] would have people fired for this and a Judge would find whoever ordered this to be in contempt. However, I really expect this just to be ignored beyond the ACLU/News reporting on it. :/
- spiritplumber 12y agoAt the very least if this does go to court, the judge is very likely to call BS.
- rosser 12y agoDepends entirely on the judge whose bench it ends up before.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 12y ago> In the Sarasota case, the U.S. Marshals Service claimed it owned the records Sarasota police offered to the ACLU because it had deputized the detective in the case, making all documentation in the case federal property. This is pretty outrageous.
- angersock 12y agoBrazen, really. They're not even trying anymore.
- higherpurpose 12y agoUsually a sign of third world government/justice system. In such countries they don't have to bother to hide their crimes because they know they have all the power and no one will do anything to them. Unfortunately many in the US law enforcement have started feeling like that, because in truth, usually nothing happens to them when committing crimes either.
- angersock 12y ago:(
- javajosh 12y agoIndeed. Usually the best accountability mechanism is internal to the organization (or the person), but George W Bush demonstrated unequivocally that if you absolutely refuse to hold yourself accountable, there's literally nothing anyone outside your organization can do. It was like discovering a superpower. Loyalty is everything, principle nothing. So vilify whistleblowers, hold the line against criticism. The important psychology here when behaving unethically and illegally on behalf of your org is to remember that the org is defined to be good and if you criticize it, you will be defined to be bad and moreover, there will be real-life consequences on the order of lost career, imprisonment, or death. Another important feature these days is the use of secret interpretations of law that justify breaking it, providing a soothing balm to those who's consciences need it.
- adventured 12y agoDid you mean Barack Obama? Or Bill Clinton? Or Ronald Reagan? Or Richard Nixon? Or Lyndon Johnson? Or Franklin Roosevelt? They all abused their power, often to extremes. The illegal war Kennedy and Johnson put us into in Vietnam was drastically worse than Iraq. The only reason spy agencies under Nixon didn't do what they have under Bush and Obama, is they lacked the technology to pull it off. That's the sole reason it didn't happen sooner. J Edgar Hoover was director of the FBI for 48 years, under numerous Presidents, all of which were complicit in the abuses that took place. They knew what he was and didn't stop him. Hoover would probably be doing worse today than anything the NSA is doing, he lacked the technology, not the willingness to violate the Constitution. If FDR was willing to intern Japanese Americans during WW2, what kind of other vile police state measures do you think he would have happily gone along with had the technology existed to eg spy on every single American in 1941? He absolutely would have brushed the Constitution aside, all he lacked was the technology. None of this mess began with Bush. And the Bush mentality is the opposite of unique among Presidents. He's just one of many involved over decades of abuses leading up to this point.
- fiatmoney 12y agoThe notion of "ownership" of public records is a bit tenuous to begin with. You can own the paper (except they obviously don't, and you can make a copy on your own paper), or you can own a copyright on particular documents (except that US government documents, including municipalities, are public domain). Really they're asserting some quasi-classification right to prevent a record's release because they "deputized" the author, but it's pretty unclear under what actual statutory authority they're operating.
- Spooky23 12y agoIn most cases, state and municipal works are copyright protected, unless they specifically waive their rights. I believe that California does, for example. Most states do have freedom of information laws for access to records, but there are broad exemptions for law enforcement and other public safety purposes.
- rosser 12y ago17 U.S.C. § 105 only bars the Federal government from holding copyrights on works it created. Case law, however, holds that states and local governments may retain copyright.
- snarfy 12y agoSo what. Release it. I'll take a copyright violation.
- grecy 12y agoGiven we're talking about the (ab)use of this stingray surveillance device, who's (assumed) widespread use the feds don't want the average citizen to know about, I suggest they would come down on you with enormous damages for that copyright violation.
- rosser 12y agoYou seem to think I disagree with you. I'm just correcting misinformation.
- wmeredith 12y agoVote with your dollars, it's likely the most important vote you've got. The ACLU single donation page is here: https://www.aclu.org/secure/make-gift-aclu-3?s_src=UNS140001C00 https://www.aclu.org/secure/make-gift-aclu-3?s_src=UNS140001... The ACLU membership page is here: https://www.aclu.org/secure/our-civil-liberties-are-under-attack-1 https://www.aclu.org/secure/our-civil-liberties-are-under-at... I have been an ACLU member for years, but am otherwise unaffiliated. Crap like this is why I'm a member. They are on the front lines.
- cstavish 12y agoThe ACLU needs a "let me donate but don't send me a pound of mail each year" membership option.
- javajosh 12y agoAmen to that. That's a big issue with most charities, actually. I wonder how the cost/benefit works out, though? I'm guessing it's probably still worth it to send the mail.
- baddox 12y agoAt this point, it's almost certain that the benefits outweigh the costs, considering that non-profits still compete, and every non-profit I've heard of sends tons of mail.
- yaddayadda 12y agoAt this point, it's almost certain that the PERCEIVED benefits outweigh the PERCEIVED costs, considering that non-profits still send tons of mail. There is little doubt that there are benefits to their current model. tvanantwerp covered some of those benefits. But there are costs and benefits that don't appear to be included in their current calculations. If anybody doubted the difference that lots of little contributions can make need only look at successful crowd-sourcing systems and campaigns. I believe that most non-profits have been told to go after the big fish donators and if they have to destroy all the little fish in the process, "oh, well". My point, and based on the other comments, I'm not alone, is that the little fishes' contributions may add up and be worth more than the big fishes with a lower overall cost (because it costs to produce and distribute those tons of mail).
- nilsimsa 12y ago"Recently, the Tallahassee police department revealed it had used stingrays at least 200 times since 2010 without telling any judge because the device’s manufacturer made the police department sign a non-disclosure agreement that police claim prevented them from disclosing use of the device to the courts." So just by signing an NDA, I'm not obligated to disclose information to the court?
- charonn0 12y agoThat one bothers me too. Just like I can't sign away my obligation not to commit a crime, they can't sign away their obligation to uphold the law.
- javajosh 12y agoImagine if this worked for handgun manufacturers. "I'm sorry, but I can't say if I shot him or not; the use of my gun is covered by an NDA with the manufacturer."
- hga 12y agoA better analogy would be traces. They're almost never even theoretically useful, because they terminate with the being gun stolen or sold in a way that can't be traced, but they start with asking the manufacturer which distributor bought the gun, which leads to the gun store, where the ATF Form 4473 tells you who bought it at the retail level. If manufacturers forced distributors and gun stores to sign NDAs ... well, we know how that vs. the clear laws and regulations on the books would resolve. Somehow these other Constitutionally enumerated rights seem to be getting about as much respect as the 2nd Amendment does....
- DannyBee 12y agoYou actually are, and in fact, the convictions have started to be reversed as a result of this ... Good thing an NDA caused rapists/etc to go free!
- jacquesm 12y ago> Good thing an NDA caused rapists/etc to go free! No, good thing illegal behaviour by police departments was identified and rightly led to overturning the convictions resulting from that behaviour. Whether the perps were murderers, pot smokers or speeders (or innocents...) does not matter.
- Jaecen 12y ago> the device’s manufacturer made the police department sign a non-disclosure agreement that police claim prevented them from disclosing use of the device to the courts. I don't know where to begin with this, other than to say it's quite clear that this police department is not interested in participating in the justice system.
- logn 12y agoDefending against this would be a perfect use of Florida State Guard, as such groups aren't controlled by the federal government. Unfortunately as of 1947, Florida now only has the Florida National Guard which is under federal control. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_State_Guard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_State_Guard For all the talk of 2nd Amendment (guns rights) advocates, I think they miss the obvious use cases: well organized (and locally controlled) militias, such as the Florida State Guard.
- bmelton 12y ago> For all the talk of 2nd Amendment (guns rights) advocates, I think they miss the obvious use cases: well organized (and locally controlled) militias, such as the Florida State Guard. That's because Florida outlawed them[1], along with many other states. [1] - http://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?mode=View%20Statutes&SubMenu=1&App_mode=Display_Statute&Search_String=870.06&URL=0800-0899/0870/Sections/0870.06.html http://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?mode=View%20St...
- bashinator 12y agoWouldn't outlawing militias be unconstitutional under the second amendment?
- mullingitover 12y agoOnly if the federal government outlawed them. The states have a right to maintain a militia, but not an obligation.
- hga 12y agoRight now the Supremes are refusing to admit that it means anything besides having a right to have a gun in your home for self-defense. The "and bear" arms minor detail just might as well not exist. Militias, which the bare wording of that Florida law wouldn't quite seem to outlaw (presumptively assume it was part of the general post-Reconstruction effort to keep freedmen "in their place"; with the exception of efforts to suppress dueling American gun control got it's start in that), aren't even operationally part of the 2nd Amendment except as a justification for the RKBA part, and that was basically a sop thrown at the Founders who disliked standing armies but couldn't get far with veterans like Washington pointing out the limits of militias. I can go a lot further in this analysis if you wish, but one of the foundational principles is above, a tension between the militias (safe but less effective), "regulars" (less safe, more effective), and "select militias" (utterly dangerous and not effective except in internal oppression). Our Founders did not like the idea of select militias at all, the phrase had connotations around the strength of e.g. Communist ... and surprise, surprise, our modern, paramilitary police are very close to that definition. With outsiders like the Federal Marshalls when they pull these sorts of stunts (see also Ruby Ridge) pretty much fitting it to a T. The other thing to initially look at is the Constitution's provisions for militias. Outlawing them at the state level would negate the rights and duties of the Congress about them ... something in part sidestepped with the creation of the National Guard, which until Heller made the point moot our betters insisted were the militia.
- MrBlue 12y agoWelcome to the USSA.
- winslow 12y agoSerious question. At what point do you think the public truly hits a tipping point and lashes back at the government? Or are we just going to sit unorganized and go back to our facebook and nightly entertainment. Personally I think it will have to be an economy downturn worse than the housing bubble to get the public to organize.
- leorocky 12y agoLike how has this news affected your personal life at all. Did this action diminish your capability to have a job of your choosing? Did it prevent you from raising children? Did it prevent you from doing something you love? How different is your life now? Because the voting public isn't going to care unless their ability to live their life has been affected, and it hasn't.
- deciplex 12y agoRight around the time it's too late.
- rhizome 12y agoWho is going to be the first device manufacturer to provide Stingray protection for their phones? Apple? Google?
- X-Istence 12y agoIt looks and acts like a normal cell phone tower... so there is no good way to provide protection against it.
- rhizome 12y agoStingray apparently works by overloading signal over an area. I'm sure some math comparing device motion with sudden-tower-appearance could be put together into a reasonable heuristic.
- X-Istence 12y agoStingray works by having a stronger signal (It's closer to the user, kind of like a wifi hotspot). This can happen at anytime anyway, carriers have put up mobile towers before so that they can take down a single or multiple towers in an area for maintenance, or to provide extra coverage. Are there possible ways to detect it, possibly, but will there be a HUGE amount of false positives, I fear there will be.
- rhizome 12y agoMy solution was only with 10 seconds of thought from a layman. I'm not even an Electrical Engineer. I'm guessing the best-of-the-best in the Google-rola and Apple-A7+ hives are capable of deeper thoughts on the issue. They're at least closer to the point of contact from the tower than I am.
- dcherman 12y agoThat's pretty scary. That implies that in addition to the target, anyone in the general vicinity of the target ( up to whatever the range of these things are ) would be tracked as well. It's a good thing we can trust our agencies not to keep databases containing this unrelated but invasive information....right?
- eyeareque 12y agoI knew the news yesterday was to good to be true.
- javert 12y agoPeople in the future are going to be so confused. "If the Americans were the first to systematically limit government power in a written constitution, why did they just start ignoring it all of a sudden?"
- eropple 12y agoIt wasn't "all of a sudden". We've been doing it--sometimes for good reasons, often times bad--since the country's inception. "John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it!" is two hundred years old.
- hga 12y agoAndrew Jackson's famous quote is actually part of the checks and balances in the system, a guard against an out of control Federal Court system, even if this example is awful. The check against that is the ability of the Congress to impeach and convict a President. It should also be noted the Congress can remove anything they want from the remit of the Supreme Court, and have done this more than a few times in the past (generally or all also bad) and some in recent times. Of the three branches, our Founders were supremely suspicious of the courts, if you'll pardon the pun. Life tenure, insulated from political pressure aside from impeachment and conviction, they've proven themselves to be equally capable of doing ill as has the Congress and Presidents.
- nitrogen 12y agoWas this before or after https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7843618 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7843618, or was this a separate case entirely?
- ianstallings 12y agoIt just makes you wonder what they are hiding? Is it the capabilities of the device or something else? I don't understand why the feds would get involved. I hope they keep fighting to find out.
- err4nt 12y agoI believe it's more information about how the department has been using it in cases, records of the number of times it's been employed in the field, and I don't doubt they are looking for uses where the police may have used it to gather information illegally.
- ianstallings 12y agoYes but how would that involve the Federal government? That's really what I mean, the involvement of the US government vs the state or local government.
- contingencies 12y agoAdded to Wikipedia over here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stingray_phone_tracker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stingray_phone_tracker If anyone wants to add more info, it's a worthy cause.
- aagha 12y ago"Recently, the Tallahassee police department revealed it had used stingrays at least 200 times since 2010 without telling any judge because the device’s manufacturer made the police department sign a non-disclosure agreement that police claim prevented them from disclosing use of the device to the courts" What complete and utter BS. Does that mean that the DA too had no idea about the use of stingray because the police couldn't tell them either. I think figuring out who should know (and who shouldn't) is probably very very selective!
- anonbanker 12y agoSo, accept upon proof of claim that this wouldn't prejudice the rights of the people of the state if the court gives full formal equity to the federal marshalls, and that this wouldn't be a classic case of Champerty and Maintenance[1]. Personally, I'm viewing this as another "pretend to fail" moment where they claim something is an insurmountable roadblock, when it's easily solvable. 1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Champerty_and_maintenance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Champerty_and_maintenance