5 ms·
Police use helicopters for all sorts of things. What is problematic isn't the monitoring from above, it's that it is so cheap. A helicopter with crew costs over
by alkonaut 12y ago
Police use helicopters for all sorts of things. What is problematic isn't the monitoring from above, it's that it is so cheap. A helicopter with crew costs over $1000 per hour, so we know you know we aren't being monitored indiscriminately from above. Its simply to expensive. With drones, the cost of air surveillance drops to a whole other level. A level that almost allows for mass surveillance.
The same argument can be made about drone warfare: it's not the shooting/bombing from above that is disturbing, it's that it can be performed at almost zero risk.
The same argument we saw in communications surveillance. When listening to a phone call was expensive it was one thing, when listening to communications became free we know what happened.
Cost, however, shouldn't be what limits surveillance, regulation should. If police can switch from a helicopter to a drone for sime mission, and save 90%, that should be a good thing.
- LoganCale 12y agoExactly right: it's the fact that this makes mass surveillance so much easier that is the problem with certain surveillance technology being used by law enforcement.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoThe NSA does not appear to have the capability of analyzing all the data it taps in a way that would actually be considered intrusive. Knowing the state of AI I just can't imagine this. It's not like in "Person of Interest" where the government has a machine to automatically sift out problems. Same with drones and law enforcement. I can see them using drones in a surveillance capacity, for traffic control, maybe even to track a fugitive. But large-scale drone surveillance? Peaking into people's homes? Tracking people the way they can't track them right now through CCTV footage? No way, no how. The biggest risk from drones is that they fall out of the sky all the time. This will partly resolved through break throughs in artificial intelligence, but for now birds, lines, insects, power failures, hackers or even projectiles can take down a drone, potentially hitting someone. That's why they are used sparingly. A crashing drone is even more obvious than one flying above you making tons of noise. Not very clandestine operations...
- rl3 12y ago> The NSA does not appear to have the capability of analyzing all the data it taps in a way that would actually be considered intrusive. The intrusive nature of this context is not so much the analysis of your personal data, but storage of it. When someone falls under the microscope, sensitive data collected in the past can be pulled from storage, effectively enabling retroactive surveillance. For example, the NSA essentially collects and stores everything they can on everyone, including American citizens. What makes American citizens unique is that they are afforded extra legal protections. However, these protections don't usually extend to the storage of data on US persons, but simply the "collection" and "interception" of said data, which, in NSA's odd legal nomenclature, can simply be translated to mean accessing data that is already stored. In my opinion, the best hope for real privacy is not storing data that enables retroactive surveillance in the first place.
- briantakita 12y ago> Cost, however, shouldn't be what limits surveillance, regulation should. How do you regulate the regulators? If our government follows it's current course, the "Tzar of Surveillance" will also be a (past/future) executive & major shareholder of a drone manufacturer.
- alkonaut 12y ago> How do you regulate the regulators? That's politics. Democracy requires things like accountability, transparency. If the government has huge authorities that are almost completely opaque to scrutiny, that's a democracy problem.
- briantakita 12y ago> that's a democracy problem It's a systemic thinking problem. You seem to want to isolate every piece. That makes it easy to "pass the buck" in a round-robin fashion. It's a problem with democracy, so we should make it cheaper for law enforcement to take away our rights, because progress! Democracy won't be solved until the practice of special interests making most of our laws is removed. The special interests make laws to tighten their stranglehold on our "democracy" and to suppress our freedom. Law enforcement, surveillance, & additional laws becomes more pervasive in our lives so people who wish to exercise their democratic rights are suppressed. It's a "problem with democracy" again. In the mean time, will the democracy problem ever be solved? Will we ever make progress on that front? Are we playing the right game? To improve things, we need to start thinking more holistically, not myopically. A house, or system, divided will fall. > If police can switch from a helicopter to a drone for sime mission, and save 90%, that should be a good thing. Agreed, however what will really happen is 10x the number of drones will be bought & used.
- alkonaut 12y agoWait, if special interests make laws that's another very fundamental democracy problem. This isn't passing the buck, it's pointing out the obvious fact that its all one and the same. Democracy is having all your authorities under scrutiny and control by the people. It's hard. In a state with unbelievable amounts spent on lobbying and with self-monitoring intelligence authorities, there are certainly things to work on. Imagine a country where corporations can't sponsor political campaigns. Or where surveillance isn't monitored by secret courts applying secret laws. Democracy isn't black or white, it's always a shade of gray.
- nlawalker 12y agoThis is similar to automated license plate scanning. There was a discussion here a while ago (can't find it now) about an article discussing the automated license plate scanners, and one of the posts had a really good point: our society's regulations about what law enforcement can and cannot do, and the citizenry's relationship with said law enforcement, are based on a certain amount of inefficiency. Hand-scanning license plates and requiring expensive helicopter crews to perform overhead surveillance are two good examples. When technology eliminates those inefficiencies, the rules and regulations need to be re-examined.
- stretchwithme 12y agoI think its bad to have the police capturing plates and locations. It would be better if private citizens with concerns could simply report plate numbers without location. If there is a plate associated with a crime, the police could respond by asking where it was seen and when, with no response the rest of the time.
- Gustomaximus 12y agoI have no problem with police scanning plates. It's quite efficient to spot people with warrants and cars out of registration etc. The problem is if they store details of everyone else. As long as they scan only for 'plates of interest' this actually seems like a useful tool to me.
- clarky07 12y agoAs noted in other place here and in the article, most of these technologies could be useful and good. Unfortunately they can also be easily abused, turning into very very bad. The question isn't whether there could be good, it's if the good outweighs the bad. And if it's close, it needs to be regulated and watched to be kept in check. I agree that the scanning could be helpful in many ways, helping find amber alerts, people with warrants, etc. It could also be very bad though, so we need to be careful.
- mariodiana 12y ago
- icambron 12y ago> Cost, however, shouldn't be what limits surveillance, regulation should. If police can switch from a helicopter to a drone for some mission, and save 90%, that should be a good thing. This on my top ten list of things I want to shout from the mountaintop. If you read the legal decisions about police surveillance, they're all about analogizing to how police can follow people around, but that's resource intensive and thus limited, and does this piece of tech break that balance? Which is a terrifically insane way of thinking about it. It both makes the rules of what law enforcement is allowed to do shifty and unprincipled, it also makes legitimate deployments of law enforcement pointlessly difficult. Instead, we need strong, principled (and thus not technology-specific) rules regarding privacy, and then we can decide whether particular uses of, say, drones fall within those boundaries. Starting with the technology doesn't make any sense. I've made this point a few times on HN, but the same goes for military drones. "The problem with them is they make killing people cheaper" is a sign of a totally broken morality. Instead, start by deciding whether killing that person (and the collateral damage it will cause) is OK, and then use the most efficient means to do it. Whether there's a pilot in the aircraft can not plausibly be a proxy for whether you should blow someone up or not. (FWIW, I'm very close to categorically against killing people.)
- nitrogen 12y agoInstead, start by deciding whether killing that person (and the collateral damage it will cause) is OK, and then use the most efficient means to do it. Unfortunately, most calculations of whether a particular mission is "OK" will include cost and risk as factors.
- mpyne 12y agoTo the extent that we're relying on "cost" as a way of avoiding otherwise undesirable missions, that's only an "answer by accident"; it should be fixed properly, but that's not a reason to reduce the cost. That argument is the same reason we continue to have pointless programs like Selective Service registration, which actually somehow saves the government money by allowing them to avoiding paying some tuition benefits that our "draft dodgers" would otherwise qualify for.
- 12y ago
- dan_bk 12y ago> With drones, the cost of air surveillance drops to a whole other level. A level that almost allows for mass surveillance. If you remember, a few months ago, the reports of the surveillance planes being able to cover a whole city (by just 1 plane), then you know that these "drones" here are just gadgets.