7 ms·
> In this case, police used two versions of the stingray — one mounted on a police vehicle, and the other carried by hand. Police drove through the area using t
by ekianjo 12y ago
> In this case, police used two versions of the stingray — one mounted on a police vehicle, and the other carried by hand. Police drove through the area using the vehicle-based device until they found the apartment complex in which the target phone was located, and then they walked around with the handheld device and stood “at every door and every window in that complex” until they figured out which apartment the phone was located in. In other words, police were lurking outside people’s windows and sending powerful electronic signals into their private homes in order to collect information from within.
Seriously ? And no police officer was ashamed of what they were doing during that whole time ?
- eli 12y agoWell, sure, it sounds bad when you phrase it like that.
- Smushman 12y agoanything sounds bad when you say it like that...
- chiph 12y agoHow is this not an illegal search in the same way that the use of infrared cameras has been shown to be? http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=93127 http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=93127
- gscott 12y agoInfrared cameras look into your domicile while the StingRay looks for signals being sent out. They are not looking in to see what is there, they are capturing what is coming out. It is different enough to be litigated up to the Supreme Court. That being said, I in no way support this. I have no choice but to use my phone which makes me into a tracking target. In America it turns out we are all targets in order to exclude each one of us from being Terrorists. Police cars now capture license plates and upload them to a central database (plantir), the whole Internet is being captured and held for 3 days at a time while parts are being kept for longer, the outside of mail is being scanned and captured by the USPS, every major mail facility (fedex, ups, etc) are mandated to have federal agents who open mail and then re-seal it so you never know, etc and so on. I have had to double the tin foil on my hat because one layer is just not enough! It is getting crazy.
- robrenaud 12y agoI also don't support this, but I don't see the distinction. You/your home is emitting the infrared radiation, just like the phone is emitting the signal.
- deciplex 12y agoWhat makes you think agents of the American state have any more shame than various other examples of thugs run amok throughout history?
- adventured 12y agoThere is still a wide-spread belief that the agents of the burgeoning US police state are 'just people like everyone else,' that are 'just trying to do their jobs.'
- jhart3333 12y agoThanks for speaking for me. Actually I would rather speak for myself. Try citing a study or some statistics next time.
- pyre 12y agoSo they are not people, and most definitely are not attempting to do their jobs in any way, shape or fashion? Gotcha.
- deciplex 12y agoThey are people, and they are doing their jobs. It's just that people are capable of horrible crimes, and these jobs shouldn't exist. And nothing works better at implementing a police state than a fervent belief that your nation and culture are somehow 'special' and occupy a unique place in history. It allows you to disregard hard-learned lessons of the past. Lessons like 'Tyranny lurks always just around the corner, and the speed and ease with which it will manifest itself, is as breathtaking as it is terrifying."
- jacquesm 12y agoThe jobs should exist but there should be some actual oversight with serious penalties for transgressions.
- 12y ago
- kareemm 12y agoPerhaps you're forgetting that the police likely believed they were doing the right thing and attempting to bring a bad guy to justice. It's not a popular sentiment on HN, but not all police officers are part of the shoot / oppress first, ask questions later school of policing.
- ekianjo 12y ago> the police likely believed they were doing the right thing You mean, just like TSA officers who believe that X-raying everyone who boards a plane is the right thing if we want to catch these darn terrorists?
- pessimizer 12y ago>not all police officers are part of the shoot / oppress first, ask questions later school of policing. But these were. You're creating a false dichotomy between cops who violate people's rights and cops who think that they're doing the right thing.
- scarecrowbob 12y ago"It's not a popular sentiment on HN, but not all police officers are part of the shoot / oppress first, ask questions later school of policing." To be fair, even those of that school like believe "they [are] doing the right thing and attempting to bring a bad guy to justice."
- deciplex 12y agoLiterally everyone believes they are doing the right thing. Everyone justifies their actions, at least to themselves.
- bediger4000 12y agoLaw enforcement officers, of all people, should know and respect The Law, shouldn't they? I mean, "ignorance of the law is no excuse", and they are doing a special job which requires special knowledge, skills and care. So, I think that we can assume they knew they weren't doing "the right thing". Stingrays are pretty clearly against the spirit of American Democracy and Law Enforcement, as traditionally held. Beyond that, the ends rarely justify the means, even legally. There are supposed to be limits to how the police find stuff out. See 4th Amendment. Traditional sense of fair play, decency, etc.
- ollyfg 12y ago> police were lurking outside people’s windows and sending powerful electronic signals into their private homes in order to collect information from within. Is it just me or does this not sound terribly terrible? My neighbours wifi router sends "powerful electronic signals" into my private home every day.
- ekianjo 12y ago> My neighbours wifi router sends "powerful electronic signals" into my private home every day. Making your phone use max power to emit information is nothing like the wifi radiation you get from your neighbors.
- nness 12y agoIt is though; its all non-ionising radiation. Both the wifi and your phones broadcast information indiscriminately in the interest of connecting to infrastructure. The similarity between the two shouldn't be ignored, since there's potential for the comparison between phone's and wifi devices to come up in legal proceedings (if they haven't already).
- ekianjo 12y ago> It is though; its all non-ionising radiation. Both the wifi and your phones broadcast information indiscriminately in the interest of connecting to infrastructure. I was not referring to their nature, but to the power of the emission. > Whereas a mobile phone can range from 21 dBm (125 mW) for Power Class 4 to 33 dBm (2W) for Power class 1, a wireless router can range from a typical 15 dBm (30 mW) strength to 27 dBm (500 mW) on the high end The radiations from your phone are more powerful than from your traditional router, plus your emitter is usually close to your body, while you usually far away from a wifi router.
- yongjik 12y agoAccording to Wikipedia[1], the solar radiation at Earth is roughly 1361 W/m^2 at the top of the atmosphere. The atmosphere will deflect a small fraction of it, but won't change the value much. Therefore, if you draw a circle of 2-inch diameter on your palm and hold it out toward the sun in a sunny day, that circle receives about 3W of energy (0.0254^2 * pi * 1361 = 2.76), i.e., greater than all the energy your body receives from a "Power Class 1" mobile phone (assuming you somehow magically absorb ALL its radiation). Not to mention that the solar radiation actually contains ionizing UV rays. Sunlight is vastly more likely to cause cancer than cell phones. Literally. If you're so worried about radiation, use sunscreen. You're welcome. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_constant http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_constant