14 ms·
Who or What Broke My Kids?
- noonespecial 12y agoHow could any student not be fall-right-over excited about learning standard 7.SP.C.5 ?
- jacquesm 12y agoTom Lehrer on 'New Math': http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UIKGV2cTgqA http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UIKGV2cTgqA Enjoy the 'octal' bit.
- mbuffett 12y agoSo the author asks a room full of kids to arrange numbers on a number line, then gets mad when the kids want to know if their answer is right? As far as I could tell, it was an exercise with one right answer. Why get mad at the kids for wanting to confirm whether they understand the material?
- JonnieCache 12y agoSome of them weren't numbers, there were symbols and natural language statements which required interpretation.
- codingdave 12y agoBecause there is a deeper underlying problem in education - we have been teaching kids to pass tests for quite a while now. And the growth of the Common Core standards is now teaching them to pass that that use new terminology coined from those standards. These goals are creating changes in curriculum. Some schools are devising new curriculum that is working well, some are not doing so well. You can compare it to coding in some ways - if the entire industry was told to drop their current toolkits and use new ones, how would it go? There would be some successes, some failures, and a few years of trial and error until new best practices come about. The Common Core is making this happen within education. Some educators think it is great, some educators think it is horrible. But it definitely is impacting the kids.
- oe 12y agoWhat's the exact probability of "it will rain tomorrow" or "You'll visit the beach sometime"? Maybe the point was to figure out that there are some known and unknown factors that affect both probabilities while you could still be pretty sure that you'll go to the beach sometime.
- kedean 12y agoHe's not upset because they want to know if they're right, he's upset because they just grab some options, throw them together, and check with him. There's no thought going into it and I'm sure if you ask the kids why they chose the locations they did, they'll have no response. I recently graded some of the math final tests for my wife's second grade class, and the students who are doing well all did well because they extracted the parts from the problem that were required (even simple things like how many jugs of milk are shown below), while the students with a history of not doing so good in math instead picked numbers off the paper and either added or subtracted them, assuming they just needed an answer. There was no thought about the process, just the end result. Got some numbers? Good enough.
- delluminatus 12y agoWhen did we brainwash kids into thinking that math was about getting an answer? That's what school is about. It's not math in particular. Doing well in the US mandatory education system is the art of finding the right answer.
- pdonis 12y agoWhere finding the "right answer" is really more like guessing the teacher's password: http://lesswrong.com/lw/iq/guessing_the_teachers_password/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/iq/guessing_the_teachers_password/
- falcolas 12y agoI'm 36, and math in my youth was always about getting the right answer, and proving how I got that answer, even up through college calculus and discrete mathematics. Heck, that's one of the things I really enjoyed about math, when compared to, say, English. So, if math isn't about getting the right answer, it's been broken a long time. Even today, math as I've explored it (which admittedly hasn't been much) has right and wrong answers. Sure, there's a bit of fuzz in the answers now, but a probabilistic model which can't determine ham from spam some majority of the time isn't kinda right, or even on the spectrum of right. It's just wrong, and needs to be fixed.
- mmphosis 12y agoYou are right.
- Spearchucker 12y ago"...and proving how I got that answer..." That's the part that counts, and is largely missing today.
- nl 12y agoI'm not at all convinced that has changed. I've read the Common Core (and the Australian equivalent) and they certainly require proving how answers were obtained.
- goodcanadian 12y agoI am not so sure you are talking about about the same thing as the article. Usually, when "proving your answer," I found there was still an expected procedure for you to follow, and you would lose points for deviating from that procedure even if what you did was mathematically correct. What the article talks about is learning how to reason about a problem even if your reasoning is questionable and even if you don't arrive at an answer.
- sanxiyn 12y agoThat is unbelievably terrible. You would lose points for a mathematically sound justification?!?! For example, when solving quadratic equations, I often used trial substitutions and the fact quadratic equations have at most two solutions to justify answers, instead of using quadratic formula. Why wouldn't this get the full mark? (I would actually argue this is a better procedure if you are looking for integer-only solutions, for example.)
- Kenji 12y agoIf I have to solve exercises and after that, I have no way to know whether or not I did the right thing, I don't learn anything at all. The point of exercises is to learn something new and uncover your misunderstanding of the subject. Your wrong solution clearly points to the things you have to work on. No solutions = no learning. Mathematics is about getting answers. It's a formal way to declare problems and seek for answers. Right answers. I'm glad I wasn't taught maths by this person.
- ronaldx 12y agoThe article's point is perhaps that it's better to try and gain some intuition for whether or not you have the right answer, rather than checking the answer key. Relying on the answer key (or waiting for the teacher to say "you are right!") is an extremely poor habit and we should avoid teaching students to depend on that (in maths class or otherwise): in real life, there is no answer key. One of the philosophical ideas of maths is that there are multiple ways of looking at a problem, and those multiple ways should feed back onto each other to confirm your answer. Maths is not just a bunch of rules that have to be followed without question: in this case, maths is modelling something practical and the answer needs to match reality. Without that, the probability model could not even have been invented. If you can't get beyond the stage of do_question+check_answer, you are never going to be capable of anything more than grinding out other people's mathematical results. I'm sorry you weren't taught maths by this person.
- Kenji 12y agoBefore you've gotten a firm grasp on the subject, you might be convinced that your answer is right but it's not. Especially when the maths becomes more complicated. If nobody tells you it's wrong, you will incorporate more and more wrong things in your understanding. I notice this horrible effect every time I'm solving exercises for uni and there are no solutions. I think I've done good work. Sometimes, everything really was right, other times, I made fundamental mistakes all across the exercises, showing me that I didn't understand something important. Of course, when you're in research, there's no key. That's why it's so difficult. But it doesn't make sense to reinvent the wheel, as in, researching things that are already well known.
- wirrbel 12y agoI firmly believe there should be two math subjects taught at school. One being "Calculating" where students do the boring calculations and all the stuff, calculus, algebra, etc. and another one where the interesting and challening part of math is taught in an accessible and fun way. There are a lot of topics in math and related to math that could be explored in that second, new subject, probabilities, paradoxa, symmetries, basic set theory, even concepts of linear algebra/groups, etc. that are normally taught in university can be broken down to really great middle-school or high-school lessons. The only problem with that in normal math classes is, that the angry parent will quickly complain when that is talked about in a normal math class because they think that their kids should be bored to death by calculations that their smartphone does better already. I was recently talking to a retired high school teacher who had taught language classes (he was really not a maths guy). We started talking about password security and piece by piece we discussed how easy those passwords could be guessed and in the end he had a good understanding of the concept of probability/information/entropy. This really made me think, if a really non-maths person can enjoy and understand a topic that a lot of students who have gotten STEM degrees directly refuse (something like "I do not understand what entropy is, that is something about the my room being in order or not but I have given up .....") To repeat myself: There are great concepts and modern curricula available, sometimes for decades. However mathematicians, math teachers and parents are just not supportive in chaning anything substantially.
- mathetic 12y ago> One being "Calculating" where students do the boring calculations and all the stuff, calculus, algebra, etc. and another one where the interesting and challening part of math is taught in an accessible and fun way. Wow. That can start a flame war. I am a huge fan of set theory and probability but since when calculus and algebra are boring? Sure if all you do is evaluate bunch of integrals, it is but what if you are learning about Fourier Series/Transform? It requires vector algebra heavily as well as calculus and I think it is just as stimulating as anything else. Sure it involves "calculating" but it is not a bad thing, calculating is at the heart of the subject.
- sanderjd 12y ago
- oe 12y agoI'd say it's the parents. Listening to parents of elementary school kids they seem to get confused or angry if there isn't one single right answer to an assignment. For example drawing shapes one line at a time and listing the lines as "commands" to a computer. There might be multiple ways to form a shape. No use trying to argue that it might be valuable to understand how to think with algorithms, even though it might produce several different answers.
- goldfeld 12y agoThat just moves the goal post, doesn't it? Such a parent is as much a broken kid as their offspring in this respect.
- oe 12y agoThe parents might be afraid that their child could "fail" such an assignment, even if it's elementary school and the children aren't graded.
- zacinbusiness 12y agoYou hit the nail on the head here. Most of my family is entirely and strongly anti-education. My brother and I (32 and 29, respectively) were the first and so far only people in our family to ever go to college. My grandparents championed it, but our father has gotten progressively more and more anti-intellectual (he's what you might call a "crazy redneck"). Upon our last meeting he actually asked me if I am "actually smart" or if I am "just good with the computer." The sad part is he had a chance to go to college, my grandparents were going to pay for it if he would have just gone. But he's paranoid and thinks college is where they convince you to not love Jesus and to get rid of your guns.
- edwhitesell 12y agoIMO, this is one teacher who gets it. There is a lot of math that is entirely about answers that are right or wrong. Most of the time that includes how you arrived there. Given the references to MAP and Common Core in the blog, I'm sure there's a lot of that in the classrom. However, there is so much of the K-12 education that arguably should be about exposure. Discussion about probabilities of pictures and phrases on a number line is a great example. Have kids make their case among peers regarding why 'It will rain tomorrow' is .9 in one group, but .75 in another. For most, you don't get to pick your desired area of study/career until College. So why not use K-12 to expose kids to all sorts of different things without standardized tests as the only goal?
- ugk 12y agoSo many schools seem to "teach only towards the test" because of the heavy reliance on standardized testing. I don't claim to have any answers, but society has pushed for this and it's a logical result IMO.
- xsmasher 12y ago>One student had seen the weather and knew there was a 90% chance of rain the other had not seen the weather and though the probability was 50% since it would either rain or not. They compromised and picked the middle but that’s not the part I cared about, I cared that they had a reasonable discussion about their thoughts. Wow. One of those students was right and the other was wrong; if the teacher praised the discussion instead of pointing out AND EXPLAINING the right answer, then the teacher did a disservice to the entire class. I've heard jokes about touchy-feely "Bill has five apples and John takes two, how do we feel about that?" math, but I honestly believed they were jokes.
- jcarpio 12y agoWhich is then followed by: > Why Constructing a Viable Argument and Making Sense of the Reasoning of Others is Crucial. This may seriously be the most vital mathematical practice. Where the emphasis is on developing an understanding, a viable one (ostensibly leading to a correct answer).
- xsmasher 12y agoWhere the emphasis is on discussion and understanding each others feelings. >We brought it back together as a whole class to follow it up and each group shared the most interesting conversation that they had. Where's the part about explaining a correct methodology and the correct answer? I don't believe that rote memorization is the right way to teach math, but discussion and actual understanding are not the same thing. Discussion can LEAD TO understanding, but should not be mistaken for understanding.
- NPMaxwell 12y agoNeither student was right or wrong. This is a Bayesian problem. Each student had a distribution of priors based on evidence. Each source of evidence had its own level of quality which stipulated the variance of the two sets of priors. The challenge is how to combine these priors to create a posterior distribution. Another way to look at it is that, because "random variation" is how we refer to unknown influences, the perfect-knowledge probability was either 1 or zero. Neither student had perfect knowledge.
- netcan 12y agoMath gets a lot of attention and therefore a lot of criticism from people who think math education is substandard and from people who think it is overemphasised to the detriment of creative thinking and such. I think that overall, our math education is surprisingly good, possibly better than any other subject. Especially if you consider the level of proficiency a high school graduate at below average achievement has. Reading, writing and arithmetic. Those are still the things our education system is best at. I don't mean that the average person will use trigonometry confidently, but they will use basic algebra. That in itself is an achievement. The same cannot be said of foreign language education, most science classes or anything else that requires cumulative learning. Most people that learn a foreign language (apart from english) for years in school do not come out with even a basic ability to communicate in it. I think part of the reason is the very long tradition of teaching the subject. But I think another reason we're good at teaching math is the sort of fundamental property of the subject. It's unforgivingly right or wrong, which helps cut through the cynicism of a youth that doesn't want to be in that class. The problem with the "holistic" (scare quote intended) approach to subjects is that it opens the door to nonsense of the bikesheding type. It's hard to distinguish nonsensical but enthusiastic from genuinely thoughtful. The hard right-wrong distinction in maths gives kids a feedback loop of positive and negative reenforcement. At the end of the year it's glaringly obvious if the student now has ability that he/she didn't before. I don't disagree that the ability to reason is important. But, I don't think teaching "hard" maths is debilitating to developing that ability. I'm not sure exactly where I'm going with this. Maths gets a bad rap. Teaching kids "real world reasoning" within the fake world of school is hard. No one broke the kids. They are just reacting to you changing the rules.
- j2kun 12y ago> It's hard to distinguish nonsensical but enthusiastic from genuinely thoughtful. English teachers successfully do this every day, as do history teachers and teachers in most other subjects. Why can't we let mathematics teachers do this when their students provide proofs via creative thinking? Certainly anyone with sufficient training in mathematics can do this. But overall your comment seems to fall short of reality. Math education in the US produces students that seriously underperform compared both to other countries and in light of the skills and knowledge required for technical careers. Contrary to your belief, high school students still generally can't do algebra. In my experience teaching the subject they don't learn algebra until they take pass calculus, and even then it's because it's a cumulative learning process, not in spite of it. Even if we teach reading, writing, and arithmetic well, that's just not enough.
- goodcanadian 12y agoI must have been taught critical thinking by my parents as even as a child, I could see that the education system was mostly about regurgitating not even the "correct" answer, but the answer expected by the teacher. If you want to see who "broke the children," you need not look much further than that. I am glad that teachers occasionally realize that there is value to being able to reason about a problem rather than just returning the answer by rote. It is rare that grade school teachers even notice there is a problem.
- nbouscal 12y agoA good post on the subject: http://lesswrong.com/lw/iq/guessing_the_teachers_password/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/iq/guessing_the_teachers_password/
- monochr 12y agoAfter reading most of the replies in this thread everyone who thinks that maths is about answers needs to read A Mathematicians Apology: http://www.math.ualberta.ca/mss/misc/A%20Mathematician%27s%20Apology.pdf http://www.math.ualberta.ca/mss/misc/A%20Mathematician%27s%2... Mathematics has nothing to do with answers. It has everything to do with the most sublime and subjective beauty there is. The fact that this purely aesthetic system has says anything about reality should be more shocking than if we lived in a world where playing Beethoven's 5th symphony made it rain food from the sky: http://www.dartmouth.edu/~matc/MathDrama/reading/Wigner.html http://www.dartmouth.edu/~matc/MathDrama/reading/Wigner.html
- graycat 12y ago> Who or What Broke My Kids? From the OP, sounds like heavily that teacher did. Let's see why: > understanding that all probabilities occur between zero and one Better would be, "a probability is a number between 0 and 1 with both 0 and 1 possible". Try not to use "occur" here because if event A is "it rains" and it does rain, then we say that "event A occurred". So, it is better wording to say that a probability "is" than to say that it "occurs". > differentiating between likely and unlikely events Using the word 'differentiating' here is not good because (1) it is crucial in calculus where it has a quite different meaning and (2) it is just too long for the simple concept of, say, 'identifying' likely and unlikely events. The worst is, > The basic premise of the activity is that students must sort cards including probability statements, terms such as unlikely and probable, pictorial representations, and fraction, decimal, and percent probabilities and place them on a number line based on their theoretical probability. I have no idea what is intended here! Probability theory was the main foundation of my Ph.D. in engineering from my research in stochastic optimal control, and I can't make much sense out of the teacher's statement. Calculating probabilities of poker hands would have made much more sense. Or, just for a start: We shuffle a standard deck of 52 cards and pick the top card. What is the probability (a) the card is the queen of hearts? (b) the card is a king? (c) the card is diamond? (d) the card is a spade? (e) the card is a face card? Suppose that first card was none of (a)-(e), and we pick the next card from that deck. Now what is the probability of each of (a)-(e)? Or: We flip a fair coin five times. What is the probability we get Heads exactly three times? > where they can solve any computation problem with technology with no issue. I wish that were so! I guess the teacher has not heard of the problem in the set NP-complete and how common such problems are in business planning and scheduling. > the probability was 50% since it would either rain or not Uh, can we place some real money on that!!!!!!
- maxerickson 12y agoThe point of the lesson/activity is to evaluate whether the students understand that 1/8, 0.35 and 50% are comparable things. It wouldn't be a great idea to assume that the preponderance of 7th graders have mastered this. If you click through to the pdf, the language in the standards is more careful, so it's a little easier to make sense of.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoThese conversation and facilitation skills among kids are really great, and I agree the teacher should be encouraging them, but I have some serious questions as to whether this teacher and I have the same definition of "math". To me, math is a skill involving the manipulation of abstract symbols. It doesn't involve sharing, being nice to other kids, helping each other out, or any of that. Those things are great, but they ain't math. Now "teaching math in a primary school setting" may involve the combination of all of those things, and that's fine. So I guess we agree. But this essay was terrible. If this teacher came to me with this definition of math as an answer on a test, I'd fail them.
- joaren 12y agoWho the hell cares about definitions? Oh right, mathematicians, and they manage to make a beautiful subject terribly boring by insisting it's all about manipulating symbols, instead of the underlying structures they represent. I mean, programming is about typing and manipulating text into a box, right?
- DanBC 12y ago> To me, math is a skill involving the manipulation of abstract symbols. It doesn't involve sharing, being nice to other kids, helping each other out, or any of that. Those things are great, but they ain't math. Coincidentally the math stack exchanges are regarded as the most toxic parts of that community.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoYou know, the really sad part about this essay is, because the teacher doesn't know what the hell they're teaching, they miss the bigger picture. These kids have been learning-crippled. It's not just math. They're looking for a mechanical process for everything. That's a tragedy. But it's lost in some misguided rant about how math might be involved in what's going on.
- sandworm101 12y agoWhy? Because students today are focused on "doing well". That means getting good grades. Look at your tests, be them locally-created or standardized. How are they graded? Do students get good grades for debate or mechanically computing the right answer? Who? An American culture that constantly enforces a science v. arts dichotomy. I say American because in no other country is this split enshrined in language: Metric units for the scientists and English for everyone else. I say American because few other countries produce so many millionaires with zero science education. Look at your student's role models. Athletes. Celebs. Seth McFarlin. Politicians. Donald Trump. The American system does not reward scientific creativity in the same way it does social aptitude. Change would be painful, so painful that it cannot happen for a generation or two Just try suggesting highway signs be changed from mph to kph. And that's easy part.
- throwaway344 12y agoI think that the obsession with "doing well" is by no means an exclusively American trait. Just look at the Indian obsession with IIT-JEE, or Koreans with the CSAT, or the English with A-levels, or the French with the bac. American students, in my opinion, don't really obsess more about our system that anyone else.
- QuantumChaos 12y agoI think the point the author makes is fundamentally correct: the correctness of answers comes from human reasoning, and is subject to discussion and debate. It's not something completely external, and education shouldn't be a game to guess what these external decrees are. As the author says, what should matter is what the student thinks is correct, not whether they think their answer will be accepted as correct. However, the author uses language that is belittling and rude. I think that teachers who use students as an emotional outlet for their frustrations are very harmful. I would rather see the teacher find another way to get the students to see her point of view, than emotionally browbeating them.
- euank 12y agoHe is talking about the same problem that is discussed in Lockhart's Lament [0]. If you've never read this piece of writing, I encourage you to do so now as it presents our math education system in a wonderful and critical light. I can't speak as elegantly as Lockhart, so I won't damage the piece by summarizing it or discussing it in the post; rather, I'll leave you to read it and draw your own opinions. [0]: http://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament.pdf http://www.maa.org/external_archive/devlin/LockhartsLament.p...
- overgard 12y agoNobody broke the kids, they were doing exactly what they were taught to do. I'm not a fan of the education system in the least bit, but something about this rubbed me the wrong way. She's probably exaggerating when she said she had a "meltdown", but all the same, what are you supposed to think as a kid when your teacher has a tantrum in front of you because you're doing what you were trained to do? To the kids she's just part of the institution, and in this particular case the institution is sending them very conflicted messages. "Think for yourself! As long as you're thinking what you're supposed to be thinking." In any case, I think the real problem with the education system is it's constantly trying to bullshit kids into "learning" things they really don't need to learn. (And they don't really learn it. Quick sanity test: what do you remember about high school trigonometry? But you "learned" it right? Or did you, really?) Most kids aren't stupid. They're naive, but they're not stupid. They can tell when their time is being wasted. They're out to give the right answer and not think about it because when you're literally trapped in a system like that, the most logical thing to do is minimize effort and not make waves until you can make your way out. So that's what kids do, and then pompous teachers are surprised that kids aren't "passionate" about these things. Well no kidding they're not! Why should they be?
- demallien 12y agoLike 3pt141597, I remember everything about high school trig. Not only do I remember it, but as it turned out, 10 years after leaving school, I actually started having to use it regularly (graphics programming). I also remember high school level calculus. Sadly I can't say the same for university-level maths, which I regularly have to break out the text books for when I need them (stats and probability, complex numbers being my two regular bugbears). When I think about it, I struggle to find a single useless class from high school. If anything, I regret mostly that I didn't make enough of the opportunities that my school provided me - I really regret not having put in the effort in art classes for example.
- silencio 12y agoI thought lightly of all the arts classes I had to take in school and that my parents wanted me to take for "a well rounded education". Drawing, painting, ceramics, piano... It took me almost 10 years after high school to realize how useful it's been for me in so many random little ways. Everything from being able to craft some of the things I needed for my wedding (designing my ring to sewing a ring pillow and painting table numbers) to just everyday mundaneness when I'm meeting with a client and I can just draw out what they're thinking and get the point across easily. The piano especially useful because it's so relaxing and good for taking my mind off stress/pain better than painkillers. Never in a million years as a kid would I have thought sitting in an art history class or 10+ years of playing a piano would come in as handy as all the obsessive studying I did of science, english, math and other classes. I'm so disappointed courses like that are disappearing (along with home ec - never had that, but my husband can't mend clothes or cook...) but so many people are struggling with basic math/language skills that I can understand why.
- Confusion 12y agoIt's unclear to me what the problem is that this teacher encountered. The students were given an exercise to learn something. They wanted to validate whether they learned something, by validating their solution. This could be achieved by reaching agreement with other students or by asking the teacher. So the problem is that only that ne was unclear that they were supposed to reach agreement instead of asking nir?
- jowiar 12y agoIf I were a teacher/professor, the words "Will it be on the test" would be criterion for an an F, or a detention, or something along those lines. But somehow we've codified that mentality into law? Jesus. We've broken school by making it all about getting a piece of paper with a number on it, rather than by being about being able to do things better each day. Learning is about answering "Can you do more, or do things better today than you did yesterday?" Repeat this process and eventually you're good at things.
- overgard 12y ago> If I were a teacher/professor, the words "Will it be on the test" would be criterion for an an F, or a detention, or something along those lines. So I assume you're not giving tests then? Because jesus, if you are, and those tests are consequential to the kids future, that's a pretty damn relevant and reasonable question. (Also: seriously, you'd punish a kid for asking a question?) The only way that attitude even remotely makes sense is if your students are there voluntarily, but lets be real: they're probably not. Either they're forced to be there (K-12), or they're compelled to be there for job prospects (college). You're probably lucky if even %10 are there because they want to be there.
- was_hellbanned 12y agoNot the parent commenter, but: >Because jesus, if you are, and those tests are consequential to the kids future, that's a pretty damn relevant and reasonable question. The point of a test isn't to test every single detail of what you were taught, it's to hit a random distribution of topics and examples of what you were taught. This gives a pretty good indicator of how well you learned the subject overall. Asking "is this going to be on the test" shows that you have no intention of actually learning everything you're taught, which is the point of the class, and instead you're only interested in memorizing the minimum to pass a limited test, which is not the point of the class.
- ubercow13 12y agoKnowing what a test is going to be like is pretty useful if that test matters at all. Otherwise there is a higher chance that the people who fare well on the test will be those who happened to work more on the topics or skills which come up. I'm happy my lecturer for group theory in university let me know which of the 5+ page proofs of theorems from the course wouldn't need to be known for our exam - it wouldn't have been very good use of my time to fully internalise all of them. However they were interesting and I think it added value that they were in the course. I think you just have an idealised picture of how tests work. In the best maths exams I have taken, you know all you could within reason about what you need to know and what will be the content of the test, and yet the questions still surprise you and cause you to think in new ways.
- mtsmithhn 12y agoYou hear about this all the time these days. Is this issue prevalent in all schools now from public to private and low to high socioeconomic status?
- jameshart 12y agoMy son's elementary school homework this week included, after a series of arithmetic exercises involving adding pairs of even numbers, this sequence of questions: What happens when you add together two even numbers? Is that true for all even numbers? Why? Part of me was overjoyed to see an actual mathematical question being posed, but... what exactly was my second grader son expected to write under the 'why' part of the worksheet? There was a couple of inches of blank space left for him to fill in his answer. Is the teacher going to read his answer there and mark is right or wrong and hand back the homework? I don't know if I have much hope that this will be used by the teacher to gauge each child's understanding in order to facilitate further classroom discussion. Have the kids been taught a particular explanation in class which the homework is expecting them to reproduce? What is the teacher's goal in sending home this question as an exercise? The fact that two even numbers always add up to an even number, as do two odd numbers, is an interesting insight into the shape and flavor of numbers. It gives you a practical tool - you can use this knowledge to parity check mental calculations and intuitively reject wrong answers - as well as an insight into the idea that esoteric mathematical properties numbers have can have interesting consequences when they interact, which is kind of the essence of a lot of mathematical thinking. Is that always true? Why? are probably the most important questions in mathematics. But... I have no idea how you teach that, except by having a one one one conversation with each student about it. I don't think you can get much value out of asking them on a single page worksheet and sending it home as homework, though.
- salgernon 12y agoWe have to reference Tom Lehrer and the New Math era of the 60s: "But in the new approach, as you know, the important thing is to understand what you're doing, rather than to get the right answer." http://www.lyricsfreak.com/t/tom+lehrer/new+math_20138395.html I did new math in the 70s and it did prepare me for understanding unix file permissions. chmod 0755 foo.pl!
- jameshart 12y agoI love Tom Lehrer dearly, but I don't see how it's appropriate here. Do you think that trying to teach kids to understand what they are doing is wrong? Nowhere am I suggesting that I have the impression that the child writing down "When you add two even numbers you always get 7" would be considered a valid answer on this worksheet - clearly they're trying to get kids to comprehend parity. Or are you suggesting that the answer would be different if you were missing two thumbs?
- tokenadult 12y agoI've lost count of the number of times that Colin has posted an interesting article on mathematics education on Hacker News over a weekend. This submission here is particularly good. The problem indicated is quite stark, and very commonplace. Most pupils in a mathematics lesson in elementary school swiftly learn that "getting the right answer" is the point, and some check out and soon begin to doubt their own ability to REASON to the right answer. The author of the submitted article writes, about a seventh grade class, "The basic premise of the activity is that students must sort cards including probability statements, terms such as unlikely and probable, pictorial representations, and fraction, decimal, and percent probabilities and place them on a number line based on their theoretical probability." As the author makes clear, the particular lesson arises from the new Common Core State Standards in mathematics,[1] which are only recently being implemented in most (not all) states of the United States, following a period of more than a decade of "reform math" curricula that ended up not working very well. I am favorably impressed that the lesson asked students to put their numerical estimates of probability on a number line--the real number line is a fundamental model of the real number system and its ordering that historically has been much too unfamiliar for American pupils. The author continues by elaborating on his main point: "When did we brainwash kids into thinking that math was about getting an answer? My students truly believe for some reason that math is about combining whatever numbers you can in whatever method that seems about right to get one 'answer' and then call it a day." I like the author's discussion of that issue, but I think she misses one contributing causal factor--TEACHER education in the United States in elementary mathematics is so poor[2] that most teacher editions of mathematics textbooks at all levels differ from the student editions mostly just in having the answers included[3] and don't do anything to develop teacher readiness to respond to a different approach in a student's reasoning. What I LOVE about the Singapore Primary Mathematics series,[4] which I have used for homeschooling all four of my children, is that the textbooks encourage children to come up with alternative ways to solve problems and to be able to explain their reasoning to other children. The teacher support materials for those textbooks are much richer in alternative representations of problems and discussions of possible student misconceptions than typical United States mathematical instruction materials before the Common Core. Similarly, the Miquon Math materials[5], which I have always used to start out my children in their mathematics instruction before starting the Singapore materials, take care to encourage children to play around with different approaches to a problem and to THINK why an answer might or might not be correct. (Those materials, both of them, are very powerful for introducing the number line model of the real number system to young learners, as well as introducing rationales as well as rote procedures for common computational algorithms. I highly recommend them to all my parent friends.) I try to counteract the "what's the correct answer" habit in my own local mathematics classes (self-selected courses in prealgebra mathematics for elementary-age learners, using the Art of Problem Solving prealgebra textbook[6]). I happily encourage class discussion along the lines of "Here is a problem. [point to problem written on whiteboard] Does anyone have a solution? Can you show us on the whiteboard how you would solve this?" Sometimes I have two or three volunteer pupils working different solutions--which sometimes come out to different answers [smile]--at the same time. We DISCUSS what steps make mathematical sense according to the field properties of the real numbers and other rules we learn as axioms or theorems in the course, and we discuss ways to reality-check our answers for plausibility. We don't do any arithmetic with calculators in my math classes. [1] http://www.corestandards.org/Math/ http://www.corestandards.org/Math/ [2] http://www.aft.org/pdfs/americaneducator/fall1999/amed1.pdf http://www.aft.org/pdfs/americaneducator/fall1999/amed1.pdf http://www.amazon.com/Knowing-Teaching-Elementary-Mathematics-Understanding/dp/0415873843 http://www.amazon.com/Knowing-Teaching-Elementary-Mathematic... http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/18/opinion/q-a-with-liping-ma.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/18/opinion/q-a-with-liping-ma... [3] When I last lived overseas, I had access to the textbook storage room of an expatriate school that used English-language textbooks from the United States, and I could borrow for long-term use surplus teacher editions of United States mathematics textbooks. They were mostly terrible, including no thoughtful discussion at all of possible student misconceptions about the lesson topics or of alternative lesson approaches--but they were all careful to show the teachers all the answers for the day's lesson in the margins next to the exercise questions. [4] http://www.singaporemath.com/category_s/252.htm http://www.singaporemath.com/category_s/252.htm [5] http://miquonmath.com/ http://miquonmath.com/ [6] http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Store/viewitem.php?item=prealgebra http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Store/viewitem.php?item=p...
- javajosh 12y agoWhen Feynman was a boy he'd always relate the math problem to a real world puzzle. With trig problems, he might imagine being given a riddle involving a flag post and rope and calculating distance. One got the sense that he was, in effect, using math to prepare himself to solve future, real-life riddles. Or rather, math was giving him the tools to (correctly) answer questions he otherwise could not have answered - and Feynman's great preoccupation was his obsession with solving puzzles of all kinds, and he would enthusiastically (perhaps greedily?) grab at all the tools he could. (Physics leans heavily on trig almost constantly, so a total mastery of it would be quite handy for a budding young physicist). It's also interesting to me that he was, at an early age, concerned with the usability of math, and was unafraid to create his own notation that was more comfortable for him (he liked the square root symbol and created analogs for sin(), cos(), etc.) Frankly, I think this is a fantastic way to approach learning. After all, it feels good to solve puzzles; if you solve enough of them, the way they fall together, the way they relate to each other (sometimes in unexpected ways) become useful insights in themselves. With a large, solid core of puzzle mastery, you might even be able to turn your attention to the more difficult puzzles of "how to teach". (Of course, the greatest thing you can teach is the love of solving puzzles!) I can't hold back anymore: what a foolish teacher! To get emotional over kids asking if their answers are right! In general, the yearning to be correct in one's calculations (and ordering cards is a calculation) is a good instinct, not to be beaten out of them.
- abecedarius 12y agohttp://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/freedom-learn/201003/when-less-is-more-the-case-teaching-less-math-in-school http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/freedom-learn/201003/whe... "Benezet showed that kids who received just one year of arithmetic, in sixth grade, performed at least as well on standard calculations and much better on story problems than kids who had received several years of arithmetic training." I've wondered if it was a big waste of time to teach arithmetic in elementary school, if kids that age mostly just aren't ready and they'd catch up fine if you waited. This experiment seems to say that it's worse: it inculcates cargo-culting operations until you get the 'right answer'. (I haven't read the original paper; the reference came from http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/05/23/ssc-gives-a-graduation-speech/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/05/23/ssc-gives-a-graduation-...)
- stretchwithme 12y agoI think learning comes naturally to all of us when we are trying to find an answer or solve a problem. Perhaps a good way to interest kids in math is to offer them the opportunity to make something that actually requires learning some math. Let them try to empirically do something that can really only be done with a formula. Show them the power! Without it, the world as we know it would not exist. If you're really motivated, you'll spend years seeking the answers. We should be motivating without coercing, providing tools for discovery, then just stay out of the way.
- calinet6 12y ago3 + 4 = _____ There's your answer. When kids are measured by "correct answers" and pressured to find them, then that is all they will care about. They aren't, then, doing math— they're generating correct answers. When you add multiple choice computer-readable tests into the fold, the problem compounds on itself. That is what broke our kids.
- SonOfLilit 12y agoIn his “Intuitive Explanation of Bayes’ Theorem”, Eliezer Yudkovsky wrote: It’s like the experiment in which you ask a second-grader: “If eighteen people get on a bus, and then seven more people get on the bus, how old is the bus driver?” Many second-graders will respond: “Twenty-five.” They understand when they’re being prompted to carry out a particular mental procedure, but they haven’t quite connected the procedure to reality. I was awe-struck, so I asked a friend who sometimes teaches second-graders to try this. 11/18 wrote “25″, 5/18 wrote “25 passengers on the bus” and 2/18 returned a blank note. I think this is a big part of the explanation. If you’re taught addition as a process that happens in a notebook, not in reality, then you have no way to separate answers that make sense from those that don’t. You also have no way to connect math to things you experience in your life, and I think the most common way to develop an interest in something is to find out it’s related to something else that you’re already interested in. In the last Super Bowl, the Seattle Seahawks scored 8 points in the first quarter, and 14 in the second quarter. Who won the match?
- mydpy 12y agoYou're calling your students "broken"? Can we start there?
- tks2103 12y agoWhat cost effective alternatives are there to public schooling in the U.S.? Is it possible or feasible to home school your kid with success?
- briantakita 12y ago> Who or What Broke My Kids? Rigid Institutions, Rigid Hierarchies, Social Stratification, Judgement, Power & Control, Special Interests, Lack of Freedom, Lack of Autonomy
- apeace 12y agoI recommend a simple, fun solution that kids of all ages LOVE: 1. Download DrRacket http://racket-lang.org/download/ http://racket-lang.org/download/ 2. Show the kids cool functions from the 2htdp/image library, like (circle 10 'solid 'red) 3. Show them the animate function from the 2htdp/universe library 4. Leave them to their devices and instruct when they have questions It won't be long before they want to make a game, and they'll need to learn all sorts of things about coordinates, shapes, colors, animations, and functions. Kids love functions. They'll have no idea how much math they're doing, yet at the end of the day they'll actually get it. For probability, check out the (random) function.
- MisterBastahrd 12y agoIt wasn't until a 10th grade class in world history that I encountered a teacher who wanted you to not only know the answer, but why the answer was correct. He ended up being one of my favorite teachers ever.
- darkhorn 12y agoShe is a teacher but as you expect she is not a statistician. If she would have studied statistics in statistics department for a year she would know what to teach. First you start with a coin, you have 1/2 chance to get this and that etc. This means 50%, then you repeat your move 100 times and you say see, the output is 53/100. Then you repeat and the output is 502/1000. So they start to get what 50% means. Then you do it with die and so on. However she has started it in wrong way. And I'm sure that most of the kinds do not know what 50% chance rain means.
- drdaeman 12y ago> If You Can Type the Problem into Wolfram Alpha and Get an Answer You Aren’t Doing Math If something can be computed with WA, it's somehow a waste of human time to do by hand. I could only hope, eventually, someday, we'll teach those aspects of math somehow combined with algoritmization and programming. Like, "Read on algorithms that could solve this class of problems, understand those (how they work and why), implement them, run the problem sets to see how it works in practice."
- bittermang 12y agoSchool did. When I was a very young boy, 2 or 3, my parents did everything in their power to ensure I could read. They would read books to me, I would read books to them. It is the very reason I am so well spoken and intelligent to this very day. Books were awesome. I loved books. Note the past tense. Loved. I have not been able to will myself to read a book on my own since the third grade. It was Lois Lowry's The Giver, that is the last book I can confirm to you that I read, in whole, because I wanted to. It was in the second grade that I had to do my first book report, and the entire concept of reading a book not for joy, but for work's sake, was a concept I could never rationalize. Even while I was reading The Giver, a book I had selected out of the elementary school's own library through my own volition, I received snide and discouraging comments from the library staff and teachers. "He shouldn't be reading that book." "That book is too advanced for his age." And on, and on. Something changed. I lost my will and my zest for books. Even books I would've very much liked to have finished and I found interesting, such as Mick Foley's Have a Nice Day!, his autobiography about breaking in to the wrestling business, I have not been able to finish. I have no will left inside of me to crack open a book, to even lift one off of the shelf. I feel like my love for books was steadily beaten out of me at a young age by the very institution whose job it was to educate me with them. At least this author seems to be on the right track. In all of my years of watching society ask "What is wrong with the kids today?" so few have bothered actually trying to ask the kids themselves.
- ehsanu1 12y agoIf you have trouble finishing books, try audiobooks. That's what has worked for me, and I got subscription at audible.com, which is great.
- timtas 12y agoWhatever broke the kids, it's fairly predictable that Common Core will break them more. Hey, let's do a probability problem? How many teachers will turn this lesson on it's head as this teacher did transforming it from something useless to students and painful to teacher? My guess is somewhere south of 1%. In the spirit of the true lesson here, I welcome well-supported alternate guesses. Centrally directed (er, suggested) curriculum will, I predict, relieve teachers from their responsibility to get results. How can you fault the teacher in the next classroom for not having had a meltdown and simply suffering the through the banality of the exercise as formulated by elite geniuses who have surely figured out the ideal pedagogy.
- nymanjon 12y agoJohn Taylor Ghatto & John Holt have already laid down in great detail of the problems of government schooling and solutions to those problems as illustrated in many of the comments in this thread.