3 ms·
I agree the political articles bring out some screwy ideas. Is your "solution" that you want a situation where you won't to experience what other peopl, even ot
by joe_the_user 17y ago
I agree the political articles bring out some screwy ideas. Is your "solution" that you want a situation where you won't to experience what other peopl, even other hackers, think about these issues.
I mean, if this is a community, then we should respectfully debunk racist ideas rather than just shutting them. Otherwise, the same discussion happens in more screwy venue.
(Agreed, there should be limit to how much of this discussion happens here BUT the limit should not be zero).
- davidw 17y ago> I agree the political articles bring out some screwy ideas. Is your "solution" that you want a situation where you won't to experience what other peopl, even other hackers, think about these issues. Yes, that's my solution. There are way too many issues that even reasonable people will simply agree to disagree on. And these discussions often tend to attract plenty of people who aren't reasonable.
- mynameishere 17y agorespectfully debunk racist ideas The problem, of course, is that not every idea can be debunked, because some of them are true. And when you start with the conviction that you're bound to "debunk" everything, and can't, it gets ugly. Here's a racist comment: Africans are, on average, less intelligent than Japanese. Now, you're just not going to want to get into that argument, because it's unwinnable. The only way to win it is to avoid it, or to start throwing imprecations around. This is a serious dilemma for the anti-racist side of the argument, because they are believers in equality--and when you believe in something that doesn't exist, it's religion.
- gommm 17y agohmm... I could understand how you could defend something like Africans are, on average, less educated than Japanese or something like Africans have less opportunity from their environment to educate themselves and thus have less knowledge and intelligence (but then which type of intelligence?) than Japanese... But defending your original quote, you would have to prove me that african kids raised in the same conditions as japanese kids are less intelligent than the japanese kids... And I don't believe there is any studies proving this... In our world there is no equality of circumstances and we are pretty much a product of our environment so how could the produce of wildly varying environment be equal? So I don't think you can single out a 'race' as being more or less intelligent, you have to consider the political environment, the culture, the natural environment... and so on
- mynameishere 17y agoWell. It's pretty clear that your ignorance is fundamental. I can't possibly explain the world to you in a comment here. I recommend starting with this, http://www.amazon.com/Blank-Slate-Modern-Denial-Nature/dp/0670031518 http://www.amazon.com/Blank-Slate-Modern-Denial-Nature/dp/06... Pinker is a liberal but he's also a scientist, and so it's a good intro into reality.
- joe_the_user 17y agoYes, that is a racist idea Yes, I would not want to get into that argument. No, that doesn't prove you should never address ideas with racist overtones... Thank you...