7 ms·
A footnote about the publishing industry
- markbnj 12y agoI don't know why the idea that there might be a "better way" to produce fiction would even occur. It's a work of art, not a product. Are we worrying about the inefficiencies of cottage industries in, say, the production of music, painting, sculpture, or other literary forms such as poetry and the various forms of theatrical writing? It seems an odd lament for a writer, though I don't know that he actually meant it that way.
- jordan0day 12y agoHas capitalism succeeded so wildly that it's now basically invisible? So something created and meant to be sold, but having some other quality ("art", in this case), can't be considered a "product"?
- mstolpm 12y agoWhile the story itself might be art, the book, ebook, audiobook or DVD is a product. Publishers aren't producing art, they are in the business of distributing. (Most don't even sell to the customer but need either the bookstore or Amazon to do so.)
- markbnj 12y agoRight, but the comment I was referring to wasn't about distribution. It was about the limitations of the method of production, which, obviously are real and inherent (imho). What caught my eye was the offhand comment about not having found a "better" way to produce content (even going so far as to note that collaborations don't necessarily lead to greater efficiencies).
- edavison1 12y agoWriters, including critically acclaimed ones, can't produce their art without a legit publishing house making sure that their books are readable. There is a long chain of people in publishing working to ensure you maintain that perception, so I guess that's on them, but everyone knows they're awful distributors and most of the value they create comes from elsewhere in the 'creative' process.
- maxerickson 12y agoIf you read much of his blog, I think it is fair to say that he sees much of his writing as product.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoMaybe I haven't read enough, but I got more of an impression that the industry in which a successfully writer of fiction is embedded views the writer's output as product. And it is a product to the industry around it - works of fiction are advertised, printed, stocked, sold, shipped and consumed. Of course it's not just a product, but still that is the industry's main view of it. Much like how the music industry regards songs as "content" not "works of art". "How many copies can we sell?" is a more relevant question than "what is the piece's artistic merit?"
- maxerickson 12y agoThis post captures a lot of the tone I was thinking about: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/05/crib-sheet-singularity-sky.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/05/crib-she...
- jasode 12y agoI don't agree with the blog's author (Charlie Stross) but I will attempt to interpret what he's trying to say. He's not advocating for a more efficient fiction production method. The examples he cites are slow-growth authors that don't catch fire immediately and the failure of Agile XP "pair-programming" for consistently producing fiction any faster (the 75% contributed by both writers chestnut). If you take these premises as unchangeable, he's saying that authors require a stable industry that "nurtures" their career and a ruthless capitalist Darwinism would destroy that environment. I guess an analogy would be trashing the tenured status of mathematics professors and let other measurements such as crowdsourced student voting and dollar amounts of incoming grants dictate whether those math professors would have jobs. Under that dog-eat-dog scenario, a Charlie Stross type of prediction says that mathematician Andrew Wiles wouldn't have had the luxury to think for years on proving Fermat's Last Theorem. Good work by good creators (authors, mathematicians, etc) takes years to produce and unlike a tomato that can be grown from seed to fruit in 75 days, their slow intellectual output needs a commercial environment that doesn't punish them while 2 corporations negotiate their financial differences.
- ivan_ah 12y agoLike the OP, I think the big publishers are going down in flames soon. They just don't provide enough value in the value chain. Unlike the OP, however, I think the publishing industry is on the verge of a great renewal. The only people that matter are authors and readers, and eBooks and print-on-demand can make this connection happen, without the need to pay any middlemen. More on this here http://minireference.com/blog/techzing-interview/#opportunities http://minireference.com/blog/techzing-interview/#opportunit...
- Mister_Snuggles 12y agoThe missing thing here is editors. A lot of books, regardless of format, would be a lot less enjoyable without a good editor to make sure the story is consistent, well-paced, etc. A number of authors thank their editors in the afterword. That said, there's still room to disrupt the industry a bit.
- WalterBright 12y agoImplicit in these threads is the assumption that Amazon would never provide editor services. If Amazon dealt directly with authors, without going through a traditional publisher, I don't see any fundamental reason why they wouldn't. After all, better books => more profits. And, of course, there's no particular reason why editors cannot contract out their services to authors. I know some authors, and they review/edit each others' books.
- opendais 12y agoAmazon would have to charge and book editing isn't a process that scales. At which point, authors just go off and find their own editors/etc and become a minipub.
- WalterBright 12y agoYes, and so does a publisher. Publishers don't provide free services; it gets paid for by the author in the form of reduced royalties. If there's increased money to be made in edited books, the market will find a way.
- lazyant 12y ago"(Bezos) picked publishing because it was obviously the most dysfunctional. " , from what I remember from a biography he picked books because they could be bought by users without checking them out first, they are easy to store and mail and you didn't have to pay for them until you sold them. From Wikipedia: "After reading a report about the future of the Internet which projected annual Web commerce growth at 2,300%, Bezos created a list of 20 products which could be marketed online. He narrowed the list to what he felt were the five most promising products which included: compact discs, computer hardware, computer software, videos, and books. Bezos finally decided that his new business would sell books online, due to the large world-wide demand for literature, the low price points for books, along with the huge number of titles available in print"
- yawz 12y agoUnfortunately a new balance is not easily achieved. Take "editing" as an example: Most of us read "well edited" books, therefore we take "editing" for granted. I am an amateur book reviewer & blogger. And I regularly come across badly edited or not-at-all edited books/stories. IMHO, editing can be (at least for me) the difference between greatly enjoying a story and parking a book on the side after a few dozen pages. Then publishers also come with some sort of brand loyalty. I have my favorite publishers (and editors for that matter). For example, when I hear about the book rights acquisitions of a new author from my favorite publishers or imprints I get really excited. Because I know they've been publishing the type of content I enjoy. So, all in all, it's shortsighted to see publishers as just "middle-man". This ecosystem has evolved to be more complicated than that.
- dublinben 12y ago1. Editing can and will still happen outside of the traditional publishing relationship. Authors should hire editors directly before releasing their books. Many authors already trade editing with other authors. 2. You're an incredible outlier for even being cognizant of the publisher of your favorite books, let alone having any kind of loyalty. Readers who are not industry-insiders never hear about book rights acquisitions.
- jasode 12y ago> You're an incredible outlier for even being cognizant of the publisher of your favorite books, I don't know what kind of books grandparent had in mind (fiction or non-fiction?). For me, I have a general awareness of technical book publishers and their strengths. Some examples... In general an Addison-Wesley or Morgan-Kaufmann book is better edited than an Apress book. Also, some publishers tend to gravitate towards certain strengths such as MK's line of books on big data & data mining. O'Reilly and Manning publishers tend to respond very quickly to the latest technologies (some might say "fads") with a topical book whereas Addison-Wesley is much more conservative. Of course, there are exceptions to all of the above but the general tendencies of tech publishers can be used to signal the potential quality of a book (especially for unknown authors.) I don't think the HN crowd would be outliers by having a sense of where the various tech book publishers fit in the marketplace.
- b1daly 12y agoMarkets for artistic works are unique in that the creators are often (usually) not primarily motivated by money. Everyone else in the business is, more or less (meaning many authors write as an avocation, while very few people would consider doing extend work of a tedious nature like editing for no money). With the rise of ebooks they are also subject to the wildly counter intuitive aspects of markets for digital goods. High fixed costs with near zero marginal cost, leading to a fat head, long tail market structure. Authors such as Stross who are commercially successful are in a highly elite group, so I tend to discount their concerns as being generalizable as a societal concern. Not to say that I don't empathize. Or envy:) It's unclear to me how the disruption of the publishing industry would affect the quality of published work. The services publishers provide, funding, editing, marketing, legal, are essential to the creation of good work. If there is no mechanics to pair such services with gifted authors, then it seems a certainty that the quality of published work will go down in the aggregate. But as far as I can tell, the profound change in publishing due to the changes in media itself has yet to shake out into a new stable structure.